Originally posted by VolBrian
Dude, lolpreseason, something I really don't care about tactics wise at any level. We win that game by 50 if the AI's were on.
I'm telling you. If you want to really prove your point, you're gonna have to select random leveled playoff teams and compute the punting averages with the return averages. If what you're saying is true, then all of those teams will be giving up 20+ yards per return every game and having a punting average less than 40 every game. Even then, it's a matter of opinion which strategy is worth what to each user, no exploit.
LOL as if there is a ST AI that would change during a regular season matchup.
Ok lets go back to the championship game VS lost last season with what was essentially the same ST depth chart order as the lolpreseason game...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1357394
2:59 4th & 9.5 OWN 41.5 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 19 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin (4.5 yd return) [diving tackle: Hung Jury]
13:10 4th & 10.5 OWN 39.5 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 27 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin [TD] (68 yd return)
11:29 4th & 15 OWN 37 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 27 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin [TD] (65 yd return)
10:02 4th & 5.5 OWN 46.5 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 17 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin (12 yd return) [tackle: Terrance "Big Fella" Cody]
5:52 4th & 14 OWN 42 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 32 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin (14 yd return) [diving tackle: Craig Bromley]
1:15 4th & 11 OWN 23 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 17 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin (6.5 yd return) [tackle: Craig Bromley]
9:49 4th & 23 OPP 46 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 18 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin (13 yd return) [tackle: Conrad Spvoda]
6:51 4th & 13 OWN 45 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 23 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin (8.5 yd return) [diving tackle: Mumbles FS]
0:40 4th & 8.5 OWN 24.5 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 30 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin (11.5 yd return) [tackle: Random Name]
11:16 4th & 3 OWN 48 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 23 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin (12.5 yd return) [diving tackle: Winchester Jones]
6:30 4th & 7 OWN 23 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 27 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin [missed diving tackle: Jordan Crawford] (13 yd return) [tackle: Mumbles FS]
3:16 4th & 9.5 OWN 30.5 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 31 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin (12 yd return) [diving tackle: Jordan Crawford]
0:42 4th & 16 OWN 14 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 36 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin (19.5 yd return) [diving tackle: Winchester Jones]
Are you really going to stand here and tell me that the extra 5 yards on average of field position was worth the 2 punt return tds (there were a couple times where the field position was worse) that yall gave up? You needed everything to go your way to win that game... why not eliminate the possibility of punt return tds at minimal cost?
Dude, lolpreseason, something I really don't care about tactics wise at any level. We win that game by 50 if the AI's were on.
I'm telling you. If you want to really prove your point, you're gonna have to select random leveled playoff teams and compute the punting averages with the return averages. If what you're saying is true, then all of those teams will be giving up 20+ yards per return every game and having a punting average less than 40 every game. Even then, it's a matter of opinion which strategy is worth what to each user, no exploit.
LOL as if there is a ST AI that would change during a regular season matchup.
Ok lets go back to the championship game VS lost last season with what was essentially the same ST depth chart order as the lolpreseason game...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1357394
2:59 4th & 9.5 OWN 41.5 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 19 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin (4.5 yd return) [diving tackle: Hung Jury]
13:10 4th & 10.5 OWN 39.5 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 27 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin [TD] (68 yd return)
11:29 4th & 15 OWN 37 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 27 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin [TD] (65 yd return)
10:02 4th & 5.5 OWN 46.5 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 17 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin (12 yd return) [tackle: Terrance "Big Fella" Cody]
5:52 4th & 14 OWN 42 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 32 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin (14 yd return) [diving tackle: Craig Bromley]
1:15 4th & 11 OWN 23 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 17 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin (6.5 yd return) [tackle: Craig Bromley]
9:49 4th & 23 OPP 46 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 18 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin (13 yd return) [tackle: Conrad Spvoda]
6:51 4th & 13 OWN 45 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 23 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin (8.5 yd return) [diving tackle: Mumbles FS]
0:40 4th & 8.5 OWN 24.5 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 30 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin (11.5 yd return) [tackle: Random Name]
11:16 4th & 3 OWN 48 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 23 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin (12.5 yd return) [diving tackle: Winchester Jones]
6:30 4th & 7 OWN 23 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 27 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin [missed diving tackle: Jordan Crawford] (13 yd return) [tackle: Mumbles FS]
3:16 4th & 9.5 OWN 30.5 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 31 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin (12 yd return) [diving tackle: Jordan Crawford]
0:42 4th & 16 OWN 14 Punt by Slobber Nocker, 36 yd, fielded by Aria Tesolin (19.5 yd return) [diving tackle: Winchester Jones]
Are you really going to stand here and tell me that the extra 5 yards on average of field position was worth the 2 punt return tds (there were a couple times where the field position was worse) that yall gave up? You needed everything to go your way to win that game... why not eliminate the possibility of punt return tds at minimal cost?
Edited by doobas on Sep 20, 2010 11:54:49 (Not a bug, but should be made as a suggestion.)






























