I think if a play is so drastic that everyone is only using one we can bypass the week 12 rule for the betterment of the game
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Yes, we are aware the I slam play is frequntly cheesy and many teams are running it over and over. No, we are not updating things in-season.
Ravenwood
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by l40niners1
If a play is so messed up why not just take it out of the sim until fixed? Its the same for everyone..
All it would really take to tone it down with the current code is adding a little delay at the start of the play, actually.
Once again, we go back to that week 12 thing.
Well, in the interest of preserving a week 12 'gentlemen's agreement', a bunch of people are cheese balling your sim, and making a mockery of this game in the process.
Removing a play from the playbook doesn't change the sim - it acknowledges a flawed play, and hopefully means the league championships aren't decided by a well known exploit.
Originally posted by l40niners1
If a play is so messed up why not just take it out of the sim until fixed? Its the same for everyone..
All it would really take to tone it down with the current code is adding a little delay at the start of the play, actually.
Once again, we go back to that week 12 thing.
Well, in the interest of preserving a week 12 'gentlemen's agreement', a bunch of people are cheese balling your sim, and making a mockery of this game in the process.
Removing a play from the playbook doesn't change the sim - it acknowledges a flawed play, and hopefully means the league championships aren't decided by a well known exploit.
Making changes mid-season is generally a bad idea.
I would like to know the off season schedule
Are going to go to day 45, then roll over to day -6? -8?
This would be helpful for planning purposes - as an owner I would rather have more "pre-season" time than "post-season" time to play with ticket pricing and let the OC & DC scout
I would like to know the off season schedule
Are going to go to day 45, then roll over to day -6? -8?
This would be helpful for planning purposes - as an owner I would rather have more "pre-season" time than "post-season" time to play with ticket pricing and let the OC & DC scout
BMoreAbsurd
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by l40niners1
If a play is so messed up why not just take it out of the sim until fixed? Its the same for everyone..
All it would really take to tone it down with the current code is adding a little delay at the start of the play, actually.
Once again, we go back to that week 12 thing.
IIRC the APL riot began around week 10.
Just sayin'.
Originally posted by l40niners1
If a play is so messed up why not just take it out of the sim until fixed? Its the same for everyone..
All it would really take to tone it down with the current code is adding a little delay at the start of the play, actually.
Once again, we go back to that week 12 thing.
IIRC the APL riot began around week 10.
Just sayin'.
There's no way to appease everyone at this juncture and just addressing that it's an issue is really all you can do.
Jiddy78
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jiddy78
Originally posted by Bort
We have made a point of not doing updates mid-season after week 12.
Where were you last offseason?
And the first 12 weeks of this season?
This season has been fail.
Read that last sentence over and over again.
I hope you see it as inspiration more than degradation.
Up to you.
BTW...No response needed.
Just hope you see it....
Originally posted by Bort
We have made a point of not doing updates mid-season after week 12.
Where were you last offseason?
And the first 12 weeks of this season?
This season has been fail.
Read that last sentence over and over again.
I hope you see it as inspiration more than degradation.
Up to you.
BTW...No response needed.
Just hope you see it....
hokegoalie
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ccf
I honestly haven't seen any problem with this play. My teams are stopping it just fine,
BBBBBBBBBBB
I honestly haven't seen any problem with this play. My teams are stopping it just fine,
BBBBBBBBBBB
buffalobills_tw
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
It wasn't as well known of a problem - teams were passing more. The test server didn't really have time to get rolling until the season started either.
It is well known that teams find an exploit and run it over and over since season 1, but nothing has been done. There are suggestions to give defense bonus after seeing same play many times or penalize offense running the same play after certain times, but again, nothing is done to prevent it.
The problem is not just certain plays, there are and will be plays worked better than others. The issue here is the same play being run the whole game or most of the game.
It wasn't as well known of a problem - teams were passing more. The test server didn't really have time to get rolling until the season started either.
It is well known that teams find an exploit and run it over and over since season 1, but nothing has been done. There are suggestions to give defense bonus after seeing same play many times or penalize offense running the same play after certain times, but again, nothing is done to prevent it.
The problem is not just certain plays, there are and will be plays worked better than others. The issue here is the same play being run the whole game or most of the game.
joemiken
offline
offline
Thanks for the update. While the power backs/Slam plays have been a problem this season, changing it right before the playoffs would've been a horrible idea. I'm glad you're not catering to the whiners and fools.
Can't wait to see what Season 9 brings. I'm anxiously awaiting the D-Play Creator.
btw, it's not specifically the Strong I Slam that's the cause of the problems. Removing that play wouldn't solve a damn thing.
Can't wait to see what Season 9 brings. I'm anxiously awaiting the D-Play Creator.

btw, it's not specifically the Strong I Slam that's the cause of the problems. Removing that play wouldn't solve a damn thing.
Last edited Mar 31, 2009 17:29:39
BMoreAbsurd
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ravenwood
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by l40niners1
If a play is so messed up why not just take it out of the sim until fixed? Its the same for everyone..
