User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > DPC blitzing when player set to move to another assignment
Page:
 
r8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TS_SuperStar721
Originally posted by r8

Say you have your LOLB set on TE -> HB or Blitz
If the TE is on the field, and runs a route, the LOLB covers the TE.
If the TE is on the field, and stays in to block, the LOLB moves to the "Blitz" part.
If the TE is NOT on the field, and the HB runs a route, the LOLB covers the HB
If the TE is NOT on the field, and the HB stays in to block, the LOLB moves to the "Blitz" part.


What if the setting is "SS on HB->or Zone" and the SS is still blitzing like on these plays I posted:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=687779&pbp_id=17522885
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=687779&pbp_id=17523694

This is a SS with almost 70 vision, so a failed vision check can't be it.

am I misunderstanding something?


Errr.... The HB stays in to block on both of those plays, so yes, the SS is going to blitz.
 
Link
 
wait...even if the next progression is "or Zone" it skips the zone and automatically blitzes when the HB stays in to block?
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
All this arguing means nothing to me....progression or not....the real bug is the blitzing when not being set to..


All i want to know is why the defenders are BLITZING when the last option is ZONE.

This blitzing bug really kicked me hard, in a 1 point loss in the playoffs....

Anytime I have a player man to man (without move) on a HB, if the HB stays in, he's blitzing, rather then playing back in a zone like its set up to.
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TS_SuperStar721
wait...even if the next progression is "or Zone" it skips the zone and automatically blitzes when the HB stays in to block?


EXACTLY, this makes no sense why this would happen
Edited by EagleOtto on Jul 24, 2009 16:00:18
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by r8
Originally posted by odg62

well i look pretty dumb, but i still dont see how the replays i posted dont show the progression. specifically the one where the CB chases the TE across the feild.


That's the way the "Zone" works for the Cover options, it basically creates a small zone around the player, and they lock onto the first player that cuts through it. So it's actually kind of a Zone2Man deal.


okay, back to the bug i guess, whats up with the play in the OP where the SS and MLB blitz post change but lock onto a guy pre change

Post change - http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=589199&pbp_id=16540914

Pre-Change - http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=589244&pbp_id=14791120
 
r8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TS_SuperStar721
wait...even if the next progression is "or Zone" it skips the zone and automatically blitzes when the HB stays in to block?


I'm sorry, I read your post wrong.

If that SS is set to HB or Zone, then we have a problem. What confuses me though, is that is definitely something that I specifically tested before Bort uploaded it to the live server

I'll take another look at it.
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
Examples:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=690497&pbp_id=17865369
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=690497&pbp_id=17865926
ROLB and CB2 both are set to cover man (w/o move) on the HB, and set to zone.
Both blitz after reading Hb staying in.




 
Link
 
Originally posted by r8
Originally posted by TS_SuperStar721

wait...even if the next progression is "or Zone" it skips the zone and automatically blitzes when the HB stays in to block?


I'm sorry, I read your post wrong.

If that SS is set to HB or Zone, then we have a problem. What confuses me though, is that is definitely something that I specifically tested before Bort uploaded it to the live server

I'll take another look at it.


I figured that's what happened. Thanks for going ahead to take another look at it. I've temporarily changed the HB duties to the LOLB in the DPC in hopes that the SS won't do that anymore for the playoff game I have tomorrow.
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
good thing just about everyone is sending their HB out on routes most every play these days. Dont let the OCs find out about this.

Also, Endiku - you were right i was wrong, im an ass
Edited by odg62 on Jul 24, 2009 16:09:06
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by odg62
good thing just about everyone is sending their HB out on routes most every play these days. Dont let the OCs find out about this.

Also, Endiku - you were right i was wrong, im an ass


No worries dude.

You have some interesting play replays and I am glad you brought them up because if anything, they can be used as good examples of how plays SHOULD work.

EG examples how a more post snap read of the checkdown list makes for realistic football sims.

