User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Taking defensive playbook or offensive playbook with you
Page:
 
Pvt Phin
offline
Link
 
+1000
 
Toric
offline
Link
 
I don't care how we do it..

But we need to do something.

The Off book i wrote took me 2 days (not counting the excel time laying it all out) to get in place.

I saved it under 3 manes but the truth is 1 pissed off staff member has the ability to wipe out all that work. ya I know hire better staff.

also as an OC and the guy who created the book i think it bites that i could spend all that time. have an owner go awol and watch my book just go poof.


there are 1000 reasons that we should be able to d/load and upload this book.

I am reaching fr the far away ones i know but no matter the reason it would be huge!


Think about the number of crazed Cords there would be if something went wrong and that data was lost.

Bort you are a programming God but give yourself a little help on this one..
1 post that says we had a bug guys re upload your books!

or hours trying to recover lost books
 
GIEFF
offline
Link
 
This is a horrible idea. The playbook should stay with the team. Otherwise, all it takes is one rogue GM to post it on the forums for EVERY team to see.
 
Pvt Phin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GIEFF
This is a horrible idea. The playbook should stay with the team. Otherwise, all it takes is one rogue GM to post it on the forums for EVERY team to see.


Agreed

Originally posted by Toric
I don't care how we do it..

But we need to do something.

.....................

I saved it under 3 manes but the truth is 1 pissed off staff member has the ability to wipe out all that work. ya I know hire better staff.


Agreed. So I thought this up and I think it is a good way to fix this all and make it so that everyone is happy.

First, I don't think everyone should have the option to create playbooks (i.e newer members/members that arn't GM's/Owners) I don't want to personally exclude them but, if you havn't been a GM before you "kinda" wouldn't understand what your doing, and newer members would mess with it to much. I just don't think it should be available to them.

So I came up with this.
http://i37.tinypic.com/2ceiwix.png

How it works:

When you create an account the "My Playbooks" goes under the created players (for everyone).
~~~In this picture I replaced the created players with the playbook so you could see my GMed Teams.

The only way for a Playbook to show up is if under the AI Offense/AI Section of the tactics, you create and save a playbook. In some cases there may be more than one person accessing the AI's. So maybe when you click the save a preset button the playbook will be "saved" to the person that created it. The only way the Playbook will be deleted forever is if the original creator deletes with the option in the drop down. Like Toric said, you don't want some mean owner to delete your work so that is where it comes in handy. This would mean, that the Owner wouldn't be able to edit the AI. That is where if the owner edits something on the AI and Alert is sent to the creator to approve of the change. Once the change is confirmed it is permanetly set in place, unless you yourself changes it or the owner gets another approval. This may be come an issue if the OC/DC is inactive for awhile or leaves on break, so maybe if the OC/DC trusts the Owner enough he should be able to allow acess to the owner.

This is all very confusing, and Bort and the mods will have to decide how they go about that so I want to now mention some other features.

The Copy Option allows you to copy the playbook and create an exact duplicate, in this case you will be given the option to change the playbooks name and the team. Now you will only be able to change the team if you have access to their OC or DC position. Say your an DC for one team, you cannot take your Playbook and transfer it to a team you only OC.

The Deactivate Option allows you to deactive the playbook so that it is not in use, you can still keep it but it will not be used. Also, when you say resign from a OC/DC job, or the Owner cuts you from it the playbook automatically deactivates so the team that cut you, cannot use the playbook anylonger. +To go with that once you deactive a playbook the Owner cannot see it.


I know this needs some work, but i think its a good start.
Last edited Jul 26, 2008 12:29:55
 
WhiteHouse
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vmann2485
i think that everyone whos a DC or OC should be able to develop a playbook save it on thier computer and upload it later if they go to another team as thier DC or OC


Of course it is a brilliant Redskins fan who come up with the good ideas.
 
justafish2002
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrobb525
Originally posted by GIEFF

This is a horrible idea. The playbook should stay with the team. Otherwise, all it takes is one rogue GM to post it on the forums for EVERY team to see.


Agreed

Originally posted by Toric

I don't care how we do it..

But we need to do something.

.....................

I saved it under 3 manes but the truth is 1 pissed off staff member has the ability to wipe out all that work. ya I know hire better staff.


Agreed. So I thought this up and I think it is a good way to fix this all and make it so that everyone is happy.

First, I don't think everyone should have the option to create playbooks (i.e newer members/members that arn't GM's/Owners) I don't want to personally exclude them but, if you havn't been a GM before you "kinda" wouldn't understand what your doing, and newer members would mess with it to much. I just don't think it should be available to them.

So I came up with this.
http://i37.tinypic.com/2ceiwix.png

How it works:

When you create an account the "My Playbooks" goes under the created players (for everyone).
~~~In this picture I replaced the created players with the playbook so you could see my GMed Teams.

The only way for a Playbook to show up is if under the AI Offense/AI Section of the tactics, you create and save a playbook. In some cases there may be more than one person accessing the AI's. So maybe when you click the save a preset button the playbook will be "saved" to the person that created it. The only way the Playbook will be deleted forever is if the original creator deletes with the option in the drop down. Like Toric said, you don't want some mean owner to delete your work so that is where it comes in handy. This would mean, that the Owner wouldn't be able to edit the AI. That is where if the owner edits something on the AI and Alert is sent to the creator to approve of the change. Once the change is confirmed it is permanetly set in place, unless you yourself changes it or the owner gets another approval. This may be come an issue if the OC/DC is inactive for awhile or leaves on break, so maybe if the OC/DC trusts the Owner enough he should be able to allow acess to the owner.

