User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Gameplan doesnt run in playoff game WTF?
Page:
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whodey08
Here's the AI:[IMG]http://i29.tinypic.com/whk3kg.jpg[/IMG] (click image to enlarge)

Here's the game link:http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=687668

Now you tell me.....did it follow the AI?

Same offense that we ran for the last handful of regular season games and scrimmage games! But now all of a sudden it does its own thing? I just don't get it!!!!???

35% of 1st downs and 35% of 2nd downs were supposed to be outside runs. So how is it that the first outside run was not until 6 minutes left in the 2nd quarter!!!!

Such crap!

EE PRO LEAGUE


Why do you set time remaining in quarter in the general part of the OAI ?. maybe the sim only looked at the last 900 of the game or something like that.
You are probably doing it all the time and never had a problem, but just in case.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ryanshaw


You have actually mis-interpreted what I said and as a result you have missed the point. I never claimed that the sim determined the result of the game and then went back and worked out the plays. What I did say is that the sim messes around with the randomness of the playcalling. This is almost undeniable based on the stats - the question is how and why. It is my GUESS that the sim has some built in momentum counter (which would be reasonable based on what Bort has said) which probably starts off the game favouring the stronger team (as you would expect). As momentum moves against you in a game (which is affected by the results of plays) the sim then alters the weighting of your playcalls in the AI against plays that are doing well. As a result, the worse things are going for you in a game the more of a departure there will be from the preset AI percentages. This is all guesswork but it does seem to fit the pattern I have seen. My point is that if the sim is adjusting the percentages it is totally wrong and unfair as there is no reason that the coaches would suddenly be unable to do basic arithmetic on the sidelines just because you start doing badly on the field!

None of your examples disprove what I have said. Your SI slam game was close because you called runs all the time - so what? I did not actually claim (others have) that the sim makes up playcalls that you never called - I said it changes the percentage chance of some AI outputs being called. If you were running 90% the same play it is pretty unlikely that this would make much of a difference.

You need to stick to the facts. If you have certain playcalls with a 35% chance of being called and they actually get called only 1 time in 21 plays, the statistical chances of that happening are very, very small. It is quite easy to find similar examples and taken together they show with a high degree of likelihood that the plays are not being selected strictly at random based on the percentages in the AI. Whether this is because of a deliberate effect (as I have guessed) or just because the random number generator is screwed is a matter of interpretation, but the fact that Bort or the admins have refused consistently to answer this matter does make me think it is the former.


OK first of all, you're right, I did misinterpret what you said. But I still think you're wrong about the sim messing around with the randomness to favor a stronger team. You keep saying the facts are undeniable. What facts? Care to post them? You also keep saying based on what Bort said. Can I get a quote? It's kind of hard to convince me of this stuff when you're providing no evidence, but you keep saying all the evidence is there.

Like I said, I'm sure there's times when a 35% output only gets called once or twice a game, but I'm sure for every one game like that, I can show you 100 games where the play call DID get roughly called 35% of the time in a certain situation. Sounds like you are basing your whole argument on a couple of statistical anomalies which are bound to happen.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Anyways, if you don't mind ryan, can we please get back to the bug at hand in this topic? It definitely isn't the same problem you have had in the past, and I don't want to de-rail this thread any more.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Originally posted by islander1


Did one of you have the tactics/AI page open after 1pm?



Don't know.

But as for the FG thing:

http://img407.imageshack.us/img407/5112/picture5w.png

LOL. In the very same picture you have us kicking a FG, and the AI tester saying Punt. I love it.


I had problem with the OAI/DAI tester from the replay page. It sometime runs the wrong test.


Ok here's the replay:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=687627&pbp_id=17484724

The situation:
0:09 4th & 4.5 OPP 46.5 63.5 yd field goal attempted by Long Distance, made [FG]

I'll enter it exactly, even down to the last second in the tester:
http://img31.imageshack.us/img31/8817/picture1emg.png

Comes up as Punt.

For good measure, here's our first down input being tested. The plays I showed earlier, where we were running one of the best scat backs in the game up the middle out of I-formation. Lol...like that was our master gameplan against one off the best rush Ds in the game.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=687627&pbp_id=17482923
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=687627&pbp_id=17483751

Here's the exact situation in the first replay down to the second tested: http://img521.imageshack.us/img521/7214/picture2eks.png
The second replay:
http://img526.imageshack.us/img526/595/picture3due.png

I guess you're just going to have to take my word for it that those output names are the actual plays we selected. I assure you they are though. I'd just prefer not to take like 10 different screenshots, because they all don't fit on the same screen. I COULD if people honestly still think I'm doing something wrong, but I'll leave it up to someone to ask me to first.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Is there a reason a moderator has posted in every thread around this one, but not a word in this thread?

A "forwarded to Bort, looking into it" at the very least would be nice . I'd hate for it to cost another team a playoff game. We worked our asses off gameplanning all season, and it really sucked to go out like this on a gameplan we didn't even set.

I'll show a couple of more playcalls that we didn't have in our offense...

