User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > World League? Poll the Audience.
Page:
 
jxgator33
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JayHoov73
I love the idea of a World League.


 
blln4lyf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Outlawz
I personally LOVE the idea of it & I think it is much needed in GLB right now.

I've also heard some concerns about how promotion/relegation would be handled. After giving it a little thought, I think promotion/relegation could be very simple.
Here is what I’m thinking …

We start the World League with the top 4 teams from each Pro League (the most fair way to start it), then as it plays out you take the 8 teams from each Conference that don’t make the playoffs & they get relegated back to the Pro League they originally came from. So now you have 16 spots open in the World League … just take the 2 teams that make the Championship Game in each Pro League & promote them to the World League.

That make the World League a “make the playoffs or get out” type of thing & for promotion, you wouldn’t have to worry about what Leagues had teams demoted & trying to replace them with other teams from that League, instead you just take the 2 teams in each Pro Championship Game & move them up.

Just my 2 cents, but I think this could work pretty well in the long run.

o_O The bottom 8 teams are surely not going to 1 from each league.
Edited by blln4lyf on Jul 8, 2009 17:09:59
Edited by blln4lyf on Jul 8, 2009 17:09:47
 
Outlawz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blln4lyf
Originally posted by Outlawz

I personally LOVE the idea of it & I think it is much needed in GLB right now.

I've also heard some concerns about how promotion/relegation would be handled. After giving it a little thought, I think promotion/relegation could be very simple.
Here is what I’m thinking …

We start the World League with the top 4 teams from each Pro League (the most fair way to start it), then as it plays out you take the 8 teams from each Conference that don’t make the playoffs & they get relegated back to the Pro League they originally came from. So now you have 16 spots open in the World League … just take the 2 teams that make the Championship Game in each Pro League & promote them to the World League.

That make the World League a “make the playoffs or get out” type of thing & for promotion, you wouldn’t have to worry about what Leagues had teams demoted & trying to replace them with other teams from that League, instead you just take the 2 teams in each Pro Championship Game & move them up.

Just my 2 cents, but I think this could work pretty well in the long run.

o_O The bottom 8 teams are surely not going to 1 from each league.


No, of course they won't, but that's my point ... don't worry about where the relagated teams came from, just promote the 2 teams from each Pro League title game into the World League.
That way, after a couple of seasons, you truly have the best of the best in GLB fighting it out in the World League.
 
blln4lyf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Outlawz
Originally posted by blln4lyf

Originally posted by Outlawz


I personally LOVE the idea of it & I think it is much needed in GLB right now.

I've also heard some concerns about how promotion/relegation would be handled. After giving it a little thought, I think promotion/relegation could be very simple.
Here is what I’m thinking …

We start the World League with the top 4 teams from each Pro League (the most fair way to start it), then as it plays out you take the 8 teams from each Conference that don’t make the playoffs & they get relegated back to the Pro League they originally came from. So now you have 16 spots open in the World League … just take the 2 teams that make the Championship Game in each Pro League & promote them to the World League.

That make the World League a “make the playoffs or get out” type of thing & for promotion, you wouldn’t have to worry about what Leagues had teams demoted & trying to replace them with other teams from that League, instead you just take the 2 teams in each Pro Championship Game & move them up.

Just my 2 cents, but I think this could work pretty well in the long run.

o_O The bottom 8 teams are surely not going to 1 from each league.


No, of course they won't, but that's my point ... don't worry about where the relagated teams came from, just promote the 2 teams from each Pro League title game into the World League.
That way, after a couple of seasons, you truly have the best of the best in GLB fighting it out in the World League.


I get that, I just don't like the idea of teams being demoted to diff. Pro Leagues...shouldn't happen imo.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blln4lyf
Originally posted by Outlawz
Originally posted by blln4lyf
Originally posted by Outlawz


I personally LOVE the idea of it & I think it is much needed in GLB right now.