All it would really take to tone it down with the current code is adding a little delay at the start of the play, actually.
Once again, we go back to that week 12 thing.
Well, in the interest of preserving a week 12 'gentlemen's agreement', a bunch of people are cheese balling your sim, and making a mockery of this game in the process.
Removing a play from the playbook doesn't change the sim - it acknowledges a flawed play, and hopefully means the league championships aren't decided by a well known exploit.
THANK you.
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by l40niners1
If a play is so messed up why not just take it out of the sim until fixed? Its the same for everyone..
All it would really take to tone it down with the current code is adding a little delay at the start of the play, actually.
Once again, we go back to that week 12 thing.
Well, in the interest of preserving a week 12 'gentlemen's agreement', a bunch of people are cheese balling your sim, and making a mockery of this game in the process.
Removing a play from the playbook doesn't change the sim - it acknowledges a flawed play, and hopefully means the league championships aren't decided by a well known exploit.
THANK you.
jdbolick
offline
offline
Nice to get some confirmation, but I am concerned from reading the Season 9 announcement that the running game as a whole will get nuked instead of just addressing one overpowered and overused play. From what I've seen and read, running is next to impossible on the test server.
JHight
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ccf
I honestly haven't seen any problem with this play. My teams are stopping it just fine,
You don't have a team about AA and the one that is in AA is 6-10. You don't see it successfully done in either the low leagues or outside of the playoffs.
I honestly haven't seen any problem with this play. My teams are stopping it just fine,
You don't have a team about AA and the one that is in AA is 6-10. You don't see it successfully done in either the low leagues or outside of the playoffs.
Originally posted by Cerneo
Originally posted by Bort
As a designer eager to see his new stuff in use, I would actually LOVE to upload all the newest stuff right now. I used to do updates continuously throughout the season in seasons 1-2 and put in hotfixes all the time. Then people started complaining about midseason updates, no matter how minor, and we came up with the unwritten rule referenced above.
Well lest say next season you have a new play a pass one this time, every time its a TD, only one team knows this until game 4, it is then made public and every team uses it.
Would you do nothing?
If it's truly unstoppable I'd look at it and try to figure out why. With the D play creator going up, I'm going to take a pretty strong guess that there's going to be far less of a chance of an unstoppable play any more.
Originally posted by Bort
As a designer eager to see his new stuff in use, I would actually LOVE to upload all the newest stuff right now. I used to do updates continuously throughout the season in seasons 1-2 and put in hotfixes all the time. Then people started complaining about midseason updates, no matter how minor, and we came up with the unwritten rule referenced above.
Well lest say next season you have a new play a pass one this time, every time its a TD, only one team knows this until game 4, it is then made public and every team uses it.
Would you do nothing?
If it's truly unstoppable I'd look at it and try to figure out why. With the D play creator going up, I'm going to take a pretty strong guess that there's going to be far less of a chance of an unstoppable play any more.
Ccf
offline
offline
Originally posted by JHight
Originally posted by Ccf
I honestly haven't seen any problem with this play. My teams are stopping it just fine,
You don't have a team about AA and the one that is in AA is 6-10. You don't see it successfully done in either the low leagues or outside of the playoffs.
That's true, but I've done some scouting for a couple of mediocre AAA teams, and while it was successful, it's not really to the point of an exploit.
Originally posted by Ccf
I honestly haven't seen any problem with this play. My teams are stopping it just fine,
You don't have a team about AA and the one that is in AA is 6-10. You don't see it successfully done in either the low leagues or outside of the playoffs.
That's true, but I've done some scouting for a couple of mediocre AAA teams, and while it was successful, it's not really to the point of an exploit.
Last edited Mar 31, 2009 17:31:21
Procrustes
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by l40niners1
If a play is so messed up why not just take it out of the sim until fixed? Its the same for everyone..
All it would really take to tone it down with the current code is adding a little delay at the start of the play, actually.
Once again, we go back to that week 12 thing.
while not altering the sim midway through the season is the best rule of thumb, i'm guessing most people would've preferred to make an exception in this case.
there needs to be a mechanism in place to handle situations when the line is crossed from "cheese" to "sim-breaking"... and i'm not sure the forums are the best vehicle for that.
perhaps next time, a poll? an "owners tribune"? we need something.
Originally posted by l40niners1
If a play is so messed up why not just take it out of the sim until fixed? Its the same for everyone..
All it would really take to tone it down with the current code is adding a little delay at the start of the play, actually.
Once again, we go back to that week 12 thing.
while not altering the sim midway through the season is the best rule of thumb, i'm guessing most people would've preferred to make an exception in this case.
there needs to be a mechanism in place to handle situations when the line is crossed from "cheese" to "sim-breaking"... and i'm not sure the forums are the best vehicle for that.
perhaps next time, a poll? an "owners tribune"? we need something.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























