User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > INT's coming at a high rate in playoffs
Page:
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mark_NH

Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Mark_NH


don't even try to say nothing is different.


Nothing is different.

Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by HydrOshocK


Well you'll have to forgive us for being skeptical considering the glaring differences in league wide passing stats between last season and this one. Add in all the talk we were hearing last season about how certain people didn't feel like our lower level QBs should be converting over 50% of their passes and playing as good as they were and I'm sure you can see how we've come to that conclusion.

Yeah, but I guess if you say so......


I didn't say it was the same as last season. I said it the playoff sim is the same as the reg season one from this season.




ohhhh... you mean the changes were in season 3... like week 15? That's about the time I noticed a 30-40% drop in my QBs performance...

hey, I understand this game is ever evolving... that's part of the intrigue. But, I guess I(as well as others) just want to adjust to "known" changes. It's all cool if you don't wanna throw out a bone and give it to us too easily. Is it confidence, speed, agility? Pass length? Or something funky with advanced tactics? Just a hint?
I am just frustrated we're going into the conference championship game(vs. a rivalry) with a feeling of flying blind...

But, 100-300 FP can buy my love any day, Bort!


 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mark_NH

ohhhh... you mean the changes were in season 3... like week 15? That's about the time I noticed a 30-40% drop in my QBs performance...

hey, I understand this game is ever evolving... that's part of the intrigue. But, I guess I(as well as others) just want to adjust to "known" changes. It's all cool if you don't wanna throw out a bone and give it to us too easily. Is it confidence, speed, agility? Pass length? Or something funky with advanced tactics? Just a hint?
I am just frustrated we're going into the conference championship game(vs. a rivalry) with a feeling of flying blind...

But, 100-300 FP can buy my love any day, Bort!


I have a problem with things changing without pointers from the developers on how to cope with the changes. Clearly the passing game has changed (our completion rate dropped drastically in the last half of the season.)

I have real concerns about the offseason - Bort has stated changes will be made, which will affect builds. If you're level 1-16, this doesn't make much difference, because you level up fast enough that you can change your build to suit the changes, but if you're level 20+, you're going to get minimal level ups next year, and since you built to take advantage of the current sim, it'll be hard to correct course next season. I understand the game is in flux, but since we're paying for it, there is more responsibility on Bort's part make sure the sim changes don't adversely affect the players. I think whatever happened mid season did adversely affect the players - there are too many reports of the passing game dropping off for it to be mass hysteria and whining. (And BTW, if this is a beta game, as we keep hearing, then everyone should be reporting problems they are seeing. It's not whining, it's called being a beta tester.)

T
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Did you ever think to consider you need higher confidence to perform better in the playoffs? I mean it's alot of pressure.
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr
Originally posted by Mark_NH


ohhhh... you mean the changes were in season 3... like week 15? That's about the time I noticed a 30-40% drop in my QBs performance...

hey, I understand this game is ever evolving... that's part of the intrigue. But, I guess I(as well as others) just want to adjust to "known" changes. It's all cool if you don't wanna throw out a bone and give it to us too easily. Is it confidence, speed, agility? Pass length? Or something funky with advanced tactics? Just a hint?
I am just frustrated we're going into the conference championship game(vs. a rivalry) with a feeling of flying blind...

But, 100-300 FP can buy my love any day, Bort!


I have a problem with things changing without pointers from the developers on how to cope with the changes. Clearly the passing game has changed (our completion rate dropped drastically in the last half of the season.)

I have real concerns about the offseason - Bort has stated changes will be made, which will affect builds. If you're level 1-16, this doesn't make much difference, because you level up fast enough that you can change your build to suit the changes, but if you're level 20+, you're going to get minimal level ups next year, and since you built to take advantage of the current sim, it'll be hard to correct course next season. I understand the game is in flux, but since we're paying for it, there is more responsibility on Bort's part make sure the sim changes don't adversely affect the players. I think whatever happened mid season did adversely affect the players - there are too many reports of the passing game dropping off for it to be mass hysteria and whining. (And BTW, if this is a beta game, as we keep hearing, then everyone should be reporting problems they are seeing. It's not whining, it's called being a beta tester.)

T


Originally posted by Bort


No, the only think I monkeyed with, really, was trying to fix the elusive back problem where they dance around too much, get them to run forward and maybe break some tackles, etc. I haven't touched the passing or coverage side of things all season.


Nothing happened mid season.
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Did you ever think to consider you need higher confidence to perform better in the playoffs? I mean it's alot of pressure.


