only 22 speed :'(
Forum > Suggestions > Controlling a Player's Weight (Diet)
Raid
offline
offline
my perfect build:
5'5" 390 LBS RB
100 str. 10 agi
25 speed 100 carry
100 confidence 100 vision
all specs in bottom rung for POWER
5'5" 390 LBS RB
100 str. 10 agi
25 speed 100 carry
100 confidence 100 vision
all specs in bottom rung for POWER
bigtony2tone
offline
offline
Way to kill the thread. I never want to see the ability to just choose your height/weight from the beginning. I would like to be able to reroll a 5'9" RB, but that's currently not available. I seriously hope this idea (mine in particular) gets taken seriously by Bort.
The greatest part of all is, no current players would be negatively affected, as you'd have a max/min for every position on weight, and you'd just get to start "training" your weight program once it'd be implemented. It'd also give higher level players something to do. You could fluctuate your weight each year based on what your team is looking for. Say your team wants your OT a bit faster/quicker. Work on losing weight. Your strength would drop slightly every night (based on level and training intensity, say .2 strength loss?) and your speed and/or agility would increase the same amount.
I got my fingers crossed.
The greatest part of all is, no current players would be negatively affected, as you'd have a max/min for every position on weight, and you'd just get to start "training" your weight program once it'd be implemented. It'd also give higher level players something to do. You could fluctuate your weight each year based on what your team is looking for. Say your team wants your OT a bit faster/quicker. Work on losing weight. Your strength would drop slightly every night (based on level and training intensity, say .2 strength loss?) and your speed and/or agility would increase the same amount.
I got my fingers crossed.
kretchfoop
offline
offline
I would sign him...most likely put him in the FB position and adjust tactics accordingly.
kretchfoop
offline
offline
Originally posted by bigtony2tone
Way to kill the thread. I never want to see the ability to just choose your height/weight from the beginning. I would like to be able to reroll a 5'9" RB, but that's currently not available. I seriously hope this idea (mine in particular) gets taken seriously by Bort.
The greatest part of all is, no current players would be negatively affected, as you'd have a max/min for every position on weight, and you'd just get to start "training" your weight program once it'd be implemented. It'd also give higher level players something to do. You could fluctuate your weight each year based on what your team is looking for. Say your team wants your OT a bit faster/quicker. Work on losing weight. Your strength would drop slightly every night (based on level and training intensity, say .2 strength loss?) and your speed and/or agility would increase the same amount.
I got my fingers crossed.
This thread is basically just a free for all on how to make size more important. I appreciate your input. This is an avenue that should at least be explored (if it hasn't been already).
Way to kill the thread. I never want to see the ability to just choose your height/weight from the beginning. I would like to be able to reroll a 5'9" RB, but that's currently not available. I seriously hope this idea (mine in particular) gets taken seriously by Bort.
The greatest part of all is, no current players would be negatively affected, as you'd have a max/min for every position on weight, and you'd just get to start "training" your weight program once it'd be implemented. It'd also give higher level players something to do. You could fluctuate your weight each year based on what your team is looking for. Say your team wants your OT a bit faster/quicker. Work on losing weight. Your strength would drop slightly every night (based on level and training intensity, say .2 strength loss?) and your speed and/or agility would increase the same amount.
I got my fingers crossed.
This thread is basically just a free for all on how to make size more important. I appreciate your input. This is an avenue that should at least be explored (if it hasn't been already).
vrock627
offline
offline
i like this idea, but there would need to be a weight cap, then things would be kinda weird, with all the Linemen the same size... but if there wasnt a weight cap you would see some dude name "Tubby McTubberson" who would weigh 2000 lbs.
oh sorry just noticed someone posted about weight cap above me
oh sorry just noticed someone posted about weight cap above me
Last edited Jul 12, 2008 02:26:18
kretchfoop
offline
offline
If this were done correctly, weight would be important at the very early levels (as a bigger HB would become stronger more quickly). At the later levels, this would be one more thing for players to do (as the leveling becomes very cumbersome) and feel like they actually should be checking in on their players.
Amyrlin
offline
offline
I like this idea. It opens up more ways to diversify the offensive line, which is a good thing. oldskool mentioned something to the effect of "all offensive linemen will be the max weight" - I disagree with that. If weight has a negative effect on agility and speed and a positive effect on strength, we'll start to see real differences between pure strength o-linemen (aka inside run blockers), balanced o-linemen (aka pass blockers), and speedy/agile o-linemen with less strength (aka outside run blockers).
