User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > What sense is it that the best teams only have 1 person on the depth chart.
Page:
 
Coach Greedy
offline
Link
 
I repeat my earlier comments

From what I have read the injury's wont even keep them out of 1 single game, just reduce their stats for a while, This is weak and unrealistic. The best teams should have strength in depth and need it to win, but as you say the top teams only have a skeleton crew.

I understand why the developers are worried about keeping a player out injured for a period of time, but thats real life. Players should be able to pick up injury`s that mean they miss various amounts of game time, and if they don't get the injury treated, which will cost $ then the injury may well return.

Look how many QB`s went down this season in the NFL and back ups and veterans had to step in, and look at what an impact that had on the league. This way owners will need to sign 2 maybe 3 QB`s and similar for all positions. So in the long run the developers get even more people playing at a competitive level.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by caponesgun
They are going to implement a mandatory roster size eventually. From what I could tell, it was in the 40s. A lot of teams are using various workarounds this season that won't exist next season. Which is fine, the game is in a beta. If they lose because of it, they'll learn and move on (hopefully). I'm all for mandatory depth, I have several players on my roster who I could release and not really notice. That's what backups are for.In the odd chance in game where I need one, there one is...skilled and everything.


Mandatory roster size won't change anything, they'll just sit on the roster and not on the depth chart.

 
Link
 
You guys, the reason a lot of team's don't have backups is because... WHO WANTS TO PLAY BACKUP? I mean I have backups, but it's harder to recruit them than you think.
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
Originally posted by CONN CHRIS




It can easily be solved by making a certain depth at each position mandatory for a line-up to be valid prior to game time.



I agree with this thread.

Seriously, injuries is not whats going to solve this. People should not be playing, let alone rewarded for playing just 1 HB or just 2 WR's in a game. Its simply unrealistic and those of us trying to play more realistically or suffering.

I like the suggestion of having a mandatory depth at each position for a lineup to be valid.



Crazy. Maybe a limit on the high side, yes. Low side, no. If someone can play their ppl the whole game then good for them. No one will ever tell me as a coach who or how many players I have to have. Dumbest idea ever. Vilita, you have players in positions that aren't even in USE YET. Get a clue.

Last edited Apr 14, 2008 11:33:59
 
Armaro
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn

Crazy. Maybe a limit on the high side, yes. Low side, no. If someone can play their ppl the whole game then good for them. No one will ever tell me as a coach who or how many players I have to have. Dumbest idea ever.


The game is supposed to be simulated in the fashion of the NFL. You can't just leave your starters in the whole game and win in the NFL. You can always fiddle with your substitution rate if you wanted to keep your starters in the whole time despite the mandatory depth chart.
Last edited Apr 14, 2008 11:34:35
 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ohmybriguy
For a game that is trying to attract people and new players, why is it that it that the teams are better off to not have good depth and rotations during a game. I cam to the conclusion that i had to cut almost 60% of my team, cause all the best teams only have 1 or 2 players at most for positions. It penalizes teams who sign young and new players or players who cannot find teams. Am i wrong in my thinking?

Just cant figure out why it would be better to only have 2 DE's play during a game when in the NFL they are always rotating players to get fresh legs.


few problems with this.... not saying your wrong, but your thinking as an owner.

Problem #1. People who pay to play this game as players, dont want to be bench players. everyone complains about being a starter. so getting strong depth is not only hard, but a headache with all the letters from disgruntaled players.

Problem #2. Salary issues. Players want money and contracts that pay them well. starters want money as will backups. so this will again cause issues with many teams.

Problem #3. EXP issues. in the long term, players with 3 or 4 backups will end up spliting exp then having 2 or 3 in teh same position.

 
Fat Banana
offline
Link
 
I know our team lost a couple of games this last season because at a critical point in the game the sim replaced our starting QB with the backup QB who promptly threw an interception on his very first (and only) play of the game. That happened twice and we lost both games. So the owner of the team just cut all of the backup QB's and after that we won all our remaining games to make the playoffs.

