There is no excuse for a GLB cornerback stepping forward at the snap, so please don't make any.
jdros13
offline
offline
This has been around for a long time - never really went away.
Happens more often when the receiver is on creative route running - always assumed it was a fake.
Happens more often when the receiver is on creative route running - always assumed it was a fake.
datongw
offline
offline
My two cents from my experience:
1) CBs never run up to the WR right after the snap, if they want to get closer to the WR, they'll line up closer. Even in bump and run situations, the CB never runs up to the WR, they simply try to jam the WR to disrupt timing of the pattern, jam and release, never step forward and run toward the WR.
2) As far as pump fake and coverage distance goes, the coverage distance has ZERO effect on whether a player gets pump faked out. The distance between the CB and WR will help determine how fast the CB can recover if he gets faked out, that along with the angle of the cut/pursuit. What effects whether DB gets pump faked out is the coverage style, zone defenders will get pump faked out, m2m defenders will not get pump faked out (they are watching the WR, not the QB, so how do you get pump faked if you are not even looking)? On the other hand, m2m coverage is more prone to jukes and head fakes than zone coverage.
3) Even when people get faked out, they don't just freeze and stand there. How many times do you see players not moving at all during a play? If you get faked out, the worst thing can happen is you slip while trying to change direction, even then, guys get up in a snap (LBs and DBs at least). On defense, you start moving when the ball is snapped and you don't stop until the whistle blows, it's not a game of freeze out there. Defensive players who freezes during the play usually end up keeping the bench warm.
These are really the basic mechanics of the game, I think it's important for people who code this game understand this. I'm sure it's pretty difficult to code this game perfect down to every detail, but at least get the fundamentals right.
1) CBs never run up to the WR right after the snap, if they want to get closer to the WR, they'll line up closer. Even in bump and run situations, the CB never runs up to the WR, they simply try to jam the WR to disrupt timing of the pattern, jam and release, never step forward and run toward the WR.
2) As far as pump fake and coverage distance goes, the coverage distance has ZERO effect on whether a player gets pump faked out. The distance between the CB and WR will help determine how fast the CB can recover if he gets faked out, that along with the angle of the cut/pursuit. What effects whether DB gets pump faked out is the coverage style, zone defenders will get pump faked out, m2m defenders will not get pump faked out (they are watching the WR, not the QB, so how do you get pump faked if you are not even looking)? On the other hand, m2m coverage is more prone to jukes and head fakes than zone coverage.
3) Even when people get faked out, they don't just freeze and stand there. How many times do you see players not moving at all during a play? If you get faked out, the worst thing can happen is you slip while trying to change direction, even then, guys get up in a snap (LBs and DBs at least). On defense, you start moving when the ball is snapped and you don't stop until the whistle blows, it's not a game of freeze out there. Defensive players who freezes during the play usually end up keeping the bench warm.
These are really the basic mechanics of the game, I think it's important for people who code this game understand this. I'm sure it's pretty difficult to code this game perfect down to every detail, but at least get the fundamentals right.
Koncorde
offline
offline
1 - We don't know what the CB is responding to, so it's impossible to simply state that they "never" do anything, as it's not certain that what is happening even exists in "real life". What does a corner do in M2M if the WR runs a screen or end-around? What does a CB do if he reads a "run" play instead of a pass?
2 - Coverage distance does actually have an effect on fakes. The proximity of other players reduces a players vision.
Couple in the fact that certain SA's specifically attack vision (especialling in M2M). As per my mention of critical failures earlier it's entirely possible that this is literally the nth percentile coming home to roost because of the way the game is ultimately shaped towards achieving X where X is an "auto success". Critical Success/Failure rolls in GLB are pretty much reality breaking, but unfortunately part of the mathematical probability.
3 - Freezing solid is not usually an issue in GLB, a player will recover from their freeze pretty fluidly. Players that struggle to recover from a "freeze" tend to be those who fail successive vision checks and/or agility checks. A "freeze" as represented in GLB is not a player performing a musical statue - it represents someone wrong footed, or losing their balance, or attempting to dive but coming up way short.
As always there remains a difference between representing what exists in real life, and coding for what actually happens in GLB. The existence of one is guidance for the other - but neither will ever fully match-up. See Madden for a fine example.
