User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP Bonuses for Impact Plays made on the field - a must add
Page:
 
Vyeth
offline
Link
 
I like Borts thinking when spoke of morale effects.. One thing impact plays do is raise or deflate momentum. I think it would be huge for there to be momentum swings on impact plays like sacks , fumbles and interceptions.
 
Link
 
If a CB is a shutdown corner, then have him use less stamina and be able to stay in the game longer (more base xp)

I feel that if a RPG is to be truely successful, it has to have appeal to both the hardcore and casual player base.

The XP per snap and overnight training xp offers the casual gamer something, but you have to have that "carrot on the stick" for the hardcore gamers to remain hardcore.

They don't spend hundreds of dollars a month for very many months if the casual gamers are able to accomplish the same with little to no money invested.

I believe the league system will allow for a fairly level playing field so casuals can compete against casuals and hardcore against hardcore. Salary / level caps and trade deadlines / roster freezes should help keeping this in line.

Not sure of the proper way to make everyone happy, i just wanted to add my $0.02.
 
KyleValant
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kinglehr
Originally posted by boomer82

Originally posted by kinglehr


Like I said, the only concern here is the fact that stats are relegated to an aesthetic in the game.

As we've all shown both for or against, there are a lot of ways in which skill is raised. Obviously if there are other ways to reward stats as a skill increasing phenomenon without having to delve into XP, I'm not against that. But the game has to find a way to reward stats.


Reward stats? How about the fact if you're good, better teams will want to sign you and you can move up to "better" leagues? Or the team you're on has that much of a better chance of winning?

Rewards don't have to be all about the individual.
You're on the wrong forum for this argument. The argument is about stats as a skill increasing phenomenon, not some kind of self-gratification.


How is that statement not valid to this argument? You made a point that stats are purely aesthetic and that is a problem. You then went onto state that stats should effect your skills in some way so that a player is aptly rewarded for playing well. Boomer countered your argument by saying that a player is rewarded for putting up good numbers, because it gives them the credentials to get into a higher league, get a better contract, etc., and therefore it is not necessary for stats to have to effect your player's skill. I agree with this point: a player's stats are effected by his skill, not the other way around. Perhaps you could reward a player for playing well by giving him a SLIGHT confidence boost, and generous boosts to morale, but anything more than that is unrealistic and unnecessary IMO.
Last edited Apr 13, 2008 23:02:28
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by KyleValant
Originally posted by kinglehr

Originally posted by boomer82


Originally posted by kinglehr



Like I said, the only concern here is the fact that stats are relegated to an aesthetic in the game.

As we've all shown both for or against, there are a lot of ways in which skill is raised. Obviously if there are other ways to reward stats as a skill increasing phenomenon without having to delve into XP, I'm not against that. But the game has to find a way to reward stats.


Reward stats? How about the fact if you're good, better teams will want to sign you and you can move up to "better" leagues? Or the team you're on has that much of a better chance of winning?

Rewards don't have to be all about the individual.
You're on the wrong forum for this argument. The argument is about stats as a skill increasing phenomenon, not some kind of self-gratification.


How is that statement not valid to this argument? You made a point that stats are purely aesthetic and that is a problem. You then went onto state that stats should effect your skills in some way so that a player is aptly rewarded for playing well. Boomer countered your argument by saying that a player is rewarded for putting up good numbers, because it gives them the credentials to get into a higher league, get a better contract, etc., and therefore it is not necessary for stats to have to effect your player's skill. I agree with this point: a player's stats are effected by his skill, not the other way around. Perhaps you could reward a player for playing well by giving him a SLIGHT confidence boost, and generous boosts to morale, but anything more than that is unrealistic and unnecessary IMO.
It isn't valid because unlike your argument he doesn't address the central question: Is or isn't stats a skill improving phenomenon? We're not here for quick zingers. Whether stats are self-serving or not has no bearing on that question.

Now as far as your idea that skills affect stats as opposed to the other way around, I happen to disagree. If my argument didn't change your mind, then there's nothing I can do about it. But the fact of the matter is that stats affect confidence of a player, and confidence affects the ability to learn skills. As the saying goes, success breeds more success.

Last edited Apr 13, 2008 23:53:06
 
Doug_Plank
offline
Link
 
I'm a big fan of this idea and have been, and frankly surprised it wasnt already part of the mechanics.

This would increase the incentive to play on "hard" and would then put more onus on teams with skilled owners/GMs who plan on maintaining quality depth.

Morale and small XP boost shouldn't be mutually exclusive, imo
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Looking at it more, this would be my idea. Perhaps what can be done instead of adding a straight up XP bonus is to change the application of morale. Morale can be applied as a modifier to XP earned instead of what it functions as today.

