User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
siquu
offline
Link
 
Maybe you should try to explain why Peterson did so well in the SD game, and then compare it to the sim.

Throwing out random numbers in an attempt to discredit other and look smart does nothing to help the discussion.


 
skibodragula
McFroggin
offline
Link
 
dude......thats frickin funny right there......i wonder if willie parker will boost this season for the steelers...hahah his td game could use it...
 
cavalier
Alpine
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
See, as soon as you bring numbers of % into it, you're really asking to be owned on several levels.

Adrian Peterson on October 28th against Philadelphia ran for 70 yards on 20 carries, for a 3.5 avg.

Adrian Peterson on November 4th against San Diego Chargers ran for 296 yards on 30 carries, for a 9.9 yard average.

That's a 400% increase. And he didn't even boost for that game.

So much for realism?


That is exactly the point here. To be realistic it got to be a random part of the equation. I have also played professional sport at the highest level and I can assure you that individual performances are extremely volatile for some players.
 
cavalier
Alpine
offline
Link
 
Warlock, I never thought that you had anything against our team and I understand that your intentions are to make this sim better. Thanks for that and it is only healthy to have discussions.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by siquu
Maybe you should try to explain why Peterson did so well in the SD game, and then compare it to the sim.

Throwing out random numbers in an attempt to discredit other and look smart does nothing to help the discussion.


No, because the point is you don't "have" to explain why Peterson did better. The point is it was the exact same physical laws of gravity. The exact same players. The exact same rules....but different variables resulting in wildly differing results. Its taken as a given that someone 'can' have 8 sacks in a game. Wildly unlikely, but possible. Just as its possible a QB can have 50TD's in a season. Just as its possible the NYG can lose against 5 or 6 teams in a year...but beat an un-defeated side.

For lack of a better definition - reading something like Chaos Theory would probably be a good start for a lot of people when trying to work out the permutations of what is effectively a number crunching system.

For someone like myself, who has been playing games such as Championship/Football Manager since the early 90's, the idea that odd results can come out of a simulation is all part and parcel of the game.

Things such as Super Goalie Syndrome, or the John Hartson Certainty Principle or the creation of the Diagonal Defensive Line all come from understanding certain things happen - and in some cases thats just the way it is.

Is it unrealistic for a Goalkeeper to have an amazing game even if your team is far superior? No. Is it unrealistic for a team to build a system that is extremely effective (such as the Denver Bronco's run game, or the 49'ers Passing, or the Cover 2?) No.

So why is it a "bug" of the sim for a team to get annihilated when people can provide rather logical explanations for it.

Their entire team was better. Their DE was infinitely better. They got on a roll. Morale and confidence were sapped. They had to throw, and they'd set up to run block - so they continued to get splatted.

There's nothing else to consider.
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Could it possibly be that one team just had a really good game while the other team just had a really bad game?

Not that it ever happens in real life or anything... and that sure as hell never happens in the playoffs or in bowl games.

So never mind. Me and my FAIL will just leave the thread now.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by siquu

Maybe you should try to explain why Peterson did so well in the SD game, and then compare it to the sim.

Throwing out random numbers in an attempt to discredit other and look smart does nothing to help the discussion.


No, because the point is you don't "have" to explain why Peterson did better. The point is it was the exact same physical laws of gravity. The exact same players. The exact same rules....but different variables resulting in wildly differing results. Its taken as a given that someone 'can' have 8 sacks in a game. Wildly unlikely, but possible. Just as its possible a QB can have 50TD's in a season. Just as its possible the NYG can lose against 5 or 6 teams in a year...but beat an un-defeated side.

For lack of a better definition - reading something like Chaos Theory would probably be a good start for a lot of people when trying to work out the permutations of what is effectively a number crunching system.

For someone like myself, who has been playing games such as Championship/Football Manager since the early 90's, the idea that odd results can come out of a simulation is all part and parcel of the game.

Things such as Super Goalie Syndrome, or the John Hartson Certainty Principle or the creation of the Diagonal Defensive Line all come from understanding certain things happen - and in some cases thats just the way it is.