ANOTHER 1st down call that is not in our outputs:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=687627&pbp_id=17484303

Tester with exact situation:
http://img199.imageshack.us/img199/765/picture4jzk.png

That's 3 drives in a row where our 1st down playcalling has not been used. Let's see the 4th one.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=687627&pbp_id=17485394

What a surprise! Another one doesn't follow our AI. First of all, that was an awesome interception lol. But back to the matter at hand. It's a pass out of the strong I.
For our first down setting, we only had 3 Strong I Outputs: 2 outside runs, and a FB Streak. This play is none of those.
http://img41.imageshack.us/img41/9503/picture6nog.png


I'm not saying I want a re-sim of the game or anything, because it is too late for that. But obviously a huge bug happened here where the computer ran basic AI, and it should definitely be looked at. I'd hate for another team to get hit by this like we did...because honestly, it sucked after putting in hours of gameplanning all season.
Edited by Sik Wit It on Jul 24, 2009 11:59:58
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Is there a reason a moderator has posted in every thread around this one, but not a word in this thread?


+1

 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
Originally posted by whodey08

Here's the AI:[IMG]http://i29.tinypic.com/whk3kg.jpg[/IMG] (click image to enlarge)

Here's the game link:http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=687668

Now you tell me.....did it follow the AI?

Same offense that we ran for the last handful of regular season games and scrimmage games! But now all of a sudden it does its own thing? I just don't get it!!!!???

35% of 1st downs and 35% of 2nd downs were supposed to be outside runs. So how is it that the first outside run was not until 6 minutes left in the 2nd quarter!!!!

Such crap!

EE PRO LEAGUE


Why do you set time remaining in quarter in the general part of the OAI ?. maybe the sim only looked at the last 900 of the game or something like that.
You are probably doing it all the time and never had a problem, but just in case.


There is 900 seconds in a quarter and that box is filled in at 900 seconds so the SIM follows that AI for the entire quarter. I have separate inputs above that one for close to the endzone stuff. But that INPUT covers all quarters for 1st and 2nd down and it most certainly did not follow it.

I have used the same AI all season and never had a problem til the playoffs!
Edited by whodey08 on Jul 24, 2009 16:36:16
 
satandole666
offline
Link
 
It really sucks that your season ended this way.

It sucks even more that this thread has cuddies and no one will touch it.
 
Cylon
offline
Link
 
Just to pile on, even though it didn't affect the outcome luckily, I have an example of the AI choosing something that it wasn't supposed to as well. I had a specific 100% output for shotgun formation but this pops up:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=690505&pbp_id=18081257

Here's the right one every other time:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=690505&pbp_id=18081034
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=690505&pbp_id=18074605
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=690505&pbp_id=18077749
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=690505&pbp_id=18079224
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=690505&pbp_id=18080352
 
DrunkenCowboy
offline
Link
 
To OP,

Did you update the gameplan an hour before the sim started? In the past, when I've done that, my AI wouldn't load..it looks like there's a definite cut-off time.
 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenCowboy
To OP,

Did you update the gameplan an hour before the sim started? In the past, when I've done that, my AI wouldn't load..it looks like there's a definite cut-off time.


I had not touched my AI. Same AI I used all season. Our HB led the league in rushing yards and finished 1st in EE PRO for rushing yards due to my AI so I didn't touch it. BUt come the playoff game.....he doesn't touch the ball til 6 minutes to go in 2nd quarter and when he does he gets a 30yd gain.

THE SIM SCREWED UP OUR AI"S!!!!!!
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whodey08
Originally posted by DrunkenCowboy

To OP,

Did you update the gameplan an hour before the sim started? In the past, when I've done that, my AI wouldn't load..it looks like there's a definite cut-off time.


I had not touched my AI. Same AI I used all season. Our HB led the league in rushing yards and finished 1st in EE PRO for rushing yards due to my AI so I didn't touch it. BUt come the playoff game.....he doesn't touch the ball til 6 minutes to go in 2nd quarter and when he does he gets a 30yd gain.

THE SIM SCREWED UP OUR AI"S!!!!!!


I sure don't like how you name plays. Random inside, random outside. Why not just put the actual play you want to run as the description? With that many potential plays you are asking for trouble.

And if you use the entire AI all season and never change it good teams in the playoffs will exploit it.
 
DrunkenCowboy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Originally posted by whodey08

Originally posted by DrunkenCowboy


To OP,

Did you update the gameplan an hour before the sim started? In the past, when I've done that, my AI wouldn't load..it looks like there's a definite cut-off time.


I had not touched my AI. Same AI I used all season. Our HB led the league in rushing yards and finished 1st in EE PRO for rushing yards due to my AI so I didn't touch it. BUt come the playoff game.....he doesn't touch the ball til 6 minutes to go in 2nd quarter and when he does he gets a 30yd gain.

THE SIM SCREWED UP OUR AI"S!!!!!!


I sure don't like how you name plays. Random inside, random outside. Why not just put the actual play you want to run as the description? With that many potential plays you are asking for trouble.

And if you use the entire AI all season and never change it good teams in the playoffs will exploit it.


I have to agree here, not saying the playoff sims are totally screwed sometimes...but you don't help yourself with that AI setup
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenCowboy
To OP,

Did you update the gameplan an hour before the sim started? In the past, when I've done that, my AI wouldn't load..it looks like there's a definite cut-off time.


No, he updated it the afternoon before.
 
rjssob
HOOD
offline
Link
 
There are others in this thread that are no doubt a part of the .5 yard syndrome where people don't know how to manipulate the AI to get what they want:

2nd and 0-3
2nd and 4-7
2nd and 7+

If you set up your AI this way, 2nd and 3.5 reverts to the basic settings where as 2nd and 7.5 would hit your AI Input for 2nd and 7+

I have noticed odd things with the sim as well and from what I have read there are some great pieces of evidence to support these claims.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.