User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Why are games never close outisde of WL?
Page:
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
but is it free?
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Like...real football?


fair enough. But in real football that one bad roll is the coaches call...or the players decision.

If people want closer games they have to be prepared for more randomness including a big drop in moral or whatever determining an outcome instead of better dots or gameplans.

Honestly I prefer better dots and ai winning but I do see the other side of trying to get more realistic games and scores. In an ideal world you can get both but I havent' seen a text based sport game that brings both balance and realism yet.
 
ryanshaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by reddogrw
Having won Gold in Pro last season and getting spanked in the WL this season, those WL coordinators may be arrogant, but they are far and away better than Pro and below - not remotely close


How do you know? That is the problem - this idea is just one big assumption. There is no question that in very close matchups (eg some of the WL) tactics make all the difference. However, what many of the people on this thread keep saying is that large score differences are partly or largely due to tactics as well. In fact, the overwhelming likelihood is that it is due to build differences and that tactics make very little difference.

There is just no logical argument that offence AI can make that much difference. So it basically comes down to DAI. Obviously it has an effect but it is hard to imagine it is a game changer, especially given how stupid the average dot is no matter what you think you have asked him to do.

The harsh reality is that if you are suddenly losing in the WL it is because the other teams are marginally better than you in terms of builds and the sim is over-emphasizing these differences, just as the OP suggested.

As always, this debate could be answered by proper published testing. Don't hold your breath.
 
risico
offline
Link
 
Too many people own teams who shouldn't...
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ryanshaw
How do you know? That is the problem - this idea is just one big assumption. There is no question that in very close matchups (eg some of the WL) tactics make all the difference. However, what many of the people on this thread keep saying is that large score differences are partly or largely due to tactics as well. In fact, the overwhelming likelihood is that it is due to build differences and that tactics make very little difference.



Originally posted by
There is just no logical argument that offence AI can make that much difference. So it basically comes down to DAI. Obviously it has an effect but it is hard to imagine it is a game changer, especially given how stupid the average dot is no matter what you think you have asked him to do.



Originally posted by
The harsh reality is that if you are suddenly losing in the WL it is because the other teams are marginally better than you in terms of builds and the sim is over-emphasizing these differences, just as the OP suggested.



Please re-read your own post. You're saying that in spite of numerous people with experience in the WL saying that tactics make a huge difference, you reject that notion out of hand and insist that it can't be tactics because you don't understand how tactics could be that big a difference. This is a case where you have a preconceived notion and are not willing to acknowledge or grasp any information that would challenge that preconception. If you had any WL coordinating experience, you'd already know how wrong that notion is, given that those of us who have are keenly aware of just how bad things can go with a poor gameplan. A bad DAI or OAI can unquestionably be a 50 point swing, if not more.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Billy Corman
What's sad is that the first 3 seasons of a dot are basically throw-away if they are building for the end-game. What's that, then, $15 and 6 months? For zero results/enjoyment.

Only if you're doing it wrong.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Its just crazy how people magically fix their team in the playoffs considering tactics and ai mean nothing.
 
risico
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ryanshaw
How do you know? That is the problem - this idea is just one big assumption. There is no question that in very close matchups (eg some of the WL) tactics make all the difference. However, what many of the people on this thread keep saying is that large score differences are partly or largely due to tactics as well. In fact, the overwhelming likelihood is that it is due to build differences and that tactics make very little difference.

There is just no logical argument that offence AI can make that much difference. So it basically comes down to DAI. Obviously it has an effect but it is hard to imagine it is a game changer, especially given how stupid the average dot is no matter what you think you have asked him to do.

The harsh reality is that if you are suddenly losing in the WL it is because the other teams are marginally better than you in terms of builds and the sim is over-emphasizing these differences, just as the OP suggested.

As always, this debate could be answered by proper published testing. Don't hold your breath.


lol
 
Skoll Wolfrun
offline
Link
 
heh: between top teams in the Elites...games are close. Granted, this is just 1 league...but there is at least some attempts at balancing out the leagues.