Is it unrealistic for a Goalkeeper to have an amazing game even if your team is far superior? No. Is it unrealistic for a team to build a system that is extremely effective (such as the Denver Bronco's run game, or the 49'ers Passing, or the Cover 2?) No.

So why is it a "bug" of the sim for a team to get annihilated when people can provide rather logical explanations for it.

Their entire team was better. Their DE was infinitely better. They got on a roll. Morale and confidence were sapped. They had to throw, and they'd set up to run block - so they continued to get splatted.

There's nothing else to consider.


That's a bit of a retarded way to look at things, I'd say. Besides, you're entirely missing the point. We're not talking about a completely random event... where we're completely at the mercy of probability. Probability is dictated by variables, thanks for the news flash. If variables are incorrect, the probabilities are incorrect.

Professional athletes aren't merely born professional athletes, they start out with good genes sure, but overall it's what they do prior to stepping on the field that makes them what they are.

Julius Dee has a great build (imagine it as a tremendous work ethic, good genes and honed talent), nor do I feel that he wouldn't have had a good game against us. My problem was how the sim, rolled some pretty improbable results and that in turn removed most of the competition from the match. I.E. if not for the poor rolls by the blocking assignment check (I assume it's done in that type of a way), Julius Dee might not have completely dominated the game, by crushing the LT's confidence. If this is how important confidence is, there's a problem... the curve is probably way too steep. One or two bad plays, shouldn't equate to, you now play like a moron. This needs adjusting, if it's in-fact the case. We'll never know though... since the majority of people seem to be content with Developer's responses to these questions.

Show me where game-planning (I'm talking settings and scouting) has anything, what so ever, to do with how effective a DE (or any lineman for that matter) will be. The only control that is given... is where someone is going to play, plus who and when they rotate with. So it's basically have a good build and/or pray to the probability Gods. You might think that's fine and dandy, I don't.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Again...how is it improbable?

Why is it improbable for Dee to have a great game?

Why is it improbable for your LT to have a poor one?

Why is it improbable for these two events to coincide?

Why is it improbable (or even undesired?) for anomalous results to occur?

Bort has stated that confidence is essential and overlooked. The player building guide in the FAQ states confidence is important for O-Line positions (which is why they have specific anti-tiredness SA's, or specialist LT positional skills, or the C can boost energy and confidence on each down, or the QB has Field General ability etc).

I don't have the LT's build, and I don't know the DE's build. I can only presume he found something that worked well against the LT. Given the range of ways DE's have of damaging a teams offence, it could be any combination of things.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Again...how is it improbable?

Why is it improbable for Dee to have a great game?

Why is it improbable for your LT to have a poor one?

Why is it improbable for these two events to coincide?

Why is it improbable (or even undesired?) for anomalous results to occur?

Bort has stated that confidence is essential and overlooked. The player building guide in the FAQ states confidence is important for O-Line positions (which is why they have specific anti-tiredness SA's, or specialist LT positional skills, or the C can boost energy and confidence on each down, or the QB has Field General ability etc).

I don't have the LT's build, and I don't know the DE's build. I can only presume he found something that worked well against the LT. Given the range of ways DE's have of damaging a teams offence, it could be any combination of things.


I guess it's possible (no matter how probable) that your theory is what in-fact happened...

So, you're ok with the concept that, if single player happens to be better than his opponent... he can completely change how the game unfolds? With the only counter being to have a good build of your own and hope that the sim rolls your way. I thought this was a team sport, guess I was wrong...

Like I outlined earlier, about how teams deal with mismatches in real life, the game doesn't have such a feature. That to me, is poor design. Without such a feature, issues like this will continue to happen... this might be cool with you, I think it's BS and I guess that I'll just stop supporting this Company.





 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
But do they deal with mismatches? Terrell Owens/Randy Moss/Peyton Manning/Tom Brady is a mismatch every week - all they can do is put the best corner they have out there and hope he doesn't hurt them too badly. How do teams deal with the mismatch of their entire offence vs the NYG defence? Or the Patriots offence vs their entire defence?

