User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > This was the best suggestion on how to balance extreme attributes...
Page:
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
Just shrink the value of speed, it's the only attribute that fucks up the sim by being too high (strength maybe, but not nearly as much). guys with 10 speed need to be faster, guys with 160 need to be slower.

This has been the problem the whole time imo.
 
Rulabula
offline
Link
 
I mean come on .....look at the 50% of the GLB community. Half of them would fall into an open well.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kotoll
Which is fine Rage. If you know how to build it then you should be allowed to. Just because someone is clueless and doesn't know what levels they can take something doesn't mean it should be nerfed.

Least we get enough room to grow and make our players the way we want or at least a higher roof to push the limits.


The problem is the current SIM won't be able to handle the extreme builds and the variety of them that are now open with the new training system. So it will require Bort to make big changes to the SIM in order to adjust for them which will keep game in Beta even longer, if there really are plans to eventually come out of it.
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by chronoaug



As currently constructed, the sim can't deal with 160-170 attributes. Even if other attributes meant more, people would still have specialization guys with 160-170 (maybe not a whole fleet of them) and those guys still will break the sim as it was intended.



This is truth, because you can't get around the % bonuses from equipment and VAs. For instance, let's say you increased the value of vision, tackling, and agility and reduced the value of strength and momentum in the make tackle roll. You still have a situation, where you can have a much higher number in any one of those attributes, that help keep the score from being too low. Then throw on a huge +% to that score, and the penalty for having one of those attributes very low is gone.

Originally posted by


Originally posted by KingDan23
I don't see why guys with 160-170 in one area should be unpossible, we just need to move the engine to a point where success doesn't just depend on how high your 1st/2nd attributes are.


These two posts are why I suggested making secondary attributes more important and changing the deviations that are achieved by pushing skills high. We basically need to do two things: 1. make building a lopsided/extreme dot have some sort of cost, and 2. make it so that those lopsided dots aren't so amazing at the one thing they do right that they break the sim the few times during a game that they succeed. We want to do this, however, in a way that doesn't limit player choices. Putting caps on EQ, how high an attribute can go, or preventing sps being put into one attribute until another attribute is at a higher level creates those limits on play choice.

Making secondaries more important, in a way similar to what rage suggested (though maybe not so extreme), would address the first issue. A WR who wants to go 158 speed would have to be willing to put up with having a lot of passes knocked loose and fumbling the ball frequently, but would be able to use his speed to beat slower CBs.

Changing the deviations that are achieved by pushing skills high would address the second issue. If we are going to let that WR take his speed so high, we have to realize that the defensive dots he is going up against are going to have to be able to have some chance to cover him and to cover other builds that are more balanced or extreme in other areas. To allow this, we need to make the deviation in in-game speed that the WR gains from having 160 speed versus a CB with 130-140 an amount such that the WR can get some separation (and even burn the CB occassionally), but not be so fast that it's an auto-TD at least 1-2 times per game. Essentially, we need to look at the range of possible speeds (or any other attribute), and shrink that range to levels that work in the context of the sim.
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kotoll
Which is fine Rage. If you know how to build it then you should be allowed to. Just because someone is clueless and doesn't know what levels they can take something doesn't mean it should be nerfed.

Least we get enough room to grow and make our players the way we want or at least a higher roof to push the limits.


It's not just the clueless who think the current setup is a bit silly. It obviously wasn't intended but when you make archetypes to make some builds more efficient, allow for free and easier lvl72eq, an easier system to buy +3att aeq getting to 56-58atts, and make getting to lvl 72 quicker (not to mention the VAs that boost atts like streaky, the % ones, bull rusher, route run, etc...) all combined to make something not exactly intended by bort and co.

I mean, who cares. It won't really affect the game much with the exception of making coding and sim balancing a bit easier for bort.

If anything the new builds will just break the system even more requiring quicker sim changes and we all know how those go (screens this season?). Personally i'd rather this than every season or two when a new specialized archetype player comes in and makes things annoying that requires sim tweaks. Like rage was saying about his FB. I'm sure he'd rather bort just alter the way he coded and allowed for certain stacking way back when instead of waiting till it became a problem then hastily getting rid of scat back altogether.
 
