User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
mtbowers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rennis
Originally posted by matta

Originally posted by


When did finding one good player who happened to be a kicker (lots of them out there) for your team mean that you would be able to recruit all boosting/CE/slow build players for your other positions?


The argument is the opposite. Since there are so many good kickers, recruiting a bad player means that you're either bad at recruiting or can't identify good builds. Either way, that's a signal that the rest of your players are equally bad.

And in the case of Lima, who had many builds open in the preseason, that assessment is true.


Jesus can we lock this thread ??!!! Hello, is there a moderator in the house? This is the most asinine thread I have ever had the displeasure of reading. And yes I have read this thread http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2844543&page=1 if that helps you put this in a little perspective.

To be totally honest imo who cares how Matta evaluates teams until he/she wins multiple championships and dominates a few leagues. Until then Matta's methods don't carry any weight in my book. As I am sure my methods should not carry any weight in yours.

Final thing for the love of (insert whatever you love here) please forget this retarded thread and let's move on. Active threads are one thing but dumb ones are just....dumb.




haha btw that thread you posted about the cheerleading was hilarious omg lol
 
CTX
offline
Link
 
Matta, its not a matter of understanding its a matter of I think your theory is retarded. I understand it just fine. You say a ridiculous theory, I counter it with a ridiculous statement. Step your game up and then I will respond with a serious post

BTW, I am taking the liberty of posting your "theory" on the main forums. See if anybody else will "understand" it.

I mean, you must think you are correct so anybody who is anybody will agree with you. AND, maybe you will be heralded as a GLB-ground breaker and your name will be remembered for all-time. When we all grow up, we shall tell our grandchildren about the days of matta.
Edited by CTX on Jun 25, 2009 14:45:31
 
matta
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
Matta, its not a matter of understanding its a matter of I think your theory is retarded. I understand it just fine. You say a ridiculous theory, I counter it with a ridiculous statement. Step your game up and then I will respond with a serious post


So which part do you not agree with?
1. Bad builds are not something you want to recruit
2. Someone who recruits bad builds is either ignorant or bad at their job
3. If someone is bad at recruiting for one position, he's probably bad at recruiting for all positions.
4. A team that's poorly recruited and full of bad builds will suck

So, where's the logic flaw?
 
Av3NGeR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by matta
Originally posted by

Matta, its not a matter of understanding its a matter of I think your theory is retarded. I understand it just fine. You say a ridiculous theory, I counter it with a ridiculous statement. Step your game up and then I will respond with a serious post


So which part do you not agree with?
1. Bad builds are not something you want to recruit
2. Someone who recruits bad builds is either ignorant or bad at their job
3. If someone is bad at recruiting for one position, he's probably bad at recruiting for all positions.
4. A team that's poorly recruited and full of bad builds will suck

So, where's the logic flaw?


shudup fool
 
jonw9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Av3NGeR
Originally posted by matta

Originally posted by


Matta, its not a matter of understanding its a matter of I think your theory is retarded. I understand it just fine. You say a ridiculous theory, I counter it with a ridiculous statement. Step your game up and then I will respond with a serious post


So which part do you not agree with?
1. Bad builds are not something you want to recruit
2. Someone who recruits bad builds is either ignorant or bad at their job
3. If someone is bad at recruiting for one position, he's probably bad at recruiting for all positions.
4. A team that's poorly recruited and full of bad builds will suck

So, where's the logic flaw?


shudup fool


I don't think he understood you matta.

Perhaps your words need more numbers in them!
 
CTX
offline
Link
 
Matta, 1, 2, and 4 are all correct

However, you act like that there are no middle ground teams. You act like there are two types of teams; 1) A team with all good builds 2) A team with all bad builds)

That is the crux of your argument. Your argument is founded on the belief that one good build means that everybody on that team has a good build, and the same applying for bad builds. That is why people think your argument is ridiculous. You argument makes it sound like there are no teams out there with a combination of good and bad builds. That is why I think your argument is stupid.

If you don't see that flaw in your reasoning, then you are too high on your pride.
 
matta
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CTX
Matta, 1, 2, and 4 are all correct

However, you act like that there are no middle ground teams. You act like there are two types of teams; 1) A team with all good builds 2) A team with all bad builds)

That is the crux of your argument. Your argument is founded on the belief that one good build means that everybody on that team has a good build, and the same applying for bad builds. That is why people think your argument is ridiculous. You argument makes it sound like there are no teams out there with a combination of good and bad builds. That is why I think your argument is stupid.

If you don't see that flaw in your reasoning, then you are too high on your pride.


Ah, the argument is that you don't understand Bayesian Statistics or the basic argument associated with it. See, in Bayesian Statistics, there's no defined answer, but rather a distribution that surrounds that value. So my opinion of the quality of your team is defined by the distribution of your performance. When I receive an updated signal from your team, say that your kicker is a bad build, I update the distribution of your performance based on the quality of that signal, which is pretty good in this case, and therefore reduce the expectation of the performance of your team.

Therefore, the wording of my statement is correct. The issue was that you were only viewing the problem through inferential statistics in which you have private information of the outcome. However, that's not clearly not the case.

So, as you can see, you actually didn't understand the argument, and I venture that your remedial high school education means that you probably still don't.