I don't think there should be a hard weight cap - that would lead to a bunch of players all being the same weight. Instead, it should be exponentially harder to gain/lose weight as you move farther from your initial starting weight - so an NT who rolled 280lbs to start might 'max out' around 325lbs, while an NT who rolled 300lbs to start might 'max out' around 345lbs.
I'm thinking that weight management would be like training - there are 3 options, corresponding to Gain Weight, Maintain Weight, and Lose Weight (perhaps Protein, Balanced, and Carbs, respectively? I realize that's not the most realistic assessment of gaining/losing weight, but it gives the names more interest as well as makes them intuitive - most people will understand that Protein -> Big Muscles, Carbs -> More Energy -> Faster. I'm going with this.)
Intially Balanced is free, and Protein and Carbs are both relatively cheap. As you increase/decrease your weight, further increases/decreases become more expensive - for example, if you're bulking up, Carbs may cost $20 the first day, $22 the second, $25 the third, $35 the fourth, etc. - with the rate of increase accelerating, and rate of return decelerating. The opposite will get more expensive but more slowly - with a Protein diet, the cost of Carbs might be $20-$21-$22-$24 etc. The justification for the increasing cost on both ends is that as you get heavier/lighter from your natural weight, it requires ever more specialized products to gain/lose weight without an adverse effect on game form.
There is a hidden 'normal' range for each player, based on his starting 'base' weight. In this normal range, a Balanced maintains the player's weight. Outside of the range, a Balanced diet naturally brings the player's weight back into the range.
This is also a nice money sink. A pro team might want its defensive tackles to remain as heavy as possible. Well, as the DTs consume Protein, it gets more and more expensive - first more expensive to gain weight, then more expensive to even maintain it. Thus, the team has to choose whether to subsidize its DTs' $1500-a-day protein expenditures, or pay less and have more money for other uses.
I don't think there should be a hard weight cap - that would lead to a bunch of players all being the same weight. Instead, it should be exponentially harder to gain/lose weight as you move farther from your initial starting weight - so an NT who rolled 280lbs to start might 'max out' around 325lbs, while an NT who rolled 300lbs to start might 'max out' around 345lbs.
I'm thinking that weight management would be like training - there are 3 options, corresponding to Gain Weight, Maintain Weight, and Lose Weight (perhaps Protein, Balanced, and Carbs, respectively? I realize that's not the most realistic assessment of gaining/losing weight, but it gives the names more interest as well as makes them intuitive - most people will understand that Protein -> Big Muscles, Carbs -> More Energy -> Faster. I'm going with this.)
Intially Balanced is free, and Protein and Carbs are both relatively cheap. As you increase/decrease your weight, further increases/decreases become more expensive - for example, if you're bulking up, Carbs may cost $20 the first day, $22 the second, $25 the third, $35 the fourth, etc. - with the rate of increase accelerating, and rate of return decelerating. The opposite will get more expensive but more slowly - with a Protein diet, the cost of Carbs might be $20-$21-$22-$24 etc. The justification for the increasing cost on both ends is that as you get heavier/lighter from your natural weight, it requires ever more specialized products to gain/lose weight without an adverse effect on game form.
There is a hidden 'normal' range for each player, based on his starting 'base' weight. In this normal range, a Balanced maintains the player's weight. Outside of the range, a Balanced diet naturally brings the player's weight back into the range.
This is also a nice money sink. A pro team might want its defensive tackles to remain as heavy as possible. Well, as the DTs consume Protein, it gets more and more expensive - first more expensive to gain weight, then more expensive to even maintain it. Thus, the team has to choose whether to subsidize its DTs' $1500-a-day protein expenditures, or pay less and have more money for other uses.
kretchfoop
offline
offline
Originally posted by kretchfoop
(pulling out the defibrillator)
I will not let this idea die.
(pulling out the defibrillator)
I will not let this idea die.
Last edited Jul 12, 2008 19:35:42
Alex44
offline
offline
I like the idea, and it wouldn't be that horrible for already created players seeing as they could start doing it too right now without too much difference. We are all still relatively low leveled in comparison to where we will be in a few seasons.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