Confidence becomes a kind of resistance to morale reduction.

Aside from winning and losing, 1)Make negative stats a morale decreasing factor and 2)Make positive stats a morale increasing factor.

Then, split it up. Decide a cutoff point where the XP bonus from morale is 0. Then a certain range above that will be 5% XP bonus... and perhaps those with 100 morale will be 10% bonus. The opposite would be the case for those with morale below the cutoff.
Last edited Apr 14, 2008 00:03:53
 
methomps
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Doug_Plank
I'm a big fan of this idea and have been, and frankly surprised it wasnt already part of the mechanics.

This would increase the incentive to play on "hard" and would then put more onus on teams with skilled owners/GMs who plan on maintaining quality depth.

Morale and small XP boost shouldn't be mutually exclusive, imo


The only incentive it would give would be the incentive to play against lower competition to get more stats.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kinglehr
Looking at it more, this would be my idea. Perhaps what can be done instead of adding a straight up XP bonus is to change the application of morale. Morale can be applied as a modifier to XP earned instead of what it functions as today.

Confidence becomes a kind of resistance to morale reduction.

Aside from winning and losing, 1)Make negative stats a morale decreasing factor and 2)Make positive stats a morale increasing factor.

Then, split it up. Decide a cutoff point where the XP bonus from morale is 0. Then a certain range above that will be 5% XP bonus... and perhaps those with 100 morale will be 10% bonus. The opposite would be the case for those with morale below the cutoff.


That's awesome -- morale as the buffer to the XP bonus/penalty. That way you take into account the psychological impact of making the impact play or that costly mistake. Good stuff, kinglehr. I think even Bort and DD could get onboard with this.

Originally posted by Doug_Plank

The only incentive it would give would be the incentive to play against lower competition to get more stats.


I think you can counter that with one or both of the following methods:

1) Higher the LVL = the lower morale/XP bonus for positive plays and the higher the morale/XP penalty for negative plays.

2) Add a "Level of Competition" modifier where:
--A lower lvl competing against higher lvl (positive plays) = higher morale/XP bonus rate for the low lvl and lower morale/XP bonus rate for the high lvl.

--A lower lvl competing against higher lvl (negative plays) = lower morale/XP penalty
rate for the low lvl and higher morale/XP penalty rate for high lvl.

--In both cases, The wider the difference in lvl, the larger the impact (whether accelerated/decelerated) on the morale/XP bonus and morale/XP penalty rates.

What I believe the above two methods would do is make it far more beneficial, from a progression standpoint, for players to compete against an equal or higher level of competition.
Last edited Apr 14, 2008 09:20:45
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Just wanted to add one last thing for those who argue that "failures" increase learning more than "success"...

I certainly believe this to be true for mental learning... but physical learning is entirely dependent on success.

How do you make a better jump shot? By shooting the ball over and over until your muscles remember the exact motion required to successfully execute said jump shot and consistently produces such motion.

How do you have become a better physical tackler? By doing tackling drills over and over and over.

In a similar vain, producing stats in a game is just that extra repetition that the other guy doesn't get. That is what I want rewarded.
Last edited Apr 15, 2008 01:07:49
 
SlyLoK
offline
Link
 
Why not do it with all plays?

A WR as an example - Each catch gives 5 EXP ( up to 10 catches 0 exp after? ) - A TD gives 15 exp - A fumble takes away 10 exp - A dropped pass takes away 10 exp.. ect.

Then maybe at the end of the season there could be milestone exp rewards.

Again a WR - Bonus exp for having 70+ catches - Bonus for 1000+ yards - Bonus for having less than 5 drops .. ect ( or maybe the end of season rewards could be flex points? ).

Just a thought.
Last edited Apr 15, 2008 04:13:46
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SlyLoK
Why not do it with all plays?


But still use the Morale buffer for XP bonuses/penalties idea that kinglehr came up with earlier. That way, the player's confidence attribute affects how much xp they're rewarded or penalized at the end of the game. I personally think it's an excellent concept and one that the devs should strongly consider.

Here's kinglehr's idea again:

Originally posted by kinglehr
Looking at it more, this would be my idea. Perhaps what can be done instead of adding a straight up XP bonus is to change the application of morale. Morale can be applied as a modifier to XP earned instead of what it functions as today.

Confidence becomes a kind of resistance to morale reduction.

Aside from winning and losing, 1)Make negative stats a morale decreasing factor and 2)Make positive stats a morale increasing factor.

Then, split it up. Decide a cutoff point where the XP bonus from morale is 0. Then a certain range above that will be 5% XP bonus... and perhaps those with 100 morale will be 10% bonus. The opposite would be the case for those with morale below the cutoff.



