or you can just randomly position the KR and his 3 blockers...where ever and make the Kicker kick directly to the KR or at least within a few yards of him. that would be the laziest way to code this...which seems to be the norm around here.
Originally posted by DTRAIN or you can just randomly position the KR and his 3 blockers...where ever and make the Kicker kick directly to the KR or at least within a few yards of him. that would be the laziest way to code this...which seems to be the norm around here.
Thats unnecessary... Bort just needs to analyze kickoff distances and position the starting point of the returner better as well as possibly restricting the extreme directional kicking.
Originally posted by beenlurken dubc... the reason I think this is a glaring problem now is because you convinced Bort to increase the hang time on Kickoffs/Punts.
Coverage dots get down the field faster than real life coverage players so it made no sense to make KO/P hang times longer to be more realistic.
Now replays, like the one linked in the OP, look even more ridiculous because we have ridiculously long KO hang times allowing ridiculously fast coverage players even more time to get down field before the kick is fielded. The coverage players were almost traveling as fast as the ball was in flight. Just to be clear, the problem is not the coverage players its the unreasonable long hang times that do not match the speed of the game.
Also, a big part of the problem is that Bort either needs to code a minimum kick distance so all kicks travel a minimal distance to where all returners (at all levels) are able to run up and field the catch or position the returners at the 20 or 25 yardline at the lower levels considering low level kicks cant kick that far (makes no sense to start near the EZ).
Originally posted by beenlurken Thats unnecessary... Bort just needs to analyze kickoff distances and position the starting point of the returner better as well as possibly restricting the extreme directional kicking.
This would be ideal...
My main thing is giving the KR team the advantage because the K team over runs it, allowing the long return\TD
Originally posted by beenlurken Thats unnecessary... Bort just needs to analyze kickoff distances and position the starting point of the returner better as well as possibly restricting the extreme directional kicking.
thats basically the same thing im saying. randomly pick a spot for the returner and blockers to be, and kick it in that direction so that they can field the kickoff. and it should be somewhat based on the ability of the K. Same way its calculated on Punt Returns. The Punt returner is usually in a fairly good position.
What causes returners not to field the kick? Is it a vision check and they don't catch it or is it a speed thing where they don't get to the kick fast enough?
If it's the later that needs to be addressed first IMO. Return men are among the fastest on the team and it's hard to drop a ball on a player in real football (College level or above, which is what GLB is based on) because he's not fast enough to get to it.
If it's a vision check that causes them to miss it, absolutely they should have to pay for it. When a QB makes a bad read and throws a bad pass it gets picked. When the ball carrier takes a monster hit he coughs up the ball and the other team can get it. Why do returners get this "get out of jail free" card when other players don't?
Originally posted by CDZYO 1) The kick returner shouldn't run so far in front of the kick that it sails over his head. 2) If it does happen, the kickoff team should be allowed to down the ball instead of waiting for the official returner to touch it. 3) If the kickoff team is going to wait for the kick returner to touch the ball, they should still converge on the ball so that when the returner *does* touch it, he doesn't have open field in front of him.
Grant that these are sophomore-level players -- low vision, whatever. Why isn't the kickoff team playing the ball?
Even if they can't recover it because that would make it OP, at least let them down it. I know it's not the same rule as real football but would be a nice compromise so that the KO team doesn't get screwed by the KR sucking
Originally posted by John Waylon What causes returners not to field the kick? Is it a vision check and they don't catch it or is it a speed thing where they don't get to the kick fast enough?
If it's the later that needs to be addressed first IMO. Return men are among the fastest on the team and it's hard to drop a ball on a player in real football (College level or above, which is what GLB is based on) because he's not fast enough to get to it.
If it's a vision check that causes them to miss it, absolutely they should have to pay for it. When a QB makes a bad read and throws a bad pass it gets picked. When the ball carrier takes a monster hit he coughs up the ball and the other team can get it. Why do returners get this "get out of jail free" card when other players don't?
Its a strictly speed thing... GLB is insistent on having kickers suck at the lowers. At one point I believe they set a minimum kick distance (when the lolCkickers were being used to cause ff's)... I would argue it wasnt enough but will say that this problem was not as big before the changes last season as it is now. Now not only do kickers kick it so short that its difficult for speedy returners to get underneath it to field it but they allow directional kicks in the lower levels that make it almost impossible for the returns to get there running at an angle.
Another way to look at is that there is a reason kids dont play on an NFL regulation sized field growing up.
If Bort insists on having young kickers suck (I am not against this) and having them play on a huge field, then he needs to... 1. better position the returner (start him at the 25-30 yardline) in the lower levels 2. limit the kickers directional kicking to more towards the middle of the field (no more sideline ko's) 3. he needs to decrease the hang time of KO's (coverage players shouldnt be running at almost the same speed as the kick) at all levels (this one extends all the way to Pro... increasing the hang time was a horrible decision all around) 4. I would even suggest decreasing the spacing between both the coverage players and the blockers at the lower levels... it is pointless to have them span the entire width of the field.
fellas i think u might be making this too hard. lets simplify this.
just code the K to kick the ball in the general direction of the KR on all kickoffs. if they need to play with the speed/flight of the ball thats fine also. but you dont want them to eliminate the randomness of where or what side of the field to catch the kickoffs. we dont want to see just straight on kickoffs.
randomly put the KR and his 3 wall blockers back there and force the K to kick it in that general direction.