User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > General Discussion > Music > What is it with your fetish in thinking that if they can't perform live, you shouldn't listen to them?
Page:
 
฿ones
offline
Link
 
Live albums =/= live dude.

More times than not unless it sounds really raw live albums have been EQ'd in studio a lot still. It's a good change to hear new solos and covers sometimes but usually live albums aren't just a recorded version of the show live. (plus you can't reproduce feeling crowded, in front of tons of loud amps, screaming your ass off, etc. for the larger bands who make the live albums)
 
LoveGoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joshua1207
Modest Mouse preforms better live. They need more live albums lol.


The best of the best usually perform better live because of the emotion they transcend. Prince, Bon Jovi, Garth Brooks. They're all better live, but this is obviously an elite of the elite thing.

The reasoning behind it is that the version which the record label or whoever wants to release in studio is what it is, but it's not perfect or grandiose. These guys can go out there and do better than what was allowed or preferred in studio. Throw on the crowds and emotion like Bones is talking about and you can see how it's possible.
 
฿ones
offline
Link
 
I don't think it's an elite of elites thing, but it is very apparent in that area of performers.

When you perform, and perform with passion. The crowd hears it. It's VERY hard to get extreme amounts of passion into a studio album just because of how many takes you're forced to make and many times they record each part on it's own. It's so pieced up and long strung that emotion becomes much harder to convey. More power to you if you don't need many takes or record each part together (which isn't an ideal thing to do. What if the bassist misses the bridge and skips into the solo? what if the guitarist wants 3-4 takes of the solo? etc.)

It's something about a crowd cheering for you, singing the things you love so much (from a vocalists point of view) that you might F up the lyrics once or twice (many many more times) but the emotion comes out so much more. From a guitarists PoV it's the final way to mesh the people you're appealing to with you and your brothers. It's the final product coming together to be beautiful. It's the tedious piecing together of a mosaic where anything and everything is possible if you have the time for it and you're finally assembling the big pictures (songs) together and showing them directly to an audience (gig). You get charged, you lose your senses a bit. You just do, and let the guitar be your 6th appendage. There is no seam of conscienceness in your head to your hands to your guitar. It is one. Unified.

Sorry if I rambled a bit...remembering good times with my ex-band before they fired me.

EDIT: On point though, the more you work the sweeter the euphoria becomes and the more passionate you get. Usually the best of the best also work the hardest, usually.
Last edited Apr 22, 2009 16:40:25
 
eb45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Goose the Redeemer
The Mona Lisa is a picture of a face and nothing more. There is not really any deeper, intrinsic meaning to the painting. It's pretty devoid of a real artistic statement too, yet it's considered the greatest work of visual art ever.


Except it's the mystery behind that deeper, intrinsic meaning, including whether or not it exists that makes it the greatest work of visual art ever.

Also, I will now only answer to "lollable douchehead".
 
Link
 
Originally posted by ฿ones
Live albums =/= live dude.

More times than not unless it sounds really raw live albums have been EQ'd in studio a lot still. It's a good change to hear new solos and covers sometimes but usually live albums aren't just a recorded version of the show live. (plus you can't reproduce feeling crowded, in front of tons of loud amps, screaming your ass off, etc. for the larger bands who make the live albums)


This. I'm not a fan of live albums. I love live music, but recorded live music usually falls short. Occasionally there are some exceptions, like when bands reinterpret their songs or go on impromptu jams. For the most part, though, live albums are an easy way for record labels to make more money off an artist.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Goose the Redeemer
Originally posted by Joshua1207

Modest Mouse preforms better live. They need more live albums lol.


The best of the best usually perform better live because of the emotion they transcend. Prince, Bon Jovi, Garth Brooks. They're all better live, but this is obviously an elite of the elite thing.

The reasoning behind it is that the version which the record label or whoever wants to release in studio is what it is, but it's not perfect or grandiose. These guys can go out there and do better than what was allowed or preferred in studio. Throw on the crowds and emotion like Bones is talking about and you can see how it's possible.


Not true at all. Sometimes the best live performances come from unknown bands. And lol at Garth Brooks transcending emotion.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by eb45
Originally posted by Goose the Redeemer

The Mona Lisa is a picture of a face and nothing more. There is not really any deeper, intrinsic meaning to the painting. It's pretty devoid of a real artistic statement too, yet it's considered the greatest work of visual art ever.


Except it's the mystery behind that deeper, intrinsic meaning, including whether or not it exists that makes it the greatest work of visual art ever.

Also, I will now only answer to "lollable douchehead".


Goose is a robot. He doesn't comprehend art and human emotion or any correlation between the two.
 
฿ones
offline
Link
 
There are bands I can handle live albums for, and just because they deviate a lot. I still don't count it as 'the live experience' for that band. I've heard RHCP live (seen, raw video of some place in Denmark IIRC. It was pretty nice) and Pearl Jam live and those are about the only bands who capture their sound and make it even more their own on stage what with random jams and just having fun when they know they're being recorded.

