User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Make weight not such a gigantic factor in realized speed
Page:
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock

the burden of evidence falls on you to prove your thesis.


If this thread needs to become about whether weight really does affect speed or not, I won't fight it because I think it will make it harder to ignore. This debate has already been done many times in many other threads, and I think most people who read those threads will agree with me. Which is why I worded the OP how I did, and also why links should suffice to win this "debate" for my side. Although I like the direction TrevJo is headed in and am interested to see how that pans out.

There was a thread in GLB main with a bunch of solid build/speed comparisons maybe 2-3 months ago... iirc the guy that started it was actually trying to nail down a formula that predicted final speed given weight, speed, and other factors. I think that would be a good place to start. Anyone else know what I'm talking about and wanna find a link?
Edited by w_alloy on Feb 4, 2010 18:47:25
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
Originally posted by Warlock


the burden of evidence falls on you to prove your thesis.


If this thread needs to become about whether weight really does affect speed or not, I won't fight it because I think it will make it harder to ignore. This debate has already been done many times in many other threads, and I think most people who read those threads will agree with me. Which is why I worded the OP how I did, and also why links should suffice to win this "debate" for my side. Although I like the direction TrevJo is headed in and am interested to see how that pans out.

There was a thread in GLB main with a bunch of solid build/speed comparisons maybe 2-3 months ago... iirc the guy that started it was actually trying to nail down a formula that predicted final speed given weight, speed, and other factors. I think that would be a good place to start. Anyone else know what I'm talking about and wanna find a link?


Weight definitely affects speed...this is well known. The effects are not enormous but, they are certainly significant...and a player that relies primarily on speed absolutely wants to be as light as possible.

That being said, I am not sure that I advocate changing the current set up, especially since you can hand select player size at this point.

I suppose it might be a good idea to make it more clear to n00bs that weight does indeed matter.

 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
You can stop being defensive any time now. Let's move on.


That's not being defensive, it's called not wanting to try and look for a needle in a haystack. It would be one thing if we knew a little more about what goes on behind the scenes, but we don't. My entire point was that the OP is mistaken and I think that I did a very good job of showing why...

If the OP is correct, what explanation is there for the comparison of the two FBs that I showed? I mean if it's a gigantic factor, wouldn't it be true in all cases or at least be considerable in less than optimal settings? In the examples that I showed, the weight was less than a 2% difference in max speed, that is nominal if anything.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Weight definitely affects speed...this is well known. The effects are not enormous but, they are certainly significant...and a player that relies primarily on speed absolutely wants to be as light as possible.

That being said, I am not sure that I advocate changing the current set up, especially since you can hand select player size at this point.

I suppose it might be a good idea to make it more clear to n00bs that weight does indeed matter.


This.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by TrevJo

You can stop being defensive any time now. Let's move on.


That's not being defensive, it's called not wanting to try and look for a needle in a haystack. It would be one thing if we knew a little more about what goes on behind the scenes, but we don't. My entire point was that the OP is mistaken and I think that I did a very good job of showing why...

If the OP is correct, what explanation is there for the comparison of the two FBs that I showed? I mean if it's a gigantic factor, wouldn't it be true in all cases or at least be considerable in less than optimal settings? In the examples that I showed, the weight was less than a 2% difference in max speed, that is nominal if anything.


Frankly, unless I can see the builds, I don't trust any examples that you bring up. I'm sorry if this seems petty but I don't want to get into it.

ETA: I'm not really calling you a liar... It's just that I don't trust you to be objective. Plus, the replays are 40 days apart and from different seasons, and there are a ton of factors to account for. I'm not going to go through all of them with you when neither of us can see the build of your FB 45 days ago.
Edited by w_alloy on Feb 4, 2010 19:30:14
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology

The effects are not enormous but, they are certainly significant


I think it depends on your definitions of "not enormous" and "certainly significant". It does seem that we disagree on this issue though, as I think a 5% difference in speed is an enourmous differnce in football.

I think it matters a great deal that there are still over a year's worth of players out there who were created under the old system, and the vast majority did not understand how important weight was when they created their players.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
Frankly, unless I can see the builds, I don't trust any examples that you bring up. I'm sorry if this seems petty but I don't want to get into it.

ETA: I'm not really calling you a liar... It's just that I don't trust you to be objective. Plus, the replays are 40 days apart and from different seasons, and there are a ton of factors to account for. I'm not going to go through all of them with you when neither of us can see the build of your FB 45 days ago.


