User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > How is JohnnyDollar not an admin of this site yet?
Page:
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Originally posted by datongw


If the offense has the option to put the rushing QB in only to run, never need to pass, then the defense should have an option in the AI that select a different play if that QB is in the game. Big part of football is strategy, but tough to do that when your hands are tied.


I'll play devils advocate on this one. If this change was made the point would be moot because every rushing QB in the game would be forced into retirement. I'm not in any way associated with a team that has a rushing QB, but I would assume that they'd have had to sacrifice a lot of their passing ability to become a viable runner. So if a player is really only viable for one situation and then only if he can catch his opponent off guard. If the opposing team were given the ability to adjust to that player, the situation is no longer viable and neither is the player. To a degree the same would also apply to blocking TE's.

I do think the defensive reactions leave a lot to be desired when the QB is rushing and should be improved, but I don't think forcing a lot of players into retirement due to a change in the sim is the answer. Also I get the realism argument, but lets be fair it's not like the offense can call audibles either, and there are tons of exploitive plays being created with the DPC that offenses would be able to destroy if they could adjust to them.


Well, that's like saying if I build a super fast receiver with no other skills he should be able to play and dominate? The fact is the primary job for the QB is to pass the ball, not to run the ball, even great runners like Vince Young doesn't run that much once he gets to the Pros. Putting a runner that can't throw to play QB and he doesn't have to throw would be an exploit, wouldn't it? If defense can't adjust to that, at least make the defense react faster when he runs. Right now unless the defender is set to blitz, he basically watches until the QB crosses the LOS, that's a bit ridiculous, is it not? I know he's going to run but I can't react to it until he crosses the LOS?

I don't think it will force the player into retirement, even if it does, it's really not a big deal, tons of players gets forced into retirement every season.
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
I never called anyone an idiot. However, there was an implication that testers are using information for their own gain. As someone in that group of people I might take offense. Especially as you never named anyone specifically.

 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
I never called anyone an idiot. However, there was an implication that testers are using information for their own gain. As someone in that group of people I might take offense. Especially as you never named anyone specifically.



Oh boo hoo. Maybe Bort shouldn't only give out testing privileges to his buddies then? Because until testing access is done equitably, people will always rightfully complain.
 
Andreas Illum
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay

...


Wow... didnt know anyone could Troll so fast...
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Originally posted by datongw



I really have no problem with this game having random factors, afterall everything is determined by dice rolls. I spend a lot of time into scouting and that definitely helps, we do have one of the better defenses in the game. But as a DC, I'd just like to see the playing field get even a little.


Honestly, being a DC has been the best part of this game for me. I have won some games, and blown some games too learning it. But watching the plays you just made in the DPC work is a cool feeling. Even when I give up a long gain, I see where my guys were, and think about how I can get them in better position. I like having to consider what to cover and what to pray doesn't get called. I think while offense does have builds worked out better, they aren't better at game planning. They select a pitch right, and don't set up the absolute counter to it in the percentages. I think DC's see which play they fear more than the OC's do.


I do both OC and DC, and I love DC more to be honest. But it's much tougher to be a good DC than OC. I love the DPC, I think it's great and I use it all the time. But it does get really frustrating all the time since we are always behind the 8 ball trying to catch up.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by Saris

Originally posted by datongw



If the offense has the option to put the rushing QB in only to run, never need to pass, then the defense should have an option in the AI that select a different play if that QB is in the game. Big part of football is strategy, but tough to do that when your hands are tied.


I'll play devils advocate on this one. If this change was made the point would be moot because every rushing QB in the game would be forced into retirement. I'm not in any way associated with a team that has a rushing QB, but I would assume that they'd have had to sacrifice a lot of their passing ability to become a viable runner. So if a player is really only viable for one situation and then only if he can catch his opponent off guard. If the opposing team were given the ability to adjust to that player, the situation is no longer viable and neither is the player. To a degree the same would also apply to blocking TE's.

I do think the defensive reactions leave a lot to be desired when the QB is rushing and should be improved, but I don't think forcing a lot of players into retirement due to a change in the sim is the answer. Also I get the realism argument, but lets be fair it's not like the offense can call audibles either, and there are tons of exploitive plays being created with the DPC that offenses would be able to destroy if they could adjust to them.


