Originally posted by shutd0wn
Originally posted by shaffe
So the current Oceana A, an extremely competitive league with a whole host of pretty good teams, will become AA#1 next year?
Meanwhile the other three AA leagues will have new teams who, honestly, will kind of suck. Shouldn't the current teams in Oceana A get dispersed throughout the AA levels intead of keeping them all in one league to beat up on each other? My team (Tasmania Devils) is pretty good and still improving, but we don't really stack up with the top teams in our league as our domination by Samoa in the playoffs shows. I'd hate to waste a few seasons for things to shake out while las vegas, grinnel, samoa, and the other top flight teams get shifted up when I could be in another AA league where we could potentially have more success.
Am I making sense?
This may sound like a total jackass, but I'm just being honest of what I think to add to this discussion.
The only real reason any team would want to "disperse" to another AA is for selfish reasons. Instead of having your team towards the bottom half of the division you want your team to be on the upper half.
And while I agree, losing sucks; so does bothering the administration staff for your selfish motives.
They are getting bombarded with teams wanting to move to new leagues or lower leagues just so they can compete for a title. I agree in some rare cases it’s acceptable, I am pretty sure the majority are people who just want an easy street.
Although I dont know the history of your team, and its current situation. The fact still remains EVERY team has a head start over any new team added to the Oceania. It would be unfair to them to have an established team thrown into the mix.
Breaking up the A division is a HORRIBLE idea. Maybe if there was a specific situation for a specific team, I would be willing to agree. But until then, Thorn is right when he states, eventually the talent will even itself out.
They didn't seem to mind throwing second season teams into the Pro's at the beginning of this year.
My thing with this is, if you divided up the new AA, there would be 8 teams in each league, 4 in each conference. These are the teams most likely to win and move up to AAA. There would still be competition at the top, and 12 new teams in each conference, so it's not like you were 1 of 2 or 3 teams in a conference with 13 or 14 who had a whole season head start on you.
By creating 3 AA leagues made up of entirely season 3 teams, you insure that 6 season 3 teams move up to AAA in season 4.
My team isn't effected by this, so I'm not arguing for personal reasons. In fact, I stand to gain more by having season 3 teams move into AAA next year. What I want is the fastest way to balance the leagues out so everything is more competitive from top to bottom.