User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Offical Thread for Promotion System Changes (Enforcing Level Caps Etc)
Page:
 
Moretti
offline
Link
 


This game does not follow real life as younger players could be better than older players. For the most part, excluding bad builds, that cannot occur here.

In a cap level 18 league, teams that consist of level 25 players will dominate teams that are in the 15 to 18 level range with little to no tactical changes, especially in casual league where the ability to have superior game planning and tactics is extremely limited.

i think the fact that should be considered is that winning or even being competitive isn't a right. You have to wok for it. If a team cant cut it, there are reasons for it. Its not hard to be a playoff team in this game. If your team sucks then force them to improve instead of rewarding them by allowing them to win using unfair advantages.
 
Clarka3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Moretti
This game does not follow real life as younger players could be better than older players. For the most part, excluding bad builds, that cannot occur here.

In a cap level 18 league, teams that consist of level 25 players will dominate teams that are in the 15 to 18 level range with little to no tactical changes, especially in casual league where the ability to have superior game planning and tactics is extremely limited.

i think the fact that should be considered is that winning or even being competitive isn't a right. You have to wok for it. If a team cant cut it, there are reasons for it. Its not hard to be a playoff team in this game. If your team sucks then force them to improve instead of rewarding them by allowing them to win using unfair advantages.


+1
 
DarthVisor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chysil
the point would be that no one should be the clear cut winner? A team that games the system to get into a lower cap than they truely belong can simply run away with it.

the people complaining are not wanting to be there "shoe in to win it all", they are trying to make it so that there is no "shoe in the win it all" etc


+1

I wish Bort or Catch would comment on this.
 
Clarka3
offline
Link
 
just send catch that message he's asking for and use this subject. if enough people do that, they'll have to change it.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DarthVisor
+1

I wish Bort or Catch would comment on this.


I don't think they will. I think they have the attitude that some people like to play the game this way and that is a gamer they don't want to lose.

When they bowed to a few teams that thought a 3 cap promotion after winning the league wasn't fair the league promotion system went to crap. They caved to the handful of teams that thought they should be able to win every season. It just wasn't fair a team should get promoted to a cap they couldn't win, that isn't fair they cried!

But now you could have a league with 4 dominant teams, and you could be that 5th team that competes but has no real shot to beat the teams that gamed the cap, but you could wind up getting promoted with those same 4 teams throughout the capped leagues.

It's sad because last season I played in a league with a really good team that started the season 6-0, but then they determined they probably wouldn't win the league because they wouldn't be boosting, so they threw the rest of their games to only get a 1 cap jump. That team is dominating the 22 cap and actually a few teams requested to move out of the league just because of this one team.

For every team that will request to leave a league because of a team like that, there are 10 other teams that just take it in the behind.
 
Link
 
I also say that the effective level needs to go away. Teams could very easily hold SP until leagues are set in off season. The effective level is actually one of the easiest things to exploit.
 
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Clarka3
just send catch that message he's asking for and use this subject. if enough people do that, they'll have to change it.


Already done. Got a positive response too.
 
Clarka3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dr. E
Already done. Got a positive response too.


he must have gotten tired of responding to that message, because i didn't get a response haha
 
DarthVisor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Clarka3
he must have gotten tired of responding to that message, because i didn't get a response haha


Glad to hear it. I sent similar. Got a form letter type response.

Hope they listen. Would make the game so much better.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Clarka3
Originally posted by Dr. E

Already done. Got a positive response too.


he must have gotten tired of responding to that message, because i didn't get a response haha


I didnt get a response from one either
 
MarBro456
Diamond Cutter
offline
Link
 
I got a positive response about mine.
 
Link
 
Thanks for the support guys. Let's hope with all our the messages Catch and Bort are getting they will really think about working on this!
 
OklahomaWolf
offline
Link
 
+100,000,000,000,000,000,000

i agree, its unfair that higher lvl's are in a lvl 18 we dnt even have a chance
 
ilracefan
offline
Link
 
I like how people are complaining about getting promoted more than they should and turn around and complain about teams that "play below their ability" to keep that from happening. In this game you have 2 choices, play to your full ability in the current season and hope you get gold and be happy you did, but get screwed by getting thrown into a league where you most likely won't be able to compete, or not worry about playing your best this season to get properly promoted next season and try to win in that one.

Don't complain that teams get over-promoted, then complain about teams sandbagging so they don't get over-promoted. If the over-promoting wasn't happening in the first place, then the sandbagging wouldn't happen near as often! Don't get me wrong, there would still be teams sandbagging, no matter what system of promotion you use, but I think most of the sandbagging is a DIRECT result of the current promotion system.

I just had my team demoted to cap 4, to rebuild and have a core group of guys all striving for the same goals. Our plan is to experiment with some plays, play with the AIs some and not worry about winning games. Some people call it losing intentionally, some people call it sandbagging, I call it trying to build a team and get properly promoted so that next season when our builds are actually going to affect how we play, we will be in a league where we can compete.

I don't know what the perfect fix is, if there even is one, but the current system is most certainly NOT working.

Let's just hope this thread is getting some attention from the powers that be, something needs done, and hopefully it will happen soon.
 
MarBro456
Diamond Cutter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ilracefan
I like how people are complaining about getting promoted more than they should and turn around and complain about teams that "play below their ability" to keep that from happening. In this game you have 2 choices, play to your full ability in the current season and hope you get gold and be happy you did, but get screwed by getting thrown into a league where you most likely won't be able to compete, or not worry about playing your best this season to get properly promoted next season and try to win in that one.

Don't complain that teams get over-promoted, then complain about teams sandbagging so they don't get over-promoted. If the over-promoting wasn't happening in the first place, then the sandbagging wouldn't happen near as often! Don't get me wrong, there would still be teams sandbagging, no matter what system of promotion you use, but I think most of the sandbagging is a DIRECT result of the current promotion system.

I just had my team demoted to cap 4, to rebuild and have a core group of guys all striving for the same goals. Our plan is to experiment with some plays, play with the AIs some and not worry about winning games. Some people call it losing intentionally, some people call it sandbagging, I call it trying to build a team and get properly promoted so that next season when our builds are actually going to affect how we play, we will be in a league where we can compete.

I don't know what the perfect fix is, if there even is one, but the current system is most certainly NOT working.

Let's just hope this thread is getting some attention from the powers that be, something needs done, and hopefully it will happen soon.


I had a suggestion that was totaly different than, "Someone is cheating... enforce the rules.....................but it was locked due to this one being endorsed. But..... here was mine:

The current system allows for some leagues to have teams that can be 10+ levels higher than other teams in the league. While some think it is intentional, it isn't always. Some teams have no care about winning in the lower leagues and don't game plan, they just concentrate on building their dots, having losing seasons, and promoting once or not at all. After a few seasons, it leads to a big disadvantage and even not gameplanning they are still too powerful to beat.

System I propose:

Each season when teams move up, put them in the league where their levels fit. Let the promotion be where they go from there, depending on how they did the previous season....... ie...... regular, competitive, or elite..... top playoff teams go to elite, next tier (lower playoff teams and the ones just missing), go to competitive, the teams that do really bad, go to regular.......

From that point, all teams still start where they can be competitive...... Gameplanning, boosting etc. can determine how their season plays out. Also by the point when the teams want to get serious, they'll be at a level where they can truly test their mettle against others.

Edited by MarBro456 on Aug 10, 2010 17:28:12
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.