User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Major changes need a separate, temporary forum...
Page:
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Well, hmmm. There has to be a compromise in there.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Forget the coach idea as it relates to this IMO. There will be other things to discuss in the future, and a way to organize the discussion would be helpful, and create less moderation headaches.


Thinking about ideas in general and getting what's valuable without allowing pressuring:

The discussion is better organized if the number of threads is very limited and kept on topic. If such a forum is made, only Admins should be able to start threads about ideas that have come up in the one main discussion thread in Suggestions.

Basically, you make your suggestion in the one basic suggestions thread for whatever the hot topic is, and if an Admin thinks it's worth discussing he makes a thread in the big topic forum. Off-topic posts in the threads in that forum would be deleted, and repeatedly forcing deletions of posts would result in suspensions and the like.
 
dawgs1235
offline
Link
 
NO FORUMS! AHHH.

forums are what got us here in the first place. it should be a news wire that is updated properly.
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Time Trial
Originally posted by blump

I thought the entire point of having the one thread was so Bort didn't have to go through 500 threads. But ya, it might have been smart to divide it into sections, and in it's own subforum. I don't think you'd want it to be a full forum where anyone can post a new topic, though, it would be just as cluttered as the suggestion forum.


If one idea had its own subforum, you would be able to organize the ideas far better. Then you would also be able to see which ideas are generating the most comments. If the OP or mods update each idea's OP with good ideas built up through discussion, it would make it really easy to see which ideas are supported or what concerns need to be addressed (and potential solutions proposed).

This would actually make it easier to read for the users, easier to update for the OPs and Mods, and then easier to disseminate into one final post before moving to archives.


quoting for Bort. Although this would still end up with the 9000 threads?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I suppose "like" threads could be merged somewhat. People tend to get pissy when their thread gets merged, though, since theirs was "better" or "different", or secretly they just wanted the attention from it, etc.


See my idea. Let only Admins create the threads, based on posts deemed worthy from the general suggestion thread (a sticky at the top of Suggestions for the main topic).

Once you allow anyone to create a thread, you open it up to pressuring, regardless of the topic.
 
dawgs1235
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
See my idea. Let only Admins create the threads, based on posts deemed worthy from the general suggestion thread (a sticky at the top of Suggestions for the main topic).

Once you allow anyone to create a thread, you open it up to pressuring, regardless of the topic.


I think the problem is TOO much information.

I still think the announcement/alerts should be used in a different way.

I hate to pull out World of Warcraft, but they've got a much larger community, a more complex game, and a more loyal fan base. Changes are made all the time and are organized as such.

http://www.worldofwarcraft.com/patchnotes/

With a simple "official post" you could address game updates, filling us in on pretty much whatever you change. When an update is made to this site, you should set an alert to trigger in people inbox. Could be something that people subscribed to as well.

Me and an owner of two teams would love as much information as possible! Guys on my team with 3 players? not so much.
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jpjn94
Isn't this kind of how the Announcements forum was used way back in day?

Oh and good idea stinky


thats what i was about to post. but good idea nonetheless.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Bort

I suppose "like" threads could be merged somewhat. People tend to get pissy when their thread gets merged, though, since theirs was "better" or "different", or secretly they just wanted the attention from it, etc.


See my idea. Let only Admins create the threads, based on posts deemed worthy from the general suggestion thread (a sticky at the top of Suggestions for the main topic).

Once you allow anyone to create a thread, you open it up to pressuring, regardless of the topic.


I think it's a bad idea. Admins really don't have time to search through for every good idea which is the point of it in the first place and "pressuring" isn't all bad, there is going to be pressuring either ways no matter what you do but at least you might be able to make some good changes that need to be made because of the "pressuring".
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dawgs1235
Originally posted by Ken1

See my idea. Let only Admins create the threads, based on posts deemed worthy from the general suggestion thread (a sticky at the top of Suggestions for the main topic).

Once you allow anyone to create a thread, you open it up to pressuring, regardless of the topic.


I think the problem is TOO much information.

I still think the announcement/alerts should be used in a different way.

I hate to pull out World of Warcraft, but they've got a much larger community, a more complex game, and a more loyal fan base. Changes are made all the time and are organized as such.

http://www.worldofwarcraft.com/patchnotes/

With a simple "official post" you could address game updates, filling us in on pretty much whatever you change. When an update is made to this site, you should set an alert to trigger in people inbox. Could be something that people subscribed to as well.

Me and an owner of two teams would love as much information as possible! Guys on my team with 3 players? not so much.


This is fine if you are talking about information from the Admin down to the user. We are talking about discussions amongst users.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Time Trial

This is fine if you are talking about information from the Admin down to the user. We are talking about discussions amongst users.


And discussions from users about a feature that hasn't been clearly defined yet.
 
dawgs1235
offline
Link
 
ah.

good point.

I still think a uniform Bort to all method of contact need to be figured out asap.
 
The Big House
offline
Link
 
Yes, Get 'er done!
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I need to make an easier forum creation/edit tool to do this. Public forums are all created manually at the moment, just by doing some SQL calls.

I know Pallow would like that idea.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
See my idea. Let only Admins create the threads, based on posts deemed worthy from the general suggestion thread (a sticky at the top of Suggestions for the main topic).

Once you allow anyone to create a thread, you open it up to pressuring, regardless of the topic.


We already have that - it's the announcements forum that gets little use these days.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dawgs1235
ah.

good point.

I still think a uniform Bort to all method of contact need to be figured out asap.


Announcements on the home page? Changelog?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.