I mean I could see the point in saying "Oh noes I can't gameplan for their DE!" but then you'd have to have known pre-game their DE was going to have such an impact. I mean, what exactly would you have gameplanned for? How exactly would you have dealt with the mismatch?

Fact is - it is a team sport. We don't know if it was his DE's skills alone, or a collective effort thanks to boosting and investment across the entire defence. If he had been on a level 1 team on his own against your offence, I'd wager he wouldn't have had anything like the impact.

But as it was - your O-Line got creamed and he was the fastest to the QB.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
But do they deal with mismatches? Terrell Owens/Randy Moss/Peyton Manning/Tom Brady is a mismatch every week - all they can do is put the best corner they have out there and hope he doesn't hurt them too badly. How do teams deal with the mismatch of their entire offence vs the NYG defence? Or the Patriots offence vs their entire defence?

I mean I could see the point in saying "Oh noes I can't gameplan for their DE!" but then you'd have to have known pre-game their DE was going to have such an impact. I mean, what exactly would you have gameplanned for? How exactly would you have dealt with the mismatch?

Fact is - it is a team sport. We don't know if it was his DE's skills alone, or a collective effort thanks to boosting and investment across the entire defence. If he had been on a level 1 team on his own against your offence, I'd wager he wouldn't have had anything like the impact.

But as it was - your O-Line got creamed and he was the fastest to the QB.


It's not so much the pre-game adjustments I'm talking about here, it's the in-game adjustments. Such as keeping the FB back to block on passing plays (paying particular attention to the one man wrecking crew).

The players you mention, get game-planned for extensively... sometimes it works (like the Giants vs Brady) and other times it doesn't (like the Bears vs Manning). Look at what teams do to prevent Hester from running back kicks, they shank the kicks on purpose. This is all game-planning, an option that isn't available, in regards to lineman. When the Bears didn't respect Steve Smith enough to alter their game-plan, in the 05 play-offs, he roasted them. That's an example of bad coaching. On the opposite end of the spectrum, teams that do game-plan properly can shut down marquee players (such as the AP example someone brought up earlier in this thread, only gaining 70 yards)... although, this usually gives a different player a good chance of beating you instead.

We knew Julius Dee was a really good DE, but tell me what could we have done, even if we wanted to make adjustments for him.

Combine both of these issues and you have a severe problem.

Why do you keep thinking that I actually care about the results of the game in question? Win or lose, it doesn't F-ing matter, I just want some accuracy in the sim... why is that such a problem for you? Do you honestly believe that 10 int games and 6 sacks by a single player, should be commonplace in the play-offs? Going by the NFL standard, that everyone keeps referring to, those types of things rarely ever happen. I also gave multiple reasons why they are that rare.

Based on your lack of regard for these points, I assume that you never played competitive football at a high level. If you had, you'd understand how important these things are. If I had to guess, you seem like an armchair QB that repeats the garbage that they hear on ESPN to their friends (hoping to appear, like you have real knowledge of the game).

 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock


It's not so much the pre-game adjustments I'm talking about here, it's the in-game adjustments. Such as keeping the FB back to block on passing plays (paying particular attention to the one man wrecking crew).


:thumb:

This is the first time you've brought up actually what you want to see included in the game. In which case you make fair and valid points. Or fairly valid, one of the two. The new AI will effectively allow you to more accurately gameplan for the DE by letting you select your formation. Whether there'll be an option to include a 'focus' for your FB is another matter entirely. It'd be a good suggestion.

However it will always be limited, in terms of a simulation, in that there will never be the fine controls of football once you're into the actual match.

Originally posted by Warlock
The players you mention, get game-planned for extensively... sometimes it works (like the Giants vs Brady) and other times it doesn't (like the Bears vs Manning). Look at what teams do to prevent Hester from running back kicks, they shank the kicks on purpose. This is all game-planning, an option that isn't available, in regards to lineman. When the Bears didn't respect Steve Smith enough to alter their game-plan, in the 05 play-offs, he roasted them. That's an example of bad coaching. On the opposite end of the spectrum, teams that do game-plan properly can shut down marquee players (such as the AP example someone brought up earlier in this thread, only gaining 70 yards)... although, this usually gives a different player a good chance of beating you instead.


