User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
BossHog26
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by _Mentalist_
ok well from what i can gather from reading this...

* Up to level 21, he is given 2 points split amongst all of his major attributes, and 1 point split amongst his minor skills.
* At level 22, this decreases to 1.5 points split amongst the major attributes, and 0.75 points split amongst the minor attributes.
* At level 30, this decreases to 1.125 points split amongst the major attributes, and 0.5625 points split amongst the minor attributes.
* After level 38, this decreases to 0.84375 points split amongst the major attributes, and 0.421875 points split amongst the minor attributes.

....is that its best to raise your major attributes as quickly as physically possible with training and SP's... Here's some simple math to prove why...

For the sake of making this easy to understand lets say your player only has 2 major attributes therefore each level gain he gets 1 point in each one up to level 21... so...

If your player starts out at 25 in speed and you just train without using SP's lets say you could get to 30 before leveling...
When its at 30 and you level you go up to 31... Now if you were to have put SP's AND trained it.. for sake of argument lets say you got it to 48 before leveling.. now that attribute is still going to go up by 1 making it 49... but that one attribute point it went up would have cost you 2 SP's to do... so in reality by increasing your majors as quickly as possible from the start you actually save SP's.

I know none of you will read this due to length but it makes perfect sense so kiss my ass


i read it , thats actually one of the shorter posts i have read that actually does make sense on training and assigning sp's
 
Savitar
Ghost Recon
offline
Link
 
It makes sense to me.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by BadBuc99
It makes sense to me.


does it? So he convinced you that the way you are doing things is completely ass backwards? Dont ask me to explain why either, just read every post b4 this and it tells u why...
 
Savitar
Ghost Recon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Border Runners
does it? So he convinced you that the way you are doing things is completely ass backwards? Dont ask me to explain why either, just read every post b4 this and it tells u why...


Originally posted by
but that one attribute point it went up would have cost you 2 SP's to do... so in reality by increasing your majors as quickly as possible from the start you actually save SP's.


Training your major attributes as quickly as possible yes.....dumping your SP's into those attributes early, no.
 
_Mentalist_
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BadBuc99
Training your major attributes as quickly as possible yes.....dumping your SP's into those attributes early, no.


lmao well I tried... have fun with dots that arent at their full potential and get slaughtered in 3 or 4 seasons.
 
Savitar
Ghost Recon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by _Mentalist_
lmao well I tried... have fun with dots that arent at their full potential and get slaughtered in 3 or 4 seasons.


LMAO......this coming from someone who has been playing since June 25th 2010!

Hey, when you get 3 or 4 seasons under your belt, maybe you'll know what I'm talking about.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BadBuc99
LMAO......this coming from someone who has been playing since June 25th 2010!

Hey, when you get 3 or 4 seasons under your belt, maybe you'll know what I'm talking about.


Except, he is right and you are dead wrong.
 
_Mentalist_
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BadBuc99
LMAO......this coming from someone who has been playing since June 25th 2010!

Hey, when you get 3 or 4 seasons under your belt, maybe you'll know what I'm talking about.




I dont need 3 or 4 seasons to do simple math...

 
Savitar
Ghost Recon
offline
Link
 
We'll see who has better dots down the road.
 
JoeRule124
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BadBuc99
We'll see who has better dots down the road.




Can't wait for this!
 
JoeRule124
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BadBuc99
We'll see who has better dots down the road.


What are your metrics? Effective level?
 
JimForce
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JoeRule124
What are your metrics? Effective level?


Beyond understanding.
 
Rad53
offline
Link
 
I am broadly with BadBuc99 on this one, besides which he is clearly a scholar and a gentleman who takes the time to write 'you'. The Trawlermen are for the most part following a similar strategy.

The 'cap-as-soon-as-possible' school of thought is founded on the correct assumption that by doing so you are maximising the benefits of Per-Level Gains, measured in terms of saved Skill Points. For example, a player with PLGs of 0.5 and an Attribute score of, say, 30 will go up to 30.5 when he levels, saving him 0.5 SPs. A player with a 1st-capped Attribute score of, say, 49 will see it increase to 49.5 when he levels but, as the cost of raising Attributes within the 1st-cap bracket is 2 SPs, this PLG is worth 0.5 x2 = 1 SP. This represents a notional benefit of 0.5 SPs compared to the uncapped player, and would be 0.4 or as much as 0.67 depending on Archetype. So far, I think, this should be uncontentious.