Well, that's like saying if I build a super fast receiver with no other skills he should be able to play and dominate? The fact is the primary job for the QB is to pass the ball, not to run the ball, even great runners like Vince Young doesn't run that much once he gets to the Pros. Putting a runner that can't throw to play QB and he doesn't have to throw would be an exploit, wouldn't it? If defense can't adjust to that, at least make the defense react faster when he runs. Right now unless the defender is set to blitz, he basically watches until the QB crosses the LOS, that's a bit ridiculous, is it not? I know he's going to run but I can't react to it until he crosses the LOS?

I don't think it will force the player into retirement, even if it does, it's really not a big deal, tons of players gets forced into retirement every season.


Dat,

I think you are wrong on this one, granted one case does not make it true for everyone, but, on Fhockey, we converted a QB who had 90 + throwing, into a rushing QB, who now has 68 throwing, and his completion percentage on the season is, 68% with 122 QB rating, 1438 yards thrown, 25 TD, with 1517 rushing yards, and 22 rushing TDs,

I didn't take out the gut games, 3-5 games etc, but the point is, just because a QB is set up to rush, does not make them unable to pass.
 
Bloodfart
offline
Link
 
QB's are bigger users of flex than D players so don't put all your hopes on getting a nerf any time soon.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by steellithium

Originally posted by datongw




I really have no problem with this game having random factors, afterall everything is determined by dice rolls. I spend a lot of time into scouting and that definitely helps, we do have one of the better defenses in the game. But as a DC, I'd just like to see the playing field get even a little.


Honestly, being a DC has been the best part of this game for me. I have won some games, and blown some games too learning it. But watching the plays you just made in the DPC work is a cool feeling. Even when I give up a long gain, I see where my guys were, and think about how I can get them in better position. I like having to consider what to cover and what to pray doesn't get called. I think while offense does have builds worked out better, they aren't better at game planning. They select a pitch right, and don't set up the absolute counter to it in the percentages. I think DC's see which play they fear more than the OC's do.


I do both OC and DC, and I love DC more to be honest. But it's much tougher to be a good DC than OC. I love the DPC, I think it's great and I use it all the time. But it does get really frustrating all the time since we are always behind the 8 ball trying to catch up.


Actually I disagree, and I don't DC so I could be completely wrong, but I think it's harder to be an OC because you are limited in what you can do, you can't move the TE, you can't specify what receiver to throw to on any given play, there is a ton you just can't do. While on the other side of the ball, you can sub players in for different situations, move them around, give them specific responsibilities etc.
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy
Originally posted by Darkus Black

I never called anyone an idiot. However, there was an implication that testers are using information for their own gain. As someone in that group of people I might take offense. Especially as you never named anyone specifically.



Oh boo hoo. Maybe Bort shouldn't only give out testing privileges to his buddies then? Because until testing access is done equitably, people will always rightfully complain.


Oh shut your face. I wasn't having a go at people complaining. I was having a go at unfounded accusations. At least point the finger at a person and explain why you think they are exploiting, otherwise it is just whining for the sake of whining. Which then starts to sound like sour grapes. You have sour grapes don't you, because you never got chosen, is that it?
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by datongw

Originally posted by Saris


Originally posted by datongw




If the offense has the option to put the rushing QB in only to run, never need to pass, then the defense should have an option in the AI that select a different play if that QB is in the game. Big part of football is strategy, but tough to do that when your hands are tied.


I'll play devils advocate on this one. If this change was made the point would be moot because every rushing QB in the game would be forced into retirement. I'm not in any way associated with a team that has a rushing QB, but I would assume that they'd have had to sacrifice a lot of their passing ability to become a viable runner. So if a player is really only viable for one situation and then only if he can catch his opponent off guard. If the opposing team were given the ability to adjust to that player, the situation is no longer viable and neither is the player. To a degree the same would also apply to blocking TE's.

