User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
Top 8 stay in each division....championship 2 move up from each pro league....demotion option given to owners who've owned their team the longest....suck it up butter cup to those who don't get to go back to where they came from....after plateau will F things up anyway IMO...


Makes too much sense and might make some pansies sad. Can't have that . . .
 
kwankwan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Other things to consider is:

1) How do you deal with teams that gut?
2) Where do you send teams that are demoted?



This..
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Other things to consider is:

1) How do you deal with teams that gut?
2) Where do you send teams that are demoted?



Look at my proposal. Deals with both those scenarios.
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
How about...

First Season: Any team that made the conference finals gets moved into the league. Regular tiebreakers used to determine spots for gutting teams (eg. LOL). Put teams from the same conference into the same conference in WPL.

Future Seasons: The worse team from the two teams that came from the same conference gets demoted (tiebreakers: Playoff wins, Record, Point Differential or something like that). Teams that make the championship game of their Pro leagues get promoted to World Pro. In the case of a gutting scenario, the gutted team gets dropped. If both teams gut, the promote the conference finalist from the Pro conference.

Example: For OPL Zeta, two teams in WPL in the same conference. Whichever team does worse gets demoted, with a new team from OPL Zeta coming up.

This way, there will always be two teams from each pro conference in the league.

Cons
There are a few flaws in this system.

1) A team like the Benitos could dominate for eternity, meaning that other teams from the same conference could not stay in WPL for more than one season. I don't see this as a huge issue though... in the past, if the Benitos kept winning the championship, no other team in SAPL could win anyway.

2) People can still argue that teams in USAPL are better... and in the long run, unlike the initial scenario, you will probably not have the best 32 teams in the league. However, you do get better representation, and this should hopefully prop up the value of some pretty shitty Pro Leagues (APL, EEPL, OPL come to mind immediately) more than the OP's proposed system, where, if USAPL was better (debatable), the league could be flooded with teams from that league.

3) This essentially makes some Tourneys (definitely ToC) pretty worthless. But eh. Whatevs.


 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JHight
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by the man of doom


Originally posted by crazy454



Originally posted by Joebarber




Originally posted by Havoc





[

If you promote 2 teams from each Pro league you will have to demote half of the WPL each season (dont you think that is a lot?)... why not just promote the league champion from each region and demote only 8 of the 32 teams...


Do it like European soccer.

8 Pro champs auto promote and replace the bottom 8 WPL teams.

8 Pro runner ups play an additional playoff game against WPL teams #17-24. Winner plays in WPL the next season.

I really like this plan tbh


+1


+1


+1


How do you figure out who faces who?


str of leagues

USA faces 24
Canada faces 23 ect.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by UMBF
I think we need to convince Bort that its ok to demote teams to a region other than their original one. We need to balance out the regions. USA Pro is the toughest because that's where most of the best players want to play. If the World League becomes the toughest league, then players may not be as biased towards USA Pro.


The world league in itself will balance out the leagues imo. People will go to the path of least resistance. Would you join a USAPL team that has a 50% chance of getting into the WPL or an OPL team that has a 75% chance? I would tend to think most would go OPL.
 
kwankwan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
Originally posted by FairForever

How about...

First Season: Any team that made the conference finals gets moved into the league. Regular tiebreakers used to determine spots for gutting teams (eg. LOL). Put teams from the same conference into the same conference in WPL.

Future Seasons: The worse team from the two teams that came from the same conference gets demoted (tiebreakers: Playoff wins, Record, Point Differential or something like that). Teams that make the championship game of their Pro leagues get promoted to World Pro. In the case of a gutting scenario, the gutted team gets dropped. If both teams gut, the promote the conference finalist from the Pro conference.

Example: For OPL Zeta, two teams in WPL in the same conference. Whichever team does worse gets demoted, with a new team from OPL Zeta coming up.

This way, there will always be two teams from each pro conference in the league.

Cons
There are a few flaws in this system.

1) A team like the Benitos could dominate for eternity, meaning that other teams from the same conference could not stay in WPL for more than one season. I don't see this as a huge issue though... in the past, if the Benitos kept winning the championship, no other team in SAPL could win anyway.

2) People can still argue that teams in USAPL are better... and in the long run, unlike the initial scenario, you will probably not have the best 32 teams in the league. However, you do get better representation, and this should hopefully prop up the value of some pretty shitty Pro Leagues (APL, EEPL, OPL come to mind immediately) more than the OP's proposed system, where, if USAPL was better (debatable), the league could be flooded with teams from that league.

3) This essentially makes some Tourneys (definitely ToC) pretty worthless. But eh. Whatevs.




What if the worst of the two teams doesn't get demoted, but played a playoff game vs. the winner of the PRO league, to determine the next years WL team..?
 
Firenze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ubasstards
copied from another thread

Originally posted by turnit643

World League


Suggested conference structure and promotion / relegation schedule.

* spelling out gart's suggested framework as I understand it (from here: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2958454&page=8 )


▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬


► Initial formation of the World League:


○ Season 10's final four teams from each of the eight Pro leagues get pulled up to form the initial 32-team World League.

