User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > League Moving Based on Median and Max Level of Players on Team
Page:
 
Cylon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hagalaz
Using the average level of all players on a team is a great idea. I hope the implementation of this method goes well

Will anxiously wait to see it in action.


The implementation is key. Bring down CPU teams, do the reshuffle, then promotion relegation seems like the best option unless I'm missing something.

P.S. or would it be CPU, promote winners, reshuffle, promote high levels? Oh well it's not for me to figure out!
Last edited Mar 30, 2009 07:52:54
 
Brick Wall
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Phantom_Opera
Originally posted by Boltz

i like it




 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
The one thing I'm seeing about this is that the lower # tiers are going to get STACKED over a few seasons.

BBB1 is going to be great, BBB16 awful. A few rounds of promotion... A1 is going to be stacked with talent, and A8 horrendous. Heck, I'd argue BBB1-4 would end up higher quality than A7-8 in a given region in a few seasons from now.

My only suggestion would be to fill these leagues in based on "talent" in a given region, top to bottom (as you plan on doing), and then shuffle the league #s around randomly. So BBB1 isn't necessarily the best, but everybody is still grouped by talent, and in the long run, the A leagues are fed with equal talent.
 
tsimp93
offline
Link
 
Will there still be level 13 Capped teams being released this offseason?
 
iStatic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Boltz
i like it


+1. We need a balance. People pulling 1000 yards in 1 game due to the CPU teams.
 
ijg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned
The one thing I'm seeing about this is that the lower # tiers are going to get STACKED over a few seasons.

BBB1 is going to be great, BBB16 awful. A few rounds of promotion... A1 is going to be stacked with talent, and A8 horrendous. Heck, I'd argue BBB1-4 would end up higher quality than A7-8 in a given region in a few seasons from now.

My only suggestion would be to fill these leagues in based on "talent" in a given region, top to bottom (as you plan on doing), and then shuffle the league #s around randomly. So BBB1 isn't necessarily the best, but everybody is still grouped by talent, and in the long run, the A leagues are fed with equal talent.


I agree that was my main concern too. I think even with your suggestion there will be issues. If you put a high cap as BBB1 and a low cap as BBB2, then the BBB2 winner is going to get destroyed in A1 and be at a permanent disadvantage, so nobody will want to own those teams.

If you make it so BBB1-4 are the high caps and BBB13-16 the low caps, then over time A7-8 and AA4 will be much weaker than A1-2 and AA1. This means the schemers will want to get in the low caps, so they can get to AAA the fastest and then try to upgrade the roster when they get there.

Either way, there is a perverse incentive that needs to be addressed. I think the best way is to have the BBB1-4 be strongest and 13-16 be weakest, but have different promotion rules, so perhaps winning BBB16 gets you into BBB4 instead of A8 and let the BBB1-4 winners move into the 8 A regions or just eventually merge the BBB 1-4 with A 5-8 in a new tier. Haven't done the math yet to see how feasible those ideas are though in the current promotion setup.
 
Raiders12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ijg
Originally posted by Octowned

The one thing I'm seeing about this is that the lower # tiers are going to get STACKED over a few seasons.

BBB1 is going to be great, BBB16 awful. A few rounds of promotion... A1 is going to be stacked with talent, and A8 horrendous. Heck, I'd argue BBB1-4 would end up higher quality than A7-8 in a given region in a few seasons from now.

My only suggestion would be to fill these leagues in based on "talent" in a given region, top to bottom (as you plan on doing), and then shuffle the league #s around randomly. So BBB1 isn't necessarily the best, but everybody is still grouped by talent, and in the long run, the A leagues are fed with equal talent.


I agree that was my main concern too. I think even with your suggestion there will be issues. If you put a high cap as BBB1 and a low cap as BBB2, then the BBB2 winner is going to get destroyed in A1 and be at a permanent disadvantage, so nobody will want to own those teams.

If you make it so BBB1-4 are the high caps and BBB13-16 the low caps, then over time A7-8 and AA4 will be much weaker than A1-2 and AA1. This means the schemers will want to get in the low caps, so they can get to AAA the fastest and then try to upgrade the roster when they get there.

Either way, there is a perverse incentive that needs to be addressed. I think the best way is to have the BBB1-4 be strongest and 13-16 be weakest, but have different promotion rules, so perhaps winning BBB16 gets you into BBB4 instead of A8 and let the BBB1-4 winners move into the 8 A regions or just eventually merge the BBB 1-4 with A 5-8 in a new tier. Haven't done the math yet to see how feasible those ideas are though in the current promotion setup.


That's why you need to have cross conference promotion in the BBB, so that openings/demotions from the A end up in BBB1-2. So you promote from BBB16 to BBB1 and then up into A. It may take longer for a team to get to the A league but it will help the overall competition levels throughout the BBB leagues.
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
All smart owners will do is let contracts of high level players expire, wait for promotion/relegation, and then re-sign them.

Jury rigging the leagues has never worked before and I can't see it happening this time.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy
All smart owners will do is let contracts of high level players expire, wait for promotion/relegation, and then re-sign them.

Jury rigging the leagues has never worked before and I can't see it happening this time.


How are you resigning people over a hard cap?
 
Raiders12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
Originally posted by Krunchy

All smart owners will do is let contracts of high level players expire, wait for promotion/relegation, and then re-sign them.

Jury rigging the leagues has never worked before and I can't see it happening this time.


How are you resigning people over a hard cap?


That's the whole point..the caps have to be in place for new signings to stop just this crap from happening. We've been letting the "smart owners' get away with this crap for far too long.
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Truffle Shuffle
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
What will prevent owners from signing or trading for higher level players after the reshuffle?

A reshuffle seems pointless if you can just sign free agents or trade for players that are higher level after the shuffle..

Am I missing something?
 
grantham
offline
Link
 
While I like the idea of no longer being in a league with teams that can beat us by 100+ points, I have to say it's a bit disappointing not getting the chance to fight our way up. We've gone from 1 win to 2 wins to 5 wins to 7 wins in USA BBB16. We were hoping finally to make a run at the playoffs next season. Now, based on the reshuffling, as far as I can tell, we could end up at the bottom (or top) of some new league. It kinda makes the last few seasons seem a bit of a waste.
 
Link
 
Last season was my first time as an owner. I got a 24 cap Casual team that I did not play last season so I filled it with level 1 CPUs while I concentrated on the Pee Wee team I got to get the hang of ownership. Now I have 75% of my next seasons team recruited that will not be able to be signed if I get dropped down to the 16 cap league. If this happens then I will just have to spend all of next season as a level 1 CPU team again while I recruit for Season 10. I am sure the league I am in will appreciate the competition.
 
drakeborn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
What will prevent owners from signing or trading for higher level players after the reshuffle?

A reshuffle seems pointless if you can just sign free agents or trade for players that are higher level after the shuffle..

Am I missing something?


At lest for most of the teams, this part will apply:

Originally posted by Bort
- For the leagues that have lower level teams shuffled into them (or CPUs), we will be capping them at 13/16/21/24/28/31/34 based on the teams that get shuffled there. Leagues with teams in the higher 30's, 40's, etc. will remain uncapped.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.