I do think the defensive reactions leave a lot to be desired when the QB is rushing and should be improved, but I don't think forcing a lot of players into retirement due to a change in the sim is the answer. Also I get the realism argument, but lets be fair it's not like the offense can call audibles either, and there are tons of exploitive plays being created with the DPC that offenses would be able to destroy if they could adjust to them.


Well, that's like saying if I build a super fast receiver with no other skills he should be able to play and dominate? The fact is the primary job for the QB is to pass the ball, not to run the ball, even great runners like Vince Young doesn't run that much once he gets to the Pros. Putting a runner that can't throw to play QB and he doesn't have to throw would be an exploit, wouldn't it? If defense can't adjust to that, at least make the defense react faster when he runs. Right now unless the defender is set to blitz, he basically watches until the QB crosses the LOS, that's a bit ridiculous, is it not? I know he's going to run but I can't react to it until he crosses the LOS?

I don't think it will force the player into retirement, even if it does, it's really not a big deal, tons of players gets forced into retirement every season.


Dat,

I think you are wrong on this one, granted one case does not make it true for everyone, but, on Fhockey, we converted a QB who had 90 + throwing, into a rushing QB, who now has 68 throwing, and his completion percentage on the season is, 68% with 122 QB rating, 1438 yards thrown, 25 TD, with 1517 rushing yards, and 22 rushing TDs,

I didn't take out the gut games, 3-5 games etc, but the point is, just because a QB is set up to rush, does not make them unable to pass.


I totally agree that if a QB is set to rush, doesn't mean that he is unable to pass. I have no problem with QBs that can run and pass. What I have a problem with is that these QBs are not required to pass and that even though the defense and the whole world knows about it, we have to pretend he's going to pass the ball when he comes into the game.
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black


Oh shut your face. I wasn't having a go at people complaining. I was having a go at unfounded accusations. At least point the finger at a person and explain why you think they are exploiting, otherwise it is just whining for the sake of whining. Which then starts to sound like sour grapes. You have sour grapes don't you, because you never got chosen, is that it?


Nice moderator. Will you take your teddy bear and pout in the corner?

You and your moderator cronies have shown nothing but bias towards paying customers. Bort shows the same bias to his buddies as well.

Its a shame that you and your overlord can't see why people want a level playing field.
Edited by Krunchy on Jul 21, 2009 04:54:35
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw

Well, that's like saying if I build a super fast receiver with no other skills he should be able to play and dominate? The fact is the primary job for the QB is to pass the ball, not to run the ball, even great runners like Vince Young doesn't run that much once he gets to the Pros. Putting a runner that can't throw to play QB and he doesn't have to throw would be an exploit, wouldn't it? If defense can't adjust to that, at least make the defense react faster when he runs. Right now unless the defender is set to blitz, he basically watches until the QB crosses the LOS, that's a bit ridiculous, is it not? I know he's going to run but I can't react to it until he crosses the LOS?

I don't think it will force the player into retirement, even if it does, it's really not a big deal, tons of players gets forced into retirement every season.


The only part I don't agree with is what happens to QB1 at the TE spot. If I was a LB, and you put Dan Marino out to block me, he is going to get killed. I'm not suggesting injuries, but I think there should be a severe energy drain on QB1. He is in every play, and 5-10 times a game trying to block DE's and LB's. He shouldn't be able to just pop up, and be able to throw a 60 yard TD pass.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by datongw


Originally posted by Saris



Originally posted by datongw





If the offense has the option to put the rushing QB in only to run, never need to pass, then the defense should have an option in the AI that select a different play if that QB is in the game. Big part of football is strategy, but tough to do that when your hands are tied.


I'll play devils advocate on this one. If this change was made the point would be moot because every rushing QB in the game would be forced into retirement. I'm not in any way associated with a team that has a rushing QB, but I would assume that they'd have had to sacrifice a lot of their passing ability to become a viable runner. So if a player is really only viable for one situation and then only if he can catch his opponent off guard. If the opposing team were given the ability to adjust to that player, the situation is no longer viable and neither is the player. To a degree the same would also apply to blocking TE's.

I do think the defensive reactions leave a lot to be desired when the QB is rushing and should be improved, but I don't think forcing a lot of players into retirement due to a change in the sim is the answer. Also I get the realism argument, but lets be fair it's not like the offense can call audibles either, and there are tons of exploitive plays being created with the DPC that offenses would be able to destroy if they could adjust to them.