2 - Coverage distance does actually have an effect on fakes. The proximity of other players reduces a players vision.
Couple in the fact that certain SA's specifically attack vision (especialling in M2M). As per my mention of critical failures earlier it's entirely possible that this is literally the nth percentile coming home to roost because of the way the game is ultimately shaped towards achieving X where X is an "auto success". Critical Success/Failure rolls in GLB are pretty much reality breaking, but unfortunately part of the mathematical probability.
3 - Freezing solid is not usually an issue in GLB, a player will recover from their freeze pretty fluidly. Players that struggle to recover from a "freeze" tend to be those who fail successive vision checks and/or agility checks. A "freeze" as represented in GLB is not a player performing a musical statue - it represents someone wrong footed, or losing their balance, or attempting to dive but coming up way short.
As always there remains a difference between representing what exists in real life, and coding for what actually happens in GLB. The existence of one is guidance for the other - but neither will ever fully match-up. See Madden for a fine example.
Sik Wit It
offline
offline
If they run a WR screen, I'd still rather the CB just stay where he is, then go to make the tackle. As for the end-around...that's not even in the game. Plus if they ran that, he'd actually be much more successful at defending it if he ran to the opposite sideline...not if he chased the WR. So basically when we have a failed vision check, the CB automatically assumes it's 1 play which is called probably less than .5% of the time? I guess he could read run instead of pass, but 75+ vision, 12 super vision, and pass focus isn't enough to tell the WR is running a route? I know nothing is 100%, but I still say the step-forward thing is really counter intuitive, and not realistic at all. I know we can't achieve real football here, but why not do everything in our power to make it better? I have never seen a CB take steps toward the LOS in all my time of watching football.
Sik Wit It
offline
offline
Also I can accept the fact that CBs fail vision checks. Shit happens. But it's what happens when they fail that I'm not getting. Stepping in the opposite direction the WR is going to run 99.9% of the time?
Koncorde
offline
offline
75+ vision and 12 Super Vision doesn't mean a great deal when someone can apply a mix of Awe Inspiring / Under Dog penalty of -20%, and a +45% boost to fake with Clever Instinct, and a +30% boost to fake with Quick Feet.
Why is the CB stepping forward?
If the Answer is:
1 - Creative Route Running.
2 - Head Fake etc.
3 - VA Vision damage causing failure to read play.
4 - Any of the above.
Then it's not a bug, just something that looks unrealistic because it's unlikely a WR would fake to "run backwards".
Why is the CB stepping forward?
If the Answer is:
1 - Creative Route Running.
2 - Head Fake etc.
3 - VA Vision damage causing failure to read play.
4 - Any of the above.
Then it's not a bug, just something that looks unrealistic because it's unlikely a WR would fake to "run backwards".
Koncorde
offline
offline
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Also I can accept the fact that CBs fail vision checks. Shit happens. But it's what happens when they fail that I'm not getting. Stepping in the opposite direction the WR is going to run 99.9% of the time?
But they aren't 99.9%.
99% of the time the CB steps left, right, backwards, diagonal and it's taken for granted and accepted that he was faked, or his First Step/Change Direction didn't work. 1% of the time he steps forward - and these receive more attention.
We don't even know how often it actually happens in a game. Your CB might be faked out 10/10 times, but only 2 result in him stepping forwards - the rest result in him stepping in other directions, or the pass not heading in his direction.
Also I can accept the fact that CBs fail vision checks. Shit happens. But it's what happens when they fail that I'm not getting. Stepping in the opposite direction the WR is going to run 99.9% of the time?
But they aren't 99.9%.
99% of the time the CB steps left, right, backwards, diagonal and it's taken for granted and accepted that he was faked, or his First Step/Change Direction didn't work. 1% of the time he steps forward - and these receive more attention.
We don't even know how often it actually happens in a game. Your CB might be faked out 10/10 times, but only 2 result in him stepping forwards - the rest result in him stepping in other directions, or the pass not heading in his direction.
