User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
hokeez
offline
Link
 
ahah! there are a few ways to get it. either go to each teams' profile page and click on team leaders at the top. then click on blocking/other. there is a column for first downs. click on that and it will show you from most-fewest first downs either by team/conference/or E.W AAA #2 if you want to look at that.

If you do it by conference or league you need to go to league leaders at top instead of team leaders, then click on blocking/other

Cooper has 105 first downs, Hokie has 86
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Gambit
QB - lots of ways of looking at QB's so let's see who stands out in different categories.

1st, productivity - VERY important.
1) Peabody 4025 yards
2) Amaya 3970 yards
3) Young II 3960 yards
4) Washim 3910 yards

2nd, % completion - not so important, as it can depend on style of offense, but generally an all-conference QB needs to have a good rating. I noticed the best QB's with 3000+ passing yards were in the 60%-65% range, so then I checked which of the above were in that range:

1) Peabody 61.1%
2) Young 61%
3) Amaya 60.8%

to me that elimated Washim, although he had 59.4% (close)

I pretty much ignored Yds/att or Yds/com as these relate to what kind of offense the team runs.

I then looked at TDs vs INTs and I saw that the best QB's had 25+ TD's but 3 had 30 or more (33, 30, 30) TD's. One of these with 30 TD's was Peabody. He also had a very respectful ratio of 14 INT's against these 30 TD's. Of the two remaining QB's, Amaya had 26 TD's against 20 INT's and Young II had 18 TD's against 26 INT's.

So my conclusion is that the best QB from Zeta is Peabody. Honorably mention to Amaya. Pohl also deserves an honorable mention for the best QB without top end passing numbers, but he can't really be considered All-Conference when you compare him to Peabody because Peabody was much more productive with 4025 yards passing and had comparably high completion percentage and TD's and TD to INT ratio.


So Pohl had more TD's, one more INT, and a higher completion % but Peabody is the clear choice?
 
hokeez
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gambit
I don't see any stats that I can use to compare Cooper's 1st downs to Ram SteelHead's 1st downs, so unless you can point me to where I can find that easily, I'm afraid it's a dead-end as a suggestion. In any case, I'm not sure what it means, except one HB happened to be subbed in more often on 1st down and another more often on 3rd down. Without situational data it's hard to evaluate. How many 3rd and 1 opportunities did each back have? How many 3rd and 2? etc. Unless the situations are comparable the number of 1st downs resulting from those situations isn't relevant.

I did go back and look to see if there was anything else relevant I should be taking into account. First, the issue has been raised that Cooper was splitting time. However, Ram SteelHead was also splitting time with William Stone, the #2 most prolific back, so Cooper's splitting time doesn't make him special in this comparison.

None of the backs seem to have any receiving stats worth mentioning, so that's not a way to find more insight.

However, I did find this: Ram SteelHead has 84!! broken tackles compared to Cooper's 44. Hokiepride has 28.

So this is the only other stat that's relevant that I missed, and once again it points to Ram SteelHead as the CLEAR choice of best HB in the conference!


maybe best power back, but not best overall back...how many missed tackles did defenders have when trying to tackle me or Coop? we dont break a lot of tackles because we are elusive backs
 
Link
 
Originally posted by hokeez
ahah! there are a few ways to get it. either go to each teams' profile page and click on team leaders at the top. then click on blocking/other. there is a column for first downs. click on that and it will show you from most-fewest first downs either by team/conference/or E.W AAA #2 if you want to look at that.

If you do it by conference or league you need to go to league leaders at top instead of team leaders, then click on blocking/other

Cooper has 105 first downs, Hokie has 86


I think its clear this guy just wants anyone besides a Pimp player. Not saying there are not good players out there that deserve it but the WR discussion really should his colors when he didn't give Preston Parker even honorable mention. And I'm sorry but for RB's, I'll 7 more TD's, 100 more yards and more first downs over a higher YPC.
 
hokeez
offline
Link
 
you also have to realize antwerp didnt have the same dominant running game that we do so of course he is going to throw for more yards than Pohl. only thing i could see is that peabody wins for having a larger portion of total offense for antwerp than pohl for the pimps, while both are clearly top 2 in zeta
 
hokeez
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dabutracing007
Originally posted by hokeez

ahah! there are a few ways to get it. either go to each teams' profile page and click on team leaders at the top. then click on blocking/other. there is a column for first downs. click on that and it will show you from most-fewest first downs either by team/conference/or E.W AAA #2 if you want to look at that.

