User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > RESOLVED BUGS > More screen pass issues - BUG FILED #243
Page:
 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
Another thrown low: (caught but still thrown low)

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1282506&pbp_id=1348858


AA QB with 72 passing bar:

Thrown low: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1282470&pbp_id=1345111
Edited by whodey08 on Jul 25, 2010 20:43:14
Edited by whodey08 on Jul 25, 2010 20:40:55
Edited by whodey08 on Jul 25, 2010 20:39:55
Edited by whodey08 on Jul 25, 2010 20:39:00
 
-AB-
offline
Link
 
I'm wondering how a QB can't make a 5-10 yard throw.... When they can throw a deep ball 60+ yards....... Makes no sense.
 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by abfootball
I'm wondering how a QB can't make a 5-10 yard throw.... When they can throw a deep ball 60+ yards....... Makes no sense.


Precisely what I have been trying to say since my original post!

Defenses are overloading 1 side of the Oline to create pressure and sacks and the screen is what is supposed to counter that but the screen just causes you to waste a play or take a loss of yards
Edited by whodey08 on Jul 25, 2010 20:44:58
 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
I just hope this gets its due attention since it was unfairly marked as "not likely a bug"
 
Destroyer
offline
Link
 
The screen pass is definitely an issue. Unfortunately most teams just seem to accept it for what it is and simply remove all screen plays from their offense. This is a case where GLB really needs to listen to their paying customers and take a hard look at the screen plays.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whodey08
I just hope this gets its due attention since it was unfairly marked as "not likely a bug"


There is no "fair" or "unfair" in a determination by a Bugs Mod. No one is out to get anybody.

 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
This has been said before, but after reviewing this thread I see the necessity of repeating it:

If you have no productive commentary or critique to make within a bugs thread, don't post. You only serve to complicate the issue.

This post popped up over the weekend and it might take until today when people are back on schedule to get the attention it deserves.

Now, lecture over, next post for determination.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
I see why Asdlfef made the determination of not likely a bug considering that this issue came to the forum fairly recently, was thoroughly tested, and was determined not to be a bug.

However, after reviewing the replays in this thread, I'm gonna send this one up for another round in QA because of the preponderance of higher level QB's having "low" or "bad" throws on screen plays. I think this might need some further testing just for that alone, but QA will ultimately decide that.

There is a qualifier here imo though that the QB must not be under any pressure at all or the replay is thrown out. Some of the replays here show a QB being hurried and you can expect to see a higher probability of "low" or "bad" throws by any level of QB dot when he is under pressure.

Sending to QA
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Personally, i think this is a bug. However, i'll need to review everything and see some QA research before i'm ready to call it, because of prior testing.
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
There was a thread on this, the bugs testing team did a ton of tests, and Catch determined from the results of the test that Screens are working as expected.

The only way I could justify sending this through again is because Bort's touched the code since then, although it should have made things better in this case:
Originally posted by Changelog

Make short passes a little easier to complete, and long passes a little harder

 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
Thank you for looking into this

1) I understand that pressure affects passes and don't expect every screen pass to be perfect. However....a screen pass is almost designed to bring the pressure as you want the Oline and blitzers to commit going after the QB which is sorta what makes the screen pass successful. The qb is usually backpedaling when he dumps it to the HB.

2) Just odd that a QB with a gold bar in passing with 10 in pocket presence can't hit the HB with a decent throw at least a couple of times a game. Like I posted....there were 9 bad screen passes in just that 1 game and they were all "thrown low". No jumping catch attempts or diving catch attempts.....just thrown low.

VolBrian....I really did try to keep this thread on topic. Sorry for all the BS that happened.
Edited by whodey08 on Jul 26, 2010 10:33:04
 
Dr. E
online
Link
 
Originally posted by whodey08
Precisely what I have been trying to say since my original post!

Defenses are overloading 1 side of the Oline to create pressure and sacks and the screen is what is supposed to counter that but the screen just causes you to waste a play or take a loss of yards


I agree, the screen pass needs a little love from Bort. My guess is the blocking/vision check on screens needs to be better so the OC has something to punish Defenses for their unrealistic play.
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
I think this is a good candidate for the Bugs Testers to run some tests. I'm going to mark this First Verification so we can get it moved to To Be Filed and let the Bugs Coordinators get the tests going.

Bugs Coordinators: See this post http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4069550&page=6#37533576 for suggestions on the setup for the test requests.
 
Djmr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NiborRis
I think this is a good candidate for the Bugs Testers to run some tests.


I agree, though "to be filed"? I disagree, if its going to be tested, Im moving it to "needs testing"
 
HouseRules
offline
Link
 
This one is going through test support now. Sorry I just saw this request...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.