One mans bad coaching, is another mans gameplanning. You could argue Brady vs Giants was down to bad coaching as much as the Bears vs Smith. All depends on how you approach it.

What inclusion/option would you like to see for O-Linemen?

Originally posted by Warlock
We knew Julius Dee was a really good DE, but tell me what could we have done, even if we wanted to make adjustments for him.

Combine both of these issues and you have a severe problem.


You could have done any number of things. Whether any of them would have worked is another matter entirely. The same game replayed could result in an entirely different output of individual stats, the sacks might end up more shared out, or your LT might shock block him into place a few times and sap Dee's confidence.

I don't know your team settings. I know what I suspect happened (your O-Line was Run Focus, and when you went to the pass you got creamed by an already dominate Defence). How would I have gameplanned for it? I don't know. But I have to ask the question again - did the team gameplan for him at all? What was the team expected to do? Did you have auto-adjust on at all?

Just because he did this, doesn't mean it was somehow pre-determined as something that would happen every time. It was a combination of factors.

Originally posted by Warlock
Why do you keep thinking that I actually care about the results of the game in question?


I don't, and don't believe I have mentioned that fact once. But thanks for that.

Originally posted by Warlock
Win or lose, it doesn't F-ing matter, I just want some accuracy in the sim...


What would this 'accuracy' be? Fewer sacks? Fewer anomalous results? Or would you like additional options added? In which case you've been in the wrong forum for quite some time now.

Originally posted by Warlock
why is that such a problem for you? Do you honestly believe that 10 int games and 6 sacks by a single player, should be commonplace in the play-offs?


How common are they? Seriously. How many times has it happened in the 1672 play-off games this season? I can vouch it didn't happen at all in Europe West AA2. At a random sample it didn't happen in any of the other BBB games, and I can't see any 10 interceptions either. Not even in USA Pro.

Originally posted by Warlock
Going by the NFL standard, that everyone keeps referring to, those types of things rarely ever happen.


You do realise that GLB has simulated in 80 days more games than have been played in the NFL's entire span? Over 75,000 games have been simmed...give or take a few thousand. That's very possibly more games than have ever been played in the NFL and College football added together.

Based on the fact that Derrick Thomas once got 7 sacks in 1990 (and they only started counting them in what, '87?) that's 1 instance in a total of maybe 270 games.

So extrapolated over GLB...there'll be or has been 277 of those, and approximately 137 of those per season will be the going rate, without ever becoming unrealistic.

Of course that's without considering the fact that GLB players are not at "NFL" level yet. I'm not a college football fan, but I presume at that level there have been a significantly higher number of high sack games.

Originally posted by Warlock
I also gave multiple reasons why they are that rare.


Not really.

Originally posted by Warlock
Based on your lack of regard for these points, I assume that you never played competitive football at a high level.


What qualifies as high? And does it have to be "football"? How about 3 regional awards for running, 4 Soccer, 3 Rugby and a smattering of basketball, cricket and hockey awards? How about winning every trophy with West Ham Utd on Championship Manager '99, with 97 games unbeaten?

Originally posted by Warlock
If you had, you'd understand how important these things are.


What things. You've made a couple of suggestions, on page 4 now, but otherwise just tossed out accusations of initially something being "fishy" and subsequently that the game is unrealistic with halfbaked evidence.

Originally posted by Warlock
If I had to guess, you seem like an armchair QB that repeats the garbage that they hear on ESPN to their friends (hoping to appear, like you have real knowledge of the game).


I'm British.

I don't have ESPN.

I don't read NFL Network.

My friends would vouch that I don't have any, if I had any.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
I guess it's partially my fault, assuming that most people here, would have a pretty good understanding of what I have been saying all along... I guess I should have spelled it out for the low football IQ people.

