User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
flknight
star gent
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell
Originally posted by ElvisMonster

Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell


Dude.. seriously what did you sit on today?

I simply am debating yet you continue to throw direct posts at me? If I wanted to see rankings I would yet I am providing input and discussion and you continue to have your panties in a waste. By the way maybe its because I mentioned Brett Farve (Cheese head in your avatar) that your so testy.

We will see you in the playoffs most likely, if not good luck to ya.


Ummm, I didn't think I said anything shitty to you in that post. I'm curious to see what formula you would use and the results of that formula. But all I see right now is a guy that wants to take shots at somebody else's work without doing any of their own.

I'll break it down for you so you can maybe see where I'm coming from...

1. Guy makes a little effort to add something to the league. Comes up with a ranking formula that goes a little deeper than wins and losses. Takes the time to build a spreadsheet, enter the info, and post the results.
2. Somebody's feelings get hurt because their pretend football team didn't show up where they expected it to in the rankings and proceeds to take shots at the dude that posted the rankings (nice delete job, by the way).
3. (This is the part I don't want to happen) Original guy eventually goes "Fuck this. I don't need this shit." and leaves the job for somebody else.

I think it's pretty epic that somebody took the time and made the effort to give us something to talk about. The post you deleted was out of line. If you want to keep the discussion to why you think you should be ranked higher, that's fair and I'd enjoy being a part of the debate. Unfortunately, you took a couple of personal shots at the original poster and I'd rather piss you off than have you piss him off. He's doing something.






If you read my other posts I said a big thank you for putting it together. Initially I thought there was some bias and I simply asked the question on why. Your the one that continues to go on and on regarding any post I have made. I threw some input on how I have seen most power rankings (Real Football) which considers head to head as well as record and strength of schedule. He mentioned previously that he has his formula but was looking for any suggestions.

I don't feel how bad you beat a team should be considered as much as I don't think its considered in any other polls outside of the BCS (Which is another topic of its own and you would have to agree)
How about this?
1. Straight up Record * SOS
2. Head to Head

My Top 6 List
1. Mag 7 Hitmen - 12-0 - (SOS 8.16 Ave)
2. Valencia Crocs - 12-0 - (SOS 9.5 Ave)
3. Mato Grasso Maned Wolves 11-1 (SOS 9.0)
4. Montevideo Bulls 11-1 (SOS 9.66)
5. Salt Lake City Mighty Mormons 10-2 (SOS 9.08)
6. San Juan Leopards 10-2 (SOS 9.16)


I could go on and I appreciate him putting in the time to put it together but I just questioned why head to head and overall record wasn't factored in more. I agree that my post was probably out of line but that was my first initial thoughts and that is why I removed it.




I'm still tweaking this. How did you figure SOS?
Last edited May 19, 2008 18:53:44
 
kxrnidge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell
Originally posted by ElvisMonster

Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell


Dude.. seriously what did you sit on today?

I simply am debating yet you continue to throw direct posts at me? If I wanted to see rankings I would yet I am providing input and discussion and you continue to have your panties in a waste. By the way maybe its because I mentioned Brett Farve (Cheese head in your avatar) that your so testy.

We will see you in the playoffs most likely, if not good luck to ya.


Ummm, I didn't think I said anything shitty to you in that post. I'm curious to see what formula you would use and the results of that formula. But all I see right now is a guy that wants to take shots at somebody else's work without doing any of their own.

I'll break it down for you so you can maybe see where I'm coming from...

1. Guy makes a little effort to add something to the league. Comes up with a ranking formula that goes a little deeper than wins and losses. Takes the time to build a spreadsheet, enter the info, and post the results.
2. Somebody's feelings get hurt because their pretend football team didn't show up where they expected it to in the rankings and proceeds to take shots at the dude that posted the rankings (nice delete job, by the way).
3. (This is the part I don't want to happen) Original guy eventually goes "Fuck this. I don't need this shit." and leaves the job for somebody else.

I think it's pretty epic that somebody took the time and made the effort to give us something to talk about. The post you deleted was out of line. If you want to keep the discussion to why you think you should be ranked higher, that's fair and I'd enjoy being a part of the debate. Unfortunately, you took a couple of personal shots at the original poster and I'd rather piss you off than have you piss him off. He's doing something.