Here's the "Level of Competition" modifier I suggested as well:

Originally posted by SAGA45
Originally posted by Doug_Plank


The only incentive it would give would be the incentive to play against lower competition to get more stats.


I think you can counter that with one or both of the following methods:

1) Higher the LVL = the lower morale/XP bonus for positive plays and the higher the morale/XP penalty for negative plays.

2) Add a "Level of Competition" modifier where:
--A lower lvl competing against higher lvl (positive plays) = higher morale/XP bonus rate for the low lvl and lower morale/XP bonus rate for the high lvl.

--A lower lvl competing against higher lvl (negative plays) = lower morale/XP penalty
rate for the low lvl and higher morale/XP penalty rate for high lvl.

--In both cases, The wider the difference in lvl, the larger the impact (whether accelerated/decelerated) on the morale/XP bonus and morale/XP penalty rates.

What I believe the above two methods would do is make it far more beneficial, from a progression standpoint, for players to compete against an equal or higher level of competition.


Last edited Apr 15, 2008 08:47:50
 
Beerski
offline
Link
 
I do agree with the original point that a shut down defense will lose out on XP. The payoff is that the players can train harder because they will have higher energy, increasing stat points quicker.

I do like some of the ideas in here. If a player makes a big play, it's reasonable that they will have adrenaline flowing and would not tire as quickly. Maybe something could be implemented along the lines of a sack (or whatever type of play) slightly increasing the player's energy level. That player would either gain more XP by not being subbed out, or have a higher energy level post game, possibly allowing them to train harder.

I could also see a dominant defense earning bonus points to be divided amongst the players according to snaps. Say a defense shuts out a team. The defense as a whole could earn 500 XP. If there were 50 plays, each player would earn .91 XP per snap they played on defense. That would be a bonus on top of the regular XP earned per snap. There could be bonus point totals added for benchmarks like more than 5 sacks or allowing less than 85 yards rushing.
 
Longview
offline
Link
 
Beerski has got it right.

Because QBs, WRs, and RBs, would get so many more impact plays then say a single DE or a Safety. I think if this was to be done that XP should be given to the offense and defense of a team and divided equally to each member of the Offense/Defense.

This way the Skills positions dont get more advantages then the OL or Defensive players.

 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Longview
Beerski has got it right.

Because QBs, WRs, and RBs, would get so many more impact plays then say a single DE or a Safety. I think if this was to be done that XP should be given to the offense and defense of a team and divided equally to each member of the Offense/Defense.

This way the Skills positions dont get more advantages then the OL or Defensive players.



Easy enough to solve. Create a threshold ladder. For example, maybe a QB has to complete 5 passes before he can get the first bonus whereas a DE will get a bonus as soon as he gets his first tackle. Give a bonus for the first touchdown, but the next touchdown bonus is for a the third touchdown while sacks are given bonuses each time you get one.

It's all complicated and maybe it will take awhile of discussion before we can actually get a correct system for it, but it's worth trying to put it together.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kinglehr
Easy enough to solve. Create a threshold ladder. For example, maybe a QB has to complete 5 passes before he can get the first bonus whereas a DE will get a bonus as soon as he gets his first tackle.


Too complicated. The QB could throw two td passes within those first five and not benefit from the Morale-XP bonus. Someone mentioned earlier that all stats should be recognized and I agree. Obviously, some will carry more of a Morale-XP bonus/penalty than others but having every play count to some extent certainly makes sense and keeps things simple.

Originally posted by Beerski

I could also see a dominant defense earning bonus points to be divided amongst the players according to snaps. Say a defense shuts out a team. The defense as a whole could earn 500 XP. If there were 50 plays, each player would earn .91 XP per snap they played on defense. That would be a bonus on top of the regular XP earned per snap.


I like this - a sort of global morale-xp bonus/penalty. This should be added along with the individual negative/positive-play morale-xp system that kinglehr suggested earlier. That way both group AND individual efforts are recognized.

The Level of Competition modifier (mentioned earlier) even applies here. Your defense might have shut the offense out but maybe:

--your def has an avg-LvL=12 and offense has an avg-LvL=9. Then your defensive unit would see slightly less of a bonus than if the opposing offense was of an equal or higher avg-LvL.

Back to your idea for recognition of group performance: You could also give the entire Oline a morale-XP bonus/penalty based on sack/hurries allowed per pass play and average rush yards per carry. Again, the L.O.C. (Level of Competition) modifier kicks in here based on the avg-LvL of the defense that the O-line is up against.
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 07:40:35
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.