User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Make Carrying Tactics Relevant To Fumble Chance
Page:
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HelfirePenn
The backs on our team are not fumbling, so something is either wrong with your players or game planning. Limit the amount of plays, diversify the play calls and lastly get your carry/strength up.

It has nothing whatsoever to do with that. You have been LUCKY to avoid mass fumble games, just as most people have. The people who have experienced this did so regardless of whether their HBs had great or bad builds, so that is absolutely not the problem. This is a sim issue, specifically how a random turnover leads to a cascade effect with each turnover successively raising the probability of another turnover to the point that no build has any hope of stopping the chain.
 
tonylieu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by MentalMisfit

guess HB can't get away with only 40 carrying anymore. Doesn't need to be changed at all every defense player had to train tackling to 60-70 to attempt to stop power backs now its your turn to spend 2 seasons getting your carry skill up


I don't have a HB with less than 55 carrying, and the OP in the thread I linked to had carrying over 60. Tackling at 60 and carrying at 60 shouldn't yield 5 fumbles a game.


So how many times have your HBs fumbled so far this season? Wait let me answer it for you . None. See the correlation. 55+ carrying. 0 fumbles. So stop the whining, plz.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tonylieu
So how many times have your HBs fumbled so far this season? Wait let me answer it for you . None. See the correlation. 55+ carrying. 0 fumbles. So stop the whining, plz.

Please don't post until you develop a basic level of reading comprehension. He referred to one of many HBs who has 60+ carrying and yet had many fumbles in one game. It is absolutely not a builds issue, so please stop embarrassing yourself by ignorantly spouting something that is not true. This problem is a result of one turnover increasing the chance of subsequent turnovers. If the chance of a turnover was independent of that and solely dependent upon builds, then we wouldn't see these ridiculous results.
Last edited Apr 30, 2009 22:55:44
 
tonylieu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by tonylieu

So how many times have your HBs fumbled so far this season? Wait let me answer it for you . None. See the correlation. 55+ carrying. 0 fumbles. So stop the whining, plz.

Please don't post until you develop a basic level of reading comprehension. He referred to one of many HBs who has 60+ carrying and yet had many fumbles in one game. It is absolutely not a builds issue, so please stop embarrassing yourself by ignorantly spouting something that is not true. This problem is a result of one turnover increasing the chance of subsequent turnovers. If the chance of a turnover was independent of that and solely dependent upon builds, then we wouldn't see these ridiculous results.


Stop whining, PLZ!!!
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Get off your fucking high horse. We get it. Has worked this way for a long time (if you remember Roadgraders huge complaint thread a few seasons back). Other than that, I am sick of hearing about an unfortunate game that happens in a big way from time to time. It works that way for QBs and OTs and DEs and CBs. They just don't make such a big deal about it. You get to touch the ball often and get the stats. Just because it is more noticeable and more impactful in a game with already overpowered offenses doesn't mean we need to hear about it from you in every thread. Just because Bort coddles you offensive guys doesn't mean we need to hear about.

Honestly, there should maybe be an AI option to pull someone if their morale hits X. Multiple fumble games happen in the NFL. Then that back may be pulled. That is the way it works.

Also, I am not opposed to making high confidence either make morale hits less impactful or allow it to bounce back more quickly. Energy does not need to be fixed, imo. Part of the game. Add depth and use it.

Oh, and feel free to tell me I don't have a fucking clue what I am talking about. That would be swell.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Multiple fumble games happen in the NFL.

Rarely. No HB in NFL history has ever fumbled five times in a game, and no HB has ever had more than 15 in a season. A fairly significant percentage of HBs in GLB have already exceeded the first and are on pace to obliterate the second.


This is really an easy fix. If experiencing a turnover has no effect on the likelihood of experiencing another turnover, then you don't get these cascade effects and at that point turnover probability actually would be determined by builds.


Edit:
And fyi, I've been an OC & DC since Season 3, plus I clearly own players on both sides of the ball. I care about offense and defense, which is why I was bitching about powerbacks the previous two seasons, and pointing out that the problem then was absolutely not low tackling for defenders. I've spent a hell of a lot more money on this game than I realized, and I'd like to see that investment rewarded with a sim that operates properly.
Last edited Apr 30, 2009 23:13:54
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by kretchfoop

Multiple fumble games happen in the NFL.

Rarely. No HB in NFL history has ever fumbled five times in a game, and no HB has ever had more than 15 in a season. A fairly significant percentage of HBs in GLB have already exceeded the first and are on pace to obliterate the second.

This is really an easy fix. If experiencing a turnover has no effect on the likelihood of experiencing another turnover, then you don't get these cascade effects and at that point turnover probability actually would be determined by builds.


And how many have had 800+ yard games or 10,000 yard seasons or 12 touchdown games? To compare this to the NFL in this respect and not ask for realism in the other area of a running backs game is ludicrous. It is also ridiculous for morale to have NO EFFECT - why bother with confidence at all? Yeah, yeah, he had 60 confidence. Like I said, turn up the importance of confidence in stopping the cascade, but your suggestion is not something I agree with.
 