The drop off occurred prior to the playoffs. Plus I recall reading that the sim didn't change from regular season to post season, so why would the need for confidence go up? If it did, that should be in a FAQ somewhere. I don't expect to be told how to play the game, but I do expect accurate pointers. I would say about 90% of what you read in the forums is pure conjecture.

T
 
Goober Man
offline
Link
 
It could be because your QB's play was set to HARD and he tired out in the 2nd half. Thats what happend to my QB.
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 

Out of the 4 teams that were promoted from their respective leagues in BBB to A#1 this season, 3 of us made the playoffs and we all got beat in the 1st round, with a combined turnover ratio of 16-3 against. All three of ours were season 2 teams and we all struggled with a higher turnover ratio than the season 1 teams that were veterans of the A#1 (originally the CCC). That was to be expected, but what we didn't expect is that the difference would be that drastic.

Since all of us were championship teams I'm sure we all had our bread and butter plays that we knew we should still be able to work with...instead it appeared even those options were taken away by the sim, and it was not always against superior talent. Several games we even had match up opportunities in our favor, yet for some reason we were still prone to a sporadic sim that often had us averaging ridiculous turnover #s. My QB suddenly struggled to maintain a 50% completion average even though his build and special abilities should have been improving the entire offense's performance.

In season 2 (0ur inaugural season) Reeko was legitimately over 60% against equal competition and had double the TDs as INTs. This season his QB rating dropped right at 20 points and he threw more INTs than TDs. Even though he was able to top 50% completions it was an ugly accomplishment.

There are all kinds of factors that could contribute to that, and a large part will obviously be the level difference between us and the season 1 teams, but everyone always says that a 1-2 level gap can be overcome with better builds and game planning. Nothing against my current competition but they haven't shown me anything that says their builds or game planning are that much better than mine. Every team we lost to was a championship contender and every game could've gone our way but was sabotaged by ridiculous turnovers.

Since my players are much better than they were in season 2 when it comes to build, that tells me the only logical answers are either level difference (a gap which supposedly could be overcome) or a change in the sim that effects passing until very specific build requirements are met....my guess is the latter. That's all well and good because it gives us a new challenge to meet, but how fair is it that it wasn't explained to us in detail, and there doesn't seem to be anything we can do about it at the moment.

Is it just a matter of finally closing the XP gap until our players are of equal level? If so then why all the talk about beating that with better builds and planning, and isn't that somewhat biased to the Alpha and Season 1 teams? Or if it's a sim change, then how about a better explanation in the offseason so us smart folks have a chance to get ahead of the curve please?

Not pissed, just trying to understand the logic and find a way to beat it.
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr
Originally posted by Mark_NH


ohhhh... you mean the changes were in season 3... like week 15? That's about the time I noticed a 30-40% drop in my QBs performance...

hey, I understand this game is ever evolving... that's part of the intrigue. But, I guess I(as well as others) just want to adjust to "known" changes. It's all cool if you don't wanna throw out a bone and give it to us too easily. Is it confidence, speed, agility? Pass length? Or something funky with advanced tactics? Just a hint?
I am just frustrated we're going into the conference championship game(vs. a rivalry) with a feeling of flying blind...

But, 100-300 FP can buy my love any day, Bort!


I have a problem with things changing without pointers from the developers on how to cope with the changes. Clearly the passing game has changed (our completion rate dropped drastically in the last half of the season.)

I have real concerns about the offseason - Bort has stated changes will be made, which will affect builds. If you're level 1-16, this doesn't make much difference, because you level up fast enough that you can change your build to suit the changes, but if you're level 20+, you're going to get minimal level ups next year, and since you built to take advantage of the current sim, it'll be hard to correct course next season. I understand the game is in flux, but since we're paying for it, there is more responsibility on Bort's part make sure the sim changes don't adversely affect the players. I think whatever happened mid season did adversely affect the players - there are too many reports of the passing game dropping off for it to be mass hysteria and whining. (And BTW, if this is a beta game, as we keep hearing, then everyone should be reporting problems they are seeing. It's not whining, it's called being a beta tester.)

T


+10 well said
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Did you ever think to consider you need higher confidence to perform better in the playoffs? I mean it's alot of pressure.


Of course we've considered that. But like we're saying, when you've spent a lot of time and money to adapt to the way the sim was it makes it that much harder for you to alter course when your players are all in the 20s and leveling up much slower. The only thing you can do is rearrange equipment and that hits you in the bank roll, since you usually have to hand out bonuses to accomplish that, which in turn requires a higher daily/yearly salary for your players. So you see, it's a domino effect that causes problems from a lot of stand points.
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity


Originally posted by Bort



No, the only think I monkeyed with, really, was trying to fix the elusive back problem where they dance around too much, get them to run forward and maybe break some tackles, etc. I haven't touched the passing or coverage side of things all season.


