User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Add 10 season decline to the NEVER going to happen list
Page:
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Wanting to get 100% of the FPs back is a crazy idea. As Americans we pay TONS of money for entertainment every year - heck, since food is a form of entertainment let's make that every day. Part of the price you pay is for the opportunity to play/enjoy whatever it is you bought. If you buy a video game and want to sell it back at Gamestop after 1 year, there is NO WAY you are getting back 100% of what you payed. Probably they will give you closer to 50% in store credit and 15% in real money back. Part of the price you payed went towards the year of use and enjoyment you got out of the game.



I honestly cant believe we get any back. 70% return is a awsome deal.
The fact remains that you need a reason to repay when it comes down to it.
For now no comp in the market solves that prob,but that all ends here soon.

Many paying players admit they wont repay with things as is. Check the post that got locked.
That should be motivation enough to solve this prob PRONTO.

If I was to put up a link that said EA'S NEW MMORPG and attached a click counter what do you thinkthe hits would be from this forum alone?

Point is its comming and people will go there...we ALL will atleast go check it out.
Then the dilema become why should I go back to GLB?
Do I go pay them to start a cycle over or no?
As is you got your answer from mmorpg guys and sim guys.
the ones who say they will repay WILL sing a different toon when its them ontop and have a year and a half into a toon...just wait and see.
 
methomps
offline
Link
 
I for one would never go to an EA MMORPG because they are all about nailing you for new releases that aren't any better than the old. They add a glitzy new feature and phase it out 3 years later, but the same bugs stay in for years. Whether you agree with the decline or not, Bort&co are still the way to go because they are responsive and constantly moving forward with actual improvements to the game instead of shiny ones.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Hopefully smart people will realize that the answer is to not start all your players at once. Create a new player every season and you will always have 10 and always have viable players, rather than creating all 10 in the first season and ending up with nothing. People just need to use a little common sense.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Hopefully smart people will realize that the answer is to not start all your players at once. Create a new player every season and you will always have 10 and always have viable players, rather than creating all 10 in the first season and ending up with nothing. People just need to use a little common sense.


Exactly. And one reason I feel that it's necessary to hold to the "decline will occur" is that I'll likely create a player or two next season, and the season after that, etc. (recycling FP's by retiring some underperforming players to help pay for that).

I'll be doing that on the basis of it being etched in stone that "Players Will Decline." I'd feel betrayed then if they didn't, as the money I'd spend to make sure I always had someone near his peak would have been thrown away in that case.

And you know what? I'll bet that other competing games with a similarity to this one will have player decline. EA sports coming out with a game (online or otherwise) where the best players are 50 years old after a while? I don't see it happening.

What might well happen is people will actually in-game control their players, and many will enjoy that; but since I don't have the manual dexterity for that I'll prefer this type of game, though with more individual instructions for players.
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by tpaterniti

Hopefully smart people will realize that the answer is to not start all your players at once. Create a new player every season and you will always have 10 and always have viable players, rather than creating all 10 in the first season and ending up with nothing. People just need to use a little common sense.


Exactly. And one reason I feel that it's necessary to hold to the "decline will occur" is that I'll likely create a player or two next season, and the season after that, etc. (recycling FP's by retiring some underperforming players to help pay for that).

I'll be doing that on the basis of it being etched in stone that "Players Will Decline." I'd feel betrayed then if they didn't, as the money I'd spend to make sure I always had someone near his peak would have been thrown away in that case.

And you know what? I'll bet that other competing games with a similarity to this one will have player decline. EA sports coming out with a game (online or otherwise) where the best players are 50 years old after a while? I don't see it happening.

What might well happen is people will actually in-game control their players, and many will enjoy that; but since I don't have the manual dexterity for that I'll prefer this type of game, though with more individual instructions for players.


Nice, I agree with both of you...Im dumb ...touchet Tap But you know why i made the error I did.
I read the rules and the Faq and thought I had all the mechanics I needed.

and Ken I want to know if I should boost or not the same way you need to know to create a player or not.
I will not boost with no future to look forward to...I dont care about the USA Pro League. I would rather do as tap suggested and just spend that money on a new toon.
I cant see why anyone not in a top league already would boost.

the guys in USA Pro have toons in place ready to step in and replace the open spots anyway..so why bother? Your not stopping people from reaching the top lvl from making a cap your making sure that there is too much compition to have team or player rule the roost.

Tap is right ...your better off making a new player evers 2 or so seasons and not 30 in one year.
So lets add that to the FAQ since it happens to be a frequently asked question!?!
Player decline IS the something people should know well before they pay?
 
Link
 
well I'm glad this got taken care of. I for one highly support player decline and think it adds to the game.