Sik Wit It
offline
offline
See my last post. i can accept he'd fail vision checks. I know why the CB is stepping forward within the sim mechanics...because apparently that's what happens when they fail a vision check. My point is they SHOULDN'T be stepping forward, because that simply isn't football. What if a DE failing a check to get off the line ran backwards? What if a HB failed a vision check and turned around and ran backwards 3 more yards? How about a FB not knowing who to block running into the backfield instead? I remember that bug specifically because I made a huge thread and kept bumping it till it was fixed. The point is the act of the CB failing the vision check is just not football.
Sik Wit It
offline
offline
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Also I can accept the fact that CBs fail vision checks. Shit happens. But it's what happens when they fail that I'm not getting. Stepping in the opposite direction the WR is going to run 99.9% of the time?
But they aren't 99.9%.
99% of the time the CB steps left, right, backwards, diagonal and it's taken for granted and accepted that he was faked, or his First Step/Change Direction didn't work. 1% of the time he steps forward - and these receive more attention.
We don't even know how often it actually happens in a game. Your CB might be faked out 10/10 times, but only 2 result in him stepping forwards - the rest result in him stepping in other directions, or the pass not heading in his direction.
I think you misunderstood the wording of my post. I didn't mean the CB steps in the wrong direction 99.9% of the time, I meant that some of the fakes have him stepping in a direction a WR would only go maybe .01% of the time. Probably closer to .001%. Who really uses the WR screen anymore? I wouldn't have a problem with him getting faked right, left, backwards, whatever, because those are all viable ways a WR would run. But we only have 2 plays with the WR going backwards. In one, he continues to move past the LOS afterwards (one of the new SB plays), and the other is the WR screen. Either way, you always want to stay in FRONT of the WR. Completely overcommitting themselves to an option that would only give them success maybe .01% of the time...probably less than that, is just dumb.
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Also I can accept the fact that CBs fail vision checks. Shit happens. But it's what happens when they fail that I'm not getting. Stepping in the opposite direction the WR is going to run 99.9% of the time?
But they aren't 99.9%.
99% of the time the CB steps left, right, backwards, diagonal and it's taken for granted and accepted that he was faked, or his First Step/Change Direction didn't work. 1% of the time he steps forward - and these receive more attention.
We don't even know how often it actually happens in a game. Your CB might be faked out 10/10 times, but only 2 result in him stepping forwards - the rest result in him stepping in other directions, or the pass not heading in his direction.
I think you misunderstood the wording of my post. I didn't mean the CB steps in the wrong direction 99.9% of the time, I meant that some of the fakes have him stepping in a direction a WR would only go maybe .01% of the time. Probably closer to .001%. Who really uses the WR screen anymore? I wouldn't have a problem with him getting faked right, left, backwards, whatever, because those are all viable ways a WR would run. But we only have 2 plays with the WR going backwards. In one, he continues to move past the LOS afterwards (one of the new SB plays), and the other is the WR screen. Either way, you always want to stay in FRONT of the WR. Completely overcommitting themselves to an option that would only give them success maybe .01% of the time...probably less than that, is just dumb.
Edited by Sik Wit It on Aug 28, 2009 19:52:33
Koncorde
offline
offline
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Completely overcommitting themselves to an option that would only give them success maybe .01% of the time...probably less than that, is just dumb.
Hence the phrase "critical failure".
We don't know what exactly the CB is reading, so it's difficult to say what he is moving towards. He may be routing to a point to make an interception, or maybe he's genuinely moving to react to the Creative Route running or Head Fake.
Or maybe it's simply the fact that the default distance setting of coverage causes a CB to move to the "0" distance when a critical failure occurs - though I would expect this to be more common if that was the sole cause.
Completely overcommitting themselves to an option that would only give them success maybe .01% of the time...probably less than that, is just dumb.
Hence the phrase "critical failure".
We don't know what exactly the CB is reading, so it's difficult to say what he is moving towards. He may be routing to a point to make an interception, or maybe he's genuinely moving to react to the Creative Route running or Head Fake.
Or maybe it's simply the fact that the default distance setting of coverage causes a CB to move to the "0" distance when a critical failure occurs - though I would expect this to be more common if that was the sole cause.
thunderdoozer
offline
offline
I agree this should be fixed, but I don't know how that would effect coverage on the WR screen play.
Sik Wit It
offline
offline
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Completely overcommitting themselves to an option that would only give them success maybe .01% of the time...probably less than that, is just dumb.
Hence the phrase "critical failure".