The issue, then, is whether the uncapped player can train sufficiently before capping in order to negate or indeed surpass this SP saving. Wth an Attribute score of 30, he will be Normal training around 20% per day, saving him ~0.2 SPs per tick. It will therefore take him 2 days to cancel out the SP savings of a 1st-capped 0.4 PLG player, 2.5 days to match a 1st-capped 0.5 PLG player and 3.33 days to match a 1st-capped 0.67 PLG Archetype. On the basis that beyond the first couple of matches, players do not level every 2 days, he is better off waiting and training until he can 2nd-cap the Attribute, at which point the SP savings begin to outweigh the benefits from continued training (but I not going to bore you with the maths on that one any more than I may have done already). As player level (and the time available for training between each level-up) increases so does the advantage of waiting until one can 2nd-cap. You just have to be prepared to accept the early losses, but that is part and parcel of slow building.

There are exceptions to this. On balance, one can justify 1st-capping the primary Attribute of 0.67 PLG Archetypes on day 0 and, of course, once an Attribute starts getting into the mid-30s, the reduced training % is such that 0.5 PLG Archetypes should also follow suit.
Edited by Rad53 on Aug 1, 2010 03:47:39
 
Airhead
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rad53
I am broadly with BadBuc99 on this one, besides which he is clearly a scholar and a gentleman who takes the time to write 'you'. The Trawlermen are for the most part following a similar strategy.

The 'cap-as-soon-as-possible' school of thought is founded on the correct assumption that by doing so you are maximising the benefits of Per-Level Gains, measured in terms of saved Skill Points. For example, a player with PLGs of 0.5 and an Attribute score of, say, 30 will go up to 30.5 when he levels, saving him 0.5 SPs. A player with a 1st-capped Attribute score of, say, 49 will see it increase to 49.5 when he levels but, as the cost of raising Attributes within the 1st-cap bracket is 2 SPs, this PLG is worth 0.5 x2 = 1 SP. This represents a notional benefit of 0.5 SPs compared to the uncapped player, and would be 0.4 or as much as 0.67 depending on Archetype. So far, I think, this should be uncontentious.

The issue, then, is whether the uncapped player can train sufficiently before capping in order to negate or indeed surpass this SP saving. Wth an Attribute score of 30, he will be Normal training around 20% per day, saving him ~0.2 SPs per tick. It will therefore take him 2 days to cancel out the SP savings of a 1st-capped 0.4 PLG player, 2.5 days to match a 1st-capped 0.5 PLG player and 3.33 days to match a 1st-capped 0.67 PLG Archetype. On the basis that beyond the first couple of matches, players do not level every 2 days, he is better off waiting and training until he can 2nd-cap the Attribute, at which point the SP savings begin to outweigh the benefits from continued training (but I not going to bore you with the maths on that one any more than I may have done already). As player level (and the time available for training between each level-up) increases so does the advantage of waiting until one can 2nd-cap. You just have to be prepared to accept the early losses, but that is part and parcel of slow building.

There are exceptions to this. On balance, one can justify 1st-capping the primary Attribute of 0.67 PLG Archetypes on day 0 and, of course, once an Attribute starts getting into the mid-30s, the reduced training % is such that 0.5 PLG Archetypes should also follow suit.


You're forgetting that once the SPs are assigned it's the next attribute that gets trained.

 
_Mentalist_
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Airhead
You're forgetting that once the SPs are assigned it's the next attribute that gets trained.



^^This
And when you take multi-training into account once the first attribute is capped.. the increase you get on 2 attributes at once increases your ALG's even that much more cause now you get the full benefit on 1 main attribute and 2 other major attributes.. The math is there.. you just have to look at it in terms of the ALG's converting into SP's.

Trust me.. by level 22 on mine vs. his dots.. mine will be almost a 1/4 more effective and have maximized the potential in attributes alot higher than his.. you'll just have to watch if you actually care.
Edited by _Mentalist_ on Aug 1, 2010 20:21:18
Edited by _Mentalist_ on Aug 1, 2010 20:18:29
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.