User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > Do you believe in Evolution?
Page:
 
shaun123987
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by NiteMaestro

To be polite to all theories, I say this.

Evolution may not be right. Like many say, it is just a theory.

However, as theories go, it is the most convincing and supported. Moreover, I have yet to see any other theory present as powerful of a case that evolution has.

Yes, there are holes in it,

but name something scientific that doesn't.


Pythagorean theorem



A^2+B^2=C^2 ?
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shaun123987
So all the mutations just happen to be positive mutations that help them with what they need to survive? What about mutations that make them inefficient?


If a mutation makes a creature less efficient, then it is less likely to be successful (which in evolutionary terms means "breed") and pass on its genes. So bad mutations usually die with the host, while good mutations are more likely to help the creature survive and therefore pass on its DNA.
 
JoSCh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shaun123987
Originally posted by OttawaShane

That's like asking if I believe the sun rises in the east and sets in the west.

And for those confused...evolution isn't purposeful, or all of a sudden. Members of a species will occasionally have mutations. Like a longer beak. If that beak helps the bird thrive, it will be a better breeder, and it will help make more birds with long-ish beaks. In time, if the mutations helps the species, all of those birds will thus have longer beaks. Or they've all accidently pecked each others eyes out in the nest, and the trait vanishes or the species dies out.



So all the mutations just happen to be positive mutations that help them with what they need to survive? What about mutations that make them inefficient?



They die off?

For someone who seems to spell and formulate questions well, you sure ain't much for thinkin'.
 
Semineer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shaun123987
Originally posted by OttawaShane

That's like asking if I believe the sun rises in the east and sets in the west.

And for those confused...evolution isn't purposeful, or all of a sudden. Members of a species will occasionally have mutations. Like a longer beak. If that beak helps the bird thrive, it will be a better breeder, and it will help make more birds with long-ish beaks. In time, if the mutations helps the species, all of those birds will thus have longer beaks. Or they've all accidently pecked each others eyes out in the nest, and the trait vanishes or the species dies out.



So all the mutations just happen to be positive mutations that help them with what they need to survive? What about mutations that make them inefficient?



Why would an animal evolve into something that doesn't work? The species would die off. Maybe this will help...did snakes use to have legs? Some believe so and there are a few species out there that have protrusions from their body right about where legs would be a good spot to go, like lizards. Those species maybe got a late start on shedding their legs.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shaun123987
Originally posted by OttawaShane

That's like asking if I believe the sun rises in the east and sets in the west.

And for those confused...evolution isn't purposeful, or all of a sudden. Members of a species will occasionally have mutations. Like a longer beak. If that beak helps the bird thrive, it will be a better breeder, and it will help make more birds with long-ish beaks. In time, if the mutations helps the species, all of those birds will thus have longer beaks. Or they've all accidently pecked each others eyes out in the nest, and the trait vanishes or the species dies out.



So all the mutations just happen to be positive mutations that help them with what they need to survive? What about mutations that make them inefficient?



The animals with mutations that made them inefficient don't last long enough to breed for more than a generation or two, if they even make it out of the nest/womb/egg.

And of course, females choose breeding partners that haven't starved to death or incapable of movement or buying flowers. So mutations that don't help don't tend to last long.

Some mutations are of course neutral, and will survive - like blonde hair in humans.

I have a theory that boobs are getting bigger due to natural selection, but it could be obesity and implants that are skewing the numbers.
 
shaun123987
offline
Link
 
It's all pretty random with natural selection...
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JoSCh
Originally posted by shaun123987

Originally posted by OttawaShane


That's like asking if I believe the sun rises in the east and sets in the west.

And for those confused...evolution isn't purposeful, or all of a sudden. Members of a species will occasionally have mutations. Like a longer beak. If that beak helps the bird thrive, it will be a better breeder, and it will help make more birds with long-ish beaks. In time, if the mutations helps the species, all of those birds will thus have longer beaks. Or they've all accidently pecked each others eyes out in the nest, and the trait vanishes or the species dies out.



So all the mutations just happen to be positive mutations that help them with what they need to survive? What about mutations that make them inefficient?



They die off?

For someone who seems to spell and formulate questions well, you sure ain't much for thinkin'.


Actually I really respect that a sceptic asked that question - it shows he *is* thinking and putting the pieces together. Nice work.
 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Shooting Star
Originally posted by fistofreak

if soemone that believes in evolution would like to give me some "Proof" of evolution then i would be glad to talk about it.


Explain antibiotics. There's all the proof you need about evolution.


sick burn
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Wouldn't an example of inefficient mutation be people breeding dogs to be smaller and smaller? If you set those dogs free into the wild they probably wouldn't last a week, not because they've been domesticated, but because of their lack of physical assets and ability to provide for themselves.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy
Originally posted by OttawaShane

There was a lot of art created back when the bible was written, and none of it depicts a brontosaur.


That's because they wore disguises, silly.


damn, I've been pwned.
 
Semineer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
Wouldn't an example of inefficient mutation be people breeding dogs to be smaller and smaller? If you set those dogs free into the wild they probably wouldn't last a week, not because they've been domesticated, but because of their lack of physical assets and ability to provide for themselves.


Does human intervention still count?
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
Wouldn't an example of inefficient mutation be people breeding dogs to be smaller and smaller? If you set those dogs free into the wild they probably wouldn't last a week, not because they've been domesticated, but because of their lack of physical assets and ability to provide for themselves.


Pretty much...that is human selection as opposed to natural selection.

In human selection the ones that weren't desired were unable to breed, in natural selection the ones that weren't desired died.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
Wouldn't an example of inefficient mutation be people breeding dogs to be smaller and smaller? If you set those dogs free into the wild they probably wouldn't last a week, not because they've been domesticated, but because of their lack of physical assets and ability to provide for themselves.


There are cases in dog breeding where the breed is becoming unviable. Dachsunds are getting too long and are having spinal problems. Flat faced dogs are having severe breathing problems, not to mention eyes that easily pop out of the socket.

To carry on your excellent point - people exploited mutations to create dog breeds by breeding dogs with certain traits so they could create new dogs with those traits. But in the instances I've mentioned above, some of those mutations have become so extreme that even as lapdogs, those animals are becoming unviable.

 
JoSCh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
Originally posted by JoSCh

Originally posted by shaun123987


Originally posted by OttawaShane



That's like asking if I believe the sun rises in the east and sets in the west.

And for those confused...evolution isn't purposeful, or all of a sudden. Members of a species will occasionally have mutations. Like a longer beak. If that beak helps the bird thrive, it will be a better breeder, and it will help make more birds with long-ish beaks. In time, if the mutations helps the species, all of those birds will thus have longer beaks. Or they've all accidently pecked each others eyes out in the nest, and the trait vanishes or the species dies out.



So all the mutations just happen to be positive mutations that help them with what they need to survive? What about mutations that make them inefficient?



They die off?

For someone who seems to spell and formulate questions well, you sure ain't much for thinkin'.


Actually I really respect that a sceptic asked that question - it shows he *is* thinking and putting the pieces together. Nice work.


Possible if he's young, smart, and repressed. But this is the internet; I suspect a trap and wanted to start ridiculing him early. Pre-emptive douchebaggery? Possibly, and if so, I'm sorry.
 
divine_monkey
offline
Link
 
We've devolved from Monkeys. Clearly something went wrong.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.