User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > A way to allow for users to have some say over height at creation, while adding dynamic weight change and doing away with the "Reroll" method of generating starting attributes
Page:
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Firenze
As always, drifter brings another great idea.


true

Originally posted by Firenze
And as always, it'll be lost in the voids of Suggestions forever.


false

EPICIZED!
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Woah, I witnessed an epicism.
 
Makalele
offline
Link
 
Excellent suggestion +1
 
Jdog81
offline
Link
 
i guess some people don't know how to make small topic titles.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Johnb21
i guess some people don't know how to make small topic titles.


Would you rather it was "I've got an idea" or "I can improve the game by..." ?
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Johnb21
i guess some people don't know how to make small topic titles.


ITT: people find ANYTHING they can to complain about

You certainly know what the thread is by the title, isn't that the point?
 
AlexFleischut
offline
Link
 
I love this idea. +1
I am not too sure about height idea though. But we really do need to get rid of the stupid rolling for player creation.

Last edited Apr 19, 2009 20:30:37
 
Link
 
I really really love this idea

One caveat though...

Implementing it may be a little tough because people will complain that it isn't fair and want their "perfect" slow build player to be grandfathered into it...

And unless you spell it all out for Bort and the coders, they will likely change it, screw it up, or not do it at all.

I haven't looked at all of your spreadsheet, but make sure you have all the logistics covered...

EDIT: You have all of your bases covered which is quite spectacular

But you should put kickers/punters in there too

You can lessen the gain/loss of points to avoid exploits, but I would love to make a little Gary Anderson type kicker lol
Last edited Apr 19, 2009 21:55:25
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AlexFleischut
I love this idea. +1
I am not too sure about height idea though. But we really do need to get rid of the stupid rolling for player creation.



I'd love to discuss what your reservations on height are if you care to elaborate.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by caesarrodneybengal
I really really love this idea

One caveat though...

Implementing it may be a little tough because people will complain that it isn't fair and want their "perfect" slow build player to be grandfathered into it...

And unless you spell it all out for Bort and the coders, they will likely change it, screw it up, or not do it at all.

I haven't looked at all of your spreadsheet, but make sure you have all the logistics covered...

EDIT: You have all of your bases covered which is quite spectacular

But you should put kickers/punters in there too

You can lessen the gain/loss of points to avoid exploits, but I would love to make a little Gary Anderson type kicker lol


Hadn't thought about kickers. Since height isn't going to matter for a kicker in any respect, it's probably not a good idea to give them the option to "sell" height for points. Maybe they stay random?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by caesarrodneybengal

I really really love this idea

One caveat though...

Implementing it may be a little tough because people will complain that it isn't fair and want their "perfect" slow build player to be grandfathered into it...

And unless you spell it all out for Bort and the coders, they will likely change it, screw it up, or not do it at all.

I haven't looked at all of your spreadsheet, but make sure you have all the logistics covered...

EDIT: You have all of your bases covered which is quite spectacular

But you should put kickers/punters in there too

You can lessen the gain/loss of points to avoid exploits, but I would love to make a little Gary Anderson type kicker lol


Hadn't thought about kickers. Since height isn't going to matter for a kicker in any respect, it's probably not a good idea to give them the option to "sell" height for points. Maybe they stay random?


I was thinking that you could get random stuff but use one point to customize it within the min and max heights for kickers/punters

That way you can customize it but it just won't be too costly because it doesn't have an effect

And weight should have some factor in kicking/punting because a fat kicker/punter will be worse because they will be slower and less explosive...it should really be minor and just to keep people honest with their stamina vs strength
 
BellyCheck
offline
Link
 
I stopped in on the thread b/c I've got a ridiculously light LB... but shouldn't strength get you a weight gain over time? I would say it should probably, to be realistic, go from your "birth" as a draftee through the fill-out process. If you think of a kid coming out of college, as he hits the weight room you can often get weight up, over several seasons, 20 lbs of muscle mass. I don't think it makes sense that through working out your guy will gain more than that, but why not make 3 points of added strength equal to 1 pound of weight, up to a max of 20 lbs? So up to your first 60 *natural* strength points added (i.e., not equipment points), you can add weight. Cap it at 300 (if you ask me,) because your seriously heavy lineman types are more likely to need to lose non-lean mass (blubber) than pump up their weight through lifting.

I hope this wasn't discussed along the way along with the original suggestion. I read about a page then realized we were on exactly the same page, but different paragraphs.

Belly

Edit - or relate it to ONLY strength points gained through training, and make it a pound per point.
Last edited Apr 22, 2009 21:15:26
 
TheBearJew
offline
Link
 
+1
 
BellyCheck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by caesarrodneybengal
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by caesarrodneybengal

And weight should have some factor in kicking/punting because a fat kicker/punter will be worse because they will be slower and less explosive...it should really be minor and just to keep people honest with their stamina vs strength


Also if their thighs rub together they'll get distracted.
Last edited Apr 24, 2009 03:42:51
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BellyCheck
I stopped in on the thread b/c I've got a ridiculously light LB... but shouldn't strength get you a weight gain over time? I would say it should probably, to be realistic, go from your "birth" as a draftee through the fill-out process. If you think of a kid coming out of college, as he hits the weight room you can often get weight up, over several seasons, 20 lbs of muscle mass. I don't think it makes sense that through working out your guy will gain more than that, but why not make 3 points of added strength equal to 1 pound of weight, up to a max of 20 lbs? So up to your first 60 *natural* strength points added (i.e., not equipment points), you can add weight. Cap it at 300 (if you ask me,) because your seriously heavy lineman types are more likely to need to lose non-lean mass (blubber) than pump up their weight through lifting.

I hope this wasn't discussed along the way along with the original suggestion. I read about a page then realized we were on exactly the same page, but different paragraphs.

Belly

Edit - or relate it to ONLY strength points gained through training, and make it a pound per point.


You will still gain weight as your strength exceeds your stamina by more and more, effectively achieving the same thing
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.