User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > ATTN: Tying Flex Points to Contracts as an Incentive or Condition
Page:
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk
I guess the rule is fine. Just seems largely pointless. No way to police AIM conversations or emails, that's for sure.


You're right. But that's like saying "it's raining, my feet are going to get wet, so screw it, I'm not going to use an umbrella even though it'll keep the rest of my body dry."


I'm on a roll with these analogies
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk
I guess the rule is fine. Just seems largely pointless. No way to police AIM conversations or emails, that's for sure.


That's the point I made in the discussion. Now every "Can I have your AIM?", "Post your email here" forum thread or PM has to be suspected of FP contracts and researched, and if it isn't then the rule is more or less a waste of time.

To Jed
I'm curious as to "how serious it is". In the entire thread morgan3 had I saw exactly one accusation against one person, and methinks if it was serious enough to warrant a complete rule implementation you need more than one guy saying one thing.

Furthermore, there are far too many "he cheated" topics that immediately receive "Ban him!" condemnations without any research into the topic. I'm hesitant to give those kinds of people that kind of power.
 
hud
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by norsemanvike

Q: How does one do this magical "transfer between friends"? Or is this just an instance where you can buy your friend xome flex points using his account or giving him money via paypal?
A: The second half or your question is your answer.


and please, please remember that you still do this at your own risk, which is a high risk. GLB will not help when people complain that they got hosed by there e-friend. You can still get burned, and even this is discouraged. Make sure you completely trust this person, and even then, beware.
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
This was implemented after I had a talk with Tim Harper after an FP contract thread was closed and morgan showed that PM.

I'm not sure what thread your talking about l0l.
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
Explain why owners doing this is bad?

There are countless "We need no boost leagues" threads and so on, because people complain of the "unfair advantage" given to those willing to pay for flex points to boost and customize their players. Is that next to go out the window?

I just don't get why it's bad if an owner says "Come play with us I'll buy your boosts." I can see where it's bad if one side doesn't live up to their end of the bargain, but IMO that's why there should be flex points contracts to begin with.

Just seems silly and pointless. Almost like someone with the ear of those in charge got strung out by someone else in his league, and suddenly...."Oh, we better do something about this." I even remember seeing some sort of official post somewhere that said somewhere that the site wasn't responsible for boost-promises that went unfulfilled, and that you should do them at your own risk.

What important person is getting effed over that the policy suddenly need "revising"?
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by superpunk

I guess the rule is fine. Just seems largely pointless. No way to police AIM conversations or emails, that's for sure.


That's the point I made in the discussion. Now every "Can I have your AIM?", "Post your email here" forum thread or PM has to be suspected of FP contracts and researched, and if it isn't then the rule is more or less a waste of time.

To Jed
I'm curious as to "how serious it is". In the entire thread morgan3 had I saw exactly one accusation against one person, and methinks if it was serious enough to warrant a complete rule implementation you need more than one guy saying one thing.

Furthermore, there are far too many "he cheated" topics that immediately receive "Ban him!" condemnations without any research into the topic. I'm hesitant to give those kinds of people that kind of power.


Since it's impossible to police everything off-site, there's no way to look into/research a case based on that as the only evidence, so no, that won't waste time.

As for how serious it is, if it's to the point where even one person is actually publicly advertising it on this site, it's serious enough to be dealt with.

And rest assured, we put no stock in people who run around screaming "BAN!!" all the time. We have a set of rules and a large set of penalties which can be given for breaking those rules and only dole out punishment when those are broken, not when we're told to ban someone.
 
Norsemanvike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk
I guess the rule is fine. Just seems largely pointless. No way to police AIM conversations or emails, that's for sure.


As hard as it may be, it normally leaks out, somehow someway. It's like people who create a facade of themselves for new people. Eventually, they won't be able to maintain that facade and their true colors will come through. For the chronic abusers, it's just a matter of time. But at least they'll know in the back of their minds, they'll have to ask if it's worth the risk for this player or that player? Can they trust them to keep their secret for the duration of GLB?

We will suspend/ban a player 2, 3, 4+ months from now based on evidence that can be traced back today, tonight, or this off-season. The database transaction logs are detailed enough to do it if we needed to go back that far.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk
Explain why owners doing this is bad?


Because if this were to be the mainstream norm, then the best players would just go play for the owners who will pay the most real money. In turn, the only way to recruit would be to offer as large FP contracts as possible. It happened in Cyberdunk and really hurt that game.
 
hud
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by superpunk

Explain why owners doing this is bad?


the mainstream norm


That is what these rule will prevent. Obviously some will try and circumvent these rules, and maybe one will get away with it. But these rules makes sure that this will not become the norm here and rip apart the creators intention for this game.

 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by superpunk

Explain why owners doing this is bad?


Because if this were to be the mainstream norm, then the best players would just go play for the owners who will pay the most real money. In turn, the only way to recruit would be to offer as large FP contracts as possible. It happened in Cyberdunk and really hurt that game.


It's like being the Yankees. The owners willing to spend the much will generally have the best players. The team owners willing to spend the much will generally have the best teams.

I don't understand why that's bad, or how opposing it doesn't make you a communist , but then again I don't know what Cyberdunk is.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
I'd like to report every person that owns every player on their team for using FP contracts. I mean, think about it: They bought FP for that player's owner for the sole reason of getting that player on that team. Doesn't that break this rule?
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk
I don't understand why that's bad, or how opposing it doesn't make you a communist


Think about every sport that has a salary cap
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Well in the NFL it doesn't matter how rich the owner is, he gets no unfair advantage in recruiting because of money. Baseball has the most ludicrous collective bargaining agreement of any sport with a meaningless soft cap that people can just circumvent or run roughshod over at will, so I think using baseball as an example of a good system to run is not the greatest idea.
Last edited Jul 11, 2008 16:00:55
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
I'd like to report every person that owns every player on their team for using FP contracts. I mean, think about it: They bought FP for that player's owner for the sole reason of getting that player on that team. Doesn't that break this rule?


No, because if those players didn't (re)sign there because they were given FP
 
GmanV2
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
OK, fair enough. I'm happy a clear ruling was made on this, and also happy to see further clarification provided.

So, my idea when I get a team, to reward my MVP and Offense/Defense MVPs every season with paypal xfer loot for FPs (or w/e they want to do with it) will be ok, so long as it's never tied to extending or anything else?

That seems awright to me.

@Oldskool - I think this rule works from the perspective of certain RL laws, like the one against Necrophilia for instance, sure, the authorities aren't going to constantly search for late night funeral home orgies, but it's nice to know that if they found out about one, they could immediately arrest all those sick stiff stuffers.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.