yep, I mean I have no problem when the HB's pull out these jukes when the defenders are ahead of them/in front/looking at each other face to face/the HB running towards them, but it annoys me the most when the defenders are coming at them from the side or from an angle/diagonally and they are still juked out. Realistically, a defender will never get juked out when the HB is running near the sidelines and the tackler is coming at him from the sides/angle. Only juke i've seen work at times like this is when the ball carrier performs a dead stop and then quickly changes direction, leaving the defender to grab air/lose his balance a bit, but of course, it should also slow down the ballcarrier.
Forum > Suggestions > Fix the pathetic "jukes/headfakes" already, pretty please?
butler312
offline
offline
Originally posted by fishdan
Jukes seem to happen when the HB actually has no place to go. Make it realistic -- calculate a move the back could ACTUALLY have made, and make the defender react to that move in a realistic fashion. If the juke makes him think the RB has stopped -- he would still move towards the spot the RB was at at that moment. These incredibly talented defenders suddenly imploding is crazy.
Case in point -- on this play I specifically set the LDE into zone and brought the SS around there to stop this run.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=566676&pbp_id=10581074
This play I really don't have a problem with, as the defenders were in front of him and he had other options. I think it is very plausible that he could have faked a cut back inside and gotten the defenders to bit on it. It kind of reminds me of Adrian Peterson against the Bears. It shouldn't be something that is very common though, as it is an exceptional play.
Originally posted by Angelo Bruno
Any way to stop these?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=481488&pbp_id=10393091
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=481488&pbp_id=10386339
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=481488&pbp_id=10384150
These I do have a problem with. Defenders are being faked out from angels that are just stupid.
Jukes seem to happen when the HB actually has no place to go. Make it realistic -- calculate a move the back could ACTUALLY have made, and make the defender react to that move in a realistic fashion. If the juke makes him think the RB has stopped -- he would still move towards the spot the RB was at at that moment. These incredibly talented defenders suddenly imploding is crazy.
Case in point -- on this play I specifically set the LDE into zone and brought the SS around there to stop this run.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=566676&pbp_id=10581074
This play I really don't have a problem with, as the defenders were in front of him and he had other options. I think it is very plausible that he could have faked a cut back inside and gotten the defenders to bit on it. It kind of reminds me of Adrian Peterson against the Bears. It shouldn't be something that is very common though, as it is an exceptional play.
Originally posted by Angelo Bruno
Any way to stop these?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=481488&pbp_id=10393091
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=481488&pbp_id=10386339
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=481488&pbp_id=10384150
These I do have a problem with. Defenders are being faked out from angels that are just stupid.
odg62
offline
offline
The main problem is O players dont break stride when faking, no one can fake someone out like that without breaking stride, it dosent happen.
LoS.BeastKnight
offline
offline
Originally posted by Staz
Originally posted by Cmfix64
this works both ways i think... i have also seen plenty of jukes and headfakes that the defender seemingly is unaffected by and loses no speed then proceeds to make the tackle... and i know its a juke/HF because his dot shrank
Exactly, I was going to mention that as well.
1. Ball carriers need to lose speed when making those moves, and actually move in another direction.
2. Defenders need to reflect the move being made. A juke generally leaves a defender off balance, giving the ball carrier more space. Head fakes just cause them to slow up, or be a little indecisive.
3. Attempted jukes/head fakes need to show up, even if they failed.
About number one, speed loss is dependant on agility
Juke= make chance of defender slipping depending on agility juke sa and speed( if your juking at one metre per sec whats the point) versus vision tackling and agi
Originally posted by Cmfix64
this works both ways i think... i have also seen plenty of jukes and headfakes that the defender seemingly is unaffected by and loses no speed then proceeds to make the tackle... and i know its a juke/HF because his dot shrank
Exactly, I was going to mention that as well.
1. Ball carriers need to lose speed when making those moves, and actually move in another direction.
2. Defenders need to reflect the move being made. A juke generally leaves a defender off balance, giving the ball carrier more space. Head fakes just cause them to slow up, or be a little indecisive.
3. Attempted jukes/head fakes need to show up, even if they failed.
About number one, speed loss is dependant on agility
Juke= make chance of defender slipping depending on agility juke sa and speed( if your juking at one metre per sec whats the point) versus vision tackling and agi
Himura
offline
offline
Originally posted by odg62
The main problem is O players dont break stride when faking, no one can fake someone out like that without breaking stride, it dosent happen.