If you do it by conference or league you need to go to league leaders at top instead of team leaders, then click on blocking/other

Cooper has 105 first downs, Hokie has 86


I think its clear this guy just wants anyone besides a Pimp player. Not saying there are not good players out there that deserve it but the WR discussion really should his colors when he didn't give Preston Parker even honorable mention. And I'm sorry but for RB's, I'll 7 more TD's, 100 more yards and more first downs over a higher YPC.


Steelhead also has 126 less carries than me, so of course he will have a higher ypc.
for backs with over 250 carries only giddy has a higher ypc than I do. and cooper is only .2 away from me
 
hokeez
offline
Link
 
i just dont see a comparision between Hokie and Steelhead to be honest. I have more yards and more touchdowns than he does, those are the 2 main factors in determining how productive a running back is.

we both lost the same amount of fumbles(2) and i averaged more ypg than he did. ypc doesnt say too much. a back with 2 carries could have a higher ypc than me if both carries went for 5 or more yards. but that doesnt mean he's better
 
Duckfan127
offline
Link
 
lets not let porto vote.
 
Duckfan127
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dabutracing007
Originally posted by Gambit

QB - lots of ways of looking at QB's so let's see who stands out in different categories.

1st, productivity - VERY important.
1) Peabody 4025 yards
2) Amaya 3970 yards
3) Young II 3960 yards
4) Washim 3910 yards

2nd, % completion - not so important, as it can depend on style of offense, but generally an all-conference QB needs to have a good rating. I noticed the best QB's with 3000+ passing yards were in the 60%-65% range, so then I checked which of the above were in that range:

1) Peabody 61.1%
2) Young 61%
3) Amaya 60.8%

to me that elimated Washim, although he had 59.4% (close)

I pretty much ignored Yds/att or Yds/com as these relate to what kind of offense the team runs.

I then looked at TDs vs INTs and I saw that the best QB's had 25+ TD's but 3 had 30 or more (33, 30, 30) TD's. One of these with 30 TD's was Peabody. He also had a very respectful ratio of 14 INT's against these 30 TD's. Of the two remaining QB's, Amaya had 26 TD's against 20 INT's and Young II had 18 TD's against 26 INT's.

So my conclusion is that the best QB from Zeta is Peabody. Honorably mention to Amaya. Pohl also deserves an honorable mention for the best QB without top end passing numbers, but he can't really be considered All-Conference when you compare him to Peabody because Peabody was much more productive with 4025 yards passing and had comparably high completion percentage and TD's and TD to INT ratio.


So Pohl had more TD's, one more INT, and a higher completion % but Peabody is the clear choice?


Honorable mention to your teams qb who sucks my team was 15-1 oh wait yours wasn't my teams a 1 seed and yours isn't. Face it Porto sucks .
Last edited Jul 13, 2008 23:50:56
 
morty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gambit
HB's

The 5 most productive HB's were

1) Hokiepride (1740)
2) William Stone (1573)
3) Graig Cooper (1535)
4) Rick Fastley (1448)
5) Ram SteelHead (1426)

All these running backs had 4 point something yards per carry except one, Ram SteelHead, with an AMAZING 6.2 yards per carry!!! SteelHead also had the least number of fumbles (4) and tied for the least number of fumbles lost (2).

Rick Fastley had 18 fumbles with 6 lost so fumbles definitely elimated him. Hokiepride (11) and William Stone (13) also had a lot of fumbles.

All the running backs had 13-15 TD's except Graig Cooper with 20. 20 TD's is an impressive feat no doubt! However, it's not as impressive as 6.2 yards per carry!! Also, while Cooper had 55% more TD's than SteelHead, he also had 75% more fumbles and 100% more fumbles lost!

