+ 1
Forum > Suggestions > Add Gold / Silver / Copper Leagues For Each Level Cap And Change Promotion System
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
So you think you can get 32 SSB teams in the same league? They don't want to play each other, that's why they SSB.
What I am saying with gold leagues the majority of the teams in it will be SSB, but what about the non SSB that winds up in one of these leagues with them?
This game and the owners/agents who own/manage teams will bitch if they get forced into a gold league. I have seen too many posts from that type of player. They would act like they are being punished for winning by being placed in a stacked league and wont allow it.
You would need some serious incentives, like 3 pieces of MVP gear for the team to distribute for example, and even then it will be troublesome.
I seriously doubt there are so many SSB teams out there. My guess is any given cap will have 8 tops. That still leaves 4 playoff spots in gold (assuming that all the SSB teams have good enough coordinators to be able to win vs every non SSB team)
In any case, the suggestion has monetary incentives and fan support incentives to try and benefit the "lower end" gold teams.
So you think you can get 32 SSB teams in the same league? They don't want to play each other, that's why they SSB.
What I am saying with gold leagues the majority of the teams in it will be SSB, but what about the non SSB that winds up in one of these leagues with them?
This game and the owners/agents who own/manage teams will bitch if they get forced into a gold league. I have seen too many posts from that type of player. They would act like they are being punished for winning by being placed in a stacked league and wont allow it.
You would need some serious incentives, like 3 pieces of MVP gear for the team to distribute for example, and even then it will be troublesome.
I seriously doubt there are so many SSB teams out there. My guess is any given cap will have 8 tops. That still leaves 4 playoff spots in gold (assuming that all the SSB teams have good enough coordinators to be able to win vs every non SSB team)
In any case, the suggestion has monetary incentives and fan support incentives to try and benefit the "lower end" gold teams.
Stray Doug
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
I actually like this idea a lot, at the very least in spirit.
What do you do when you don't have an even number of teams to fill leagues? I guess just take the next best? You're possibly going to end up with a couple "silver" tier teams in leagues full of copper. That's always the problem with this sort of thing: they spillover guys. It's great for everyone but 1 or 2 teams who are stuck with crap. At least the other way the bad teams are spread around.
I think Chysil basically responded similarly, but yeah... it's not that you drop a few silvers into the copper league, but instead if need be you bring a couple coppers up to the silver to make the numbers work... as long as you have enough silver. But seems looking at current league counts this wouldn't be a terrible issue in most cases.
I don't even think you need the gold league necessarily to make this work, although I can certainly see it's value in trying to create a bit more league parity overall. But if all the teams who "would have" come in 1st/2nd/3rd, etc. are moved to the gold league, the teams who "would have" come in 3rd/4th/5th (losing only to the top teams) now become the dominant teams in silver. Still, it should in theory be a bit more balanced... I think that's more about creating enjoyment for the top teams by being able to have good competition for the teams in gold league than it is about improving things for the mid-teams in silver. But, if you didn't have a gold league, that helps address the issue Bort raised above, by creating one additional silver league across which to "spread" the borderline teams.
For example, if you had 150 clearly "non-copper" teams and 74 copper teams... that could be:
A - 32 gold (1 league), 128 silver (4 leagues) , 64 copper (2 leagues) - So the "10 best" copper get bumped up to silver, or 2.5 copper teams per silver league
B - 160 silver (5 leagues), 64 copper (2 leagues) - Again the "10 best" copper get bumped up to silver, or 2.0 copper teams per silver league
Really I think the bigger of the two issues that takes the fun out of the game is the prevalence of gut jobs and CPU squads and so on (rather than the really good teams)... if a couple such teams minorly taint the silver league, that's still a major improvement... sort of a "don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good" type thing. Gold league is just gravy.
Overall +1
I actually like this idea a lot, at the very least in spirit.
What do you do when you don't have an even number of teams to fill leagues? I guess just take the next best? You're possibly going to end up with a couple "silver" tier teams in leagues full of copper. That's always the problem with this sort of thing: they spillover guys. It's great for everyone but 1 or 2 teams who are stuck with crap. At least the other way the bad teams are spread around.
I think Chysil basically responded similarly, but yeah... it's not that you drop a few silvers into the copper league, but instead if need be you bring a couple coppers up to the silver to make the numbers work... as long as you have enough silver. But seems looking at current league counts this wouldn't be a terrible issue in most cases.
