User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > RESOLVED BUGS > Tricking the Oline Blitzes....."exploit" - BUG FILED #241
Page:
 
haole
the one who knocks
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rjssob
The easiest solution to all of this would be to add pass blocking rules to the AI and let the OC determine what strategy is going to be used. To stop this play let the OC chose a slide protection scheme where all OL block on gap over to the left or right and the Back goes the other way. Or you can do what we did and not run shotgun and then take advantage of DB's in man to man...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1309297&pbp_id=6070126


Was there a stealth fix? Because previously there's no way that QB gets that pass off, and the Center does not slide over to pick up the ROLB
 
Mike1709
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by haole
Was there a stealth fix? Because previously there's no way that QB gets that pass off, and the Center does not slide over to pick up the ROLB


I don't think so, that is a slightly different defensive formation with just 5 pass rushers on the line (and the SS coming from wide), the other examples from the OP had 6 pass rushers lined up against the O-line and the C would slide across to pick up a LB, but the trouble with those was that there was the same problem each side so the C could get one, but the HB hadn't got time to get in position to pick up the other.
 
haole
the one who knocks
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike1709
I don't think so, that is a slightly different defensive formation with just 5 pass rushers on the line (and the SS coming from wide), the other examples from the OP had 6 pass rushers lined up against the O-line and the C would slide across to pick up a LB, but the trouble with those was that there was the same problem each side so the C could get one, but the HB hadn't got time to get in position to pick up the other.


Good eyes
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
i definitely agree that something is wrong here but i'm not sure how to procede. In my opinion the O-line should get a vision boost every time the same position blitzes.....then again i'm not entirely sure vision is working as intended.

Another thing that could be done would be to increase the width of the dots on the o-line.....too often LBs seem to just teleport through linemen....when you're breaking through the offensive line you tend to slow down at least a little.

Anyways, marking this as a bug w/ consideration to how big of an exploit it is. What I think should be done:

-run tests w/ varying builds (including high vision, high agility linemen) to ensure it's not a build issue
-consider a re-write of blocking logic. Priority should go to the guys who are closest to the QB.....pretty self-explanatory
-have a discussion on the GLB main forum....or somewhere that is actually paid attention to by good GLB minds (aka, not here ) on how to fix this issue (as there are good ideas but no single one is a clear fix)

Forwarding this on
Edited by kuaggie on Aug 16, 2010 18:29:19
 
neoliminal
offline
Link
 
Can I suggest a simple system for the blocking?

1. Offense makes vision checks on who looks like they are blitzing.
2. Audible if more blitzing than blocking. (if turned on)
3. Each blocker is assigned a block, CENTER OUT. (This is where the bug is, IMHO... ROLB is normally OUTSIDE the RDE)

You see this in real football where the o-line is pointing to who they are going to block. Same thing here. Point at potential blitzers and when the play starts go for your blocking assignment.

If your block isn't blitzing because you misread, vision checks until you figure it out and then pick a new block.

Sucks a lot of fun out of the game to have this kind of exploit.
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
It's kind of comical how the RG tries to slide across the backside of the line to go after the RO in a lot of these like this one...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1340907&pbp_id=8305673

But this sort of thing is way to consistent to not be an exploit-blitz even w/o the RG slide...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1340907&pbp_id=8302698

I DC and haven't implemented these sorts of exploits in my AIs, but dang, since all these other teams are doing it, guess I may as well join the exploit crowd and add them in too - even though it makes my stomach curl to have to do such things. Go with the flow I suppose until it gets addressed/fixed.


 
shey
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Toriq
I DC and haven't implemented these sorts of exploits in my AIs, but dang, since all these other teams are doing it, guess I may as well join the exploit crowd and add them in too - even though it makes my stomach curl to have to do such things. Go with the flow I suppose until it gets addressed/fixed.


Our predicament as well. Stay on the high road, and possibly lose to a team who has fully implemented this exploit? Or travel on the low road....

Originally posted by neoliminal
Can I suggest a simple system for the blocking?