I think that sometimes things happen like your ROLB who is supposed to cover FB and then HB and does just that (though according to the DPC he shouldn't have) and they are friggen awesome. They break up the play and give the defense something to have the players react more fluidly and naturally and makes for a better sim.

I'm glad we can stop arguing because it was distrcting from the greater issue.

Which is the Blitz|Zone issue.

If you are set to zone and you blitz this is wrong and if you are set to blitz and you zone, this is wrong as well, so the more we can provide good data the more we can help r8 and Bort.

I was just trying to make sure we were focusing on the real error and I sidetracked us.

 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
r8, I'm curious about this being missed vision checks? Would this possibly be covered then by the fixes Bort was making? Where if you miss your vision check you might zone coverage and maybe since I think I saw you note it was 50/50 zone|blitz the game just flips a coin and has the player react one way or the other so this is a case of people noticing the 50% of the time where it chooses the wrong option and they don;t post up the plays where the missed vision check resulted in the right behaviour?

Also, how can we help you convince Bort to make the coverage list fluid and post snap as well?

My own suggestion would be to use the existing mechanics. So that the Checkdown list initially determine the players primary line up location (if set for cover man) and their first read.

Using an example I have used before.

SS is set for Cover Man TE, HB, FB, Zone.

In the present Sim, on any play except 5WR he will (if he makes his vision check pre snap) line up on the TE to cover the TE. If the TE pass blocks, he will Drop into a zone. (Which presently is a tiny bubble zone you say?)

My suggestion/desire for a more fluid and realistic defense is that this behaviour would be the same until w get to the snap.

At snap the vision check is to see if their coverage runs a route or pass blocks.
If the check is made AND their coverage was pass blocking, then the player makes a second read against their check down list. If this read is also pass blocking they move to the next read. These should be pass|fails and occur in successive tics until they no longer have a coverage check down list, at which point they would do their default action of Zone|Blitz.

The reason for this is that if they miss a lot of checks, they'll only stay standing in place for a few tics before they get to their default actions. If they make a check, they'll immediately move off to accomplish it but because of the time it took there may be a delay and coverage not perfect, which is realistic and good.

The last thing I would want and I mentioned it elsewhere is that the 'default action' be more user definable. So instead of blitz|zone you have Blitz|Flat Weak Third|Flat Strong Third|Under Weak Third|etc.... (All the possible zones)

This allows you to 'guess' the direction of a play and if your reads for coverage are all pass blocking your players knowledge (eg your coaches setting for that DPC play) send you off to the part of the field where you would be best able to help on the play.


 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu
The last thing I would want and I mentioned it elsewhere is that the 'default action' be more user definable. So instead of blitz|zone you have Blitz|Flat Weak Third|Flat Strong Third|Under Weak Third|etc.... (All the possible zones)


this is long overdue
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu
I think that sometimes things happen like your ROLB who is supposed to cover FB and then HB and does just that (though according to the DPC he shouldn't have) and they are friggen awesome. They break up the play and give the defense something to have the players react more fluidly and naturally and makes for a better sim.


After r8 saying what was right i double checked that play and actually, the ROLB was set to cover HB. I had assumed based on my own tendencies that i had the ROLB set to cover the FB but in fact i did not. On that play the LILB was set cover FB -HB (which he actually did as the HB began his route, but then he broke off into a zone)

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=589244&pbp_id=14790739

(also thats a tough replay to keep posting, that play played a big part in my team finishing 9th)
Edited by odg62 on Jul 24, 2009 19:27:14
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
I am noticing this when the player is set to fall into a zone. Not sure if it is the same thing but watch the CB. He is set to cover the HB or zone. He appears to blitz and this did not happen before todays sim that I noticed.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=678916&pbp_id=18040090
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by odg62
Originally posted by Enkidu

The last thing I would want and I mentioned it elsewhere is that the 'default action' be more user definable. So instead of blitz|zone you have Blitz|Flat Weak Third|Flat Strong Third|Under Weak Third|etc.... (All the possible zones)


this is long overdue


yes!!! we need to be able to define the zone they fall into. Would allow for much more control.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.