User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AA Leagues > Canada AA #2 > Season 14 Power Rankings
Page:
 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
pabst wrote a GM script to use a set of formulas that griffin8r developed, and I'm hearing good things about it. I just installed it, but I've been told that it takes a while to rank and I haven't seen any results yet. I'll report back if it's anything worth pursuing.
 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
Here's the output after eight games (without cleanup) -- how does it compare to what you're seeing?

Pos Score Name Season Playoffs
1 1805 Goose Green Gentoos 1805 0
2 862 North Alaska Insomniacs 862 0
3 840 Sin City Red Devils 840 0
4 782 Saskatchewan Hell Hounds 782 0
5 438 Bosphorus Oftas 438 0
6 381 Indianapolis Stampede 381 0
7 325 Windsor Wildcats 325 0
8 225 Destruction Bay Destroyers 225 0
9 55 Rum Runners 55 0
10 34 The Disturbed 34 0
11 18 Hudson Hitmen 18 0
12 18 Winnipeg Infidels 18 0
13 8 Beaver Lodge Bigfeet 8 0
14 8 SEBRING GECKO S 8 0
15 -8 Kingston Loyalists -8 0
16 -19 Thunder Bay Huskies -19 0
17 -31 Sainte-Foy Nordiques -31 0
18 -80 Medellin Baby Niners -80 0
19 -89 Barkmere Bulldawgs -89 0
20 -103 Texas Copperheads -103 0
21 -234 Rocky Mountain Caddies -234 0
22 -291 Montreal Shamrocks -291 0
23 -418 Orlando Ninjas -418 0
24 -712 Tallinn Tornadoes -712 0
25 -719 Serenity Valley Browncoats -719 0
26 -930 Bangkok Storm -930 0
27 -1016 Arctic Blubberin' Esquimaux -1016 0
28 -2311 St. James's Gate -2311 0
29 -2393 Great Bear Lake Shamans -2393 0
30 -2800 Edmonton Slashers -2800 0
31 -3302 Jefferson Parish Kenner Fades -3302 0
32 -4389 Yukon Do It -4389 0
 
Link
 
Interesting... Some teams are similarly ranked, others not, and I can't figure out why.
Can you post the link?

Thanks
 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Michael_418131
Interesting... Some teams are similarly ranked, others not, and I can't figure out why.
Can you post the link?

Thanks


http://userscripts.org/scripts/show/66880

Here's griffin8r's explanation of how it works:

Originally posted by griffin8r

Team A plays team B. Team A beats team B by X points. If X > 63, MoV=63, but MoL is unaffected.

aW = Team A's total wins, aL = their total losses, bW, bL, etc.

Team A gets (MoV*(bW^2)/(bL^2)) points added to their raw power ranking.

Team B gets (MoL*(aL^2)/(aW^2)) deducted from theirs.

This leaves the possibility for 0 points added for beating a winless team, and 0 points deducted for losing to an undefeated team. However, the raw ranking score (R) is tweaked downward to create an adjusted score (A) - so even losing to an undefeated can still have a big impact on your score in a multiplicative fashion

If the team has a positive R, R/(aL+1) = A

If the team has a negative R = A

Teams are ranked by their A, not their R.

Now

In the playoffs, the A from the regular season is carried over, and each game the team plays takes the raw R from that game and adds it directly to the A, adding either a W or a L to the team's overall record to calculate the A and the bonuses/penalties from the opposing teams W/L.

So, say team A beats team B in the first round of the playoffs. Team A gets:

(A) + (MoV*(bW^2)/(bL^2))

and team B gets

(A) - (MoL*(bL^2)/(bW^2))

team B will have no more adjustments to their score except as prior opponents win or lose deeper into the playoffs, where team A will get another direct alteration to their score based on their performance in the following game.


 
Pher Hobbits
offline
Link
 
So, magic. Got it.
 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pher Hobbits
So, magic. Got it.


Heh.
 
Precisionist
offline
Link
 
Well big test coming up for Sin City, to see if they deserve that ranking.
 
Link
 
To CDZYO...

Ahh, finally, a weighted ranking that makes sense. Tonight, I'm going to grab the script and start posting alongside the one we have. Thanks much.

Here's something to consider using our team's last game as an example, and why rankings -any and all- should never be taken at face value.

My team, Rum Runners, played Sin City, a well coached team with a winning record -now undefeated in the Eastern Conference, but they haven't played anyone as equally challenging as themselves up until they played us. We lost to them by a relatively narrow margin ("relative" by GLB standards, anyway). The outcome of this game would have been very different had it not been for a typo in our OAI. I had a 3rd Quarter 3rd-Down play that was improperly set to run on downs 1 thru 4. This resulted in us going for 1st down on 4th down with 5 yards to go for the 1st when the score was tied. Normally we would have punted. Had we punted, field position would have been better for us. Instead we suffered 2 turnover on downs which was followed by two Sin City field goals. The moral here is human error in the AIs will inversely impact game outcomes and scoring in general.

The other more obvious example is a team that picks up many players once the season has begun, such as Bosphorus, another well-coached team who, I understand, picked up something like 6 new players since early Feb.

Again, thanks a lot.



 
pistaccio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Precisionist
Well big test coming up for Sin City, to see if they deserve that ranking.


Well, what do you think now?

edit for Michael_418131: Yeah, we were short on LB position, that's why The Disturbed scored that much point against us. Now and then, we try to fill the gaps in our roster, I think they were helpful
Edited by pistaccio on Feb 24, 2010 08:46:01
 
Link
 
Originally posted by pistaccio
Well, what do you think now?

edit for Michael_418131: Yeah, we were short on LB position, that's why The Disturbed scored that much point against us. Now and then, we try to fill the gaps in our roster, I think they were helpful


we beat you shouldnt we be in first
 
pistaccio
offline
Link
 
Ask this to Bort, not me

Anyway, here is your answer:
Edited by pistaccio on Feb 25, 2010 16:08:41
 
pistaccio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by scarletmbb
5. How are ties broken in the standing?
-----a. If there are only 2 teams, it's just based upon the head-to-head matchup
-----b. If there are more than 2 teams, then it's based upon these factor in this order:
1. # of head-to-head wins against the other teams with the same record
2. # of points scored
3. # of points allowed.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=81987
 
Precisionist
offline
Link
 
Well the Offas pretty much put us in our place. Gameplanning goes out the window after a certain level difference.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Precisionist
Well the Offas pretty much put us in our place. Gameplanning goes out the window after a certain level difference.


Agreed. Picking up those new players helps too. Nonetheless, they are a good team.
 
Link
 
To CDZYO...

I grabbed griffin8r's script.
Will post results later on this afternoon (after today's games -see, I didn't forget).

We're getting wacked on the east coast with bad snow storms, and between work and trying to dig-out, I've had my hands full.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.