User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania A Leagues > Oceania A #2 > Season 9 Good Game Thread
Page:
 
Frausette
offline
Link
 
GG Samoa....

The Lost Fumbles killed us this Game...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=510873
 
mocfam10
offline
Link
 
100% sure we got hit with the random offensive AI bug this game. Our offense was TOTALLY backwards from what the AI dictated. And no one changed it last minute as I am the only one with offensive power. I change d the AI yesterday. Honestly, the confidence...already shaken in GLB, is completely gone now. Good luck to everyone the rest of the season (s).

<---Done
 
sunshineduck
offline
Link
 
GG, Fiji

wait, not really
 
Link
 
Belated GG to OC and GG to Tonga. I was out of town from Friday to Sunday and I was happy with the results of both games. Don't be too upset at your loss Tonga, sometimes you just lay an egg and sometimes your opponent just may have had a better game plan then you did. I'm sure that we may face each other again in the playoffs, and we will have to put together another good gameplan to win.
 
mocfam10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Alex Wondertramp
Belated GG to OC and GG to Tonga. I was out of town from Friday to Sunday and I was happy with the results of both games. Don't be too upset at your loss Tonga, sometimes you just lay an egg and sometimes your opponent just may have had a better game plan then you did. I'm sure that we may face each other again in the playoffs, and we will have to put together another good gameplan to win.


Yeah, your Offensive game plan was great. But if you checked the Bug thread, you've see my complaint. It wasn't about laying an egg. There was definitely a bug that caused our offense to do something totally different. I even gave access to two outside individuals, neither could find the error. And said that based on the AI, it should have worked 100% of the time. I could except it if the offensive AI actually did what we told it to do. But it didn't. At all. That was my problem.

You did have an excellent game plan though. GL to you the rest of the way.
 
Link
 
Do you have a link to the thread? If there is a bug, I'd like to know about it.
 
@ftermath
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Alex Wondertramp
Do you have a link to the thread? If there is a bug, I'd like to know about it.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2671549
 
Link
 
I was reading that thread, and I honestly think that your problem lies in your Big I Left I run output. Some of the outputs that you described are similar to the types of outputs that I use. Everytime, I had a problem with it I found that it was due to an oversight on my part. Since, there really isn't any Big I plays that exist every time that output is called it's going to refer to your Basic AI. In the thread, it was stated that the Basic AI was set up as 20/80 run/pass. I think what happened was that early in the game the random number generator kept drawing the BigILeft output causing the output to revert back to your 20/80 Basic AI.

 
mocfam10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Alex Wondertramp
I was reading that thread, and I honestly think that your problem lies in your Big I Left I run output. Some of the outputs that you described are similar to the types of outputs that I use. Everytime, I had a problem with it I found that it was due to an oversight on my part. Since, there really isn't any Big I plays that exist every time that output is called it's going to refer to your Basic AI. In the thread, it was stated that the Basic AI was set up as 20/80 run/pass. I think what happened was that early in the game the random number generator kept drawing the BigILeft output causing the output to revert back to your 20/80 Basic AI.




Nope, that wasn't it. Forbin and I have already been through that conversation in PM. The chances of a rand function picking the close to the same output number every time to genarate Big I coming up, is virtually impossible. Especially, the entire game. I could see if it happened half the time. But not every time. I've worked with the rand function in grad school and have worked some pretty huge complex simulations with it. The rand function just doesn't work that way at all. Also, the 20/80 was the run left/right option. The run/pass was 50/50 and hadn't been changed since season 7 in the basic.

In essence, there was and is no explanation for the offensive results from that game. And that's why no Mod is going to touch that thread. I have access to anyone who want it. And no one came away saying there is an error on my part. The only thing that Forbin said was that I may have a AI that has too my outputs. And it basically "broke" the sim. I have a lot of different outputs for any given input with my AI so I can change things on the fly. There probably lies a limitation of outputs that Bort has never discussed. And when you get close to it, it says "crew this AI" But that's all we could come up with. He said that after he took out some of the possibilities, it worked fine.

Hence, a sim error, not user error. Which I know to be 100% truthful and even verified by others. I have no issues taking a loss when I'm totally out schemed. (Though, you did a great job scouting our D and finding holes. lol) But when the sim does the exact opposite of what you specify, it's frustrating. Enough so that I've given up on management of teams. The game is too fresh. I'd rather just reply with a "set" and let someone else do that management stuff.

EDIT: I just thought about it, but the Offensive and Defensive AI isn't based on the Rand function to generate the output selected. The part of the AI that uses a true rand formula is when you select "Pick a random play" That's totally randomized. Maybe I use math way too much in real life, but it you break down the outputs and compare to the actual sim it should be very close. Especially on first down as it isn't controlled by anything else other than having the ball on 1st down. The only other thing thatcan override that is if you have a "I'm down by X amount, so do this instead" setting. Which we never came close to.

Even when there was just basic AI, I could run a script and get the run/pass percentage spot on. All evidence points to bug. A rand bug....wait. I'm thinking too much now. lol
Edited by mocfam10 on May 19, 2009 08:04:48
 
Piggskin
offline
Link
 
GG Canberra
 
Link
 
i suggest that you click on the follow my AI exactly box, That way you know for sure if there is an error that it is something that you typed in. I think not checking that box, leaves too much ambiguity and will allow some other factors besides your inputs and outputs to come into play. I would also suggest that you be sure to tidy up ambiguous outputs, remove 0% outputs, and try to get as specific as possible. It can take a lot of time, but it is easier to debug when something goes wrong.

Also, regarding the AI, it may not be a 100% rand function, but more like a lottery. Where each input is its own draw. Calling I slam 20% of the time on 1st and 10, doesn't necessarily mean that over course of a game that 20% of the calls will be I Slam. What it does mean is that on that on each 1st down there is a 20% chance of calling the I slam, regardless of what was called on other first downs. It is possible for the course of a whole game that for each 1st down drawing that you pull the I Slam, as each 1st down is independent of each other. Which would result in calling the I slam 100% on 1st downs in the game, even though you had the output set up for 20%


Edited by Alex Wondertramp on May 19, 2009 16:06:17
Edited by Alex Wondertramp on May 19, 2009 16:05:12
 
sunshineduck
offline
Link
 
GG BearCats. we haven't had any time to work on AI, and you guys shut us down good. hope to see you in the playoffs
 
sunshineduck
offline
Link
 
GG Minnesnowta
 
Frausette
offline
Link
 
dooooh what a big loss.... i didnt expect this.


really GG Peons
 
sunshineduck
offline
Link
 
GG Phoenix
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.