We don't know what exactly the CB is reading, so it's difficult to say what he is moving towards. He may be routing to a point to make an interception, or maybe he's genuinely moving to react to the Creative Route running or Head Fake.
Or maybe it's simply the fact that the default distance setting of coverage causes a CB to move to the "0" distance when a critical failure occurs - though I would expect this to be more common if that was the sole cause.
Well could you at least do the "pass it on to Bort" thing so we know for sure if it's intended or not? Because you don't seem so sure yourself.
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Completely overcommitting themselves to an option that would only give them success maybe .01% of the time...probably less than that, is just dumb.
Hence the phrase "critical failure".
We don't know what exactly the CB is reading, so it's difficult to say what he is moving towards. He may be routing to a point to make an interception, or maybe he's genuinely moving to react to the Creative Route running or Head Fake.
Or maybe it's simply the fact that the default distance setting of coverage causes a CB to move to the "0" distance when a critical failure occurs - though I would expect this to be more common if that was the sole cause.
Well could you at least do the "pass it on to Bort" thing so we know for sure if it's intended or not? Because you don't seem so sure yourself.
Sixx
offline
offline
Originally posted by Koncorde
75+ vision and 12 Super Vision doesn't mean a great deal when someone can apply a mix of Awe Inspiring / Under Dog penalty of -20%, and a +45% boost to fake with Clever Instinct, and a +30% boost to fake with Quick Feet.
Why is the CB stepping forward?
If the Answer is:
1 - Creative Route Running.
2 - Head Fake etc.
3 - VA Vision damage causing failure to read play.
4 - Any of the above.
Then it's not a bug, just something that looks unrealistic because it's unlikely a WR would fake to "run backwards".
That's one of the dumbest things I've heard for an excuse.
So you are telling me that a decent CB is going to screw up within the first yard of a route everytime?
If it's not a bug then why are there so many threads about this problem? Hell this has been going on since I started in season 6, but yet it's not a bug.
As for everyone saying it's "pump fake", how many CBs playing m2m do you see getting pump faked irl?
They don't because they're not looking at the QB.
How bout trying to fix this and quit making excuses as to why it's not been fixed?
75+ vision and 12 Super Vision doesn't mean a great deal when someone can apply a mix of Awe Inspiring / Under Dog penalty of -20%, and a +45% boost to fake with Clever Instinct, and a +30% boost to fake with Quick Feet.
Why is the CB stepping forward?
If the Answer is:
1 - Creative Route Running.
2 - Head Fake etc.
3 - VA Vision damage causing failure to read play.
4 - Any of the above.
Then it's not a bug, just something that looks unrealistic because it's unlikely a WR would fake to "run backwards".
That's one of the dumbest things I've heard for an excuse.
So you are telling me that a decent CB is going to screw up within the first yard of a route everytime?
If it's not a bug then why are there so many threads about this problem? Hell this has been going on since I started in season 6, but yet it's not a bug.
As for everyone saying it's "pump fake", how many CBs playing m2m do you see getting pump faked irl?
They don't because they're not looking at the QB.
How bout trying to fix this and quit making excuses as to why it's not been fixed?

jdbolick
offline
offline
Originally posted by Koncorde
Why is the CB stepping forward?
If the Answer is:
1 - Creative Route Running.
2 - Head Fake etc.
3 - VA Vision damage causing failure to read play.
4 - Any of the above.
Then it's not a bug, just something that looks unrealistic because it's unlikely a WR would fake to "run backwards".
That is absolutely retarded. Something is almost always responsible for any "bug" happening. The idea that events have to be random to be considered bugs is absurd. What makes it a "bug" is that the catalyst is producing an unintended, destabilizing result.
Why is the CB stepping forward?
If the Answer is:
1 - Creative Route Running.
2 - Head Fake etc.
3 - VA Vision damage causing failure to read play.
4 - Any of the above.
Then it's not a bug, just something that looks unrealistic because it's unlikely a WR would fake to "run backwards".
That is absolutely retarded. Something is almost always responsible for any "bug" happening. The idea that events have to be random to be considered bugs is absurd. What makes it a "bug" is that the catalyst is producing an unintended, destabilizing result.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