I've also heard some concerns about how promotion/relegation would be handled. After giving it a little thought, I think promotion/relegation could be very simple.
Here is what I’m thinking …

We start the World League with the top 4 teams from each Pro League (the most fair way to start it), then as it plays out you take the 8 teams from each Conference that don’t make the playoffs & they get relegated back to the Pro League they originally came from. So now you have 16 spots open in the World League … just take the 2 teams that make the Championship Game in each Pro League & promote them to the World League.

That make the World League a “make the playoffs or get out” type of thing & for promotion, you wouldn’t have to worry about what Leagues had teams demoted & trying to replace them with other teams from that League, instead you just take the 2 teams in each Pro Championship Game & move them up.

Just my 2 cents, but I think this could work pretty well in the long run.

o_O The bottom 8 teams are surely not going to 1 from each league.


No, of course they won't, but that's my point ... don't worry about where the relagated teams came from, just promote the 2 teams from each Pro League title game into the World League.
That way, after a couple of seasons, you truly have the best of the best in GLB fighting it out in the World League.


I get that, I just don't like the idea of teams being demoted to diff. Pro Leagues...shouldn't happen imo.


Wouldn't have to demote to different leagues. Go back to original league and demote another team from the bottom there to make room. The 2-14 team that thought they were going to escape relegation because of the two crappier teams behind them (but actually got squeezed out by a returning WL team) wouldn't have much of an argument for staying in their Pro league.
 
yoshi_yoshi
offline
Link
 
Teams that promote to World Pro from XPL MUST go back to XPL once they are relegated.

That restriction will require some thinking from Bort as to how promotion will work.
 
blln4lyf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by blln4lyf

Originally posted by Outlawz

Originally posted by blln4lyf

Originally posted by Outlawz



I personally LOVE the idea of it & I think it is much needed in GLB right now.

I've also heard some concerns about how promotion/relegation would be handled. After giving it a little thought, I think promotion/relegation could be very simple.
Here is what I’m thinking …

We start the World League with the top 4 teams from each Pro League (the most fair way to start it), then as it plays out you take the 8 teams from each Conference that don’t make the playoffs & they get relegated back to the Pro League they originally came from. So now you have 16 spots open in the World League … just take the 2 teams that make the Championship Game in each Pro League & promote them to the World League.

That make the World League a “make the playoffs or get out” type of thing & for promotion, you wouldn’t have to worry about what Leagues had teams demoted & trying to replace them with other teams from that League, instead you just take the 2 teams in each Pro Championship Game & move them up.

Just my 2 cents, but I think this could work pretty well in the long run.

o_O The bottom 8 teams are surely not going to 1 from each league.


No, of course they won't, but that's my point ... don't worry about where the relagated teams came from, just promote the 2 teams from each Pro League title game into the World League.
That way, after a couple of seasons, you truly have the best of the best in GLB fighting it out in the World League.


I get that, I just don't like the idea of teams being demoted to diff. Pro Leagues...shouldn't happen imo.


Wouldn't have to demote to different leagues. Go back to original league and demote another team from the bottom there to make room. The 2-14 team that thought they were going to escape relegation because of the two crappier teams behind them (but actually got squeezed out by a returning WL team) wouldn't have much of an argument for staying in their Pro league.


Asked in another thread, you answer here

I do like this idea better than any other I have read..
 
Outlawz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by blln4lyf

Originally posted by Outlawz

Originally posted by blln4lyf

Originally posted by Outlawz



I personally LOVE the idea of it & I think it is much needed in GLB right now.

I've also heard some concerns about how promotion/relegation would be handled. After giving it a little thought, I think promotion/relegation could be very simple.
Here is what I’m thinking …

We start the World League with the top 4 teams from each Pro League (the most fair way to start it), then as it plays out you take the 8 teams from each Conference that don’t make the playoffs & they get relegated back to the Pro League they originally came from. So now you have 16 spots open in the World League … just take the 2 teams that make the Championship Game in each Pro League & promote them to the World League.

That make the World League a “make the playoffs or get out” type of thing & for promotion, you wouldn’t have to worry about what Leagues had teams demoted & trying to replace them with other teams from that League, instead you just take the 2 teams in each Pro Championship Game & move them up.

Just my 2 cents, but I think this could work pretty well in the long run.

o_O The bottom 8 teams are surely not going to 1 from each league.


