User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > I thought Borts new system was going to eliminate the disparity in teams
Page:
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheSandman
http://goallineblitz.com/game/announcement.pl?id=256

http://goallineblitz.com/game/announcement.pl?id=260

Somebody lied......

Edit: Put in the right link.


Again, huh?
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddoc
Was reading an article in the paper the other day about how, despite numerous measures taken to try and give an advantage to failing teams, and to make long term success difficult to impossible and to retain parity in the NFL, certain teams seem impervious to this and continue to have winning season after winning season (Colts, Pats, Steelers), or alternatively losing season after losing season (Raiders, Lions)

It made me laugh and think of GLB.


Found the article in question, even.

http://www.usatoday.com/sports/football/nfl/2009-11-26-nfl-parity-cover_N.htm
 
Torg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dub J
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc

there should be no cloud demotions PERIOD except to cap 14 to start over


Agree 100%


+1
 
NtropiK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dub J
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc

there should be no cloud demotions PERIOD except to cap 14 to start over


Agree 100%


Good idea.
 
THE_Mongoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
there should be no cloud demotions PERIOD except to cap 14 to start over

Agree 100%

+1
Edited by THE_Mongoose on Nov 30, 2009 07:07:39
 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by THE_Mongoose
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
there should be no cloud demotions PERIOD except to cap 14 to start over

Agree 100%

+1


Agree, but promotion also needs to be forced.
 
Hagalaz
offline
Link
 
J hennessy, one question then...

Is the "higher leveled players than caps" issue NEW?

Answer: NO. And it will go away within a few seasons with the new boosting rules and promotions. So yes, we are better off IN REGARDS TO THIS PARTICULAR ASPECT ONLY (aka, not the sim, not the game, just this) than we ever were.
 
VenomCoach
offline
Link
 
Bort doesn't seem to get his own system. A good team of level 34 players should not be in a level 34 league they should be in a level 38 or if really good in a 42. His voluntary refusal of promotion causes teams to be able to trophy hunt. The mediocre to poor 34s should be playing with good 28s or great 24s. Then you have a good league but when the inmates set their league level this cannot happen.

He tweaked the original system which would very rarely allow a higher over level player to be on a team and those over level players would have been on ass horrible teams.

The original system encouraged teams to get out of the capped leagues and into the pyramid. Every change to the original system has encouraged teams/players to stay in the capped leagues.

Obviously a level 46 cap was not necessary as the average level of players in the level 46 league is above that of uncapped minors.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by griffin8r
Originally posted by THE_Mongoose

Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
there should be no cloud demotions PERIOD except to cap 14 to start over

Agree 100%

+1


Agree, but promotion also needs to be forced.


 
Osmlol
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by J Hennessy
thank you Mar.

Honestly been in GLB since season 1 but am tired of following Borts changes because he is just going to change them again next season, just like he does with the dots abilites every season. Hey build a player this way (everyone go rush out and do it now) 2 seasons later --- well that didnt work to well so now you must change his entire build or just build another.....

so basically then these guys lost in th eplayoffs (the ones with lvl 35-37's) and got promoted anyway to lvl 34 cap.

makes sense I guess

thanks again


Right? Bort should just leave the mess alone and not fix it? Right? Shut up.
 
tonylieu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hagalaz
Most likely they BOOSTED BEFORE DAY 41!!!!

How come no one understood the announcement? -_-


The point of boosting before day 41 is that then they would be placed in the appropriately capped league. Otherwise, what is the point of that new rule? What's the difference whether a player boost to 25 for example before (new rule) or after day 41 (old rule), then to be placed in cap-22 league any way?
Edited by tonylieu on Nov 30, 2009 09:48:47
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tonylieu
Originally posted by Hagalaz

Most likely they BOOSTED BEFORE DAY 41!!!!

How come no one understood the announcement? -_-


The point of boosting before day 41 is that then they would be placed in the appropriately capped league. Otherwise, what is the point of that new rule? What's the difference whether a player boost to 25 for example before (new rule) or after day 41 (old rule), then to be placed in cap-22 league any way?


