User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > When it's all said and done best RB ever
Page:
 
stat2883
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by stat2883

even worse is trying to do it for WRs

--at least there the general consensus is Jerry Rice, but after that it gets cloudy real fast. Even Rice may not be a stone cold lock.


Don Hutson FTW


you could pretty much call him the Jim Brown of WRs....or would Brown be the Hutson of RBs? Both those guys were ahead of their time.
Last edited Apr 17, 2008 00:04:31
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PRUETER
I think Bo Jackson would've had the rushing record if he never got hurt.He had power and amazing speed.


I do think that Bo Jackson was incredible and it's a shame that his career just wasn't one that really allows for him to be seriously discussed as a best ever.
 
larrycsonka
offline
Link
 
It might be late, but the Csonka reference was a good one.
 
favre466
offline
Link
 
So was a Green Reference
 
purehatred
offline
Link
 
Putting Ahman Green's name in a thread with the likes of Eric Dickerson, Jim Brown, Barry Sanders, Walter Peyton and others makes you a pathetic Packers homer.

But yeah...LTD is the most complete back of this era, he's putting up giant statistical numbers, he's not a back like Sanders that can't block and has to come out in short yardage situations, and he's a constant threat to break a big play (unlike guys like Curtis Martin and to an extent Emmitt Smith who sort of piled up yardage numbers).

Soooo...if you figure he probably has 3-4 prime years left and maybe 2-3 years where he's just sort of playing on his name alone, he'll be approaching the all-time rushing ecord, he'll have completely obliterated the rushing TD record, and he'll also have added 7 K in receiving. IF the Chargers ever get to a Super Bowl or two, I'm not sure how you can deny that LTD is the best and most complete RB ever.
 
tjack07
offline
Link
 
I know he had a short carrer due to injury, but you gotta include Bo Jackson in this talk..if you are old enough and remember watching him, he was something else! Im not saying hes the best ever, but his name should be brought up. my list reads as Barry Sanders, Walter Payton, Jim Brown, Eric Dickerson, LT and Bo Jackson. I know LT is still young and can easily move up in that list, but not yet.
 
Drewg81
offline
Link
 
I can't believe Jerome Bettis was even named as honorable mention in here (somewhere on page 1 or 2). That's ridiculous...

Jim Brown might have been a tremendous douchebag, but the guy was amazing. It's a shame his legacy is tainted by his actions, but to the blacks back in his time, he was a leader and someone to look up to. Unless you lived in those days (which I didn't either), you can't even imagine what it was like. Books and stories aren't going to do it justice. When it comes to the top 5, he's in there...with a solid case for number 1.

There are a lot of great backs who fall off the lists for one reason or another. Look at O.J. Simpson. Granted, he's a murderer, but he was an amazing running back. First one to put up 2000+ yards in a season (in 14 games I beleive). Earl Campbell as well. Not a murderer, but still awesome. Does Emmitt Smith get left off because he played for so long? He was the total package. Do you leave off Gale Sayers?

In my opinion, it's Sanders. Maybe after all that's said and done, LT will pass him. Until then, I will remember him crying and whining after playoff losses. If Jim Brown is knocked for being a racist wife beater, and OJ a murderer, I can knock LT for being a bitch a lot. Of course that can always be overlooked if you win a ring or two...look at Peyton Manning.
 
Princess Cleo
offline
Link
 
It took till page 4 for someone to mention Earl Campbell? Sure his stats don't really look great now but he was a beast who carried the Oilers for several years. It's too bad his body has paid the price for his playing days, I don't blame running backs when they retire early now.
 
favre466
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by purehatred
Putting Ahman Green's name in a thread with the likes of Eric Dickerson, Jim Brown, Barry Sanders, Walter Peyton and others makes you a pathetic Packers homer.


Settle down big guy, just messing around
 
Link
 
bo jackson would have been the best ever
 
WEglAudacity
offline
Link
 
As an Auburn fan, I got to see a lot more of Bo Jackson play than those who only started following him in the pros. He was something to see.

I was so disappointed the injury ended things so soon.
 
Maksim
offline
Link
 
Emmit Smith is best

end of fred
 
Shane Falco
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WEglAudacity
As an Auburn fan, I got to see a lot more of Bo Jackson play than those who only started following him in the pros. He was something to see.

I was so disappointed the injury ended things so soon.


If you lived in the state of Alabama you couldn't swing a dead cat w/out seeing something about Bo, and he deserved every bit of the attn. - Bo was an amazing RB to watch, a team leader, and from all accounts a heckuva nice guy -- even Bama fans were upset when he got hurt.

As a side note I saw an interview w/ him a few months back and apparently Bo could throw the ball too -- on a bet he threw a football straight up and hit the main scoreboard over the field in the Super Dome
 
PRUETER
offline
Link
 
I saw something ESPN had on him,it was about 1 or 2 hours long.It showed everything he did from highschool to the pros.I was amazed at some of the stuff I saw,I knew he was good but until you see piece that ESPN did on him you'll never see what type guy he was unless you followed him really good in highschool and in college.Bo Jackson was a beast.Not only in football but in baseball aswell.It's just a shame that someone that good got hurt and had to give it up.Not just a shame for him but also for football.
 
WEglAudacity
offline
Link
 
http://youtube.com/watch?v=iK5SNZqGS-I

I think one of my favorites was the way he ran over Deion Sanders (Florida State).

He was superhuman.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.