 
K Rod
offline
Link
 
well im officially not putting any more money into this...i mean, we should at least get like 25% back or smthn...because after all my guys retire im done....and im pretty sure every person that doesnt put money into will be gone 2...or they will just make another account...either way it screws you guys over...
 
ress5609
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by deMolisherk
well im officially not putting any more money into this...i mean, we should at least get like 25% back or smthn...because after all my guys retire im done....and im pretty sure every person that doesnt put money into will be gone 2...or they will just make another account...either way it screws you guys over...


You get 70% of your flex points back...
 
K Rod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ress5609
Originally posted by deMolisherk

well im officially not putting any more money into this...i mean, we should at least get like 25% back or smthn...because after all my guys retire im done....and im pretty sure every person that doesnt put money into will be gone 2...or they will just make another account...either way it screws you guys over...


You get 70% of your flex points back...


ok...i thought they were saying you dont get anything after a certain point...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by LoperK
tpaterniti, why are we not allowed to make discussions on this?


because you're wrong
 
Leahmic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Animalmother


the guys in USA Pro have toons in place ready to step in and replace the open spots anyway..so why bother?



Like I said in the other thread. You are not counting the teams that move into USA pro,
the losing teams in USA pro...you think they are going to be picky on who they want to bring to their teams?
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
Na I think the top teams will stick together for the most part and replace there toons like everyone else...
Your fighting to be second best anyway but you paid for it?
You could slow your pace ..save your money and play in the lower leagues anyway.
Just because you boost doesnt mean you get to the top....

Is the plateau of being the best long enough for you to find a team and win it all...clocks ticking and the top guys are grinding back with you.

 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Animalmother
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by tpaterniti


Hopefully smart people will realize that the answer is to not start all your players at once. Create a new player every season and you will always have 10 and always have viable players, rather than creating all 10 in the first season and ending up with nothing. People just need to use a little common sense.


Exactly. And one reason I feel that it's necessary to hold to the "decline will occur" is that I'll likely create a player or two next season, and the season after that, etc. (recycling FP's by retiring some underperforming players to help pay for that).

I'll be doing that on the basis of it being etched in stone that "Players Will Decline." I'd feel betrayed then if they didn't, as the money I'd spend to make sure I always had someone near his peak would have been thrown away in that case.

And you know what? I'll bet that other competing games with a similarity to this one will have player decline. EA sports coming out with a game (online or otherwise) where the best players are 50 years old after a while? I don't see it happening.

What might well happen is people will actually in-game control their players, and many will enjoy that; but since I don't have the manual dexterity for that I'll prefer this type of game, though with more individual instructions for players.


and Ken I want to know if I should boost or not the same way you need to know to create a player or not.

Tap is right ...your better off making a new player evers 2 or so seasons and not 30 in one year.
So lets add that to the FAQ since it happens to be a frequently asked question!?!
Player decline IS the something people should know well before they pay?


Well, now you know. "No decline" is never going to happen. If a Senior's League (completely unrealistic, but meant as a compromise so you don't have to stop playing your players, and one that if implemented I'll likely use) wouldn't be good enough for you, and a coaching class that one can only get into after playing ten seasons isn't good enough for you, you shouldn't boost your players.

And I know I should keep creating new ones.

I'm in favor of seeing it in the FAQ as well, but...either way...I read about the decline before I made anyone. It was a sticky thread. You didn't; your error. And you have your answer, so it's pretty much time for you to accept it.
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
I have no choice but to accept it so I do!

Now lets fix it...

Coaching is fine but why not let people just ROLL coaches to begin with?
If I wanted a coach I would download NFL head coach (worst selling game in the genre)


The retirement league is the best option ive heard so far but again how unrealstic is that? Players cant live forever or you QUIT! So it's ok if they do..eventhough its totaly unrealistic as long as others retire?
The logic is odd but ill take the old crappy player if thats my only option.


Ok now the dilema:
Do I boost next season because my guys will one day make it to the retirement league?
We dont know if there is one....
If there isnt one I will not boost...
If there is a retirement leage.. I may boost but not unless I know HOW MUCH the players will degrade.
Do they loose 30 stats...100...10? WTH is it? I need to know or I wont pay.

So if there is one do I miss a season of Boosts and how does that effect the retirement league?
Do only players boosted 3 times for 10 seasons make it in?

So you got your question answered maybe ...by the NEVER going to happen post.
the rest of us didnt...
I have no clue whats going on with my money and 30 boosted players.
Neither does anyone else with even 1 boosted player.
Do we boost again?
When will we know?

and the GD FAQ still hasnt changed...
Last edited Jun 1, 2008 21:37:50
 
LoperK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by imwatchingespn
Originally posted by LoperK

tpaterniti, why are we not allowed to make discussions on this?


because you're wrong


Wrong about what? They are ideas, 99% of them are not mine. I am not wrong about anything you moron.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.