No, the point of boosting before day 41 is to prevent players at the level cap of the league with 3 boosts left for the season to join a team, then boost, then boost 3 times when the season starts to be 6 levels over the level cap before the season starts. If you played it right with exp, you could be 7 levels over before the first game. Looks like you didn't understand the announcement either.

Of course it won't even out the first time round because teams aren't currently setup in a fashion to make it realistically possible. If you stop and think about it logically for a second, which is what I did, teams have boosted, progressed, etc. under the old rules for 12 seasons now. So now these new promotion rules exist, how many teams actually exist that fit them nicely since they were all created under the older restrictions? Not many, but as time goes on, more and more teams will fit the restrictions and then can be placed in capped leagues that more closely match the team. Right now, he has to try and put teams that are as close as together as possible in the same league, without any perfect fits, which likely means there will be some anomaly or disparity in some or all leagues. Some teams just aren't a perfect fit anywhere. Move them up a level and they get crushed, keep them where they are and they crush everyone else. There are teams in both situations.
 
Jayce Jones
offline
Link
 
Can some one do something about the Minn VIkings? Yesterday my Bears played them and the Vikings have several players over the cap limit.

Jared Allen is a 71 playing in a 48 league, Peterson is a 65 (but for some reasoning his carrying isn't that high, must have good vision), Farve is close to the 400 days limit but still he's a 79. I could go on but the whole team is stacked.

wait...can Bort even help me?
 
tonylieu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by silenthatred
No, the point of boosting before day 41 is to prevent players at the level cap of the league with 3 boosts left for the season to join a team, then boost, then boost 3 times when the season starts to be 6 levels over the level cap before the season starts. If you played it right with exp, you could be 7 levels over before the first game. Looks like you didn't understand the announcement either.

Of course it won't even out the first time round because teams aren't currently setup in a fashion to make it realistically possible. If you stop and think about it logically for a second, which is what I did, teams have boosted, progressed, etc. under the old rules for 12 seasons now. So now these new promotion rules exist, how many teams actually exist that fit them nicely since they were all created under the older restrictions? Not many, but as time goes on, more and more teams will fit the restrictions and then can be placed in capped leagues that more closely match the team. Right now, he has to try and put teams that are as close as together as possible in the same league, without any perfect fits, which likely means there will be some anomaly or disparity in some or all leagues. Some teams just aren't a perfect fit anywhere. Move them up a level and they get crushed, keep them where they are and they crush everyone else. There are teams in both situations.


LOL, how is it different before this rule?
The new season has not yet started, yet teams with players way above caps are abundant. When season starts, they can boost again to be 6+ level above caps.
You can argue the semantics all you want, but I personally prefer to look at the end result which is no different from before this new rule. It's like trying to patch a leaky boat with duct tape.
 
milkoman16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MarBro456
The levels aren't a factor when it comes to the promotion.

Like say............ My team was in a 13 capped league..... By the end of the season we were level 24s (we boosted before playoffs)......... We made the playoffs, but lost the conference championship to a better team................ Due to not being in the league championship game, we got promoted 2 levels............ Now we are a team of level 24s in a 22 capped league.... Only way we would've been promoted toa 26 cap was if we had won a conference championship..

That is incorrect sir - I have seen several lvl 13 capped teams win the Championship & only move up to a 22 capped league for season 13. What sucks is the fact that some of these teams have an entire roster of SSB lvl 24's.

The problem here is that most teams that promote to a 22 capped league based on the structuring system don't stand a chance against one of those teams. You can't recruit any player over 22 so your already at a 2 lvl disadvantage going forward not to mention those teams having another 50-100 days of training on their players.

My team made the Finals only to lose to a team full of SSB's - I assumed the following season we as well as them would promote up to a 26 capped league but was suprised to find us both in a 22 capped league - makes no sense imo.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.