3. Each blocker is assigned a block, CENTER OUT. (This is where the bug is, IMHO... ROLB is normally OUTSIDE the RDE)


+1!

Originally posted by neoliminal
Sucks a lot of fun out of the game to have this kind of exploit.


Bingo
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kuaggie
-run tests w/ varying builds (including high vision, high agility linemen) to ensure it's not a build issue


So you thing C's and OG's should have 90+ Vision and sacrifice strength to get rev-caked a ton just because of exploity positioning in the DPC......

I think too many examples are being brought into play here...my main concern are the ones where the sack occurs just a few ticks into the play...you know, the ones where the HB/QB barely move, but the LB shoots through the line.
 
haole
the one who knocks
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by .spider.
So you thing C's and OG's should have 90+ Vision and sacrifice strength to get rev-caked a ton just because of exploity positioning in the DPC......

I think too many examples are being brought into play here...my main concern are the ones where the sack occurs just a few ticks into the play...you know, the ones where the HB/QB barely move, but the LB shoots through the line.


Yep, obviously we should all change our builds to prevent these one-tick sacks so that just as we get everything switched over it can be changed back, render our new builds useless and cause about 1,000 rage quits.

I think the wide range of examples will hopefully show that something is fundamentally wrong with the blocking logic, and not that this is a minor glitch.

And I'd also like to point out, for like the 1,000th time, that part of the problem here is a system that penalizes the offense for running the same play over and over, but does not penalize the defense for blitzing the same gap or running the same coverage for an entire game.
 
randey
offline
Link
 
As the DC of the Rhinos who made that play:

There ARE plenty of ways to neutralize that blitz (within the current sim) and a little bit of scouting would give you that option.

In the game Rhinos Vs. Dead presidents:
5 Singleback Passes
1 Sack
4 Deflections

1) 5 Passes did not lose you the game.
2) It is not a automatic sack - (yes vision DOES play a role)


6 3wr Shotgun Passes
2 Sacks
1 Deflection
3 Completions

In both of the sacks, there were 6 blitzers and 6 blockers and the blitz does confuse the o-line / hb. This happens in RL too btw.

So a 50% completion percentage out of Shotgun, using a play that CAN get you burned badly if the ball is completed successfully. You literally have 3 cb's on an island. If you can't "exploit" that then the problem is with offensive builds and OCing. The blitz CAN be picked up (http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1309259&pbp_id=7320130) and the QB has all day to throw on man coverage to 4 targets.

Even if Bort and Co. decide this blitz is too effective and code things to "fix" this blitz it will only create and leave the option to use the next effective blitz. There are several current problems within the offense / defensive line interactions.

1) Defensive rev cakes - They are overpowered, but without them, offenses would be even more unstoppable, and the run game would be ridiculous. Defensive lines are also unable to change direction, rip / swim / spin through blocks effectively to pass rush. The typical lineman has to have help to get any pressure at all because he is unable to get past a blocker quickly.

2) Offensive Read Assignments - Are totally unrealistic. Even if this particular blitz is removed, there are plenty of other ways to "trick" o-lines to hesitating or missing a blitzer from practically any gap on the line. But just because a blitzer comes through unblocked doesn't mean its a bug. If every blitzer is picked up on every play every formation, then why blitz? You just backtracked 5 seasons where everyone rushed 3 / 4 and double and triple teamed wr's downfield.

The bottom line is that the interaction between O and D lines is completely whacked out and needs a complete re-written code for it. It has needed it for some time, but has been consistently ignored or relegated to give archetypes, or whatever. That's fine, but know as more specialized and refined builds with higher caps are hitting their prime that these dots will be prime for taking advantage of the given sim.

P.S. Penalize a Defense for running the same play over and over?

So if an offense passes 25 times from singleback will i get penalized if my CB1 plays man on WR1 every play? Am I now forced to run zone with my man CB to avoid him being penalized for running man too much? My LOLB is penalized for covering the TE every play in singleback? Or would i just make 4 different slight variations the same play and then run each one at 25% to avoid a penalty of one play being used 100% of the time. Instead of that ROLB there, i could easily just place the FS there for the same effect, or would moving the rolb literally one pixel qualify as a different play?

