User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AA Leagues > Canada AA #1 > Calling out the Toronto Towers
Page:
 
Cybershot
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by anfiach
I dunno seems something is wrong with the Sim when the best teams suddenly play like ass in the playoffs vs teams that are not really comparable. Too early to say though but that is 2 seasons back to back for the east, let's see how the west does.


that's a cop out

I want to agree with every fiber of my being, but it's just simply a cop out.
We both took our #1 playoff games too lightheartedly, and it cost us.

We'll have to beat up on each other again next year! ugh
 
Lappdancer
offline
Link
 
I agree...Its not like you are playing level 10 players and losing. All the teams in the playoffs are "Generally" the same level. There is more to this game than saying I have Level 18s, they have level 17s. I should win hands down.

Maybe they have crappy tactics set in the first meeting. Maybe they adjusted better then you. MAYBE!! they got lucky...it happens in the NFL it happens here too. Get over it.

Oh, and the teams ARE comprable. Can you really look at any other than the regular season stats and say that your teams is far and away better than the other team?
Last edited May 29, 2008 07:03:46
 
anfiach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cybershot
Originally posted by anfiach

I dunno seems something is wrong with the Sim when the best teams suddenly play like ass in the playoffs vs teams that are not really comparable. Too early to say though but that is 2 seasons back to back for the east, let's see how the west does.


that's a cop out

I want to agree with every fiber of my being, but it's just simply a cop out.
We both took our #1 playoff games too lightheartedly, and it cost us.

We'll have to beat up on each other again next year! ugh


I'm not just looking at our league, I think there is something seriously flawed with the sim. But I don't disagree that we didn't take our opponents seriously and they played really solid football.

It isn't losing to a lower ranked team that bothers me, I just see things happen that shouldn't unless the game is programmed to randomly apply modifiers to teams. It is less obvious in our league because the teams are all so closely matched. It is more noticable in leagues where teams are mismatched a great deal. You'll see instances that really stand out like Joe Montana steps onto the field and suddenly throws like a preschooler for an entire game. It just doesn't make sense. In a Bedford vs Toronto matchup you would say it's the other team's defense that made it happen but in a Bedford vs Kokanee matchup you would say WTF was that. I've seen it in regular season games too just not enough yet to verify it as a bug/feature.


It makes me sound like a prick but if it's true this could have serious implications. I mean could it be a feature that randomly gives a boost to weaker teams/penalty to stronger teams in order to keep losing teams interested in the game and paying money? Is it a feature that is intended to simulate a player having a really bad day? Or am I just completely paranoid and need to take medication? It will take some time and careful observation before I am convinced either way but we need to put aside competitiveness and remember that this game is still in Beta and might have a few bugs that haven't been weeded out.
 
anfiach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lappdancer
Oh, and the teams ARE comprable. Can you really look at any other than the regular season stats and say that your teams is far and away better than the other team?

Yes I can but that is beside the point.
 
Rawk02
offline
Link
 
or could it be that on a random day a player or team just play like crap and loose to a team they shouldn't you know like what happens in real life? (see: Michigan vs App State)
 
dlwktb
offline
Link
 
The Actuarials beating the Toronto Towers was not that great of an upset. The Actuarials lost a lot of close games throughout the season to evenly matched teams. Then a lot of our players boosted right before the playoffs. If you compare the levels of the starters you'll see that we were on even footing in almost every category with the Towers. Say what you want but this is just a really good 10-6 team.
 
Kenshiro
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dlwktb
The Actuarials beating the Toronto Towers was not that great of an upset. The Actuarials lost a lot of close games throughout the season to evenly matched teams. Then a lot of our players boosted right before the playoffs. If you compare the levels of the starters you'll see that we were on even footing in almost every category with the Towers. Say what you want but this is just a really good 10-6 team.


Boosting at the end of the year gives an advantage over boosting at the beginning of the year. Of course, you give up 3 levels to your competitors during the season, so of course you'll lose some games.
 
