User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - Item Crafting
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
This is a very interesting way to allow some item crafting. I was against it if it was too easy or not enough of a tradeoff, but this would work for me, and be another incentive to have players become coaches.

I would say, though, that once an item is created, it can be upgraded like any other AE. That might mean limits on how good the items can be to start, but that's fine. Also, the crafter would have to hold the "Equipment Manager" position on the team, so you can't have a ton of them making items for any given team, just in case crafting turned out as the most powerful coach ability.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Brandonhicks16
So would we have to pay MONEY for them, because then that would make need for coaches salary, and that makes the game more like football(unless you litteraly coach peewee football). Also, does our player cash go with us if we start coaching too, or do we lose that when we become a coach?


The player pays cash for them. The coach doesn't.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whitewolf
It might. Another possibly neat thing might be people that were really good at something, like say deflecting passes, would get a minor bonus to making items related to that. But really good would have to be people that earned trophies in a certain stat.


I like that idea.
 
christianhall
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
I just want to make sure of something...the items made here must follow the exact same rules current AE follows. Nothing can start out as +2 SA, nothing can have +1 SA +1 SA, nothing can come with a bonus of more than +3 Attribute or +5%, right?

Essentially, having a crafting coach should be useless if everyone on your team already has the "perfect" AE (highly, highly doubtful, but you know what I mean). Crafting shouldn't be allowed to make new godly items, it should just be a way of controlling the current AE store.


I'd hope so. Anything apart from that gives a pretty big bonus to only a couple of guys on the team. That way these equupment crafting coaches are solely used to get a couple of guys on a team the best possible piece of advanced EQ, therefore allowing a player to continually train on Intense and collect bonus tokens instead of having to shop (obviously that'd be in a situation where you know which player you want to get the coach created item.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by christianhall
OK. What if the coach and player both leave at the same time to go to the same team, in order to stick together. Would that be an exception to the item deletion rule? Obviously if it was, you'd need a way to tell that the player and coach are both moving at the same time. Perhaps contract and trade options that allow both the player and coach to be signed at the same time (obviously with separate contracts though). On second thoughts though, people may try to exploit by signing multiple players and coaches together to keep equipment, though I think that exploit could be covered by the fact there are limited coaching spots.


That wouldn't really work I think. The whole point is that we want to make sure people don't make farm teams to create equipment.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whitewolf
I would think only 1 piece per player, in a "Coaches Item" slot.


1 per player, but I was thinking it would take the place of normal equipment.
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
I just want to make sure of something...the items made here must follow the exact same rules current AE follows. Nothing can start out as +2 SA, nothing can have +1 SA +1 SA, nothing can come with a bonus of more than +3 Attribute or +5%, right?

Essentially, having a crafting coach should be useless if everyone on your team already has the "perfect" AE (highly, highly doubtful, but you know what I mean). Crafting shouldn't be allowed to make new godly items, it should just be a way of controlling the current AE store.


I disagree here. I think the crafted items should be of potential interest to all players.
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
This is a very interesting way to allow some item crafting. I was against it if it was too easy or not enough of a tradeoff, but this would work for me, and be another incentive to have players become coaches.

I would say, though, that once an item is created, it can be upgraded like any other AE. That might mean limits on how good the items can be to start, but that's fine. Also, the crafter would have to hold the "Equipment Manager" position on the team, so you can't have a ton of them making items for any given team, just in case crafting turned out as the most powerful coach ability.


I also disagree here. Once the item is done, it should be done.
Edited by whitewolf on Sep 4, 2009 19:46:49
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Interesting, would these items be limited to one bonus, or could they have dual bonuses similar to standard AE's such as two +% bonuses on one item?


I was figuring it could be special (to make it more worthwhile) and have more than one SA, etc. However, the total number of modifiers would determine who can use it. A Lv 1 player wouldn't be able to use an item with 5 upgrades, for instance. He'd have to reach the appropriate level.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
OFF TOPIC: Before spending more time adding a new feature, How about announcing the plan for boosting. I see you haven't made up your mind, and the time is just about here. Bueller? BUELLER? BUELLER?
 
Xero00
offline
Link
 
I think a limit on the amount of items on a team would make them more effective and strategic. Maybe 1 pc per position?

The level of the coaches SA should either effect the crafting cost of that SA or give the bonus a boost. Similar could be done with regular stats and bonuses for the same.

Maybe coaches with trophies for League/Conference leading stats could get a bonus. Example: 1st in Passing yards, bonus to passing quality. These bonuses could be smaller so only players with a good deal of trophies would see bigger results.
Edited by Xero00 on Sep 4, 2009 19:52:00
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whitewolf
I also disagree here. Once the item is done, it should be done.


Yes, I was thinking it would only be upgradeable by the coach. The player wouldn't be able to use his bonus tokens, etc, since he doesn't technically own the item.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
OFF TOPIC: Before spending more time adding a new feature, How about announcing the plan for boosting. I see you haven't made up your mind, and the time is just about here. Bueller? BUELLER? BUELLER?


It's already in the FAQ, man. Tpat was just confused.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
It's already in the FAQ, man. Tpat was just confused.


You should un sticky that thread in the main forum, people continually post in it bitching, and crying for an answer. Thanks for clearing that up
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
You should un sticky that thread in the main forum, people continually post in it bitching, and crying for an answer. Thanks for clearing that up


Oops, I didn't even realize. Guess I glaze over the stickies too much.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.