If you want to talk about realism you don't see any coaches in real football who pull out their starting QB for the backup at a critical time of the game just because the backup is fresher.
 
MrFreeze
offline
Link
 
I think the QB position (and the O-line) is the odd one out. But come matchday, and you only have one QB on the roster, thats not realism either.
 
kerg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fat Banana
If you want to talk about realism you don't see any coaches in real football who pull out their starting QB for the backup at a critical time of the game just because the backup is fresher.


They need sub %'s by position rather than an overall.
 
Pumchavas28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kerg01
Originally posted by Fat Banana

If you want to talk about realism you don't see any coaches in real football who pull out their starting QB for the backup at a critical time of the game just because the backup is fresher.


They need sub %'s by position rather than an overall.


BINGO!!!!!!
 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kerg01
Originally posted by Fat Banana

If you want to talk about realism you don't see any coaches in real football who pull out their starting QB for the backup at a critical time of the game just because the backup is fresher.


They need sub %'s by position rather than an overall.


That is a better idea and would be a huge improvement to team management.
 
CoachMauler
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Whatsdafus
Originally posted by kerg01

Originally posted by Fat Banana


If you want to talk about realism you don't see any coaches in real football who pull out their starting QB for the backup at a critical time of the game just because the backup is fresher.


They need sub %'s by position rather than an overall.


That is a better idea and would be a huge improvement to team management.


Agreed. Its tough because some positions have more quality depth so I would love to be able to individually tweak that kinda thing.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by Vilita

Originally posted by CONN CHRIS





It can easily be solved by making a certain depth at each position mandatory for a line-up to be valid prior to game time.



I agree with this thread.

Seriously, injuries is not whats going to solve this. People should not be playing, let alone rewarded for playing just 1 HB or just 2 WR's in a game. Its simply unrealistic and those of us trying to play more realistically or suffering.

I like the suggestion of having a mandatory depth at each position for a lineup to be valid.



Crazy. Maybe a limit on the high side, yes. Low side, no. If someone can play their ppl the whole game then good for them. No one will ever tell me as a coach who or how many players I have to have. Dumbest idea ever. Vilita, you have players in positions that aren't even in USE YET. Get a clue.



Hey genius. Did it occur to you that maybe that I did that so the backup LB's see their name on the front page as starters and feel better about their position on the team?

You might want to ask why people do things before assuming they are as clueless as you.
 
ohmybriguy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Whatsdafus
Originally posted by ohmybriguy

For a game that is trying to attract people and new players, why is it that it that the teams are better off to not have good depth and rotations during a game. I cam to the conclusion that i had to cut almost 60% of my team, cause all the best teams only have 1 or 2 players at most for positions. It penalizes teams who sign young and new players or players who cannot find teams. Am i wrong in my thinking?

Just cant figure out why it would be better to only have 2 DE's play during a game when in the NFL they are always rotating players to get fresh legs.


few problems with this.... not saying your wrong, but your thinking as an owner.

Problem #1. People who pay to play this game as players, dont want to be bench players. everyone complains about being a starter. so getting strong depth is not only hard, but a headache with all the letters from disgruntaled players.

Problem #2. Salary issues. Players want money and contracts that pay them well. starters want money as will backups. so this will again cause issues with many teams.

Problem #3. EXP issues. in the long term, players with 3 or 4 backups will end up spliting exp then having 2 or 3 in teh same position.



not saying your wrong either... but... were not talking about not having backups. They have some cpu backups on the team... the problem we are talking about is that it is actually better for your team to only have 1 guy on the depth chart to play in the game. Which is not very realistic.
 
Asher413
offline
Link
 
I'll refer to my post a few days ago- lower the XP cap in plays (currently 90), so that you only gain fatigue above a lower point, forcing depth that way.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.