User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > PR Runs out of bounds when there is nobody around him
Page:
 
manx
offline
Link
 
First time I have seen a HB do it on an offensive play, so it may not be specific to returner code

Originally posted by jktooley
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=878763&pbp_id=6157623

cause yeah... this should happen...


 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by manx
First time I have seen a HB do it on an offensive play, so it may not be specific to returner code

Originally posted by jktooley

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=878763&pbp_id=6157623

cause yeah... this should happen...




I have seen many RB do it. Then again I watch a TON of film. Bort said he will look at the PR/KR Return code. Honestly the PR/KR on my team is not experiencing this problem. Could this be an issue with the sideline recognition code and Super Elusive?

No clue, at this point it is out of my hands.
 
Link
 
I saw this happen a couple of times, two or three seasons ago, and I was wondering the same thing of why the RB, or KR, stepped out of bounds. I felt we even lost a game because the RB stepped out of bounds and didn't get the first down, and we had from deep into our territory. I grumbled on the team forum, and someone gave a pretty good explanation of this occurance.

He said that we are not watching the game "live." He said that the computer sims the game, and then we get to watch a visual representation of the game through our dots. He said that the computer simmed the RB/KR out of bounds, but for some reason, just didn't have a dot near when the visual effect took place. It made sense to me. I don't know how many of you remember the "simmed" sports games of the early 90's. Basically what you did, you would type p for pass, or r for run for each play, and then the computer would spit back a sentence of what happened. Even though there is a higher degree of complexity of what goes into the sim now, it is still kind of the same thing. The result of the play, with all the variables that are included, the result of the play is spit back at us in the form of a sentence, at the top of the screen, after every play.

Now, the guy who told me this, and myself, could be wrong. Before you go flamming on me, which I think some of you like to do no matter what is said , I don't claim this as gosspel, and it could very well be a bug. If it is, I won't that victory from two or three seasons ago back. j/k I hope you guys have a good night.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Clemson Tigers

He said that we are not watching the game "live." He said that the computer sims the game, and then we get to watch a visual representation of the game through our dots. He said that the computer simmed the RB/KR out of bounds, but for some reason, just didn't have a dot near when the visual effect took place. It made sense to me. I don't know how many of you remember the "simmed" sports games of the early 90's. Basically what you did, you would type p for pass, or r for run for each play, and then the computer would spit back a sentence of what happened. Even though there is a higher degree of complexity of what goes into the sim now, it is still kind of the same thing. The result of the play, with all the variables that are included, the result of the play is spit back at us in the form of a sentence, at the top of the screen, after every play.

Now, the guy who told me this, and myself, could be wrong. Before you go flamming on me, which I think some of you like to do no matter what is said , I don't claim this as gosspel, and it could very well be a bug. If it is, I won't that victory from two or three seasons ago back. j/k I hope you guys have a good night.


From my understanding of the sim (only what I have learned as a Bug Mod), it does not work quite this way. The play is indeed played before it is represented online. The visual representation is not always perfect. The Text Representation is however accurate in respect to the result of the play.

It is only the replay that has issues with the correct result of the play in regard to the visuals you see.
 
scarpenter23
offline
Link
 
He was tired and needed a drink???
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
I will attempt to decode what Bort has said on this issue.

He said that he is looking into "Super Elusive" to see if there is an issue with sideline recognition.

He also mentioned that the faster you go, the harder it is to change direction. So it is conceivable that someone with a very high speed, and a low agility in proportion to their speed could not make the cut. ( I am not saying that that is realistic, I am merely saying that it could be possible in the sim)
 
manx
offline
Link
 
not that this is that constructive, but it looks like in situations where the dot is headed towards the sideline, he either makes a quick cut back into defenders, or heads out of bounds because he can't make the turn at full speed. There is no in-between, and most of the pathing complaints are a result of this. It seems like some of the useless "bobbing" replays are returners avoiding going out of bounds the only way they can, with a quick cut.

Maybe he needs to look at the planned trajectory path of the ball carrier so that they stop running themselves into the sidelines. Real life people plan out their path based on their abilities, dots seem to think they are more capable than they are.
Edited by manx on Oct 26, 2009 06:06:31
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Bump above the locks for more discussion.
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
Looking at the OP, I wonder if this isn't a problem in the other direction from Super Elusive - I didn't notice a reply on what elusiveness he's running at.
However, I can imagine a situation with high speed, lower agility, lower vision, and running set away from elusive that could lead to this. From what I can gather, the pathing is recalculated every so often - how often depends on the running style; the more elusive, the more often. Super Elusive maxes out at every tick + reduces the "move towards the endzone" impetus to the pathing.
So, if you're just outside the range of the "avoid the sideline" vector when you're calculating your route, and you don't recalc for 5+ ticks, and you're going pretty fast...you could be unrecoverably running out of bounds by the time the pathing calc happens. If you don't just flat run out of bounds from the last pathing, you're probably unable to make the turn.

I'm not sure how to fix that easily. You could extend the "avoid the sideline" vector kick-in point, but then runners will avoid the sideline more, not run up along it. Probably better requires doing a guesstimate on if you're going to go out of bounds before your next pathing update, and if so...jeez, I dunno, maybe update your path sooner, or recalc your pathing now with a bigger "avoid out of bounds"? I'm not seeing anything clean to avoid that from a sim perspective.
 
manx
offline
Link
 
more HB stuff from another thread

Originally posted by jktooley
I've seen the punt returner thing for about the past 3 seasons, and now we have the HB's wanting to get involved...

I know for sure that the HB on CBID is running below 80 elusive, so you can't blame it on SuperElusive settings....

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=878763&pbp_id=6157623


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=816014&pbp_id=8111151


 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by manx
more HB stuff from another thread

Originally posted by jktooley

I've seen the punt returner thing for about the past 3 seasons, and now we have the HB's wanting to get involved...

I know for sure that the HB on CBID is running below 80 elusive, so you can't blame it on SuperElusive settings....

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=878763&pbp_id=6157623


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=816014&pbp_id=8111151




Question for you manx. Was your HB on "Super Elusive"? Not saying that was wrong, just trying to nail it down.
 
manx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Question for you manx. Was your HB on "Super Elusive"? Not saying that was wrong, just trying to nail it down.


im bringing all these in from other threads actually =/ The only two that were actually mine were the first two I posted
 
L_O
offline
Link
 
Another example. This one isn't terrible but it still seems like he shouldn't have gone out here. He is running on +30 elusiveness, has 60+ agility, and ~45 vision.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=862677&pbp_id=8978895
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.