This is all very confusing, and Bort and the mods will have to decide how they go about that so I want to now mention some other features.

The Copy Option allows you to copy the playbook and create an exact duplicate, in this case you will be given the option to change the playbooks name and the team. Now you will only be able to change the team if you have access to their OC or DC position. Say your an DC for one team, you cannot take your Playbook and transfer it to a team you only OC.

The Deactivate Option allows you to deactive the playbook so that it is not in use, you can still keep it but it will not be used. Also, when you say resign from a OC/DC job, or the Owner cuts you from it the playbook automatically deactivates so the team that cut you, cannot use the playbook anylonger. +To go with that once you deactive a playbook the Owner cannot see it.


I know this needs some work, but i think its a good start.


Seems plausible to me, lots of coding, but definitely plausible
 
S3M1N0L3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GIEFF
This is a horrible idea. The playbook should stay with the team. Otherwise, all it takes is one rogue GM to post it on the forums for EVERY team to see.


You couldn't post it on the forums.
It would be saved in your GM profile on the server. JUST AS IT IS RIGHT NOW for the team AI..

The only difference would be that a GM on team A could upload the same AI to the other team he GMs. If you're not a GM, you won't understand the situation...

This would be useful down the road but it's absolutely critical right now with this needing to be implemented within a few days....

If you're involved in more than one team (and I see that you're not), you wouldn't need this feature. The current setup would work fine for what you're doing. It doesn't work well for those of us that have to have 4-5 defenses in place by tomorrow night...

Ok, just to clarify, it took about 6-7 hours to come up with the first AI for my defense. It takes 1.5 to 2 hours to copy the 60+ inputs and outputs to the other team. This is just the BASE defense, before tweaking. 2 hours X 4 teams = 8 MORE Hours to implement the BASICS to the other teams. That's just stupid.. That means that instead of implementing plan #2 for the first team and tweaking, I'm still in "copy mode" for the other teams and wasting a perfectly good weekend when all I need is the ability to load the AI I've already created.

This also don't take into account the changes that will be needed after scrimmage #1 going into scrimmage #2. For all 5 teams.. I have to debug what I have by reviewing game film, tweak the weak spots and have the next round implemented by scrimmage #2..

Then debug again and make tweaks in prep for the season.

Seriously take a moment and think about the impact a simple change like this can have.

It has NOTHING to do with a rogue GM. It has everything to do with GMs not having to spend every waking moment on this server duplicating the work they have already put in...

I don't care about if the team keeps it or not. It was just another suggestion if someone was concerned about a GM making off with the teams plans or vice versa.

But really, if the GM puts in 8 hours of time on your defense and you fire him, you're doing it cause his AI didn't work. Do you REALLY want to keep it??

Last edited Jul 26, 2008 18:36:22
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by S3M1N0L3
Originally posted by GIEFF

This is a horrible idea. The playbook should stay with the team. Otherwise, all it takes is one rogue GM to post it on the forums for EVERY team to see.


You couldn't post it on the forums.
It would be saved in your GM profile on the server. JUST AS IT IS RIGHT NOW for the team AI..

The only difference would be that a GM on team A could upload the same AI to the other team he GMs. If you're not a GM, you won't understand the situation...

This would be useful down the road but it's absolutely critical right now with this needing to be implemented within a few days....

If you're involved in more than one team (and I see that you're not), you wouldn't need this feature. The current setup would work fine for what you're doing. It doesn't work well for those of us that have to have 4-5 defenses in place by tomorrow night...

Ok, just to clarify, it took about 6-7 hours to come up with the first AI for my defense. It takes 1.5 to 2 hours to copy the 60+ inputs and outputs to the other team. This is just the BASE defense, before tweaking. 2 hours X 4 teams = 8 MORE Hours to implement the BASICS to the other teams. That's just stupid.. That means that instead of implementing plan #2 for the first team and tweaking, I'm still in "copy mode" for the other teams and wasting a perfectly good weekend when all I need is the ability to load the AI I've already created.

This also don't take into account the changes that will be needed after scrimmage #1 going into scrimmage #2. For all 5 teams.. I have to debug what I have by reviewing game film, tweak the weak spots and have the next round implemented by scrimmage #2..

Then debug again and make tweaks in prep for the season.

Seriously take a moment and think about the impact a simple change like this can have.

It has NOTHING to do with a rogue GM. It has everything to do with GMs not having to spend every waking moment on this server duplicating the work they have already put in...

I don't care about if the team keeps it or not. It was just another suggestion if someone was concerned about a GM making off with the teams plans or vice versa.

But really, if the GM puts in 8 hours of time on your defense and you fire him, you're doing it cause his AI didn't work. Do you REALLY want to keep it??



Bobby Bowden is wise.
 
Manor
offline
Link
 
bump
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
+1 to the original concept; haven't really read the discussion.
 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
+1 like whoa
 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
Has anybody spoken to the mods/admins about this? Because this is vital. I GM for way too many teams to sit around and copy my playbook multiple times
Last edited Jul 27, 2008 08:59:46
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thebigcali
Has anybody spoken to the mods/admins about this? Because this is vital. I GM for way too many teams to sit around and copy my playbook multiple times


There are really 2 threads about the subject. Its discussed, in length, here and in the Defensive AI tactics thread. To my knowledge, no mod/admin has commented on it.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
This would really be nice. I just started getting into our defensive AI the other day, and I'm nowhere near complete, and won't be for the first preseason game either.

I've got like 30 distinct situations mapped out, and I imagine that number will only grow with time. Doing it all multiple times will not be fun..Just mind numbingly boring and monotonous.
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
I like cookies.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.