Originally posted by voegma
ummmm, No. Wow. I am convinced with such solid statements like that

My rebutals (and keep in mind this is not me saying there is no bug/issue don't make changes, I'm trying to point out the facts as I see them is all).
Originally posted by JoeRule124
Another extreme example. Double coverage and both players do it.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=2092444&pbp_id=6463699In support of my comments, if you follow the path the CB took if the ball was not caught by the WR, you see he goes to the exact intercept point of the pass. The SS looked to be in zone coverage so he reacted differently then the CB did which appeared to be in man coverage.
Originally posted by aaasahi
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=2070683&pbp_id=6256663
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=2070683&pbp_id=62580901st link) The dude got juked. Of course he couldn't protect like normal cause he got schooled.
2nd link) This one appears to support the "ummm, No." believers as the defender did not look to be where the ball was going to be but was simply trying to anticipate where the WR was going. It was like he failed a vision check and didn't notice the ball coming his way even.
Originally posted by voegma
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=2100657&pbp_id=6312761 Come on!!!!!! Really!In support of my comments, the defender is in the intercept path between the ball and where it would end up. The TE clearly "reached out" and snuffed that one out of the air. The ball wasn't even on the numbers to the TE, he made the play on the ball.
Originally posted by voegma
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=2100659&pbp_id=6318507Again this is in support of what I was saying for the same reasons.
Originally posted by Handmonster
I disagree and the reason is this. Anytime I've seen plays like this run, and I've seen a lot since this is the "Run up the gut" exploit of S29 for OCs, is if there is no bad pass, the completion rate is 100% in 1v1 situations. If it is a 2v1 situation and a pass deflection, it is always made by the helper on the play, not the coverage player. IMO, it is a big bug I am just not sure where.Nothing about my statements even implies that it is not something "exploitable" or whatever. And you are free to disagree but just because you don't like the way something is doesn't mean that the theory for what is going on is wrong. If you disagree with the theory please explain why and preferably some replays to backup.
Also, for all the "lots" you seen this exploit this season, I've seen "lots" this season where it was working exactly as one would expect it to run as well (as in the CB right on top and making the deflections). I've seen it on cuts, cutbacks, and straights so while I do see a bunch of replays here showing "issues" I've seen tons more in Pros that look to be working perfectly. I have see this "issue" out on the Rookie level but I never really care too much about how bad builds (which all rookie dots are by definition) do for things like this. Especially when the numbers are no better then the running abuse that goes on.