Also put in SRV, Hendrix, BB King, Beetles, and such as having very realistic live albums. I'm not sure if SRV BB or the Beetles did have one but I am sure they made it a damned good if they did make one.

Live albums are great and all for compilations (I'd prefer a live album spanning the years of albums to a studio compilation) but it isn't the live experience as said before.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by ฿ones
There are bands I can handle live albums for, and just because they deviate a lot. I still don't count it as 'the live experience' for that band. I've heard RHCP live (seen, raw video of some place in Denmark IIRC. It was pretty nice) and Pearl Jam live and those are about the only bands who capture their sound and make it even more their own on stage what with random jams and just having fun when they know they're being recorded.

Also put in SRV, Hendrix, BB King, Beetles, and such as having very realistic live albums. I'm not sure if SRV BB or the Beetles did have one but I am sure they made it a damned good if they did make one.

Live albums are great and all for compilations (I'd prefer a live album spanning the years of albums to a studio compilation) but it isn't the live experience as said before.



Yeah, I've heard some of Pearl Jam's live stuff, and tbh, that's one of the bands I was thinking of when I was talking about the exceptions.

I got The Clash's Live at Shea Stadium CD that came out late last year, and the production of that CD is way too good for a live CD. It doesn't sound authentic - more like a studio album w/ crowd noise and band banter mixed into it. I've heard some other live recordings of The Clash that were way better because they weren't so overproduced.
 
฿ones
offline
Link
 
I have a couple official albums from Chile (unless it was one large album with 2 covers for the two dates) of Pearl Jam and it's damned awesome.

They've always supported people to 'pirate' their live performances and they just wanted their sound to get around as much as possible. They came out with a 'simplistic' live album that just captured the performance crisply and didn't change anything else to my knowledge. They figured it'd be easier to capture the fans this way.
 
Joshua1207
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ฿ones
Live albums =/= live dude.

More times than not unless it sounds really raw live albums have been EQ'd in studio a lot still. It's a good change to hear new solos and covers sometimes but usually live albums aren't just a recorded version of the show live. (plus you can't reproduce feeling crowded, in front of tons of loud amps, screaming your ass off, etc. for the larger bands who make the live albums)


I know that, but Modest Mouse's Baron Von Bullshit album was pretty good though http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UovG_UARNzI
 
Link
 
While we're discussing bands that sound better live, you should all be ashamed for not mentioning Rush (Though they're just fucking awesome in studio; therefore, their live shows are a seperate entity), Stone Temple Pilots (Scott Weiland whipped out a megaphone and yelled into the mic, "Here I Come, I Come, I come." Well, actually, they just sound better in general, but the megaphone thing for Sex Type Thing was badass), and the wildcard, Gaelic Storm. Check them out if they are by you.

Also, Goose, what the fuck is with your username? LoveGoose sounds even trollier than Goose The Redeemer. It's like Bernie Madoff trying to change his name; we'll still know who you are.
Last edited Apr 22, 2009 21:46:42
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Joshua1207
Originally posted by ฿ones

Live albums =/= live dude.

More times than not unless it sounds really raw live albums have been EQ'd in studio a lot still. It's a good change to hear new solos and covers sometimes but usually live albums aren't just a recorded version of the show live. (plus you can't reproduce feeling crowded, in front of tons of loud amps, screaming your ass off, etc. for the larger bands who make the live albums)


I know that, but Modest Mouse's Baron Von Bullshit album was pretty good though http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UovG_UARNzI


I was going to post that exact video. I actually hate MM's studio recordings most of the time, but my god do they rock on stage.

And Baron von Bullshit Rides Again is the best album name ever created. Ever.
 
Joshua1207
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krisdaschwab912
Originally posted by Joshua1207

Originally posted by ฿ones


Live albums =/= live dude.

More times than not unless it sounds really raw live albums have been EQ'd in studio a lot still. It's a good change to hear new solos and covers sometimes but usually live albums aren't just a recorded version of the show live. (plus you can't reproduce feeling crowded, in front of tons of loud amps, screaming your ass off, etc. for the larger bands who make the live albums)


I know that, but Modest Mouse's Baron Von Bullshit album was pretty good though http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UovG_UARNzI


I was going to post that exact video. I actually hate MM's studio recordings most of the time, but my god do they rock on stage.

And Baron von Bullshit Rides Again is the best album name ever created. Ever.


You hate Modest Mouse's studio recordings?Everything before the Good News album is epic. But all of their live stuff is much better.
And yes, Baron Von Bullshit Rides Again is a great album name.
Last edited Apr 22, 2009 21:51:36
 
Link
 
I haven't heard all of their studio recordings, but the ones I've heard (roughly 10-15 songs) is quite hit or miss, mostly the latter.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.