User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > ROLB Drifing Inside On Every Run Play
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
If they run full speed towards their zones, you run into the guys complaining about LB's running away from the ball. They have to make a read first of some sort. Maybe if there was a DPC option of "run full bore" or something, but for basic tactics, they need to play the run first.


Is it possible, to make LB vision reads concurrent with every tick so as to realize the intent of each play the moment it happens but letting the amount of vision they have actually control how fast they can physically react?

If that is possible to do I would think that its the answer to all the problems and it wouldn't matter what their initial responsibility is, moving to a zone, playing coverage, or run responsibilities, so long as their actually 'reading' the play as it goes along until they are 100% sure of what is happening and how to react.

Just having the LB stand still at the start of each play is most important to me and the intentions of this thread.
But since I have your attention Bort, and the segway is there for the taking, I would have to slip in the other LB issues for a possible fix as well.
Last edited May 8, 2009 18:25:55
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Actually, I've been playing a fair amount of zone, and haven't had this issue so much. I've simply adjusted their starting position based on what I think they're going to do in the play - meaning step up, read the play, then finally go cover their zone.

Please do not make them run full tilt towards their zones. If they either stand still or take a forward step first while reading the play, that's fine with me. Busting ass away from the LOS as a default is no good, and I don't want to return to that behavior.


Man's really tricky imo. What the zones really need is a priority tree or something. Somebody's gotta be in at least a pseudo-zone looking for a HB or FB flaring out for a pass. This stuff where the ROLB covers the HB going out into the strong flat is just wierd imo.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Well, I'll play around with making them stop before passing their vision check, and see what happens, and maybe I can post up some test server replays so you can have a looksee & make suggestions. I'll see if I can get to that in the next day or so.

Ideally, I guess you'd want them to figure out which gap to go to and head there if they read run successfully, but that is easier said than done.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
What sort of vision do you believe you are setting up as a requirement to move in one or two clicks?

From observing my RoLB, it is significantly higher than 60...

PinTBC
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Well, I'll play around with making them stop before passing their vision check, and see what happens, and maybe I can post up some test server replays so you can have a looksee & make suggestions. I'll see if I can get to that in the next day or so.

Ideally, I guess you'd want them to figure out which gap to go to and head there if they read run successfully, but that is easier said than done.


Is it possible, to make LB vision reads concurrent with every tick so as to realize the intent of each play the moment it happens but letting the amount of vision they have actually control how fast they can physically react?

was curious to the answer of that one, is it difficult to implement?

If so, then just make them stand-still until they read the play...that would be good enough. But right now im getting killed on runs and pitches out that way cuz the ROLB drifts just far enough for the LG to get em since the C takes the DT on the strong-shifted DLines.
 
harryknutts
offline
Link
 
i would rather have the LBs all stand still. they dont need to be moving
 
Tigerbait0307
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MattMan Firespot
Originally posted by Bort

Well, I'll play around with making them stop before passing their vision check, and see what happens, and maybe I can post up some test server replays so you can have a looksee & make suggestions. I'll see if I can get to that in the next day or so.

Ideally, I guess you'd want them to figure out which gap to go to and head there if they read run successfully, but that is easier said than done.


Is it possible, to make LB vision reads concurrent with every tick so as to realize the intent of each play the moment it happens but letting the amount of vision they have actually control how fast they can physically react?

was curious to the answer of that one, is it difficult to implement?

If so, then just make them stand-still until they read the play...that would be good enough. But right now im getting killed on runs and pitches out that way cuz the ROLB drifts just far enough for the LG to get em since the C takes the DT on the strong-shifted DLines.


My ROLB has 70 vision and he drifts towards the inside. Its killing me also on pitch plays. He drifts inside enough to let the FB block him.