If you read my other posts I said a big thank you for putting it together. Initially I thought there was some bias and I simply asked the question on why. Your the one that continues to go on and on regarding any post I have made. I threw some input on how I have seen most power rankings (Real Football) which considers head to head as well as record and strength of schedule. He mentioned previously that he has his formula but was looking for any suggestions.

I don't feel how bad you beat a team should be considered as much as I don't think its considered in any other polls outside of the BCS (Which is another topic of its own and you would have to agree)
How about this?
1. Straight up Record * SOS
2. Head to Head

My Top 6 List
1. Mag 7 Hitmen - 12-0 - (SOS 8.16 Ave)
2. Valencia Crocs - 12-0 - (SOS 9.5 Ave)
3. Mato Grasso Maned Wolves 11-1 (SOS 9.0)
4. Montevideo Bulls 11-1 (SOS 9.66)
5. Salt Lake City Mighty Mormons 10-2 (SOS 9.08)
6. San Juan Leopards 10-2 (SOS 9.16)


I could go on and I appreciate him putting in the time to put it together but I just questioned why head to head and overall record wasn't factored in more. I agree that my post was probably out of line but that was my first initial thoughts and that is why I removed it.




Yeah, how did you get the Bulls at 4th and the Wolves at 3rd when the Bulls have the better SOS?
 
advanex1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kxrnidge
Originally posted by advanex1

Originally posted by kxrnidge


Originally posted by advanex1



Curious how the Bulls are ahead of the Crocs. The Bulls only loss comes from the Crocs this season.


The Bulls are ahead because we have more points in his scoring system, which is, and I quote fknights here:

"It's all strength of wins."

By that, I'm assuming we're ahead only because we've beaten equal/better teams than you by more points, but barely.


I don't think you guys have played better teams than we have. We have gone through you, the water works, the leopards, and the eagles. Where I believe you guys have only played 1 or 2 of those.

It looks like the rankings are made purely off of points scored and that's it. These rankings just don't make much sense to me.


I don't know, the Bulls haven't allowed more than 20 points in any game, all season long, and we've done better against the teams we've won against.

Example 1: Bulls beat the Austin Titans 38-3, Crocs only won 7-6
Example 2: Bulls beat the Texas Aggies 58-3, Crocs only won 27-3
Example 3: Bulls beat Guadalajara Water Works 29-0, Crocs only won 16-3
Example 4: Bulls beat Wacco Copperheads 55-0, Crocs only won 41-0

Regardless, I'm looking forward to (hopefully) playing you guys again in the conference finals

(I'm just assuming this tbh lol, it may/may not factor)



We played backups alot in quite a few of those games that you had "blow outs" in. That's the reason the point spread isn't the same. I also know that personally when we played against lesser teams, I set my guy to play normally. We generally had a good game coming after them.
Last edited May 19, 2008 20:21:45
 
Link
 
SOS is the average of opponents record in the conf the have played divided by games played. Example if team A has played the number 1 2 3 4 & 5 teams it would be SOS - 3. 15/5 games played. This will change weekly. The kicker will be the non conf game. The only time SOS would come in is if there are 2 teams that have the same record but havent played head to head.
 
Link
 
Opponents record is their rank in their conf. Example H Hitmen 1 Mormans 3
 
flknight
star gent
offline
Link
 
"We played backups alot in quite a few of those games that you had "blow outs" in. That's the reason the point spread isn't the same. I also know that personally when we played against lesser teams, I set my guy to play normally. We generally had a good game coming after them."


I would believe that almost everyone who is winning is playing backups. We (Samurai) have been playing almost 50/50 since day one. That's why are team stats are high put very few players are leading any statistics.
Last edited May 19, 2008 21:54:11
 
blazzinken
offline
Link
 
I have a question, when the season is over wont the SOS be almost the same? because you all play the exact same teams except yourself and one opponent from the other league
 
Link
 
Originally posted by blazzinken
I have a question, when the season is over wont the SOS be almost the same? because you all play the exact same teams except yourself and one opponent from the other league


That is correct.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by flknight
"We played backups alot in quite a few of those games that you had "blow outs" in. That's the reason the point spread isn't the same. I also know that personally when we played against lesser teams, I set my guy to play normally. We generally had a good game coming after them."