I've been saying all along that the sim isn't accurate or realistic. Based on an extensive knowledge of football, this is true and I doubt anyone would disagree with me on this. Since you have no real knowledge of the game (as a player), you merely assumed that I was talking specifically about only the mathematics. I'm not an idiot, one cannot argue mathematics intelligently. I'm not stupid enough to think that perceived anomalies, are nothing other than the laws of probability.

See, this is where you just don't get it... the game is borked. It's borked for the reasons I've already explained. The sim is inaccurate, because the variables are incorrect. Football is a much more complex sport than the average fan will every really understand. That's been clearly shown in this thread. It's not merely a game where two teams of 11 players, all line up across from one another and attempt to beat (not literally) the person standing directly in front of them. There are individual battles yes, but there are also deep strategies. Many similar to warfare... like turning a front to over-powered an enemy flank, even if it exposes a weakness in your own line. The football equivalent, would be a play that relies on misdirection.

The points I brought up aren't suggestions, they're the core of what makes football, football. This is why there was confusion on my part initially, I assumed that these aspects are part of the sim. So, when I didn't see these things being done, I thought something was "fishy". Now, I know that fish, wasn't what I smelled...

As for the team settings... I know for a fact that the LTs were set to pass block (I believe at least one other OL position and the HBs, were also set to pass block). Not that it really matters though.

So tell me again, how my evidence is half-baked, when you don't even have the slightest clue what makes football realistic? And no, none of those sports you listed are anything like American football. Football is heavily dependent on teamwork and precision.

Every play in football, has three phases... strategy, execution and the result. Within each of those phases are many variables, but very rarely are things purely luck. Right now, the sim is heavily luck dependent. Such as confidence and vision... this isn't to say that probability doesn't influence things, but I firmly believe the probability has entirely too much weight. For example, regardless of how bad an OL's vision is, he should never miss a blocking assignment. That isn't to say that he'll be able to pick up a stunt, blitz, double team, trap block or second-level defender though. The guy is generally standing right in front of him, barring the listed circumstances. The first and second sack given up, was the LT completely blowing his assignment... that's complete and utter horse shit. Which in turn ruined the LT's confidence (which then, due to the unrealistic influence of confidence, made the LT pretty much worthless for the rest of the game). So if the sim caused that, there's a major problem.

Did I spell it out enough for you now? Or will you continue to believe you know better, based on your very limited understanding of football?
 
Kyndig
offline
Link
 
I don't want to get too far into this one because quite frankly I am probably in over my head(I have absolutely ZERO football experience), but that is a really really good point Koncorde brought up about the # of games simmed and that you are bound to see some results that are a little wonky after simming near to a hundred thousand games.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kyndig
I don't want to get too far into this one because quite frankly I am probably in over my head(I have absolutely ZERO football experience), but that is a really really good point Koncorde brought up about the # of games simmed and that you are bound to see some results that are a little wonky after simming near to a hundred thousand games.


Yes, over that big of a sample size, anomalies will happen... like I said, I'm not going to argue mathematics, because it's a futile effort. Looking at only stats, is ignorant though, because they don't ever tell the entire story. Look at the plays themselves and you should see exactly what I'm talking about. As I explained, I assumed people had a pretty good understanding of football (my train of thought was, why else would they be part of a football sim). So I didn't go into great detail in my initial post... as the thread progressed and I realized how little some people actual know about football, my explanations have gotten larger, in an attempt to educate them.

From a purely mathematical standpoint, based only on the stats... he's 100% correct. Unfortunately, football is a game where luck has very little to do with it (aside from how the ball bounces or injuries, I'd say that luck has almost nothing to do with it). Everything else is planned... success comes from who planned and executed better (or executed at the better times). I don't consider that luck. In a sim there has to be randomness, the problem is when the randomness is so great, that it removes the other elements.

Simulation: the representation of the behavior or characteristics of one system through the use of another system, esp. a computer program designed for the purpose.

The sim, is not accurately, representing the behavior or characteristics of a football game. Granted this is beta and all that jazz... I don't think some sort of answer is unreasonable. At least something more than "you're stupid, deal". Which is how I interpret, the responses from the devs, that I've found thus far.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.