Well, that's like saying if I build a super fast receiver with no other skills he should be able to play and dominate? The fact is the primary job for the QB is to pass the ball, not to run the ball, even great runners like Vince Young doesn't run that much once he gets to the Pros. Putting a runner that can't throw to play QB and he doesn't have to throw would be an exploit, wouldn't it? If defense can't adjust to that, at least make the defense react faster when he runs. Right now unless the defender is set to blitz, he basically watches until the QB crosses the LOS, that's a bit ridiculous, is it not? I know he's going to run but I can't react to it until he crosses the LOS?

I don't think it will force the player into retirement, even if it does, it's really not a big deal, tons of players gets forced into retirement every season.


Dat,

I think you are wrong on this one, granted one case does not make it true for everyone, but, on Fhockey, we converted a QB who had 90 + throwing, into a rushing QB, who now has 68 throwing, and his completion percentage on the season is, 68% with 122 QB rating, 1438 yards thrown, 25 TD, with 1517 rushing yards, and 22 rushing TDs,

I didn't take out the gut games, 3-5 games etc, but the point is, just because a QB is set up to rush, does not make them unable to pass.


I totally agree that if a QB is set to rush, doesn't mean that he is unable to pass. I have no problem with QBs that can run and pass. What I have a problem with is that these QBs are not required to pass and that even though the defense and the whole world knows about it, we have to pretend he's going to pass the ball when he comes into the game.


I just showed you, that he does pass when he comes into the game, as well as rushes, not understanding your point there.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by datongw

Originally posted by steellithium


Originally posted by datongw





I really have no problem with this game having random factors, afterall everything is determined by dice rolls. I spend a lot of time into scouting and that definitely helps, we do have one of the better defenses in the game. But as a DC, I'd just like to see the playing field get even a little.


Honestly, being a DC has been the best part of this game for me. I have won some games, and blown some games too learning it. But watching the plays you just made in the DPC work is a cool feeling. Even when I give up a long gain, I see where my guys were, and think about how I can get them in better position. I like having to consider what to cover and what to pray doesn't get called. I think while offense does have builds worked out better, they aren't better at game planning. They select a pitch right, and don't set up the absolute counter to it in the percentages. I think DC's see which play they fear more than the OC's do.


I do both OC and DC, and I love DC more to be honest. But it's much tougher to be a good DC than OC. I love the DPC, I think it's great and I use it all the time. But it does get really frustrating all the time since we are always behind the 8 ball trying to catch up.


Actually I disagree, and I don't DC so I could be completely wrong, but I think it's harder to be an OC because you are limited in what you can do, you can't move the TE, you can't specify what receiver to throw to on any given play, there is a ton you just can't do. While on the other side of the ball, you can sub players in for different situations, move them around, give them specific responsibilities etc.


Both are not easy if you want to be good at it. But it's harder to be a good DC than a good OC, imo.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Originally posted by datongw


Well, that's like saying if I build a super fast receiver with no other skills he should be able to play and dominate? The fact is the primary job for the QB is to pass the ball, not to run the ball, even great runners like Vince Young doesn't run that much once he gets to the Pros. Putting a runner that can't throw to play QB and he doesn't have to throw would be an exploit, wouldn't it? If defense can't adjust to that, at least make the defense react faster when he runs. Right now unless the defender is set to blitz, he basically watches until the QB crosses the LOS, that's a bit ridiculous, is it not? I know he's going to run but I can't react to it until he crosses the LOS?

I don't think it will force the player into retirement, even if it does, it's really not a big deal, tons of players gets forced into retirement every season.


The only part I don't agree with is what happens to QB1 at the TE spot. If I was a LB, and you put Dan Marino out to block me, he is going to get killed. I'm not suggesting injuries, but I think there should be a severe energy drain on QB1. He is in every play, and 5-10 times a game trying to block DE's and LB's. He shouldn't be able to just pop up, and be able to throw a 60 yard TD pass.


LOL I agree on that one, I actually had my rushing QB throw a pass to the starting QB, that was amusing.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.