Nothing happened mid season.


If you say so. Our QB results look like this:
First four games: 65.08PCT average - 9TD, 1 int - 1 playoff team
Second four games: 57.38PCT average - 4 TD, 5 int - 3 playoff teams
Third four games: 66.4PCT average - 12 TD, 2 int - 2 playoff teams
Last four games: 53.83PCT average - 4 TD, 6 int - 2 playoff teams
Playoffs (3 games): 52.6PCT average - 4 TD, 7 int

That's more ints in the last seven games than in the first 12. That's a drop of 15% in PCT.

Maybe it's just better competition, maybe it's raw luck, but I'm hearing a lot of complaints (some of which may be unfounded, I agree) so it seems like something changed.

I think an easy solution would be to sim a scrimmage between members of our own teams on off game nights. That would allow us to test builds and tactics scientifically, instead of the click and pray system that is currently in place. If our QB dropped off against our secondary, then I could at least say...hmmm, they raised attribute X, let's work on Y with our WRs and QB and see if we can beat that. Right now we have no idea what the opponents builds are like so the only thing we can think when a player stops making plays is that the sim has changed.

I'm not bitching, btw. This is a great game, and I'm enjoying it, but I want to enjoy it more and the best way to do that is to understand it.

T
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Goober Man
It could be because your QB's play was set to HARD and he tired out in the 2nd half. Thats what happend to my QB.


Actually, often we do better in the second half. In our last game especially. This suggestion illustrates my point, however. This is just more speculation because we can't know how tired the players are at any given time in the game, and we can't know what our attributes are compared to the competition - so there's no way of knowing what works and what doesn't. And if you find something that works, and then something changes, there's no way of accurately fixing it. We know the animations are inaccurate, so you can't even look at those and say "oh look, he's too slow" or whatever.

Once again, not bitching, just want to make this better.

T
Last edited Jul 19, 2008 15:13:29
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr
I think whatever happened mid season did adversely affect the players - there are too many reports of the passing game dropping off for it to be mass hysteria and whining. (And BTW, if this is a beta game, as we keep hearing, then everyone should be reporting problems they are seeing. It's not whining, it's called being a beta tester.)

T


Soooo what you're saying is that some point between point A and point B something changed.

So lets see...

Point A - Level 15
Point B - Level 17

Wait, I think I've found something that changed!

I appreciate the point you're on about with regards to the building to suit the sim. But in a lot of cases those people who are adversely affected have built in a way that exploits some element of the gameplan. Which is fine. But if it's then amended in order to reward other elements then that's the right thing to do. Otherwise everybody will just make cookie cutter players to exploit it.
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
Nothing happened mid season.


Nope, it happened pre-season and it just took a while for some people to figure out. My only complaint is that you devs and mods knew we weren't happy with the talk about changing QB play, and we thought that you heard our voice in the matter. Apparently not. No offense Serenity, but you're way too quick to write off a legitimate complaint with a bad build or game plan excuse. Just because it may or may not effect you personally doesn't mean it's not a legitimate complaint.

Like I said, we were under the assumption that changes wouldn't be made that would negatively impact a veteran team like that because there was no confirmation of anything specific. All of the changes were supposed to be for chemistry, energy, or collusion and team stacking. Now we're finding out that's not exactly the case and that's kinda disappointing considering some of us have a pretty large financial investment in this game.

Like I've said before....like it or not, your product is now driven by supply and demand. You can't keep it in beta forever, or hope for long term financial success if you don't have a much more open dialog with your investors.

.02


 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde

Soooo what you're saying is that some point between point A and point B something changed.

So lets see...

Point A - Level 15
Point B - Level 17

Wait, I think I've found something that changed!


That would hold if the defense all leveled up from 15 to 17 and the offense stayed at 15, but clearly that doesn't happen. Everyone should be getting better.

T
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr
If you say so. Our QB results look like this:
First four games: 65.08PCT average - 9TD, 1 int - 1 playoff team
Second four games: 57.38PCT average - 4 TD, 5 int - 3 playoff teams
Third four games: 66.4PCT average - 12 TD, 2 int - 2 playoff teams
Last four games: 53.83PCT average - 4 TD, 6 int - 2 playoff teams
Playoffs (3 games): 52.6PCT average - 4 TD, 7 int

T


When you beat San Diego, a team that you threw 1 Int against early in the season, then throw 1Int against in the playoff win. What did you attribute their Interceptions to?
Last edited Jul 19, 2008 15:19:34
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.