Cybershot
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dlwktb
The Actuarials beating the Toronto Towers was not that great of an upset. The Actuarials lost a lot of close games throughout the season to evenly matched teams. Then a lot of our players boosted right before the playoffs. If you compare the levels of the starters you'll see that we were on even footing in almost every category with the Towers. Say what you want but this is just a really good 10-6 team.


True enough.


 
anfiach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rawk02
or could it be that on a random day a player or team just play like crap and loose to a team they shouldn't you know like what happens in real life? (see: Michigan vs App State)


That could very well be, but it isn't exactly a feature we were told about. I don't have an issue with it if I know to expect the possibility but we are led to believe that games are decided solely on player builds and tactics.
 
Cybershot
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rawk02
or could it be that on a random day a player or team just play like crap and loose to a team they shouldn't you know like what happens in real life? (see: Michigan vs App State)


Yea but Bedford really did completely outmatch their rival. That on I just don't get.

2 teams, 30-2 in the reg season, both lose on the same day, which just happens to be the first game of thhe playoffs?

meh

numbers don't lie imo.

If it happens again then i'll bring it up with bort. For now I'm happy saying that the acturials played a good game, and the whoever beat bedford got lucky (sorry ).
Last edited May 29, 2008 08:59:22
 
Avondell
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cybershot
Originally posted by Rawk02

or could it be that on a random day a player or team just play like crap and loose to a team they shouldn't you know like what happens in real life? (see: Michigan vs App State)


Yea but Bedford really did completely outmatch teir rival. That on I just don't get.

2 teams, 30-2 in the reg season, both lose on the same day, which just happens to be the first game of thhe playoffs?

meh

numbers don't lie imo.



I agree with you. While I think its a cop out...and a little paranoid...to say we lost because of some hidden game mechanics, this happens so much that you have to wonder. In WE-AA3, all but a couple of the top seeded teams lost to the lower seeds. There was a couple of really shocking upsets. I have players on the unbeaten Manchester Mustangs and we were able to weather the first round, but everyone we were looking forward to playing got beat.

Its just a little weird. I'm not going to use that as an excuse for why we lost, but yesterday certainly saw more than a few upsets and its got to make you wonder.
 
Cybershot
offline
Link
 
what mystifies me is the glaring difference in the likelihood of an upset during the reg season vs the playoffs.
 
anfiach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kenshiro
Originally posted by dlwktb

The Actuarials beating the Toronto Towers was not that great of an upset. The Actuarials lost a lot of close games throughout the season to evenly matched teams. Then a lot of our players boosted right before the playoffs. If you compare the levels of the starters you'll see that we were on even footing in almost every category with the Towers. Say what you want but this is just a really good 10-6 team.


Boosting at the end of the year gives an advantage over boosting at the beginning of the year. Of course, you give up 3 levels to your competitors during the season, so of course you'll lose some games.

I disagree, it just makes your decisions on point distribution more unpredictable in their affect on your game. Say everyone boosts at the end of the season, there's no advantage at all for anyone. Unless it widens the lvl gap between you and your opponent it still relies on your build to win games and teams that already know how their players will perform and can take advantage of that. Players boosting at the end of the season don't have that luxury. Yea you might run faster but maybe you needed more agility to be effective or maybe more strength. Boost at the beginning and you can use the points from levels you gain to correct performance issues. You could try to do that with your boost points at the end of the season but you have no way of knowing if you chose the right attributes to get the affect you wanted so it is more like gambling.
 
anfiach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cybershot
what mystifies me is the glaring difference in the likelihood of an upset during the reg season vs the playoffs.


I agree it is puzzling but without more data we can only guess. I'm just not afraid to pose the question because I could care less if people want to believe I'm just a poor sport.
 
Cybershot
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by anfiach
Originally posted by Cybershot

what mystifies me is the glaring difference in the likelihood of an upset during the reg season vs the playoffs.


I agree it is puzzling but without more data we can only guess. I'm just not afraid to pose the question because I could care less if people want to believe I'm just a poor sport.


Same.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.