○ The World League would be built with the same Alpha-Zeta conference structure as the rest of GLB's leagues and teams fill in to the WL according to their established Alpha-Zeta affiliation.

○ Following the initial promotion from the current Pro leagues to the World League, each Pro League will have four more slots to fill from AAA on top of the usual four, plus guts. So, in Season 11, each Pro league would experience an influx of at least eight AAA's (four naturally promoted + four World League replacements + gut replacements.)


World League - Alpha Conference:
1. APL Lion 1
2. APL Lion 2
3. CPL West 1
4. CPL West 2
5. EEPL Alpha 1
6. EEPL Alpha 2
7. OPL Alpha 1
8. OPL Alpha 2
9. SAPL Satchmo 1
10. SAPL Satchmo 2
11. SEAPL Naga 1
12. SEAPL Naga 2
13. USAPL West 1
14. USAPL West 2
15. WEPL Alpha 1
16. WEPL Alpha 2

World League - Zeta Conference:
1. APL Elephant 1
2. APL Elephant 2
3. CPL East 1
4. CPL East 2
5. EEPL Zeta 1
6. EEPL Zeta 2
7. OPL Zeta 1
8. OPL Zeta 2
9. SAPL Dizzy 1
10. SAPL Dizzy 2
11. SEAPL Garuda 1
12. SEAPL Garuda 2
13. USAPL East 1
14. USAPL East 2
15. WEPL Zeta 1
16. WEPL Zeta 2


► Subsequent promotions and demotions to and from the World league:

○ World League teams that qualify for the playoffs (16 teams) remain in the World League.

○ World League teams that fail to reach the playoffs (16 teams) return to their home Pro league.

○ Pro league Champions and runners-up (16 teams) promote to the World League.

○ At all times, each region would be repped int he World League by at least 2 teams.

○ At most, 4 teams from any region will be demoted to their original Pro league each season (2 back into each conference.)

○ At most, 2 teams from any region will be promoted to the World League each season (1 from each conference.)

○ When the situation arises that two teams are demoted back into a Pro conference at the same time, room is made for the second team by demoting an additional team from Pro to AAA, and then from AAA to AA if necessary. Removing gutted teams along the way can help with this. This is an idea that has been questioned - fearing the Pro-to-AAA demoted team would not be happy with it. Keep in mind that additional AAA teams were pulled up before they naturally should have been promoted to replace teams headed to the World League, so this is the other side of the same coin.

○ Over time this system allows regions that deserve more representation to get it. If teams from one region are able to succeed (make the playoffs) in the World League, they will stay and others from their region will join them there. In the most extreme case, one region could potentially have 18 representatives while the other 7 regions have only their 2 reps. Getting from the initial 4 reps to the potential top of 18 would take 7 seasons, would be very tough and unlikely, but possible.


► Pro's of this format:

○ Fair initial set-up.

○ Ensures representation from all regions in the future.

○ Allows for stronger leagues to eventually send more reps to the World League.

○ Requirement to stay in the World League (qualify for playoffs) is tough - as it should be for an ELITE league.

○ Turnover rate will be half of the league each season, allowing for new blood on a regular basis.

○ Promotion / relegation is handled in a fair manner.

○ Some regional conference rivalries will be preserved.

○ The long-awaited World League can finally begin.


► Con's of this format:

○ Initial season will not house the best 32 Pro teams in the game.

○ other?




 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Other things to consider is:

1) How do you deal with teams that gut?
2) Where do you send teams that are demoted?


Demoted teams go back to their original conference.

Max would be one room for one more team needed. If no guts are available to replace, then demote one more to AAA. Team going to AAA can't be too upset about that after there were more AAA call-ups than should have been when creating the World League and the opportunity exists for more AAA being called up prematurely if WL teams from that region were successful in the WL.

Edited by turnit643 on Jul 27, 2009 18:26:40
 
smallbugger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Other things to consider is:

1) How do you deal with teams that gut?
2) Where do you send teams that are demoted?



1. promote extra team from their region

2. try to send people back to their original region like borts "preference" system for minors to AA promotion. You might get what you want, but not always.
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kwankwan
Originally posted by FairForever

Originally posted by FairForever


How about...

First Season: Any team that made the conference finals gets moved into the league. Regular tiebreakers used to determine spots for gutting teams (eg. LOL). Put teams from the same conference into the same conference in WPL.

Future Seasons: The worse team from the two teams that came from the same conference gets demoted (tiebreakers: Playoff wins, Record, Point Differential or something like that). Teams that make the championship game of their Pro leagues get promoted to World Pro. In the case of a gutting scenario, the gutted team gets dropped. If both teams gut, the promote the conference finalist from the Pro conference.

Example: For OPL Zeta, two teams in WPL in the same conference. Whichever team does worse gets demoted, with a new team from OPL Zeta coming up.

This way, there will always be two teams from each pro conference in the league.

Cons
There are a few flaws in this system.

