Originally posted by Saris
Originally posted by datongw
If the offense has the option to put the rushing QB in only to run, never need to pass, then the defense should have an option in the AI that select a different play if that QB is in the game. Big part of football is strategy, but tough to do that when your hands are tied.
I'll play devils advocate on this one. If this change was made the point would be moot because every rushing QB in the game would be forced into retirement. I'm not in any way associated with a team that has a rushing QB, but I would assume that they'd have had to sacrifice a lot of their passing ability to become a viable runner. So if a player is really only viable for one situation and then only if he can catch his opponent off guard. If the opposing team were given the ability to adjust to that player, the situation is no longer viable and neither is the player. To a degree the same would also apply to blocking TE's.
I do think the defensive reactions leave a lot to be desired when the QB is rushing and should be improved, but I don't think forcing a lot of players into retirement due to a change in the sim is the answer. Also I get the realism argument, but lets be fair it's not like the offense can call audibles either, and there are tons of exploitive plays being created with the DPC that offenses would be able to destroy if they could adjust to them.
Well, that's like saying if I build a super fast receiver with no other skills he should be able to play and dominate? The fact is the primary job for the QB is to pass the ball, not to run the ball, even great runners like Vince Young doesn't run that much once he gets to the Pros. Putting a runner that can't throw to play QB and he doesn't have to throw would be an exploit, wouldn't it? If defense can't adjust to that, at least make the defense react faster when he runs. Right now unless the defender is set to blitz, he basically watches until the QB crosses the LOS, that's a bit ridiculous, is it not? I know he's going to run but I can't react to it until he crosses the LOS?
I don't think it will force the player into retirement, even if it does, it's really not a big deal, tons of players gets forced into retirement every season.
Originally posted by datongw
If the offense has the option to put the rushing QB in only to run, never need to pass, then the defense should have an option in the AI that select a different play if that QB is in the game. Big part of football is strategy, but tough to do that when your hands are tied.
I'll play devils advocate on this one. If this change was made the point would be moot because every rushing QB in the game would be forced into retirement. I'm not in any way associated with a team that has a rushing QB, but I would assume that they'd have had to sacrifice a lot of their passing ability to become a viable runner. So if a player is really only viable for one situation and then only if he can catch his opponent off guard. If the opposing team were given the ability to adjust to that player, the situation is no longer viable and neither is the player. To a degree the same would also apply to blocking TE's.
I do think the defensive reactions leave a lot to be desired when the QB is rushing and should be improved, but I don't think forcing a lot of players into retirement due to a change in the sim is the answer. Also I get the realism argument, but lets be fair it's not like the offense can call audibles either, and there are tons of exploitive plays being created with the DPC that offenses would be able to destroy if they could adjust to them.
Well, that's like saying if I build a super fast receiver with no other skills he should be able to play and dominate? The fact is the primary job for the QB is to pass the ball, not to run the ball, even great runners like Vince Young doesn't run that much once he gets to the Pros. Putting a runner that can't throw to play QB and he doesn't have to throw would be an exploit, wouldn't it? If defense can't adjust to that, at least make the defense react faster when he runs. Right now unless the defender is set to blitz, he basically watches until the QB crosses the LOS, that's a bit ridiculous, is it not? I know he's going to run but I can't react to it until he crosses the LOS?
I don't think it will force the player into retirement, even if it does, it's really not a big deal, tons of players gets forced into retirement every season.






