 
CTX
offline
Link
 
Ok, well since you are this master in bayesian statistics...in this circumstance, name all the variables associated with it?

Your explanation of Bayesian statistics, and inferences of the scientific method associated with it is extremely crude. You fail to mention the null hypothesis or any of the four probabilities in the theory. And mind you it is only a theory not a law.

So basically what I am asking is, if you are going to just throw out this terminology (which by the way you used I can tell you don't know what it is, you just used some terminology in an attempt to make yourself sound intelligent without actually understanding the concept) name everything associated with it and explain why you are placing each "statistic" or category with that probability.

EDIT: Also, when you say you are updating signal, in this case our kicker, I must say you really are fascinated with our team if you are going to such great lengths

EDIT 2: Also, you have already stated that this "argument" could not be applied to other positions, however if we assume your shoddy explanation of Bayesian Statistics is correct, you could apply it to other positions. So you don't even understand your own argument

EDIT 3: Sorry for all the edits, I just kept on realizing just how stupid your post was.
Edited by CTX on Jun 26, 2009 15:16:36
Edited by CTX on Jun 26, 2009 15:06:43
Edited by CTX on Jun 26, 2009 15:05:52
 
jonw9
offline
Link
 
I am using the Copenhagen intrepretation Schrödinger's theory on kicker builds.

If I don't look at the build, it may or may not be good. It will remain as both simultaneously.

Looking at the build would interfere, making it either good or bad.

So, I will just assume it is bad!
 
maristfan
offline
Link
 
I like to kick the fooosball. Other guys like to throw and catch the foosball and run weely fast. A couple of other guys like to hit people hard and make the fooosball pop out, so they can take it from you. I like fooosball.
 
matta
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by

Your explanation of Bayesian statistics, and inferences of the scientific method associated with it is extremely crude. You fail to mention the null hypothesis or any of the four probabilities in the theory. And mind you it is only a theory not a law.


You looked it up, on Wikipedia, I assume? Really, stop trying because you're really out of your league. Your statements make no sense.

Originally posted by
Also, when you say you are updating signal, in this case our kicker, I must say you really are fascinated with our team if you are going to such great lengths


Obviously, you don't understand the concept of signalling. When you go to a restaurant, and the counter is dirty, that's a signal. It takes no time to update your posterior belief about the cleanliness of the back of the restaurant. This makes no sense.

Originally posted by
You fail to mention the null hypothesis or any of the four probabilities in the theory.


If I was creating an explicit form I would have to state hypotheses, but since this is not freshman probability class, the implicit observation associated with the principals of the theory are all that's necessary.

Originally posted by
Also, you have already stated that this "argument" could not be applied to other positions, however if we assume your shoddy explanation of Bayesian Statistics is correct, you could apply it to other positions. So you don't even understand your own argument


No, you don't understand the argument. The quality of the assessment of build strength is predicated on the correlation between build quality and bar length (something you obviously lack). Thus, poor correlation in other areas lends itself to weaker signalling.

... honestly, if you want to argue probability based on a rudimentary review of Wikipedia, you should avoid doing it with people who have their PhD in probabilistic theory. You wouldn't step into the ring with Wladimir Klitschko, would you?











 
jonw9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by matta
You wouldn't step into the ring with Wladimir Klitschko, would you?


I know i wouldn't, but I am not a huge fan of Ultimate Fighting!
 
maristfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by matta


... honestly, if you want to argue probability based on a rudimentary review of Wikipedia, you should avoid doing it with people who have their PhD in probabilistic theory. You wouldn't step into the ring with Wladimir Klitschko, would you?



I like the gusto and originality... although it sounds a bit like B.S. Either you work for the gaming industry, or have a miserable, low-paying job in research/mathematics with that degree. Why in the world would anyone waste money pigeonholing yourself with a doctorate that is worthless in 99% of organizations worldwide, especially in a bad economy!? That's ok though, there is someone out there for everything I guess.

Let's settle it on the virtual MMORPG field, the team that wins the league proves the argument. If that team has a kicker with a gold bar we know that matta's logic is correct. If they don't have a gold bar then the kicker's scouting bars have no bearing on inferring a team's success and the owner's ability to choose "quality builds". After a quick glance there is only one kicker in the league with a gold bar, matta has it... So this should mean that lunchbox is a superior owner in terms of recruitment of good builds than everyone else in the league and they are odds on favorites to win it all. No pressure Sweden!
 
Link
 
Originally posted by maristfan
Let's settle it on the virtual MMORPG field, the team that wins the league proves the argument. If that team has a kicker with a gold bar we know that matta's logic is correct. If they don't have a gold bar then the kicker's scouting bars have no bearing on inferring a team's success and the owner's ability to choose "quality builds". After a quick glance there is only one kicker in the league with a gold bar, matta has it... So this should mean that lunchbox is a superior owner in terms of recruitment of good builds than everyone else in the league and they are odds on favorites to win it all. No pressure Sweden!


qflunchbox
 
jonw9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by maristfan
Why in the world would anyone waste money pigeonholing yourself with a doctorate that is worthless in 99% of organizations worldwide, especially in a bad economy!? That's ok though, there is someone out there for everything I guess.


I am pretty sure this holds true for any Ph.D. degree!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.