Barry Sanders. =P
Though this is true a stutter step or at least a change of direction would make more sense in this situation. But at the the
same time if i recall correctly ( correct me if im wrong) this is a result based alot upon the head fake SA and a head fake
would be more so just a quick stop or stutter then a full change of direction. so just a 1 second or even a fraction of a second stop that affects a more limited radius based off a vision area equal to the players vision attribute could be good. This way it does not limit the tackling path of the other defenders, who can keep on their way to the runner. This way the HB can still fake out a defender and get out of a tackle, but isn't faking out 4 players at a time outside his "bubble" area. also it does not seem right that a player in pursuit can be affected by this, a player completely behind the HB getting juked out just doesn't happen very often
So limited radius based on vision and if the HB see's the defender enter his "bubble" then only affecting said defender and putting the ability into a more realistic fashion.
The main problem is O players dont break stride when faking, no one can fake someone out like that without breaking stride, it dosent happen.
Barry Sanders. =P
Though this is true a stutter step or at least a change of direction would make more sense in this situation. But at the the
same time if i recall correctly ( correct me if im wrong) this is a result based alot upon the head fake SA and a head fake
would be more so just a quick stop or stutter then a full change of direction. so just a 1 second or even a fraction of a second stop that affects a more limited radius based off a vision area equal to the players vision attribute could be good. This way it does not limit the tackling path of the other defenders, who can keep on their way to the runner. This way the HB can still fake out a defender and get out of a tackle, but isn't faking out 4 players at a time outside his "bubble" area. also it does not seem right that a player in pursuit can be affected by this, a player completely behind the HB getting juked out just doesn't happen very often
So limited radius based on vision and if the HB see's the defender enter his "bubble" then only affecting said defender and putting the ability into a more realistic fashion.
LoS.BeastKnight
offline
offline
Originally posted by Himura
Originally posted by odg62
The main problem is O players dont break stride when faking, no one can fake someone out like that without breaking stride, it dosent happen.
Barry Sanders. =P
Though this is true a stutter step or at least a change of direction would make more sense in this situation. But at the the
same time if i recall correctly ( correct me if im wrong) this is a result based alot upon the head fake SA and a head fake
would be more so just a quick stop or stutter then a full change of direction. so just a 1 second or even a fraction of a second stop that affects a more limited radius based off a vision area equal to the players vision attribute could be good. This way it does not limit the tackling path of the other defenders, who can keep on their way to the runner. This way the HB can still fake out a defender and get out of a tackle, but isn't faking out 4 players at a time outside his "bubble" area. also it does not seem right that a player in pursuit can be affected by this, a player completely behind the HB getting juked out just doesn't happen very often
So limited radius based on vision and if the HB see's the defender enter his "bubble" then only affecting said defender and putting the ability into a more realistic fashion.
The closer you are the more likely you are to get faked out max radius of juke should be 1-2 yds for people running behind u.
1-3 for people infront for you
the further away you are if you are in that radius the less vision you should need to avoid it
Originally posted by odg62
The main problem is O players dont break stride when faking, no one can fake someone out like that without breaking stride, it dosent happen.
Barry Sanders. =P
Though this is true a stutter step or at least a change of direction would make more sense in this situation. But at the the
same time if i recall correctly ( correct me if im wrong) this is a result based alot upon the head fake SA and a head fake
would be more so just a quick stop or stutter then a full change of direction. so just a 1 second or even a fraction of a second stop that affects a more limited radius based off a vision area equal to the players vision attribute could be good. This way it does not limit the tackling path of the other defenders, who can keep on their way to the runner. This way the HB can still fake out a defender and get out of a tackle, but isn't faking out 4 players at a time outside his "bubble" area. also it does not seem right that a player in pursuit can be affected by this, a player completely behind the HB getting juked out just doesn't happen very often
So limited radius based on vision and if the HB see's the defender enter his "bubble" then only affecting said defender and putting the ability into a more realistic fashion.
The closer you are the more likely you are to get faked out max radius of juke should be 1-2 yds for people running behind u.
1-3 for people infront for you
the further away you are if you are in that radius the less vision you should need to avoid it
Kite188
offline
offline
no one should be juked when they are in pursuit from either behind or diagonally from an angle.
again, unless it is a full stop juke and then the runner quickly changes direction, but of course, no slowdown at all is the problem
again, unless it is a full stop juke and then the runner quickly changes direction, but of course, no slowdown at all is the problem
Ubasstards
offline
offline
Originally posted by Kite188
The defenders get juked while coming at the Hb's at an angle, they get juked out while chasing after them, they get juked out while taking a block. please wtf im tired of this shit and bort doesn't seem to have any intentions of fixing this anytime soon
am i wrong?
yes, you are wrong. I like the way it is currently working
The defenders get juked while coming at the Hb's at an angle, they get juked out while chasing after them, they get juked out while taking a block. please wtf im tired of this shit and bort doesn't seem to have any intentions of fixing this anytime soon
am i wrong?
yes, you are wrong. I like the way it is currently working
Firenze
offline
offline
Originally posted by tjsexy82
Yeah, I agree.