Defenses are in nature set up and designed to confront / oppose and negate the offense from doing what it does best. For example, your team rarely ever IF ever ran out of singleback but passed from that formation all day long. So what did you expect me to do except blitz the whazoo out of your QB in singleback. IF you were willing you could easily run out of that formation successfully or with a little extra scouting figured out how to pass from that formation. So if a defense using its personnel's abilities (which are static - relatively unchanging) to fit into a scheme (which is designed to use the personnel the most effectively) to counter what an offense can and can't do, then why should they be punished for doing what they do best? Are the Steelers penalized for being to blitz happy? Are the Colts penalized for running Tampa Cover 2 too much? Of course not. Analyze the defense's abilities and find their weakness and then beat it. Similarly for a defense, find what the offense does best and try to negate it. It is relatively simple and obvious so why penalize a defense for reacting to what an offense does?
Edited by randey on Aug 18, 2010 09:11:55
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
That exploit play you created that was discovered in preseason and quickly became the flavor of the month takes advantage of the blocking code.

Most of the stuff you posted above really has nothing to do with this exploit.
 
randey
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
That exploit play you created that was discovered in preseason and quickly became the flavor of the month takes advantage of the blocking code.

Most of the stuff you posted above really has nothing to do with this exploit.


That blitz was created at least one season ago.

Edit: and yes, most of the stuff I posted DOES directly deal with this blitz. The only thing that doesn't is the P.S. part, and that was directed at the previous comment about punishing defenses for running the same play over and over. Which is completely ridiculous.

The entire blocking code is completely screwed up. It doesn't make much sense that the ROLB is allowed through the line that easy, but then again, very little of what happens between offensive / defensive lines makes sense in this game. My play isn't an exploit, it is merely a blitz that works because of blocking assignments. I haven't changed or manipulated how an offense reads or reacts to my play. They respond as it has been coded. There are countless ways to replicate that exact same blitz under the current sim. It isn't an exploit, it isn't unstoppable, and it isn't overpowering. If OC's knew what they were doing they could very easily neutralize that entire play.
Edited by randey on Aug 18, 2010 11:49:16
 
Balls Models
offline
Link
 
so, basically....

Originally posted by randey
blah blah blah blah
blah blah
blahblburpblahblah

The bottom line is that the interaction between O and D lines is completely whacked out and needs a complete re-written code for it. It has needed it for some time, but has been consistently ignored or relegated to give archetypes, or whatever. That's fine, but know as more specialized and refined builds with higher caps are hitting their prime that these dots will be prime for taking advantage of the given sim.

blah blah blah blah
blah blah
blahblburpblahblah.


 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by randey
If OC's knew what they were doing they could very easily neutralize that entire play.


What only running out of the SB and never passing? I guess that is a way to neutralize it.

Also, you tried to mention in your previous post that this happens in the NFL too, and while that may be true, the NFL lineman won't get burned over and over again before they make an adjustment so using "it happens in the NFL" will never fly when dealing with a AI.

I do agree the blocking code is completely screwed up, especially since it is so easy to design a blitz against it, so I'm not really sure why you are trying to argue against fixing this exploit of the blocking code.

 
randey
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
What only running out of the SB and never passing? I guess that is a way to neutralize it.

Also, you tried to mention in your previous post that this happens in the NFL too, and while that may be true, the NFL lineman won't get burned over and over again before they make an adjustment so using "it happens in the NFL" will never fly when dealing with a AI.

I do agree the blocking code is completely screwed up, especially since it is so easy to design a blitz against it, so I'm not really sure why you are trying to argue against fixing this exploit of the blocking code.



No you can pass against that play. Vision does play a role in whether or not the blocker is picked up, as does agility actually.

You can also beat the blitz through particular passing plays easy.

Bottom line is that the entire blocking code of both lines needs revisited not a "fix" that attempts to stop a specific blitz. That will only cause more bugs and open up more wonky blitzes. The entire way the lines interact needs patched, not one "fix it up" that is aimed at one blitz.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.