1) A team like the Benitos could dominate for eternity, meaning that other teams from the same conference could not stay in WPL for more than one season. I don't see this as a huge issue though... in the past, if the Benitos kept winning the championship, no other team in SAPL could win anyway.

2) People can still argue that teams in USAPL are better... and in the long run, unlike the initial scenario, you will probably not have the best 32 teams in the league. However, you do get better representation, and this should hopefully prop up the value of some pretty shitty Pro Leagues (APL, EEPL, OPL come to mind immediately) more than the OP's proposed system, where, if USAPL was better (debatable), the league could be flooded with teams from that league.

3) This essentially makes some Tourneys (definitely ToC) pretty worthless. But eh. Whatevs.




What if the worst of the two teams doesn't get demoted, but played a playoff game vs. the winner of the PRO league, to determine the next years WL team..?


You mean the winner of the pro conference?

That could be a potential solution as well. I never thought about that. Actually, I like it. Add it in as a play-in game.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
Originally posted by FairForever

How about...

First Season: Any team that made the conference finals gets moved into the league. Regular tiebreakers used to determine spots for gutting teams (eg. LOL). Put teams from the same conference into the same conference in WPL.

Future Seasons: The worse team from the two teams that came from the same conference gets demoted (tiebreakers: Playoff wins, Record, Point Differential or something like that). Teams that make the championship game of their Pro leagues get promoted to World Pro. In the case of a gutting scenario, the gutted team gets dropped. If both teams gut, the promote the conference finalist from the Pro conference.

Example: For OPL Zeta, two teams in WPL in the same conference. Whichever team does worse gets demoted, with a new team from OPL Zeta coming up.

This way, there will always be two teams from each pro conference in the league.

Cons
There are a few flaws in this system.

1) A team like the Benitos could dominate for eternity, meaning that other teams from the same conference could not stay in WPL for more than one season. I don't see this as a huge issue though... in the past, if the Benitos kept winning the championship, no other team in SAPL could win anyway.

2) People can still argue that teams in USAPL are better... and in the long run, unlike the initial scenario, you will probably not have the best 32 teams in the league. However, you do get better representation, and this should hopefully prop up the value of some pretty shitty Pro Leagues (APL, EEPL, OPL come to mind immediately) more than the OP's proposed system, where, if USAPL was better (debatable), the league could be flooded with teams from that league.

3) This essentially makes some Tourneys (definitely ToC) pretty worthless. But eh. Whatevs.




I like this, but I still don't like you.
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by UMBF

I think we need to convince Bort that its ok to demote teams to a region other than their original one. We need to balance out the regions. USA Pro is the toughest because that's where most of the best players want to play. If the World League becomes the toughest league, then players may not be as biased towards USA Pro.


The world league in itself will balance out the leagues imo. People will go to the path of least resistance. Would you join a USAPL team that has a 50% chance of getting into the WPL or an OPL team that has a 75% chance? I would tend to think most would go OPL.


OPL can become dominate?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by the man of doom
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by UMBF


I think we need to convince Bort that its ok to demote teams to a region other than their original one. We need to balance out the regions. USA Pro is the toughest because that's where most of the best players want to play. If the World League becomes the toughest league, then players may not be as biased towards USA Pro.


The world league in itself will balance out the leagues imo. People will go to the path of least resistance. Would you join a USAPL team that has a 50% chance of getting into the WPL or an OPL team that has a 75% chance? I would tend to think most would go OPL.


OPL can become dominate?


No league will become dominant. Parity will exist over time.
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by FairForever

Originally posted by FairForever


How about...

First Season: Any team that made the conference finals gets moved into the league. Regular tiebreakers used to determine spots for gutting teams (eg. LOL). Put teams from the same conference into the same conference in WPL.

Future Seasons: The worse team from the two teams that came from the same conference gets demoted (tiebreakers: Playoff wins, Record, Point Differential or something like that). Teams that make the championship game of their Pro leagues get promoted to World Pro. In the case of a gutting scenario, the gutted team gets dropped. If both teams gut, the promote the conference finalist from the Pro conference.

Example: For OPL Zeta, two teams in WPL in the same conference. Whichever team does worse gets demoted, with a new team from OPL Zeta coming up.

This way, there will always be two teams from each pro conference in the league.

Cons
There are a few flaws in this system.

1) A team like the Benitos could dominate for eternity, meaning that other teams from the same conference could not stay in WPL for more than one season. I don't see this as a huge issue though... in the past, if the Benitos kept winning the championship, no other team in SAPL could win anyway.

2) People can still argue that teams in USAPL are better... and in the long run, unlike the initial scenario, you will probably not have the best 32 teams in the league. However, you do get better representation, and this should hopefully prop up the value of some pretty shitty Pro Leagues (APL, EEPL, OPL come to mind immediately) more than the OP's proposed system, where, if USAPL was better (debatable), the league could be flooded with teams from that league.

3) This essentially makes some Tourneys (definitely ToC) pretty worthless. But eh. Whatevs.




I like this, but I still don't like you.


Wow, never thought we'd agree on anything tbqh.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.