User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Coverage bug? Dubbed "CB with cement shoes"??
Page:
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Toriq
Don't see a pump fake here. perhaps a WR fake. I dunno anymore, but seems fugged up.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=799804&pbp_id=17895779



POssibly WR head fake
or
possible pathing issue because of the other CB (I see this happen a lot with this route, I moved one of teh CBs slightly to avoid it and it doesn't happen anymore.

definitely no pump fake involved
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
You know this is a game we play and when some people are explaining what happened in the sim, trying to counter the argument with THATS NOT WHAT HAPPENS IN REAL LIFE, doesn't really do anything.

No one hear says the mechanics of pump fake in this sim are good and resemble real life in anyway.

But they are what they are, so when your CB is in man to man and the QB makes a small pump action and your guy stops for X ticks, thats a pump fake, clear and simple.

 
rockitsauce
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=801721&pbp_id=18438082

Beat the bad timing of this one... I'm not even saying it's a bug. Just sucks that it happened at this time. This one actually occurred between two players that were similar in level unlike the rest of the roster where we gave up 10 levels per position.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Toriq
Don't see a pump fake here. perhaps a WR fake. I dunno anymore, but seems fugged up.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=799804&pbp_id=17895779



Originally posted by tragula
Pump fake can be seen in the replays (not in this one) which cause the CB to do many strange things, not all are what you expect from RL.


Originally posted by jdbolick

Watching it tick by tick, I didn't see the ball move back slightly at the QB the way it does on Pump Fakes. *shrug*


It's a misconception that you can always see a pump fake animation from a QB. With the animation being as jerky as it is and hardly fluid when it comes to actual mechanical motion.

In this case it looks more like a head fake / creative route run thing. It looks pretty tragic because of the way the WR leaves the CB for dead - so First Step or similar certainly kicked in. However I'm surprised that the CB didn't recover via Ball Hawk a little better than he did.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rockitsauce
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=801721&pbp_id=18438082

Beat the bad timing of this one... I'm not even saying it's a bug. Just sucks that it happened at this time. This one actually occurred between two players that were similar in level unlike the rest of the roster where we gave up 10 levels per position.


Definite pump fake, the way the CB runs along the 5 yard line at a different trajectory to the WR is a bit odd more than anything.
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dT9BmG7_PJ4
go to minute 2:10 and watch the next 20 seconds

All that video is full with additional CB mistake.

Did you see these thing happen more than 1-2 per team per game ?



I still fail to see a time when he just flat out stops, which is what happens in nearly all of these bugs. They aren't falling down or getting blown past or getting juked out or biting on pump fakes. They aren't stopping because they think someone else is picking up there man. They are just freezing while their WR keeps on going.

And something has to happen 1-2 times per team per game to be a problem? Since this bug seems to result in a touchdown the majority of the time I would say if it happens to a team a couple times a season then it definitely needs to be fixed.
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Definite pump fake, the way the CB runs along the 5 yard line at a different trajectory to the WR is a bit odd more than anything.


Again, if this is what is supposed to happen on a pump fake then this is flat out awful coding. In real football, what fake of any type would make the corner just stop in man coverage. It's not like he jumped forward to try and pick of a pass that he thought was coming from a pump fake, or he took a step the wrong direction because the wide receiver faked him out.

This is in addition to what someone said earlier that pump fakes very, very rarely influence DBs in man coverage in football. They influence those playing in zone who are watching the QB.
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
I still fail to see a time when he just flat out stops, which is what happens in nearly all of these bugs. They aren't falling down or getting blown past or getting juked out or biting on pump fakes. They aren't stopping because they think someone else is picking up there man. They are just freezing while their WR keeps on going.

And something has to happen 1-2 times per team per game to be a problem? Since this bug seems to result in a touchdown the majority of the time I would say if it happens to a team a couple times a season then it definitely needs to be fixed.


How to interpret the sim is not exactly an exact science, It is not that you can see the player move.

There are things that even 1 time a season in all GLB is a clear bug, like the defense dancing with the ball carriers instead of running toward him.
However in situation where it look like a single player just "fucked up" his job, there is an issue of the amount it happens. For example the LG not blocking anyone while a blitzing LB goes by them. If it was rare (1-2 per game) you can defintly call that the LG "fucked up" or in spoken GLB failed a vision check. However once these failed vision checks happen too often, for decent builds it deserves the name bug.
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
How to interpret the sim is not exactly an exact science, It is not that you can see the player move.

There are things that even 1 time a season in all GLB is a clear bug, like the defense dancing with the ball carriers instead of running toward him.
However in situation where it look like a single player just "fucked up" his job, there is an issue of the amount it happens. For example the LG not blocking anyone while a blitzing LB goes by them. If it was rare (1-2 per game) you can defintly call that the LG "fucked up" or in spoken GLB failed a vision check. However once these failed vision checks happen too often, for decent builds it deserves the name bug.


I hate how every time a player does something that is completely outside the realm of normal football the excuse is he failed a vision check. Do we really need a vision check to know that we should keep playing? I don't know if it is a bug or if it is working as is written in the code, but either way my point is the same, it should not happen in the game. I understand players fuck up sometime, but that shouldn't be represented in the game by them simply freezing.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
I hate how every time a player does something that is completely outside the realm of normal football the excuse is he failed a vision check. Do we really need a vision check to know that we should keep playing?


imo we definitely do not need vision checks for CBs to be able to avoid stepping forward at the start of a play in man to man coverage!
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
imo we definitely do not need vision checks for CBs to be able to avoid stepping forward at the start of a play in man to man coverage!


Amen to that.

Vision check are a key ingredient in the sim, they are responsible to make the players react "like human being" and not like machines. Without vision checks all decision by players were 100% right and with no delays.
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Bort won't bother to fix that though. He will just leave it and from now on anytime it occurs it will be looked at as a failed bump by the corner (and I am fine with a failed bump looking like that, but obviously that wasn't the case here, as that hasn't been put in yet).

The only other thing I can think of for that step up is that the WR anticipated that quick dump to the WR. That would be a reasonable failed vision check I guess. I don't believe that is what happen though, looks more like a bug to me.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.