HEY YOU GUYS
offline
Link
 
So they want to completely change how players are built after people have invested over a year IRL building these players.

Wow fuck GLB, if this change takes any 3 of Catch's 4 suggestions as the route I'm done with this game. There was only 1 on there that was remotely reasonable.
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
why not just do both, longhorn? you do realize that what you propose is a lot more difficult than you make it out to be in terms of balancing the sim at various lvls of GLB including higher ones? They're already testing things involving making secondary atts more important in the testing forum. This was a separate thing they were planning on doing in addition to making those other things viable.

There will still be extreme builds if eq is capped at 40-45 in an att because it won't be as easy for everyone to have 160spd WRs. You'll still see 140+ spd WRs like you do today while most will be in the 120s and 130s. Nothing will really change other than the scale will be adjusted down a smidge to make coding easier
 
Rulabula
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Phil Jackson
So they want to completely change how players are built after people have invested over a year IRL building these players.

Wow fuck GLB, if this change takes any 3 of Catch's 4 suggestions as the route I'm done with this game. There was only 1 on there that was remotely reasonable.


I think alot of people will feel that way.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chronoaug
. Like rage was saying about his FB. I'm sure he'd rather bort just alter the way he coded and allowed for certain stacking way back when instead of waiting till it became a problem then hastily getting rid of scat back altogether.


I actually built him to try and prove my point about how OP'd and stupid the scat back VA was when it first came out and nobody would seem to listen. The reason he's a FB instead of a HB is using a FB made it cheaper.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Phil Jackson
So they want to completely change how players are built after people have invested over a year IRL building these players.


Yeah I'm hoping they look into this further and possibly take some user thoughts and opinions into account. I know they have to "make the best decision for GLB" but I hope its not what they're talking about at the moment.
Edited by bigtisme on Oct 21, 2010 09:15:20
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
Just let safety's drop into over coverage correctly, and if team doesn't game plan for a speedster, then they get burnt. If the same speedster is running slants/ins/outs make agility more important.
 
Rulabula
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by chronoaug

. Like rage was saying about his FB. I'm sure he'd rather bort just alter the way he coded and allowed for certain stacking way back when instead of waiting till it became a problem then hastily getting rid of scat back altogether.


I actually built him to try and prove my point about how OP'd and stupid the scat back VA was when it first came out and nobody would seem to listen. The reason he's a FB instead of a HB is using a FB made it cheaper.


Always liked the Dirty Deeds build but what exactly is OP about him? Stats? I don't see anything that will break GLB and have us in an uproar.
 
jpjn94
doc ock
offline
Link
 
Just for the record; I'm not for any change, but I am worried about having a cap on an attribute. The example I gave still allows you to go to an extreme, but you have to take another attribute with you. More than likely you'd take Agility with Speed.

The cap on Equipment is fine; I guess, but I'd rather not have a change at all. The extreme builds are not the problem in the SIM right now.

 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kotoll
Originally posted by Rage Kinard

Originally posted by chronoaug


. Like rage was saying about his FB. I'm sure he'd rather bort just alter the way he coded and allowed for certain stacking way back when instead of waiting till it became a problem then hastily getting rid of scat back altogether.


I actually built him to try and prove my point about how OP'd and stupid the scat back VA was when it first came out and nobody would seem to listen. The reason he's a FB instead of a HB is using a FB made it cheaper.


Always liked the Dirty Deeds build but what exactly is OP about him? Stats? I don't see anything that will break GLB and have us in an uproar.


Though give him credit because 1.5 years is a long time to wait to prove a point
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kotoll
Always liked the Dirty Deeds build but what exactly is OP about him? Stats? I don't see anything that will break GLB and have us in an uproar.


Because they took away scat back before he got rounded out. Some of the older builds proved my point before he got there.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1279553 - however, this was what would have been unleashed, except he wasn't even finished at that point. He had 10 less pts of speed and 3 less pts of agility.

If scat back still were around he would be running routes with 160+ speed and 100+ agility now, and I would have put some of the sp I used to help his rushing into places that would have helped his receiving instead.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.