No, of course they won't, but that's my point ... don't worry about where the relagated teams came from, just promote the 2 teams from each Pro League title game into the World League.
That way, after a couple of seasons, you truly have the best of the best in GLB fighting it out in the World League.


I get that, I just don't like the idea of teams being demoted to diff. Pro Leagues...shouldn't happen imo.


Wouldn't have to demote to different leagues. Go back to original league and demote another team from the bottom there to make room. The 2-14 team that thought they were going to escape relegation because of the two crappier teams behind them (but actually got squeezed out by a returning WL team) wouldn't have much of an argument for staying in their Pro league.


This.
 
yoshi_yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Outlawz
Originally posted by turnit643

Wouldn't have to demote to different leagues. Go back to original league and demote another team from the bottom there to make room. The 2-14 team that thought they were going to escape relegation because of the two crappier teams behind them (but actually got squeezed out by a returning WL team) wouldn't have much of an argument for staying in their Pro league.

This.


This has ripple effects all the way down. AAA needs to demote an extra team, as will AA.
 
blln4lyf
offline
Link
 
Too many of these threads to bounce around imo.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yoshi_yoshi
Originally posted by Outlawz

Originally posted by turnit643


Wouldn't have to demote to different leagues. Go back to original league and demote another team from the bottom there to make room. The 2-14 team that thought they were going to escape relegation because of the two crappier teams behind them (but actually got squeezed out by a returning WL team) wouldn't have much of an argument for staying in their Pro league.

This.


This has ripple effects all the way down. AAA needs to demote an extra team, as will AA.


Yes, and much of that gets smoothed easily with guts each season. Going down the ladder there are more and more holes to fill (places for the bumped teams to land.) If we had a season with absolutely no guts (or very few) where a logjam was created, the bottom-feeder teams that got bounced somewhere down the ladder would just have to understand that their 2-win season wasn't enough to keep them in their league as they thought it might. Tough, but it's a competitive environment, it's not the casual leagues.
 
F8n4tune
offline
Link
 
People tend to forget how those teams got to the Pros(NOT all but most) , and it was by a lot of exploits in the game that are no longer in use. People who have been around know what i'm talking about and then there are those that know that will say "Like what?"

Day trading , gutting , collusion , cutting players before the playoffs so they could all sign to another going to the playoffs.

The game has been changed so many times as far as promotion that this IN MY MIND this is the nail. It just shows that the game is a waste of time if you are not already there , the relagation/promotion , then the cloud league set up was just the tip of this as we can all see now. NO I don't own a team and yes I have played for teams that were together for 5-6 seasons ALL the same players but because of all the changes they eventually broke up because the owners just didn't want to bring in ringers basically.

This game is rigged..................lol

TBF it;s waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay too late for this now , unless you start over and do it right from jump.
 
Bill Jack
offline
Link
 
I'd vote for it.
 
Ravenwood
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by F8n4tune
The game has been changed so many times as far as promotion that this IN MY MIND this is the nail. It just shows that the game is a waste of time if you are not already there , the relagation/promotion , then the cloud league set up was just the tip of this as we can all see now.


So here's a 4th argument against the notion of a World League - it's throwing yet another road block in the paths of teams who are trying to eventually work their way up to the top. Essentially, we'd be moving the goal posts.

Recap of the arguments against:

1. A world league erodes the identities and communities of the regions
2. A world league belittles the current pro leagues, which will basically become the equivalent of AAAs
3. A world league takes away the need for a tournament of champions - a tournament which adds a ton of flavour and an element of variety to the game
4. A world league, added at this point, after 10 seasons, gives the impression that GLB is all about keeping a certain few teams, players and agents at the very top of the pyramid, and be damned to everyone else.

Again, I understand the draw of having the best playing the best, but surely there's a way of doing it without all the negative baggage outlined above.

 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ravenwood
Since it is a rather fundamental shift in the game experience, why not have a poll to see what GLB agents think?


NO! These polls never go well. You have a bunch of GLBers who have no idea about the positives and negatives thinking hey, World Pro League...that'd be like the NFL! I WANT IT!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.