User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Tackling: The most useless attribute?
Page:
 
wlarson
offline
Link
 
Agreed. My DT picked up 15 power tackler and +23% tackling over the offseason, went from 30 tackles w/ 13 misses to 55 with just 7.
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wlarson
Agreed. My DT picked up 15 power tackler and +23% tackling over the offseason, went from 30 tackles w/ 13 misses to 55 with just 7.


That's neat.
 
jaxinthebox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
Why the hell are we seriously trying to figure out all of the possible factors involved? I see it in black and white. The attribute is called "T A C K L I N G"...


tack·le
   /ˈtækəl or, for 2–4, ˈteɪkəl/ Show Spelled [tak-uhl or, for 2–4, tey-kuhl] Show IPA noun, verb,-led, -ling.

an act of tackling, as in football; a seizing, grasping, or bringing down.

It's a pretty concrete term... If it isn't the most important part, by a longshot, in a tackle roll, make a new attribute. Come up with a creative name like "helps you a bit in tackling"... Use that. If I build a punter, he can still punt well if I max out P U N T I N G... I don't have to softcap throwing and carrying to make it work as intended...


^Gets it
 
Sal Basss
offline
Link
 
Of course it's not useless, you need at least 60 to get dvg
 
Meatdawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
Why the hell are we seriously trying to figure out all of the possible factors involved? I see it in black and white. The attribute is called "T A C K L I N G"...


tack·le
   /ˈtækəl or, for 2–4, ˈteɪkəl/ Show Spelled [tak-uhl or, for 2–4, tey-kuhl] Show IPA noun, verb,-led, -ling.

an act of tackling, as in football; a seizing, grasping, or bringing down.

It's a pretty concrete term... If it isn't the most important part, by a longshot, in a tackle roll, make a new attribute. Come up with a creative name like "helps you a bit in tackling"... Use that. If I build a punter, he can still punt well if I max out P U N T I N G... I don't have to softcap throwing and carrying to make it work as intended...


Nope but you need str to get the punt further then 30 yards.

VA's have changed the game. You need VA's to break tackles and make tackles.
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
Nope but you need str to get the punt further then 30 yards.

VA's have changed the game. You need VA's to break tackles and make tackles.


Wrong again. But good try. For SOME positions it's true...

See if you can dig up the % of CB's that carry DVG, Make Tackle %, Sure Tackler, Textbook Tackler... Now find how many HB's use some stack of break tackle VA's...

CB's can still tackle pretty much just as well as most DT's even though every LOGICAL major factor that should impact a tackle (size, strength, TACKLING) are MASSIVELY in favor of DT's...
 
Meatdawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
Wrong again. But good try. For SOME positions it's true...

See if you can dig up the % of CB's that carry DVG, Make Tackle %, Sure Tackler, Textbook Tackler... Now find how many HB's use some stack of break tackle VA's...

CB's can still tackle pretty much just as well as most DT's even though every LOGICAL major factor that should impact a tackle (size, strength, TACKLING) are MASSIVELY in favor of DT's...


http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1238985

176 tackles 4 missed last 3 seasons. Plays on Balanced. Goes up against level 60+ hb's regularly.

Hes not a cb, but a lb should do.
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Pretty much, it's like Bort planned every action in this game, then drew a number out of a hat to see how many dart's he would throw for that action.... Then he wrote every attribute on the outer ring of a dartboard, and randomly assigned numbers to the inner rings... He then threw said darts, and wherever the landed, he took the number and attribute that correlated, and thus created his equations...

Then, about 7 seasons in, he got bored with the whole thing, so me put all of the formulas into a blender, took a crap in the cup before closing the lid, hit blend, and WHA-LAH! VA's.
 
jaxinthebox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
Originally posted by jktooley

Why the hell are we seriously trying to figure out all of the possible factors involved? I see it in black and white. The attribute is called "T A C K L I N G"...


tack·le
   /ˈtækəl or, for 2–4, ˈteɪkəl/ Show Spelled [tak-uhl or, for 2–4, tey-kuhl] Show IPA noun, verb,-led, -ling.

an act of tackling, as in football; a seizing, grasping, or bringing down.

It's a pretty concrete term... If it isn't the most important part, by a longshot, in a tackle roll, make a new attribute. Come up with a creative name like "helps you a bit in tackling"... Use that. If I build a punter, he can still punt well if I max out P U N T I N G... I don't have to softcap throwing and carrying to make it work as intended...


Nope but you need str to get the punt further then 30 yards.

VA's have changed the game. You need VA's to break tackles and make tackles.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fvPxzQBIafo

Atwater disagrees
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1238985

176 tackles 4 missed last 3 seasons. Plays on Balanced. Goes up against level 60+ hb's regularly.

Hes not a cb, but a lb should do.



Cool. I asked you to bring me a zebra, and you came back with a donkey that you painted stripes on.
 
Meatdawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley

Cool. I asked you to bring me a zebra, and you came back with a donkey that you painted stripes on.


I proved that "if you know how to build" you can make tackles.

Sorry if it was over your head.
 
jaxinthebox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
Originally posted by jktooley


Cool. I asked you to bring me a zebra, and you came back with a donkey that you painted stripes on.


I proved that "if you know how to build" you can make tackles.

Sorry if it was over your head.


You didn't prove shit, but for the sake of argument, let's say every player needed 100 strength to tackle a 120 strength RB. That would make the sim more unrealistic than it already is. I'm certain Merton Hanks could tackle Christain Okoye 4 out of 5 Times in a head to head battle if Merton had good vision and tackling.
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=684233&playoffs=0

Yet your DT on the Blaze has missed 18% of his tackles... He's missed 7 and made 38... Why do you only build good LB's, and suck at building DT's?


Oh... and fyi... When I was talking about size, str, tackling and using CB's as an example... it's because most weigh less than 190 lbs, have sub 50 str/tkl at the highest levels, and have ZERO tackling VA's... Then you come back with a LB...



* <-------- Where you are











































































----------------------------> ( . ) <-------------- My point
 
Meatdawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jaxinthebox
You didn't prove shit, but for the sake of argument, let's say every player needed 100 strength to tackle a 120 strength RB. That would make the sim more unrealistic than it already is. I'm certain Merton Hanks could tackle Christain Okoye 4 out of 5 Times in a head to head battle if Merton had good vision and tackling.


You only need 60 str and DvG to tackle that hb.
 
Meatdawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=684233&playoffs=0


You linked my DT that is the base for all pass rushing DT's right now.

His main role is to get sacks, not make tackles.

Nice try though.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.