User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Thoughts on Borts new post about XP changes in the announcements forum.
Page:
 
keedon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hexone
Reposted but needs to be seen:

I really have no objections with this rule, but only for players that are signed after the rule is in place. Adding it now hurts owners that spent countless hours recruiting in the offseason before knowing about this rule.

Plus once a team is promoted they are in an automatic disadvantage over the rest of the competition. Man I really can't believe this is happening so close to the start of the season.


yep, i second that,
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by dergillz

Originally posted by Unconquered


Originally posted by dergillz



beautifully said. I have no further comments.


It's good for people like you're team who fail to recruit good players. Congrats


Unlike you I might be thinking of the game as a whole rather than just myself. This idea will level the game out, stop the cheaters and make it more enjoyable in the long run. I have plenty of good players on my team. It's the least of my worries.


Instead of making strict rules that affect everyone, why not have severe discipline for cheaters.


Because bringing in a high leveled team of ringers isn't cheating per se. It's just bad sportsmanship. We are doing this to encourage higher leveled players to find more suitable competition.

I love the complaints, guys. Keep them coming. You have no idea how big or small the effect will be, how the math will work, and yet you are worried it will allow other people to catch up and compete (including the other players on your own team!), or that it will somehow decimate your team. That helps prove to me that we're targeting the right area of the game: the part that people actually care enough about that they will think about fair play.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
The only thing that troubles me is people (like myself) who are on a team with a bunch of friends. We can't bank on winning the conference and moving up every season. Should we be penalized for wanting to play together with our friends?
 
Dudeamis
offline
Link
 
I hate this idea. Thanks for punishing GMs who do a good job of bringing in high level talent. Now my corner back, who is one of the highest level players in the league gets to suffer because he wanted to play on a team with friends.
 
naraic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chad13
I personally think it's a terrible idea. I have 1 level 20 (SS Bob Sanders) in a BBB team but I didn't put him there to beat up on inferior competition. I put him there because that is the team that a friend of mine managed to buy. He didn't have the option of buying a pro team...this all would be fine and dandy if owners could choose between pro leagues and lower leagues but they can't. So now my player is gonna get screwed out of legitimate experience just because no pro league teams were available?

Why should some owners be rewarded because they had a luckier draw than others?


You could have just made new players for the dirtybirds rather than try and beat up inferior opposition.
 
MD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Houndster
Originally posted by MD

So if this is based on that average league player level list, our entire league will be penalized almost.


That doesn't make any sense. If your entire league is good your average will reflect your players.


Yes it does. Our league has an average of like 14.xx. But theres a ton of players around Level 17 and up. Do all the players higher than level 14 get penalized?
 
chad13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asparagus
its a beta game. get over it, things are always changing like this. I'm happy something like this finally has been put into the game. I hope this means a level 17 OT playing in a low level league wont be doing 50-60 pancakes a game anymore.


Get over it? You think its fine that people go out and spend money on teams and then go and find out that if they put players above a certain level on their team, the players will be penalized? Good luck with recruiting decent talent if your not in an elite league. Not to mention when teams get promoted they have a very good chance of getting demoted that next season unless they get VERY lucky in recruiting due to the level differences.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Houndster
Puts an end to monopolies. I like it.


Monopolies? Tell me what team in this game has exclusive control of something or a team that is the only seller of something?
 
Mornacale
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asparagus
its a beta game. get over it, things are always changing like this.

Bullshit excuse. Bullshit excuse. Bullshit excuse.

If you take money for your game, particularly in the huge quantities that this game has obviously raked in, you simply cannot claim that it doesn't matter that happens because it's in beta.

This is a terrible change, with a potential strong negative effect on many teams that have in no way broken the rules either in spirit on in letter. It runs directly counter to the spirit of teamwork and comradery that a game like this should foster.
 
Johnny Wad
offline
Link
 
Hey Bort. What is going to be the level over/under for each league as to where a player will be effected or not effected? I know you probably can't give out specifics, just wanted a rough estimate. Thanks.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 01:18:19
 
seven7
offline
Link
 
i like the new rule and hope more fair rules for players and owners alike are put into the game soon.
 
chad13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by naraic
Originally posted by chad13

I personally think it's a terrible idea. I have 1 level 20 (SS Bob Sanders) in a BBB team but I didn't put him there to beat up on inferior competition. I put him there because that is the team that a friend of mine managed to buy. He didn't have the option of buying a pro team...this all would be fine and dandy if owners could choose between pro leagues and lower leagues but they can't. So now my player is gonna get screwed out of legitimate experience just because no pro league teams were available?

Why should some owners be rewarded because they had a luckier draw than others?


You could have just made new players for the dirtybirds rather than try and beat up inferior opposition.


I did make players for the Dirtybirds...only one player was already made.

That being said, "go make more players" is not the solution. The Dirtybirds (where my level 20 is) lost in the 1st round of the playoffs. There is no HUGE advantage that causes us to blow out every other team. I don't see any reason my SS should be penalized just because no pro leagues were available when my owner went to buy players.
 
Dudeamis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by nfratami

Originally posted by dergillz


Originally posted by Unconquered



Originally posted by dergillz




beautifully said. I have no further comments.


It's good for people like you're team who fail to recruit good players. Congrats


Unlike you I might be thinking of the game as a whole rather than just myself. This idea will level the game out, stop the cheaters and make it more enjoyable in the long run. I have plenty of good players on my team. It's the least of my worries.


Instead of making strict rules that affect everyone, why not have severe discipline for cheaters.


Because bringing in a high leveled team of ringers isn't cheating per se. It's just bad sportsmanship. We are doing this to encourage higher leveled players to find more suitable competition.

I love the complaints, guys. Keep them coming. You have no idea how big or small the effect will be, how the math will work, and yet you are worried it will allow other people to catch up and compete (including the other players on your own team!), or that it will somehow decimate your team. That helps prove to me that we're targeting the right area of the game: the part that people actually care enough about that they will think about fair play.


I thought that the point of the game is to field the best team possible, not 32 mediocre squads.
 
Meryk
offline
Link
 
Is this going to be based off of starter levels, or all players on the team, to come up with the median?
 
jprietman
offline
Link
 
im good with the new changes. i only worry that my level 19 WR may or may not be within the limit of a USA AA league, and if he isnt, he cant do anything about it because hes locked up long term.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.