PDO
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
The idea makes perfect sense. Backs in real football due have more fumbles when they attempt to break more tackles and gain extra yards, so it's reasonable that they would do so in GLB as well. Plus it's absurd to expect elusive backs to get 70 carrying when they have to spend more in speed & agility than power backs.


... except, they don't spend in "strength"
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
good idea, HOWEVER, you can already kinda achieve this based on how you make builds. carrying-> more coverup. everything else-> break tackles/big play ability
 
Xar
offline
Link
 
Both types of RB should require equivalent amounts of carrying. End of story. If all tacklers require tackling, then all ball carriers require carrying. This makes sense, no?
 
gijosh
offline
Link
 
Seriously...

stop EXPECTING to get hit with a wrap-up tackle at higher levels... once yout hit higher levels, defenders get better, at making tackles which means we can go mroe balanced or power.

As an offensive player, you hsould ASSUME because we were all at wrap up at lower levels thats the way you play when you get up tot he mid-20s and higher. Defenders have adapted our builds to compensate for the power back up the middle and the Elusive back to the flats and outside...

HBs and WRs need to adapt to thata s well and get their str/carrying/and SAs and VAs for the same up more.


Also: stop following the player build guides... theyre outdated... Obviously.

 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PDO
... except, they don't spend in "strength"

Can people like you please read before posting? If you can't, then do not post at all. Just keep your mouth shut if you cannot bother to pay attention before you post, because otherwise you waste everyone's time and interrupt the conversation between people who aren't completely ignorant and oblivious. Look at one of the games being referenced ( http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=477042 ). Both of the HBs had 60+ carrying and strength. A lack of strength is not the issue, a lack of carrying is not the issue, a lack of confidence is not the issue.

I'm getting extremely frustrated because I have explained the reason for this phenomenon and I think I've done so pretty clearly. If you've read it and just can't understand for whatever reason, please say so and point out what you don't get, and I will try to figure out a simpler way of explaining it so that you'll finally understand. If you don't even try to understand and are just trolling, then stop doing that.


Once again, builds only determine the likelihood of the first turnover a player experiences. When you have a turnover, it dramatically increases your chances of having a second, which means that HB1 after one fumble has a much higher chance of having another fumble than HB2 who hasn't yet had a fumble, even if HB1's build is a lot better than HB2's. The same is true for quarterbacks. The chances of QB1 throwing a second interception after experiencing his first is a lot higher than the chance of QB2 throwing a first interception when he hasn't had one in the game yet, even if QB1 has a much better build.

This is what causes these cascade effects resulting in ridiculously high turnovers. IT IS NOT A BUILD ISSUE, otherwise those HBs and QBs would be having high turnovers in most games instead of rarely. This is about how each successive turnover increases the chances of having a subsequent turnover, quickly pushing the probability far beyond anything a build can overcome. It doesn't happen to most people because this is a probability issue and only has like a 5% chance of happening. Therefore 95% of us will be fine in any particular game, but that has absolutely nothing to do with our builds.

Again, if you don't understand what I'm saying then please say so and I will try my best to explain it more clearly./
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by PDO

... except, they don't spend in "strength"

Can people like you please read before posting? If you can't, then do not post at all. Just keep your mouth shut if you cannot bother to pay attention before you post, because otherwise you waste everyone's time and interrupt the conversation between people who aren't completely ignorant and oblivious. Look at one of the games being referenced ( http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=477042 ). Both of the HBs had 60+ carrying and strength. A lack of strength is not the issue, a lack of carrying is not the issue, a lack of confidence is not the issue.

I'm on that team. The one that forced all the fumbles. You wouldn't believe the godly builds that are on that squad. Besides, BLPP has been forcing fumbles like mad for seasons now. It has nothing to do with this sim season. Horrible example IMO.
 
Link
 
Still a build issue. TBH.
 
gijosh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Originally posted by jdbolick

Originally posted by PDO


... except, they don't spend in "strength"

Can people like you please read before posting? If you can't, then do not post at all. Just keep your mouth shut if you cannot bother to pay attention before you post, because otherwise you waste everyone's time and interrupt the conversation between people who aren't completely ignorant and oblivious. Look at one of the games being referenced ( http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=477042 ). Both of the HBs had 60+ carrying and strength. A lack of strength is not the issue, a lack of carrying is not the issue, a lack of confidence is not the issue.

I'm on that team. The one that forced all the fumbles. You wouldn't believe the godly builds that are on that squad. Besides, BLPP has been forcing fumbles like mad for seasons now. It has nothing to do with this sim season. Horrible example IMO.


yeah i looked at those games of the team defending... those guys are all just beasts dude.

Also, I was looking at my own LB... people need to take into accoutn the whole ADV EQ. My LB has 9+ in monster and big hit, both off of ADV bonuses.... and my str is at 80+ plus I tackle on Balanced at least... If youre lower level than me, be sure to bet that Im on Power... also, I use SAs that help both my tackling and +fumbles....
so just because youre build is BADASS dont think the defenders is not as badass or more badasser than yours.

also, elusive backs running through the pile=FAIL imo
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.