I don't even think you need the gold league necessarily to make this work, although I can certainly see it's value in trying to create a bit more league parity overall. But if all the teams who "would have" come in 1st/2nd/3rd, etc. are moved to the gold league, the teams who "would have" come in 3rd/4th/5th (losing only to the top teams) now become the dominant teams in silver. Still, it should in theory be a bit more balanced... I think that's more about creating enjoyment for the top teams by being able to have good competition for the teams in gold league than it is about improving things for the mid-teams in silver. But, if you didn't have a gold league, that helps address the issue Bort raised above, by creating one additional silver league across which to "spread" the borderline teams.
For example, if you had 150 clearly "non-copper" teams and 74 copper teams... that could be:
A - 32 gold (1 league), 128 silver (4 leagues) , 64 copper (2 leagues) - So the "10 best" copper get bumped up to silver, or 2.5 copper teams per silver league
B - 160 silver (5 leagues), 64 copper (2 leagues) - Again the "10 best" copper get bumped up to silver, or 2.0 copper teams per silver league
Really I think the bigger of the two issues that takes the fun out of the game is the prevalence of gut jobs and CPU squads and so on (rather than the really good teams)... if a couple such teams minorly taint the silver league, that's still a major improvement... sort of a "don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good" type thing. Gold league is just gravy.
Overall +1
I've been on a team with a preset roster of all good agents with good coordinators and depending on the league we get in it's usually a cake walk over 90% of the teams. Maybe like 2 or 3 tough games a season (not including playoffs) and the rest are wins by 40+. Now having teams that perform that well is a bit rare I'm sure, there's probably less than 32 of them per cap, but it'd be nice to separate them, and let them play teams that will give them more of a challenge.
Arcadic
offline
offline
I enjoy the idea of this. Making caps competitive this way could ease the pain of a long boring 2 game season. I would suggest 2 things.
1. No trophies for Copper.
Encourages teams and agents to at least try and win in a real league over what could essentially be a D league for each cap.
2. Allow self-promotion of 3 caps even if not in the title game.
Keeps competitive teams wanting to reach the top able to do so.
1. No trophies for Copper.
Encourages teams and agents to at least try and win in a real league over what could essentially be a D league for each cap.
2. Allow self-promotion of 3 caps even if not in the title game.
Keeps competitive teams wanting to reach the top able to do so.
Stray Doug
offline
offline
Originally posted by Arcadic
2. Allow self-promotion of 3 caps even if not in the title game.
Keeps competitive teams wanting to reach the top able to do so.
Maybe for all teams in the Gold League... but Silvers still need to be top 2?
2. Allow self-promotion of 3 caps even if not in the title game.
Keeps competitive teams wanting to reach the top able to do so.
Maybe for all teams in the Gold League... but Silvers still need to be top 2?
you realize that there is that promotion is not a set level of caps right? It's promotion to the lowest level cap you fit in. The idea is competition is simulated by being out leveled, but rather by playing the other good teams that are of your level
Time Trial
offline
offline
The reason that Gold/Silver/Copper works so well in Pee Wee is because everyone is on an equal footing. Players all start out at Level One with no experience.
A way around that is to use creation date instead of level cap.
This suggestion seems to need the cap to be build age instead of a level cap system.
Let's say that we are talking about unveiling this in Season 14.
In Season 14 there would only be one league that participates in this division.
First Year (Season 14):
First League (Replaces a cap 14 league)
Minimum Age: Players built this season.
Maximum Age: Players built day 30 in Season 12
This league can't really have a Gold, Silver, Copper because teams didn't have a last season?
Second Year (Season 15):
First League
Minimum Age: Players built season 15
Maximum Age: Players built day 30 in Season 13
Second League
Minimum Age: Players built in Season 14
Maximum Age: Players built day 30 in Season 12
Third Year (Season 16):
First League
Minimum Age: Players built season 16
Maximum Age: Players built day 30 in Season 14
Second League
Minimum Age: Players built season 15
Maximum Age: Players built day 30 in Season 13
Third League
Minimum Age: Players built in Season 14
Maximum Age: Players built day 30 in Season 12
Fourth Year (Season 17):
First League
Minimum Age: Players built season 17
Maximum Age: Players built day 30 in Season 15
Second League
Minimum Age: Players built season 16
Maximum Age: Players built day 30 in Season 14
Third League
Minimum Age: Players built season 15
Maximum Age: Players built day 30 in Season 13
Fourth League
Minimum Age: Players built in Season 14
Maximum Age: Players built day 30 in Season 12
And so on up until you hit year 5 where no new leagues need to be created. At this point, you will have phased out all of the capped minor leagues. Or this system can continue right up through to the 12th season. Bragging rights (and an ultimate trophy) would then go to the teams with the most points for their class (Each Gold win = 10 points, silver wins = 4 points, copper wins = 1 point. Winning a trophy gives you an additional 20% to the points already earned that season.) I would say that GLB would offer some serious flex to the owner of the top five teams from each class. When I say class, I mean teams that all started together in the First League in the same season.