I'm sure there's numerous people on teams that he played for that can attest to his attributes... if you watch his replays for the past 3 seasons, you'll see that his speed is the same in all but like 3 games where I swapped some EQ or temp boosted. MAK has had 80 speed (with EQ) since S10. My build was always open to team members and I posted it numerous times over the past few seasons.

When have I ever been untrustworthy? I'm merely an asshole, a troll and like to bring up my FB A LOT. I've never been deceitful in an actual conversation though, so not sure why you don't trust my examples... as for being objective, what reason would you think that I'm not? What the fuck would I have to gain from being jaded? Last I checked, presenting actual data is about as objective as one can get... not this "being skinny is teh bestestested" thing that you have going on.

The two builds in question are 40 days a part also, so relatively speaking they're at the same level of decline and other such age related issues. As for different seasons, I'm pretty sure I noted that speed got nerfed this season, showing an example of how the same player was slower in S14 than S13.

I played for Hazy in S12, ask him what MAK looked like at plateau... then compare MAK's speed in S12 to S13 (or S11 for that matter) and let me know what you deduce (probably that his speed is fucking 80, like I've been saying). It's this novel concept called problem solving, give it a try sometime.

Weasauce man, utter weaksauce way to back out of an argument that you're losing. You can play make-believe all you want, but it doesn't change the fact that you're wrong. A 2% difference is noticeable and sometimes significant (depending on the base number), but it is not gigantic by any stretch of the imagination, in-fact it's pretty nominal by most people's opinion.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
I think it depends on your definitions of "not enormous" and "certainly significant". It does seem that we disagree on this issue though, as I think a 5% difference in speed is an enourmous differnce in football.

I think it matters a great deal that there are still over a year's worth of players out there who were created under the old system, and the vast majority did not understand how important weight was when they created their players.


Just for shits and giggles, you're saying that player A... who runs 100 yards in 20 secs is vastly inferior to player B... who runs 100 yards in 19 secs? How about if we change things up a bit, player A runs 100 yards in 20 secs and player B runs 105 yards in 20 secs. Yeah, real game breaking numbers there.

Even though, it's more like... player A runs 100 yards in 20 secs and player B runs 102 yards in 20 secs.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
5% speed is an extra yard of separation after 20 yards, which is often the difference between being covered and open, or being able to turn the corner on a pitch. Maybe calling it enourmous is a stretch, but that's a big difference. And I think weight can make more than a 5% difference.

 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
so that's why my WR sucked...
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
I just created 10 players, at 5 different positions, max and min weight of each. Height varies depending on the position, but is the same within positions.
They all have the same attributes:
Speed: 25
Agility: 15
Stamina: 14
Strength, Blocking, Tackling: 12
Jumping, Vision, Confidence, Catching, Carrying: 10
Throwing, Kicking, Punting: 8

I'm putting them on the team I co-own for the last two preseason games, on kickoffs. Next game will be on 2/5 at 9pm ET. First kickoff they should all be fresh. So that's 2 plays times 10 players.


I'm placing them in this order on the kickoff team.

MaxWt DT (340#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950504
MinWt DT (270#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950510
MaxWt OT (320#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950536
MinWt OT (270#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950539
MaxWt TE (266#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950521
MinWt TE (220#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950524
MaxWT SS (225#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950530
MinWt SS (199#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950531
MaxWt CB (202#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950515
MinWt CB (180#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950517
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
5% speed is an extra yard of separation after 20 yards, which is often the difference between being covered and open, or being able to turn the corner on a pitch. Maybe calling it enourmous is a stretch, but that's a big difference. And I think weight can make more than a 5% difference.


You can think whatever you want, but until you start showing numbers or deductive reasoning, don't expect anyone else to buy into your little thesis. I have yet to see any reasonable examples of a 5% or more difference in speed between a fat/skinny player... so far, with a very good set of controls, I see a little less than a 2% difference.

Nor do I think that 1 extra yard traveled, every 20 yards, is game-breaking or even that big of a deal in many situations. We're talking about an extra 1.8 inches every yard traveled, I do not see that being the difference maker in getting separation or turning the corner... It's most definitely not at the top of my list on things that are fucked up in GLB.
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
And on any given replay that you show me you also need to prove the following:

His Morale and Energy. Oops, Bort doesn't show that on a per play basis. Any replay that you show will be biased based on those two bars that cannot be seen.
 
Mike1709
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Time Trial
And on any given replay that you show me you also need to prove the following:

His Morale and Energy. Oops, Bort doesn't show that on a per play basis. Any replay that you show will be biased based on those two bars that cannot be seen.


But he has them on kickoffs so 50% of the time that will be first play of the game when energy/morale is at 100
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
The great race is less than an hour away.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.