Pitch to the weak side. ROLB walks inside on the snap of the ball.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=476989&pbp_id=9565318

Happens on the Offtackle play also
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=476989&pbp_id=9565479

Again
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=476989&pbp_id=9566256

Remember he has 70 vision so I don't think thats the problem.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Well, I'll play around with making them stop before passing their vision check, and see what happens, and maybe I can post up some test server replays so you can have a looksee & make suggestions. I'll see if I can get to that in the next day or so.

Ideally, I guess you'd want them to figure out which gap to go to and head there if they read run successfully, but that is easier said than done.


I guess I would say with the DPC it's quite possible for defensive coordinators to get their LBs lined up over gaps to start with. What's frustrating is when those LBs wander, especially in that man-shadow mode stuff, and totally bork a gap assignment every time.

So at least stopping until they get the read will leave the LBs where the DC told them to be and is probably the best answer.

Someone will bitch when you change it, though. Someone always does!
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by Bort

Well, I'll play around with making them stop before passing their vision check, and see what happens, and maybe I can post up some test server replays so you can have a looksee & make suggestions. I'll see if I can get to that in the next day or so.

Ideally, I guess you'd want them to figure out which gap to go to and head there if they read run successfully, but that is easier said than done.


I guess I would say with the DPC it's quite possible for defensive coordinators to get their LBs lined up over gaps to start with. What's frustrating is when those LBs wander, especially in that man-shadow mode stuff, and totally bork a gap assignment every time.

So at least stopping until they get the read will leave the LBs where the DC told them to be and is probably the best answer.

Someone will bitch when you change it, though. Someone always does!


It is an issue, particularly with pitch plays.

What we really need is a bias slider:

Outside/contain vs inside/stuff. This would bias the first pre-read motion of the LB. I don't like the sound of an LB just standing there until he makes a read...just looks lousy in the sim if nothing else.

Also...if we are going to change this, make it soon. It will affect every defense I have built. I don't want to have to dick with that after I have everything fine tuned....
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I'm not going to change it unless it's tested enough, that's for sure. Any fix we do for it should make sense and not cause some other issue, etc.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I'm not going to change it unless it's tested enough, that's for sure. Any fix we do for it should make sense and not cause some other issue, etc.


Right now it is a huge problem for defenses, specifically on weakside sweeps, and any plays the linebacker is actually expected to do much.

It ranks right up there with Safeties in zone not keeping deep responsibility, and acting like dogs chasing cars (making them relatively useless).

With the advent of the DPC, I was actually a bit afraid that offenses might have troubles moving the ball, but I neglected to understand exactly how random defenses would be this season, but games that are 50-30 with 400+ yards of offense on both sides seems to be the design intent.

Too bad.

PinTBC
 
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
I don't like the sound of an LB just standing there until he makes a read...just looks lousy in the sim if nothing else


Unfortunately we cant just leave it like it is, and if just standing there isnt appealing to your visual standards then go play WOW. fwiw we DCs just want to see this issue fixed Bort, there is no reason you cant. Just make the LB stand there while he makes his vision read at least he wont be taking himself out of the play should it come towards him.

Honestly Bort this shit has been like this for 4 or 5 seasons man, theres so many issues with the sim that fall upon deaf ears and every season you expand some without going back and fixing stuff....Just fix the issues we have plz, theres enough to keep you busy for a while cuz you never fixed em earlier.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Just make them take a read step (forward into their assigned gap). During that time is where a LB makes his 'vision check'.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Ok, what I've done to test is make the LB's not move if the HB is not moving, and then take his trajectory into account better. Seems to be more like what you'd expect.

Example play:

http://test.goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1098&pbp_id=246771

The LOLB would have drifted inwards before there; now he heads to an x-wise cutoff point only once the HB has started moving in a direction.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, what I've done to test is make the LB's not move if the HB is not moving, and then take his trajectory into account better. Seems to be more like what you'd expect.

Example play:

http://test.goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1098&pbp_id=246771

The LOLB would have drifted inwards before there; now he heads to an x-wise cutoff point only once the HB has started moving in a direction.


On which tick do they pass their vision check?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.