The CLEAR choice for best HB in Zeta Conference is Ram SteelHead.

I think the honorable mention is best deserved by Hokiepride for being the yardage leader and having the 2nd best ypc (4.9)


I think that this is short-sighted...
You regarded only the RBs with the most accomplished yards. If you are in rushing team, you certainly will make more yards with a mediocre RB than a passing team with a good one.´
I´m puzzeled that you didn´t even mention Jack Razorback ( yes, he´s from our team ), although he´s tied no. 1 in Rushing-TDs...

Btw., are we speaking of HBs or RBs? If it´s only about HBs, then you´re definitely wrong - Ram SteelHead plays as FB

Total numbers are important, but it´s only half of the truth...
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 03:50:36
 
maizenhops
offline
Link
 
nvm
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 07:24:11
 
maizenhops
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Duckfan127
Originally posted by dabutracing007

Originally posted by Gambit


QB - lots of ways of looking at QB's so let's see who stands out in different categories.

1st, productivity - VERY important.
1) Peabody 4025 yards
2) Amaya 3970 yards
3) Young II 3960 yards
4) Washim 3910 yards

2nd, % completion - not so important, as it can depend on style of offense, but generally an all-conference QB needs to have a good rating. I noticed the best QB's with 3000+ passing yards were in the 60%-65% range, so then I checked which of the above were in that range:

1) Peabody 61.1%
2) Young 61%
3) Amaya 60.8%

to me that elimated Washim, although he had 59.4% (close)

I pretty much ignored Yds/att or Yds/com as these relate to what kind of offense the team runs.

I then looked at TDs vs INTs and I saw that the best QB's had 25+ TD's but 3 had 30 or more (33, 30, 30) TD's. One of these with 30 TD's was Peabody. He also had a very respectful ratio of 14 INT's against these 30 TD's. Of the two remaining QB's, Amaya had 26 TD's against 20 INT's and Young II had 18 TD's against 26 INT's.

So my conclusion is that the best QB from Zeta is Peabody. Honorably mention to Amaya. Pohl also deserves an honorable mention for the best QB without top end passing numbers, but he can't really be considered All-Conference when you compare him to Peabody because Peabody was much more productive with 4025 yards passing and had comparably high completion percentage and TD's and TD to INT ratio.


So Pohl had more TD's, one more INT, and a higher completion % but Peabody is the clear choice?


Honorable mention to your teams qb who sucks my team was 15-1 oh wait yours wasn't my teams a 1 seed and yours isn't. Face it Porto sucks .


yea, the true factor in how good a qb is is how he leads his team to win and pohl does that
 
T-Noles813
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dabutracing007
Originally posted by Gambit

The WR nominations are done:

Jimmy Tea and Mike Smith III just outshone everyone else this season.

Honorable mentions to Gather Moss and Hiram Post for outstanding seasons as well, and to Ocho Zinco for the best yards per catch and TD to drops ratio among receivers with over 1000 yards.

These are the top 5 from Zeta Conference, and also who I think are the top 2. Glanced at Alpha and Warren Doom, Jason T. Walker and John Hennessey deserve honorable mentions if I were to include Alpha, but Jimmy Tea and Mike Smith III still the best overall.


I don't see how you can nominate WR's and not include someone that is third in yards, tied for first in TD's, with fewer drops, a higher YPC average and a higher YAC. That would be Preston Parker. Not only that you didn't even give him honorable mention.



Yea, pretend you didnt read that. No one wants T-Noles' players in the all star team, huh?
 
Florida Tider
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hokeez
ugh this pisses me off i saw it the other day, it was in a stat column like the other regular statistics but i cant remember where i saw it now. ill let ya know if i find it


Team Leaders.
 
JudeMorrigan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by morty

Btw., are we speaking of HBs or RBs? If it´s only about HBs, then you´re definitely wrong - Ram SteelHead plays as FB


As much as I hate to disagree with you, Fearless Leader, he is a fullback but he's currently on their depth chart at running back. Of course, I'm not sure that's reason to not vote him to the probowl team as a fullback. I mean, that strategy worked for Mike Alstott for YEARS.
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 17:07:27
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.