Every season your team moves up a league and is classed into Copper, Silver, and Gold based on their record from the previous season. If a team is purchased mid-stream, it would be moved down to Copper where they would need to work their way back up to Gold.
Gold and Silver teams can move on to the uncapped system after five seasons, continue on in the Gold/Silver/Copper system, sell their team, or reset everything and start again in the First League.
Players playing in Gold will receive access to better equipment, more fame, and unique trophies.
Also I think that we should just do away with stadiums and money like they basically have in the Pee Wees because that would keep parity from season to season and not disadvantage owners who join mid-stream. Equipment should be free. Training should be free. Advanced Equipment should still cost BTs... just do away with cash altoghter. It really isn't needed in this game as far as I'm concerned... we are doing fine in Pee Wee with infinite cash.
A way around that is to use creation date instead of level cap.
This suggestion seems to need the cap to be build age instead of a level cap system.
Let's say that we are talking about unveiling this in Season 14.
In Season 14 there would only be one league that participates in this division.
First Year (Season 14):
First League (Replaces a cap 14 league)
Minimum Age: Players built this season.
Maximum Age: Players built day 30 in Season 12
This league can't really have a Gold, Silver, Copper because teams didn't have a last season?
Second Year (Season 15):
First League
Minimum Age: Players built season 15
Maximum Age: Players built day 30 in Season 13
Second League
Minimum Age: Players built in Season 14
Maximum Age: Players built day 30 in Season 12
Third Year (Season 16):
First League
Minimum Age: Players built season 16
Maximum Age: Players built day 30 in Season 14
Second League
Minimum Age: Players built season 15
Maximum Age: Players built day 30 in Season 13
Third League
Minimum Age: Players built in Season 14
Maximum Age: Players built day 30 in Season 12
Fourth Year (Season 17):
First League
Minimum Age: Players built season 17
Maximum Age: Players built day 30 in Season 15
Second League
Minimum Age: Players built season 16
Maximum Age: Players built day 30 in Season 14
Third League
Minimum Age: Players built season 15
Maximum Age: Players built day 30 in Season 13
Fourth League
Minimum Age: Players built in Season 14
Maximum Age: Players built day 30 in Season 12
And so on up until you hit year 5 where no new leagues need to be created. At this point, you will have phased out all of the capped minor leagues. Or this system can continue right up through to the 12th season. Bragging rights (and an ultimate trophy) would then go to the teams with the most points for their class (Each Gold win = 10 points, silver wins = 4 points, copper wins = 1 point. Winning a trophy gives you an additional 20% to the points already earned that season.) I would say that GLB would offer some serious flex to the owner of the top five teams from each class. When I say class, I mean teams that all started together in the First League in the same season.
Every season your team moves up a league and is classed into Copper, Silver, and Gold based on their record from the previous season. If a team is purchased mid-stream, it would be moved down to Copper where they would need to work their way back up to Gold.
Gold and Silver teams can move on to the uncapped system after five seasons, continue on in the Gold/Silver/Copper system, sell their team, or reset everything and start again in the First League.
Players playing in Gold will receive access to better equipment, more fame, and unique trophies.
Also I think that we should just do away with stadiums and money like they basically have in the Pee Wees because that would keep parity from season to season and not disadvantage owners who join mid-stream. Equipment should be free. Training should be free. Advanced Equipment should still cost BTs... just do away with cash altoghter. It really isn't needed in this game as far as I'm concerned... we are doing fine in Pee Wee with infinite cash.
Time Trial
offline
offline
Originally posted by Chysil
you realize that there is that promotion is not a set level of caps right? It's promotion to the lowest level cap you fit in. The idea is competition is simulated by being out leveled, but rather by playing the other good teams that are of your level
I realize that my suggestion above offers quite a bit of a different answer to the Gold/Silver/Copper than you are offering. If you like any of the ideas, feel free to incorporate them into your own idea. If you hate the whole thing, let me know and I will make it its own suggestion.
you realize that there is that promotion is not a set level of caps right? It's promotion to the lowest level cap you fit in. The idea is competition is simulated by being out leveled, but rather by playing the other good teams that are of your level
I realize that my suggestion above offers quite a bit of a different answer to the Gold/Silver/Copper than you are offering. If you like any of the ideas, feel free to incorporate them into your own idea. If you hate the whole thing, let me know and I will make it its own suggestion.
jsid
offline
offline
-1
There's a large chunk of avid pee wee players (myself included) that don't like that promotion system. I doubt this will be the Connecticut Compromise you're making out to be. This would be a train wreck.
