I didn't want to poisen the OP if this thread with my thoughts, but since we're a few pages in, here goes.
All 3 contenders for best GLB franchise of all time, have arguments to be made for them being #1. Many of these arguements have been made in this thread, but to summarize...
VALHALLAPro's:-Highest WL win%
-3 straight completely dominant WL championships
Con's:-Too short a timespan
-Not enough championships ('only" 3)
-Lack of recruiting/replenishing a roster for continued excellence
-Rest of the game was not "caught up" with valhalla's builds. Not sure facing weaker competition makes you the best.
HHWCPro's:-7 WL Championships throughout the longest period of time and largest number of sims
-3 WL Silvers
-Won many Championships in what most would be considered GLB's "prime"
-Most wins in WL history
Con's:-Missed the playoffs last season
-Neither the most WL championships, nor the most dominant stretch
ODESSAPro's:-9 WL Championships
-2 WL Silvers
-Won many championships during GLB's "prime"
-Extremely dominant currently
Con's:-Are the four S40+ championships worth as much as earlier championships?
==================================================================
I think the above if the fair representation of the 3 teams, and why an argument can be made for and against them. Let me also say that I think S40+ WL championships are still worth a definite shitload in my eyes, otherwise I wouldn't still be on a personal quest for one. However whether those championships are worth as much as say a S21 championship, is a fair question.
As far as dominant stretches goes, Valhalla had a 3-peat in early WL, HHWC had a 3-peat in s17-s19, and Odessa currently has a 4-peat going s42-s45. In my eyes, HHWC had the toughest competition in that time period of the 3 streaks, as valhalla was a little earlier before all of GLB were on the right level with builds/VA/AE, and Odessa is in part benefiting from a dot shortage effecting many teams in GLB's elderly age. All 3 streaks are EXTREMELY impressive, as are all 3 franchises. However due to all of the above, I would rank GLB's top franchises of all times as follows.
1. HHWC
2. Odessa
-
-
3. Valhalla
HHWC and Odessa truly is a neck-and-neck battle. As-is HHWC is GLB's greatest franchise, and has done so much for so long to exemplify greatness. Their accomplishments impress me the most, and hence why I gave them the #1 spot.
ib4 #wiseisdumb