Jukes shouldn't trigger unless the player is within the tackling radius.
Yeah, I agree.
Jukes shouldn't trigger unless the player is within the tackling radius.
remus7x
offline
offline
I think the jukes that work on people chasing from behind need to be fixed seeing as how no one in a real football game would ever actually fall for them, but the biggest problem i've seen is the mass jukes.
ex- http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=473748&pbp_id=7744413
if there are 3 defenders going to a corner with a runner, they don't all just run after the guy, they play their gaps and protect different lanes.
ex- http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=473748&pbp_id=7744413
if there are 3 defenders going to a corner with a runner, they don't all just run after the guy, they play their gaps and protect different lanes.
Kryzantine
offline
offline
As someone who runs through crowds of people in Manhattan everyday terrorizing people who are run around, I wholly agree with the OP.
First off, when you make a sudden cut, there is a loss of momentum as your body "realigns", so to speak, where leg power is shifted from one to another. As a loss of momentum, there should be a huge loss of speed. But in the sim, a person who jukes a defender experiences no loss of speed as they simply stroll to the side.
Secondly, a head fake does not knock down a player. Remember Barry Sander's run against the Cowboys, when the Dallas player suddenly got confused and didn't notice Barry was running behind him? That is the absolute worst a head fake can do to you. A head fake should result in a loss of vision, maybe a tiny loss of momentum, but you can't trip and fall from a mental action.
Thirdly, defensive players learn that it is much easier to use their speed than it is for offensive players to use theirs. That's because the QB and RB are fooled as much by defensive setups than the defense is fooled by the offensive setup. There's no incorporation of that into the game.
Basically saying, the properly built agile HB is ridiculously impossible to stop. I'm not saying they should be tackled in the backfield every play or something. I'm saying they should only be allowed to go to the outside and take it to the house when the blocking has been solid by everyone and the HB simply needs to deal with a defensive player or two, like a safety or something. Juking out an entire defense is the most unrealistic and impractical thing a HB can do, but it seems like some backs have it on the back of their hands already.
First off, when you make a sudden cut, there is a loss of momentum as your body "realigns", so to speak, where leg power is shifted from one to another. As a loss of momentum, there should be a huge loss of speed. But in the sim, a person who jukes a defender experiences no loss of speed as they simply stroll to the side.
Secondly, a head fake does not knock down a player. Remember Barry Sander's run against the Cowboys, when the Dallas player suddenly got confused and didn't notice Barry was running behind him? That is the absolute worst a head fake can do to you. A head fake should result in a loss of vision, maybe a tiny loss of momentum, but you can't trip and fall from a mental action.
Thirdly, defensive players learn that it is much easier to use their speed than it is for offensive players to use theirs. That's because the QB and RB are fooled as much by defensive setups than the defense is fooled by the offensive setup. There's no incorporation of that into the game.
Basically saying, the properly built agile HB is ridiculously impossible to stop. I'm not saying they should be tackled in the backfield every play or something. I'm saying they should only be allowed to go to the outside and take it to the house when the blocking has been solid by everyone and the HB simply needs to deal with a defensive player or two, like a safety or something. Juking out an entire defense is the most unrealistic and impractical thing a HB can do, but it seems like some backs have it on the back of their hands already.
Black Peter
offline
offline
Originally posted by Deathblade
+lots
I agree with this...seems a bit out of control.
+lots
I agree with this...seems a bit out of control.
remus7x
offline
offline
Originally posted by Kryzantine
First off, when you make a sudden cut, there is a loss of momentum as your body "realigns", so to speak, where leg power is shifted from one to another. As a loss of momentum, there should be a huge loss of speed. But in the sim, a person who jukes a defender experiences no loss of speed as they simply stroll to the side.
I believe this is a product of the agility coding. There seems to be a point at which the amount of agility you have not only makes up for the sudden stop of doing a juke, but makes it not exist. Running backs with 90+ agility (in some cases lower) have a no stop, no speed loss juke just because the way the game's agi is coded.
First off, when you make a sudden cut, there is a loss of momentum as your body "realigns", so to speak, where leg power is shifted from one to another. As a loss of momentum, there should be a huge loss of speed. But in the sim, a person who jukes a defender experiences no loss of speed as they simply stroll to the side.
I believe this is a product of the agility coding. There seems to be a point at which the amount of agility you have not only makes up for the sudden stop of doing a juke, but makes it not exist. Running backs with 90+ agility (in some cases lower) have a no stop, no speed loss juke just because the way the game's agi is coded.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