I would believe that almost everyone who is winning is playing backups. We (Samurai) have been playing almost 50/50 since day one. That's why are team stats are high put very few players are leading any statistics.



We have started backups in our past 2 games to ensure max exp is earned by those players
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell
Originally posted by Cool Hand Bsby

Flawless.

Ronald, less crying more football, please.


Again.. same question I gave to GUY...

If you were ranked #2 under the Mato Grasso Wolves.. would you not question it?



Why would I question someone's opinion? There is no right or wrong. Grow up.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Cool Hand Bsby
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell

Originally posted by Cool Hand Bsby


Flawless.

Ronald, less crying more football, please.


Again.. same question I gave to GUY...

If you were ranked #2 under the Mato Grasso Wolves.. would you not question it?



Why would I question someone's opinion? There is no right or wrong. Grow up.


I'm grown... All I did is ask you a question and you still did not answer it... still waiting from an answer from you.

 
flknight
star gent
offline
Link
 
There are a lot of questions about SOS. If this is in reference to my rankings then let me say I do not use any SOS in the formula. Once again I use:

1. 25pts per win.
2. Points scored X opponent win percentage. (ie. Score 100 against Seattle .000 win percentage and you get 0 pts) (Score 20 against Valencia 1.00 win pct and you get 20)

The better the team you score on the more credit you get. I've intentionally left personal opinion out of this, thats why I don't move every team that has beaten another team over the other. Where does that stop?

There is also only 48 hours between games and between work and school there is only so much analyzing I can do.

Like I've said before this is what it is. I'm still working on the best "user-friendly" way to do this.

As of the last game I had to estimate the point scored percent prior to week 10. Last night I did go game by game, as if I started in week 1 and it did make some big changes. I may use template with tonights game.

For everyone who has taken the time to post. Thanks... Standing your ground and arguing for your team is what this is about.

Just don't make it personal, I'm not.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by flknight
There are a lot of questions about SOS. If this is in reference to my rankings then let me say I do not use any SOS in the formula. Once again I use:

1. 25pts per win.
2. Points scored X opponent win percentage. (ie. Score 100 against Seattle .000 win percentage and you get 0 pts) (Score 20 against Valencia 1.00 win pct and you get 20)

The better the team you score on the more credit you get. I've intentionally left personal opinion out of this, thats why I don't move every team that has beaten another team over the other. Where does that stop?

There is also only 48 hours between games and between work and school there is only so much analyzing I can do.

Like I've said before this is what it is. I'm still working on the best "user-friendly" way to do this.

As of the last game I had to estimate the point scored percent prior to week 10. Last night I did go game by game, as if I started in week 1 and it did make some big changes. I may use template with tonights game.

For everyone who has taken the time to post. Thanks... Standing your ground and arguing for your team is what this is about.

Just don't make it personal, I'm not.



Thanks for taking the time doing this man. I agree... between 48 hours with work and school you must not be married and have a "Honey do list".


 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell
Originally posted by Cool Hand Bsby

Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell


Originally posted by Cool Hand Bsby



Flawless.

Ronald, less crying more football, please.


Again.. same question I gave to GUY...

If you were ranked #2 under the Mato Grasso Wolves.. would you not question it?



Why would I question someone's opinion? There is no right or wrong. Grow up.


I'm grown... All I did is ask you a question and you still did not answer it... still waiting from an answer from you.



I don't know how much more clear I can make it that I would not question it. Hopefully this satisfies you. If not, I'll certainly tell you again.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by flknight
There are a lot of questions about SOS. If this is in reference to my rankings then let me say I do not use any SOS in the formula. Once again I use:

2. Points scored X opponent win percentage. (ie. Score 100 against Seattle .000 win percentage and you get 0 pts) (Score 20 against Valencia 1.00 win pct and you get 20)

The better the team you score on the more credit you get. I've intentionally left personal opinion out of this, thats why I don't move every team that has beaten another team over the other. Where does that stop?



I dont know if Points scored is the best judge of how good a team is. Does a team that loses 98-30 to Team A deserve more pts than a team that wins 7 - 6 (or loses 7 - 6 for that matter.)

I personally think that this should be based more on your Offense and Defensive rankings. Perhaps passing/rushing/total yards per game rank, passing/rushing/total yards allowed per game rank, turnover differential, and TD vs FG %
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.