User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
EagleScream
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jokerpac32
Originally posted by EagleScream

Greetings,

A number of us have seen the Canada A situation and felt that if they were to come to Canada AA they would have to improve dramatically to compete. That said, Kensington and Slack Jawed had to do that when they were promoted from AA to AAA last season so I feel they should be competitive but if they need an additional year does not matter to me, give it (the right not to be promoted this season) to them if they really want it, why not

Cheers, Eagle Scream


Class post right here. This site needs more players like this one!



Greetings,

Thanks man, for the record we have a real good group of owners in Canada AA 2 in the event you are promoted there. You should do okay against some of the teams too and I know of at least one team that is suppose to be gutted as well in the east

It will be difficult to make the playoffs but not impossible that is for sure (at least in my division, not sure about the other divisions)

Cheers, Eagle Scream
 
Jediah Prime
offline
Link
 
While I respect the opinions of the owners of A teams that are concerned they would be over their heads in the AA leagues, as an AA-league player I hate the fact that we have so many 1-15 and 0-16 teams losing by 80+ points on a regular basis. Teams like that take away from the legitimacy of many players' statistical performances at the end of the year, and there is no fun in playing against them. Those cellar-dwellar teams need to be relegated, and I would rather see them replaced by teams that worked hard to achieve A-League success -- and it is unfortunate that some of those successful teams do not feel up to the challenge.

That said, I somewhat agree with the A-League teams' arguments that it would not be giving them a fair shake after a shortened season. However, they are still in better position than whoever takes over gutted teams in AA who need to start from scratch.
 
GIEFF
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jediah Prime
While I respect the opinions of the owners of A teams that are concerned they would be over their heads in the AA leagues, as an AA-league player I hate the fact that we have so many 1-15 and 0-16 teams losing by 80+ points on a regular basis. Teams like that take away from the legitimacy of many players' statistical performances at the end of the year, and there is no fun in playing against them. Those cellar-dwellar teams need to be relegated, and I would rather see them replaced by teams that worked hard to achieve A-League success -- and it is unfortunate that some of those successful teams do not feel up to the challenge.

That said, I somewhat agree with the A-League teams' arguments that it would not be giving them a fair shake after a shortened season. However, they are still in better position than whoever takes over gutted teams in AA who need to start from scratch.


Well, if you don't like teams losing 80-0, you will HATE teams losing 120-0, because that's what you'll get with most of the Canada A teams.

 
daysend
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trauty
How are you gonna sign players before the rush is on. We can't sign anybody over level 13 until the rollover. By then the rush will already be on. Most high level guys will be available then and a lot don't mind going to a rebuilding team but you gotta have at least a few pieces in place and we haven't been allowed to try to put those pieces in place.


Well, if you want to look at it through tunnel vision then yes you are correct.

However, there are tons of players with expiring contracts that are shopping their services. I have recruited 3 players that I won't be able to sign until the offseason or after Season 4, Day 1.

Work out the playing time and contract details now. Get their verbal agreements and sign them when you are able.

Also, many of the Canada A teams have $1-2M in cash. There are even more players up for trade. Spend some cash wisely and pick up some good players there too.
Last edited Jul 21, 2008 20:40:55
 
daysend
offline
Link
 
dual post...
Last edited Jul 21, 2008 20:40:44
 
Jediah Prime
offline
Link
 
Well, it seems I should have read Bort's announcement thread first before posting my opinion (oops). What's done is done...

One thing I hadn't taken into consideration either was the number of new teams being added. WIth 1024 new teams being added, it may become incredibly difficult to sign players because there will be a LOT of competition in the FA market.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jediah Prime
Well, it seems I should have read Bort's announcement thread first before posting my opinion (oops). What's done is done...

One thing I hadn't taken into consideration either was the number of new teams being added. WIth 1024 new teams being added, it may become incredibly difficult to sign players because there will be a LOT of competition in the FA market.


One of Bort's stated goals (its buried in that forum thread) is to tilt some of the power balance back towards the players - now its too one-sided for the owners.
 
tumblingernie
offline
Link
 
Would salary caps at each level even things out? Salary + Bonus of course.
 
DickovDK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tumblingernie
Would salary caps at each level even things out? Salary + Bonus of course.



not really it would just benefit those that has build a team of their own characters. they could keep the price to a minimum thereby build a more dept
 
riley794
offline
Link
 
We have to have the demotion promotion system. What would be nice is if they added an incentive to teams moved up to the next league. For example 3 million to the team and 200 flex points for every player. That might encourage teams to move up even if it means getting their butts kicked next year against better talent. If a team still does not want to get bumped up they can bench all their starters in the playoffs and lose that way.
I cannot wait until my team can get to the pro league.
 
autogyro
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by riley794
We have to have the demotion promotion system. What would be nice is if they added an incentive to teams moved up to the next league. For example 3 million to the team and 200 flex points for every player. That might encourage teams to move up even if it means getting their butts kicked next year against better talent. If a team still does not want to get bumped up they can bench all their starters in the playoffs and lose that way.
I cannot wait until my team can get to the pro league.


The demotion/promotion system only works if you don't place arbitrary constraints upon one of the leagues which creates a massive disparity in skill level.
 
cwcapper
offline
Link
 
I hope we get to go down a level. I received one of the gutted teams and a win would be nice.
 
libertylane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by riley794
We have to have the demotion promotion system. What would be nice is if they added an incentive to teams moved up to the next league. For example 3 million to the team and 200 flex points for every player. That might encourage teams to move up even if it means getting their butts kicked next year against better talent. If a team still does not want to get bumped up they can bench all their starters in the playoffs and lose that way.
I cannot wait until my team can get to the pro league.


Originally posted by cwcapper

I hope we get to go down a level. I received one of the gutted teams and a win would be nice.


You all are a month to late... this dealt with an issue last season, promotion demotion will occur at the end of this season, it didn't occur at the end of last season b/c the canada A teams only had 8 games.
 
centurain
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Savage Smurf
Well a team that's moving up to AA#3 is about 8 levels below the rest of the league and i doubt they will put up any competition and just end back up in A leagues again.


Total BS, the 2 teams that moved up into our conference out level us. Promote the teams that dominate the lower leagues and make them play competition.
 
ripper12
offline
Link
 
The only reason why A teams wouldn't want a promotion is so that they can feel like Goliath. Either way, unless the team is gutted - the team that will get demoted will most likely dominate the league. I think it's fair to have the promotion/demotion because a) it's part of the system, and b) one team shouldn't stay in a league that they just absolutely demoralized (unless you are in pro lg) and it's just unfair to all the other teams in that league.

also there's a problem with demotion in a cap league. In Africa A8, madagascar wild were demoted from AA and had a lvl 31 hb when the cap was like lvl 24? *now 28* and they are going undefeated. so either way, there is no win win situation. but i think it's fair to give one winning season one losing season to each team, then give one team 2 losing seasons and the other 2 championship seasons.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.