38 Elite: Week 6:
Ogre Horde vs. Butte Kickin Asses 66-16
SCOTLAND SNAPPERS vs. Cannabis Blazers 0-129
Eden Sin vs. Comic Book All Stars 31-49 (diff of 18 pts)
Durham Ice Odyssey vs. Inverness Highlanders 10-55
Hollywood Legends vs. Sydney Hammerhead 13-33 (diff of 18 pts)
Santiago Voodoo vs. Estonian Enforcers 56-10
Arctic Avalanche vs. Andorian Commandos 21-35 (diff of 14 pts)
*Nebraska Blackshirts* vs. Long Island Iced Tea 10-41
East Coast Chaos vs. BP SludgeDogs 58-13
Albuquerque Mustangs vs. Seattle Needles 51-16
Ljubljana Alpdevils vs. South Tulsa Cowboys 45-20
Thunder Bay ERRATICS vs. The Evil Empire 46-35 (diff of 11 pts)
Java Brewers vs. Guċhan Raging Tritons 45-6
Ouagadougou Voodoo vs. Incomurdro Atman 56-28
Glasgow Tigers vs. Newfoundland Roughnecks 23-28 (diff of 5 pts)
University Of Pugilism vs. Yuma Fokkers 3-105

Week 5:
Long Island Iced Tea vs. Santiago Voodoo 28-31
Incomurdro Atman vs. Java Brewers 13-28
Yuma Fokkers vs. East Coast Chaos 34-37

Week 4:
Durham Ice Odyssey vs. Andorian Commandos 41-38
Eden Sin vs. Butte Kickin Asses 17-23
*Nebraska Blackshirts* vs. Sydney Hammerhead 24-33
Thunder Bay ERRATICS vs. Newfoundland Roughnecks 48-43
Ouagadougou Voodoo vs. BP SludgeDogs 34-35
East Coast Chaos vs. Albuquerque Mustangs 52-48
Java Brewers vs. Seattle Needles 30-26
 
KCChiefsMan
offline
Link
 
here we go

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1370209

of course we are the 2nd lowest leveled team in the league, so our wins aren't usually big time blowouts.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick



Please re-read your own post. You're saying that in spite of numerous people with experience in the WL saying that tactics make a huge difference, you reject that notion out of hand and insist that it can't be tactics because you don't understand how tactics could be that big a difference. This is a case where you have a preconceived notion and are not willing to acknowledge or grasp any information that would challenge that preconception. If you had any WL coordinating experience, you'd already know how wrong that notion is, given that those of us who have are keenly aware of just how bad things can go with a poor gameplan. A bad DAI or OAI can unquestionably be a 50 point swing, if not more.


At the WL level it is mostly coordinating, although there are some teams that do much better than their dots would indicate. There are actually a few WL teams that couldn't beat the better teams no matter how good their game plan was unless the better team came out with a pants on head type AI.

At the Pro level, however, there are several games where AI makes absolutely no difference. Teams can keep the same game plan and win 70-0 in 1/2 their games without changing the AI all season long.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
There are actually a few WL teams that couldn't beat the better teams no matter how good their game plan was unless the better team came out with a pants on head type AI.

That used to be more true than it is now. Now you can have a solid Pro team putting up reasonable scores against WL teams with winning records. I'd say that only the two Dogs would really have no chance against the WL elite.

Originally posted by
At the Pro level, however, there are several games where AI makes absolutely no difference. Teams can keep the same game plan and win 70-0 in 1/2 their games without changing the AI all season long.

Sure, but that's because you have more variety at the Pro level since there are eight different regions. Newly promoted teams from AAA generally don't have the levels or dot quality to compete with the Pro elite. But for the most part, tactics do matter a lot. They won't let you overcome huge gaps in talent unless the other team's gameplan is really terrible, but for the most part they do make a significant impact.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

That used to be more true than it is now. Now you can have a solid Pro team putting up reasonable scores against WL teams with winning records. I'd say that only the two Dogs would really have no chance against the WL elite.


Cypriot has no chance against WL elite either. In fact, the only reason they are even competing is they have one of the best 5 and probably one of the best 3 DCs in GLB. I imagine there are a few other teams in WL with exceptional coordinators that just don't have the dots.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Cypriot has no chance against WL elite either. In fact, the only reason they are even competing is they have one of the best 5 and probably one of the best 3 DCs in GLB. I imagine there are a few other teams in WL with exceptional coordinators that just don't have the dots.


Emmaus tbh...would be solid yet again in eepl but is nowhere near set up as well as wl elite.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Fact is tho...coordinating goes beyond tactics and ai..and that's where the best take their lead.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.