There's a large chunk of avid pee wee players (myself included) that don't like that promotion system. I doubt this will be the Connecticut Compromise you're making out to be. This would be a train wreck.
the problem with age based caps, is that you are assuming players of the same age are the same level (or should be). Between boosting, only getting 80% xp instead of max etc etc, you can have several level difference in level between players of the same age.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1511738
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1509758
both 146 days old... ones 24 the other 33 (that's the power of boosting)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1503001
again 146 days old, only 30, thanks to xp variances and probably a minor boosting difference etc
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1511738
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1509758
both 146 days old... ones 24 the other 33 (that's the power of boosting)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1503001
again 146 days old, only 30, thanks to xp variances and probably a minor boosting difference etc
dkmfan
offline
offline
I like some of the ideas, but IMO there are some serious issues with the structure you are using.
I think the GSC (gold, silver, copper) would be highly limiting in placing teams. Especially with the bonus/penalty system you propose for that placement. Sometimes the system needs to pull a few good teams up an extra cap, and the ranking "demotion" would quickly become a headache.
Instead, I would eliminate the bonuses and the GSC ranks. I would start with assigning cap pools on day 42 (plenty of time to recruit), with league assignment on day 0. The system would take the best 32 teams and make that #1, #2 33-64 and so on through the whole cap. This would offer better matching, and wouldn't hurt teams too badly if they have to jump an extra cap, since the leagues would be as competitive as possible.
Now for the exploit killers. 1) teams would be assessed on player talent- the whole roster will be considered with no regard for the depth chart. Previous success will be considered but only from the previous season (too easy to tank preseason). 2) SPs not assigned will count heavily to a players value. 3) Any team without a filled roster by day 0 will be repossessed.
This is sort of my ideal structure.
I think the GSC (gold, silver, copper) would be highly limiting in placing teams. Especially with the bonus/penalty system you propose for that placement. Sometimes the system needs to pull a few good teams up an extra cap, and the ranking "demotion" would quickly become a headache.
Instead, I would eliminate the bonuses and the GSC ranks. I would start with assigning cap pools on day 42 (plenty of time to recruit), with league assignment on day 0. The system would take the best 32 teams and make that #1, #2 33-64 and so on through the whole cap. This would offer better matching, and wouldn't hurt teams too badly if they have to jump an extra cap, since the leagues would be as competitive as possible.
Now for the exploit killers. 1) teams would be assessed on player talent- the whole roster will be considered with no regard for the depth chart. Previous success will be considered but only from the previous season (too easy to tank preseason). 2) SPs not assigned will count heavily to a players value. 3) Any team without a filled roster by day 0 will be repossessed.
This is sort of my ideal structure.
Time Trial
offline
offline
Originally posted by Chysil
the problem with age based caps, is that you are assuming players of the same age are the same level (or should be). Between boosting, only getting 80% xp instead of max etc etc, you can have several level difference in level between players of the same age.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1511738
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1509758
both 146 days old... ones 24 the other 33 (that's the power of boosting)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1503001
again 146 days old, only 30, thanks to xp variances and probably a minor boosting difference etc
Yes, but I'm also assuming that boosting players will find a home in Gold, which will keep the actual levels very similar. It will allow players who don't boost the chance to play other players that don't boost right through their entire careers. You probably don't see a lot of non-boosted players playing in Pro or World league... you won't see that many playing in Gold either.
Owners would still be able to recruit the best players for their age group (and shouldn't the best build for their age be part of the point?). Good building will be rewarded in the long term, as will boosting. Which it already does in the current system, but doesn't allow the SSB players the huge advantages that they currently are seeing. Cap-building will still exist as long as ALGs exist, but that's just part of the system.
the problem with age based caps, is that you are assuming players of the same age are the same level (or should be). Between boosting, only getting 80% xp instead of max etc etc, you can have several level difference in level between players of the same age.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1511738
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1509758
both 146 days old... ones 24 the other 33 (that's the power of boosting)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1503001
again 146 days old, only 30, thanks to xp variances and probably a minor boosting difference etc
Yes, but I'm also assuming that boosting players will find a home in Gold, which will keep the actual levels very similar. It will allow players who don't boost the chance to play other players that don't boost right through their entire careers. You probably don't see a lot of non-boosted players playing in Pro or World league... you won't see that many playing in Gold either.
Owners would still be able to recruit the best players for their age group (and shouldn't the best build for their age be part of the point?). Good building will be rewarded in the long term, as will boosting. Which it already does in the current system, but doesn't allow the SSB players the huge advantages that they currently are seeing. Cap-building will still exist as long as ALGs exist, but that's just part of the system.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























